About this vendor
Custom Cake Art of all kinds. We see the importance in making your cake unique to it’s recipients and put heart into the process. Together we will design the perfect cake for your special event. Add to your display with a custom dessert bar, candy buffet, fondue fountain and more.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Kosher
- Organic
- Sugar Free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.7
out of 5.031 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
We ordered a cake to help us celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary and beach marriage vow renewal. Emmalee (owner) was just wonderful as we were trying to arrange months ahead and from out of USA. She made it so easy…very helpful with design and flavor suggestions. Cake turned out beautifully…delicious, tender and moist and looked spectacular! I just couldn’t be more pleased and highly recommend!
Our cake was so pretty, and I was delighted to be able to have gluten free wedding cake. On top of that, it was delicious. Mahalo!!
Beautiful and delicious!! Hard to nail these two in one when it comes to cakes. She created a stunning cake for our welcoming party of our dog who we could not bring to the island of Maui with us to celebrate our wedding. Thank you for such a delicious, memorable, and creative addition to our wedding weekend.
I hired Cake Fanatics because their cakes were GORGEOUS and not being from Maui we didn't get to do a cake tasting so I just went off reviews. When my husband and I took our first bite it turned into us DEVOURING the entire slice of cake because it was THAT good. The best cake I've ever had. We ordered a larger cake and knew we would probably have extras because we had more cake than people and I am SO glad we had extras to take back to our hotel and enjoy for the rest of our trip.
The days after the wedding I had multiple friends and family ask if I had extra cake because they wanted more.
HIGHLY recommend!!!
We booked Cake Fanatics to cater our wedding, ordering 8 dozen cupcakes in various flavors, and they were all DELICIOUS! We're so happy we went with EmmaLee - our guests loved the dessert and we were able to accommodate anyone with dietary restrictions thanks to her incredible options!
I am messed up for life. Our wedding cake was the best cake that I have ever eaten! For our first layer we had marble cake with chocolate mousse filling and vanilla butter cream. Ooooh my goodness! The buttercream.. it is not your typical butter cream that you get stateside. It was perfection. The cows in Hawaii must be yielding magical milk for the butter, because that buttercream was delectable! Our top layer was almond cake with cinnamon cream cheese filling and vanilla butter cream. Our design was clean and simple with real flowers (provided from our flower vendor) cascading down the side. We were very pleased with how our cake looked and tasted. We plan on returning to Maui for our Anniversary, and I for sure would order a mini cake from Cake Fanatics, to have the traditional wedding cake for our Anniversary.
Our daughter was recently married on Maui. She read some reviews about Cake Fanatics so we decided to give them a try. After ordering the cake, and then making 4 or 5 changes after that, we ended up with a fabulous cake with raspberry filling and smooth white icing. Despite our many changes, they stayed in constant communication and brought us the perfect cake for the wedding. We were amazed at how lovely it looked
They offer vegan options!! This was a plus because my wife and I are vegan and the cake was delicious. So delicious our guests had no idea it was vegan. They delivered on time and the presentation was great.
I found Cake Fanatics on Yelp and decided to order our cake from them for our destination wedding on 7/7/17. No tasting, just decided on reviews and pictures form their website... And it was a great choice!! They were so easy to work with via email, answered email promptly and delivered on time. The cake was beautiful & delicious!! We had one layer chocolate with bavarian cream and guava filling and one layer with vanilla cake with bavarian cream and lilikoi filling. We are still talking about our fabulous cake!
Cake Fanatics is wonderful!
We had a taste testing in January of this year and all the flavors we tried we’re amazing. They were so delicious that we couldn’t decide on just one so we decided on three! Our three-tiered cake consisted of lilikoi with cream cheese filling, lemon cake with lemon filling, and French vanilla with Bavarian cream filling and fresh strawberries. Every tier was AMAZING!!!
On top of a delicious product the customer service was excellent. EmmaLee was very nice, personable and really understood our vision. We wanted a simple, classic three-tiered round cake with ribboning around every tier. It was beautiful.
