If I could rate 0 stars, I would.....
I purchased a Scott Kay bracelet and ring from this jeweler years ago. Scott Kay jewelry is known for its unique black antiquing — a design e...lement that is embedded into the metal and requires professional, careful handling during cleaning. If not done properly, the antiquing is stripped away, ruining the piece.
I’ve had them clean these pieces in the past without issue — until now.
My wife brought them in recently for their annual cleaning. She made it explicitly clear to the person behind the counter that these were Scott Kay pieces and that the antiquing must not be removed. She was met with a dismissive “yeah, yeah, yeah” attitude, and despite the clear instructions, they went ahead and completely botched the job.
They destroyed the bracelet.
The antiquing was stripped away, the finish is now tarnished, and the piece looks absolutely nothing like it should. When my wife confronted them — visibly upset — their response? “We’re no longer a Scott Kay retailer,” and a half-hearted offer to maybe “try reaching out to someone” who could help. No real apology. No offer to take ownership. Just a shrug and a weak “there’s probably nothing we can do.”
This was 100% their fault. They never should have accepted the bracelet if they didn’t have the capability to handle it properly — and now I’m left having to track down someone to recondition the piece and pay out of pocket to fix their mistake.
Absolutely irresponsible and unprofessional behavior. This jeweler clearly doesn’t understand or respect the value of the pieces trusted to them. If you care about your jewelry, especially high-end designer pieces, take them somewhere else — somewhere that will listen, treat you with respect, and most importantly, not destroy your property.