Batter Up Bakery

Best of Weddings (1x)

Arcadia, Florida

About this vendor

We don‘t know Batter Up Bakery‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.

Details

Awards and Affiliations

4.7

out of 5.0

15 reviews

Search reviews

7/13/2023 • Tracy B

I was there today. I ordered a proscuitto flatbread $14. What I received was a $14 slice of pizza. I will never go back there.

11/14/2019 • Becca T

Our cake was the BEST! Batter Up Bakery delivered right on time, they were super awesome and friendly to work with, and the cake was the most delicious thing ever. I had to hide away from my entire family so I can enjoy my ENTIRE piece to myself! We had the strawberry cheesecake filled one and the chocolate ganache. My husband and I will probably make a special trip all the way to this side of the state just to get a cake again. Highly recommend!

2/25/2019 • Rebecca L

Batter up bakery has amazing cakes! The butter cream is to die for, smooth and just the right amount of sweetness (not over the top) and the cake is moist, delish, and all around fantastic. I haven’t had a wedding cake, but I’ve ate their cakes and I have been to their cake decorating classes and brought home those cakes and they have all been fantabulous each time!!! If you’re ever in the area it’s a must go to place. Their cinnamon rolls are also off the charts amazing!!

2/20/2019 • Brooke W

Batter Up Bakery has the best cakes and cupcakes around! The strawberry shortcake is to die for!! I have used them for every event that I've had this past year and hope to do so in the future!

2/20/2019 • Christy M

These ladies make the most out of this world cakes and cupcakes. I have sent my customers to them for cupcakes and other pastries. They are ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

2/20/2019 • mayra b

Their cakes are amazing! They aren’t just beautiful to look at but taste amazing!!!! The owner Jessie really listens to the customer and I promise, you will get exactly what you wanted.

2/20/2019 • Natalie G

Jesi was very helpful, accommodating, professional, and so sweet throughout our cake planning and she did a phenomenal execution with the cake! I was extremely satisfied with the overall design and appearance of the cake, the flavors were scrumptious (we had a hard time narrowing it down as they are all so good!), and her customer service is fantastic! I’m so glad she finally opened her shop so we can enjoy more of her goodies!

2/20/2019 • Vickie P

We used batter up for catering for my wedding shower and even held the event at thier store front! It was perfect from the food to the coffee! We also used them for our wedding cake and cupcakes. Our cake tasting was so fun. They have a huge variety of flavors to choose from and everything was so yummy the day of the wedding.

2/20/2019 • Katherine K

The customer service is excellent. The baked goods are top notch and so beautiful. They do amazing work.

2/20/2019 • Crystal W

This place is amazing! I ordered a Frozen Elsa cake for my daughter last October for her birthday. Not only was it beautifully decorated the exact same way I asked but the flavors inside was also amazing. Strawberries and Chocolate! 😍😍 My daughter really enjoyed it ( as did I ) I will definitely be ordering from them again in the near future 😄

2/20/2019 • Bethany T

When I am looking for something special for my event that I know will not only look gorgeous but will taste gorgeous as well, I always look to Batter Up Bakery for my cake and dessert needs. They always make my vision come to life and with them, I know I will be in good hands. There has not been an event I have attended with Batter Up Bakery’s deserts where people are not raving about their work. Batter Up Bakery’s team and professionalism is unmatched. You will be at ease knowing you have this team on your side for your big day or event.

2/20/2019 • Megan A

Thank Batter Up Bakery has been my go to for 10 years now from birthday cakes, bridal cakes & of course a few AMAZING wedding cakes. They make the whole experience sooo easy & their cakes are just as delish as they look. You will NOT be disappointed

2/20/2019 • Samantha J

We have been a customer of Batter Up Bakery since their store-front opening in 2017. They have created every birthday and celebration cake in our family from a Lumberjack cake, farm cake, baseball cake, and many others. Their customer service and professionalism is unmatched along with their creativity! Will be a pleased customer for many years to come.