About this vendor
Whether you are planning a special event or your dream wedding, we encourage you to do something different! We specialize in pie stations for the couple that wants something just a little different. We can meet all of your unique needs - pies, whoopie pies, cupcakes and yes even wedding cakes!
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.013 reviews
Buttermilk Baking Co. made our wedding pie dreams come true!! Even before we were engaged, my now-husband and I always said that when we got married, we wanted pie at our wedding i...
nstead of cake. Boy, did Buttermilk Baking Co. turn that into the most incredible reality!! We had apple, blueberry, strawberry rhubarb, key lime, pecan bourbon, chocolate, and white chocolate raspberry pies at our wedding, and our guests were in HEAVEN! We have seriously not stopped hearing about how amazing it was from our friends and family since the wedding a week and a half ago. One of my favorite memories from the night was grooving on the dance floor, in my wedding dress, with a cocktail in one hand and a mini hand-pie in the other! Buttermilk Baking Company was an absolutely delight to work with for our wedding and we could not recommend them more.
We needed a gluten-free cutting cake and normal sheet cakes for our wedding, and Buttermilk Baking Co. was so accommodating! We were able to try gluten-free and normal cupcakes dur...
ing our tasting (packaged separately, which was so professional and appreciated), and it was honestly impossible to tell the difference between the two - a true indicator of how good their gluten-free cake is. The bakery also worked with us on a short timeline, and we had no problems with coordination and delivery.
Talk about a wonderful cake, not only was it beautiful but it also was the best tasting we have ever had!! Along with the mini cupcakes and cookies we felt we were treated to a tru...
e delight! I will never stop going to this bakery and for any special occasion I will go back. Not to mention the staff was wonderful and kind for all the nervous wedding jitters we had.
We love Buttermilk! We regularly go to Buttermilk for our sweet tooth fix, but knew we had to go to them for our wedding cake. We are especially grateful because we included a New ...
Orleans wedding tradition called a Cake Pull for our wedding and the team at Buttermilk made it happen. Ashley made sure she did the cake pull properly, and she did. It was perfect!
While we appreciate her going above and beyond for our cake pull, obviously the star of the show was the cake. It was simple, beautiful, and absolutely delicious. We opted for a strawberry cake with strawberry and buttercream filling. Everyone raved about it! The cake was perfectly done and I wish I had more at the wedding!
All around a wonderful experience, which isn't surprising!
My husband and I were so happy we chose Buttermilk Baking Co. to make the cake & cupcakes for our wedding. Pam was so easy to work with and quick to respond. With the border to Can...
ada being closed our guest count happened to be a good amount smaller than originally planned, but they were so accommodating to the change. Above all, the cake and cupcakes were absolutely beautiful and SO delicious. All our guests commented on how great the cupcakes were. Thank you again Buttermilk Baking!
Our wedding cake was delicious! And it was beautiful! Our cake was completely customized to what we wanted. Everything we tasted was delicious! Our two favorites were the choc...
olate with salted caramel and the red velvet. We were able to take the cream cheese frosting from the red velvet and put it on the chocolate cake. Our guests were raving about how great the cake was! It looked great too!
My mother-in-law ordered a cake for our rehearsal dinner which was held at Mission Oak Grille in Newburyport. The cake was so beautiful and delicious! Buttermilk Baking Company w...
as so easy to work with and the end result was perfect--thank you!
Use this bakery for your wedding!! You will not be disappointed! We had a huge wooden cake + cupcake tier and Ashley filled it with 400 mini sparkling cupcakes, half chocolate half...
golden, all topped with delicious buttercream frosting and gorgeous golden sweet decoration. The very top of the stand housed a cake with buttercream frosting succulents on top and cream cheese frosting inside the layers. I have never been to a wedding where one of the major topics was how delicious the cake was until our very own. Ashley and her team are incredibly accommodating, talented, worked within our budget, and pulled off my exact vision even better than i dreamed. Highly recommend this bakery for all of your sweet treats - even before and after your wedding day
My husband and I aren't cake people, so when it came time to think of wedding desserts for our fall farm wedding....PIE! was the obvious answer. Born and raised in Newbury....Butt...
ermilk is often a frequent stop on weekend mornings for breakfast, so I couldn't think of any other bakery that I would want making our desserts. Boy, did they come through. Not only did they make delicious apple, pumpkin, and pecan pies, but ginger molasses cookies as well. And they personalized each pie with our names and dates. It was such a perfect added touch, that made the wedding so special. Now as for the taste....I got so many of my guests saying it was the best pie they had ever had, and people were trying to take cookies home with them!! Everything was absolutely delicious and I would recommend them to anyone in the New England area! Thank you so much!
Buttermilk Baking Company did a fantastic job on the cupcakes for my wedding. They were absolutely stunning and so so delicious. Tons of our guests commented on how great they wer...
e! Ashley was super easy to work with. Very professional and she completely understood my vision. She accommodated some of our special requests (making a whole new type of cupcake and using special trays that we had). I would highly recommend using BBC for your New England wedding!
I was sponsoring a wedding reception for one of my employees, who had married at City Hall. Myself and fellow employees decided to create a small reception for the bride and groom...
. I went to speak with Ashley several days before the wedding and asked her to create a wedding cake(every bride needs a party and a cake). I had no specific cake in mind and I'm not current as far as wedding taste(being 60 years old).
Ashley and her team created the most beautiful and elegant cake. It was 3 tiers and stark white with lovely fresh flowers. The cake was called a hummingbird cake and was delicous. Being old fashioned I asked for a toy bride and groom on top of the cake. I also asked for the ability to save the top tier for the 1st year anniversary.
Owing a restaurant myself I know how difficult it is to create a last minute order, especially when the person ordering has no idea what she really wants or needs.
The cake was the hit of the party and the bride and groom loved it. I highly recommend Buttermilk for their service and especially the quality of their products. I have ordered many cakes from Buttermilk and they have all been tasty and elegant.
Ashley was incredibly easy to work with and made our wedding cupcakes and tier more delicious that we could have imagined! She is so talented and blended the various flavors we wer...
e looking for into five beautiful cupcakes that were a show stopper at our wedding. I highly recommend her to anyone for any sweet treat they are looking for.
Ashley, owner of Buttermilk Baking, was phenomenal to work with. I had the pleasure of tasting a bunch of her pies when she brought samples over to her friends business (where I ha...
ppened to be getting my hair cut). They were absolutely delicious!!!! So good in fact, that my fiancé and I decided to cancel our cake order and do pies at our wedding. We had originally wanted pies, but couldn't find a good enough baking company to do it. The presentation and taste were out of this world. Everyone loved them! We did two pies, a bride and a groom 'pick.' I chose apple and my husband chose bourbon pecan. If you're doing pies, go with Buttermilk--they are fantastic.
Contact
3 Liberty Street, Newburyport, MA
Buttermilk Baking Company