We highly recommend Cake Fanatics! We can’t wait to be in Maui again so we can order a cake just because. =)
Paula & Bobby
My wedding coordinator contacted Cake Fantastic to do our wedding cake for our June wedding a couple of weeks ago. We did do a cake tasting with them a year before and their cakes are delish! Our 3 tier cake was a Coconut and Guava cakes with Marshmallow Fondant! AMAZING! And our wedding cake still tasted AWESOME on our wedding day! The reason for the 4 star only is that we order a 3 Tier "SQUARE" cake but what they delivered was a "ROUND" 3 Tier cake...which was a bit dissapointing (2 hours LATE by the way, from Lahaina to Kihei). Not sure who's at fault....my coordinator (Sandra) for not following thru, or Cake Fanatics for not reading the order invoice correctly? Oh well this constitutes this minus ONE STAR. HOWEVER, their Cakes are INCREDIBLE...worth every penny!
Without having actually tasted the cakes because of planning a destination wedding in Maui, I relied totally on the reviews from Cake Fanatics and I was SO glad I did! We ordered a buttercream cake with a passionfruit filling and it was so good guests wanted seconds. We saved some for the next day and it was just as good! They were wonderful working with us via email to decide the right amount and perfect type of cake to fit our budget. Highly recommend!
You helped make our wedding day in Maui perfect. The cake was exactly as I ordered and it was so easy doing business with you by email. The coconut cake with mango/pineapple filling was delicious. It was delivered and I was able to get a cake plate and servers to use during our ceremony. We loved doing business with you and I highly recommend Cake Fanatics!
Mahalo!
Susanne
Dear Cake Fanactics,
I would travel to Maui just to eat the cake you made for us on our wedding day! My husband loves cake and designed ours requesting a yellow cake chocolate mousse filling with a vanilla cream frosting- all of our guest keep talking about how delicious it was! It was absolutely perfect! Thank you!
filling with
We ordered 2 small cakes from Cake Fanatics for my parents' 30 yr vow renewal and my grandma's 85th birthday which we were celebrating in Maui. I had sent them pictures and descriptions of what we wanted and everuthing turned out just how I had planned!! The only thing I was concerned about is we had showed up at the restaurant and the cakes had not been delivered but about 2 minutes later they had arrived... Still before our reservation time. Other than that momentary panic, everything turned out perfect and they tasted great!
We had our wedding cake made by Emma at Cake Fanatics. Our wedding planner communicated between us and Emma for the booking/contract process, and passed on all our instructions and photo inspiration. Although our cake arrived generally how we wanted it to look, we were slightly disappointed that it was not as detailed as we had shown in the photographs. We had a 3 tier cake, delivered to Olowalu Plantation House. The 3 tiers arrived as ordered with the flavors we had requested, and all were delicious and fresh/moist (we did chocolate cake with vanilla custard filling, pineapple cake with coconut cream filling, and marble cake with lilikoi filling). Overall, our cake was beautiful and fresh and tasted good, so we would recommend Cake Fanatics to make a cake for any event on Maui.
I am not the dessert person but my husband sure is! He loved everything about our wedding cupcake tower. He even had it for breakfast the next morning. They were able to make our tower with 4 different flavors of cupcakes and our main cake on top for us to cut. They made it exactly the way I wanted! Thank you
Our original wedding cake plans fell through. We were referred to Cake Fanatics by our photographer, Mieko Photography, who is also on the Knot, and once we contacted them, they agreed to do a cake for us on short notice.
Their website was very user friendly, explaining the choices for the cake itself, and the filling and the frosting. They also had a tool for deciding how big a cake to order based on number of guests. I'm so glad my fiance recommended we upsize that way we had leftovers ( for a few days, Yay!!! )
It was a really great experience working with Cake Fanatics. They made a cake to our design, and they delivered on the promised time.
I would highly recommend Cake Fanatics for anyone getting married, or having a special occaision that deserves a cake!
Sincerely,
Christina Crombie
Married on the SummerSolstice2015
you need to order twice as much as you think because everyone will LOVE them! They delivered everything to my venue and even picked up the cupcake stand the day after the wedding. Delicious and beautiful, what more can you ask for :)
I'm from Seattle and had to do all my wedding thru emails. I wanted to make sure my wedding cake looked just like the photo I sent her. I was a little nervous at first but right after we spoke she made me feel very comfortable!! She replied to all my emails. When I got to maui she emailed me letting me know when she would drop it off. I didn't have to worry about one thing!!! My cake was so perfect it was better then the picture I sent her!! My husband and I love red velvet! The guest weren't too excited about that flavor but the cake was so good everyone was so happy with it!! Hands down the best cake ever!!!!!!! It was so good!! I was so upset we had no cake left!! If you need a wedding cake I 100% recommend her!!!! #bestCakeEver it was so beautiful!!!
