5.0
Verified reviews from real couples
Butter Baked Cookies and Cakes LLC
Modern Tampa Bay Wedding Cakes | Affordable Luxury
Tampa Bay Area and Sarasota
Travel area: Within 50 miles See details
Ericka did such a wonder job on my wedding day. It was a beautiful cake, so delicious everyone loved it!! She was so sweet and patient despite I couldn’t be there to receive the cake. I can’t wait to continue to book with her for future events!!!
From start to finish, the experience was seamless and professional. This bakery brought our vision to life and delivered something that looked stunning and tasted even better! The taste of the cake was something we wanted to prioritize and Butter Baked not only pulled that off, but the design was also impeccable and luxurious. 1000/10!
About this vendor
Ericka McAvaddy
PASTRY CHEF & OWNER
Typically responds within 24h
At Butter Baked Cookies and Cakes LLC in Seminole, FL, we believe every wedding cake should act as a centerpiece as unique as the couple it celebrates. Founded by Ericka McAvaddy, our Tampa Bay-based bakery specializes in the art of the celebration, focusing on handcrafted treats that offer a perfect blend of modern style and homemade heart.
Your Vision, Our Craft
Ericka is deeply passionate about the creative process, from the first message with a new couple to the final delicate brushstroke of buttercream. We specialize in minimalist and modern designs tailored to your specific aesthetic. Whether you are dreaming of the organic beauty of fresh florals, an edgy abstract element, or a high-impact "full glam" showstopper, we bring that vision to life with meticulous attention to detail. No detail is overlooked because we want your wedding day to be truly unforgettable.
Quality That Fits Your Budget
We are committed to sharing our love for baking by offering thoughtful, high-quality, and affordable homemade cakes. At Butter Baked, we believe luxury should be accessible. Every couple deserves a stunning, delicious cake that fits their budget without ever compromising on the quality of ingredients or the sophistication of the design.
Our Signature Offerings:
• Custom Wedding Cakes: Tiered buttercream designs tailored to your wedding theme.
• Curated Dessert Bars: A variety of sweet treats to keep your guests dancing all night.
• Gourmet Cookies & Favors: Perfect for bridal showers, rehearsal dinners, or as a "thank you" for your guests.
The Heart Behind the Bakery
When Ericka isn't in the kitchen perfecting a floral design, she is an avid runner, balancing her active lifestyle with her creative passion for baking. This energy and joy are captured in our motto: Crave • Indulge • Smile. Our goal is to bring happiness and satisfaction with every bite, making your special occasion a little sweeter.
Serving Tampa Bay & Beyond
Local Expertise: We proudly serve St. Pete, Clearwater, the beaches, Pinellas County, and the surrounding Tampa Bay area.
The Butter Baked Club: Treat yourself throughout your engagement with our monthly subscription box featuring exclusive seasonal flavors.
Let's make your wedding day a day to remember. Contact us today to start designing your dream wedding dessert menu!
Meet the team
Ericka McAvaddy
Pastry Chef & Owner
Hi! I’m Ericka McAvaddy, and I’m obsessed with the art of the celebration. Based right here in Tampa Bay, what started as a passion project has grown into a full-scale love affair with baking and design. From the moment I preheat the oven to the final touch of a decorating tool, I am all in.
At Butter Baked Cookies + Cakes, I believe that your dream wedding cake should be as accessible as it is beautiful. My mission is to provide thoughtful, high-quality, and affordable homemade cakes that fit your budget without ever compromising on style or taste.
My Aesthetic: I specialize in minimalist and modern designs. Whether you’re looking for the organic beauty of fresh florals, an edgy abstract element, or a "full glam" showstopper, I’m here to bring that vision to life.
When I’m not in the kitchen, you’ll likely find me out on a run. I love the balance of staying active while nurturing my creative side through sugar and flour! My goal is simple, and it’s baked into our motto: Crave • Indulge • Smile. I can’t wait to make your big day a little sweeter.
Service area & Contact info
Shelly Circle, Seminole, FL
Open mapTampa Bay Area and Sarasota
Typically included in the starting cost
Travel area: Within 50 miles
Additional charges may apply
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Butter Baked Cookies and Cakes LLC
Ericka McAvaddy
|
Pastry Chef & Owner
Typically responds within 24h
Wedding vendors in Seminole
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.