EmmaLee did an amazing job. The cake was exactly what we wanted and it was delicious! We had two tiers, one with marble cake and chocolate ganache filling and the other was French vanilla with lilikoi filling. Both were out of this world! I would use them again and I would highly recommend Cake Fanatics.
I always knew I wanted a confetti cake and we were so happy with the one you made us. The cake had the exact look I was going for and I loved everything about it. All of our guests have been telling us it was the best wedding cake they have ever had and can't stop talking about it. I am usually a picky wedding cake eater and I was so thrilled that mine was delicious! I would recommend them to everyone!
We used Cake Fanatics for our Maui wedding this past January. EmmaLee did an amazing job designing exactly what I had in mind, even better than I had pictured it! It also tasted as good as it looked. The cake was the one thing that went off without a hitch that day! I would highly recommend. Thanks so much!
I loved my cake! I got vanilla on one and champagne on the other with white chocolate ganache! It was the best cake I've had! The champagne was my favorite! I cannot stop talking about it!
EmmaLee Larsen is amazing and we loved our wedding cake. We met with Emmalee six months before our wedding to do a cake tasting…we were left in awe! Her cake samples were delicious. I liked her work so much that I even ordered a cake for our Rehearsal Dinner. All her flavors are oh-so-good that the hardest part was choosing. It's so rich, but not too sweet and it just melts in your mouth and leaves you craving for more. We ordered the Snicker-doodle for our Wedding Rehearsal and everyone loved it. For our 3-tier square wedding cake, EmmaLee let me choose 3 different flavors (guava with Bavarian cream filling, yellow butter with caramel butter cream filling, and white chocolate with coconut filling)…they were heavenly!
Thank you EmmaLee and the next time we're in Maui, I will definitely order another cake from you!
You will not be disappointed! Our cake was AMAZING! Moist, delicious, full of flavor, rich and just plain ridiculously good. We ordered a french vanilla cake with coconut creme filling and vanilla buttercream frosting.
How many good wedding cakes have you had??? I personally have not. They may look "pretty", but lacked in taste. Well, our cake was not only beautiful, but the best cake we ever tasted.
Great service, too! We mailed her a special cake stand that we wanted her to use and she obliged. She's great! very talented.
I went through my Wedding Planner to secure the cake company and I was not disappointed. I ordered cupcakes and one small round cake on top. They made the frosting for the cupcakes and coral color for my colors. I loved the taste and also the layout. We didn't have a design for our cake but the butter cream was extremely smooth and very well done.
EmmaLee is a cake artist! Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful, and it tasted so good!!!
EmmaLee took two cake pictures that I sent her, "married them", and made us the most beautiful cake! I can't believe how delish the cake actually was. Most wedding cakes are a bit dry and kind of boring. Ours was 3 layers- guava, white chocolate with strawberry filling, and basically chocolate lovers.
EmmaLee was even sweet enough to come to our condo 3 days before the wedding with different flavors to try because we were bummed that with a destination wedding- we wouldn't get to do a cake tasting. I 100% recommend EmmaLee!
Thank you Cake Fanatics!!! Our wedding cake turned out so beautifully and tasted delicious too! Our guests raved about how good it was!
I had ordered a champagne cake with strawberries and cream filling; white buttercream frosting with blue, yellow, and white flowers. What came out (at a fine dining establishment)was a tiny cake with 3 layers, no strawberries, only a pink cake with Crisco sweetened frosting, that was flat and had no flowers. I would never recommend this company to anyone. On a good note, she did refund all of our money because the cake was inedible.
Worth every penny. Emmalee did a beautiful cake for our 35 guests - the coconut flavor is amazing and we had a beautiful two-tier cake with yellow buttercream frosting and edible flowers. Beautiful, delicious, and many of our guests commented on how perfect it was for our reception. Highly recommended!
Contact
5095 Napilihau St., Suite 109B PMB 311, Lahaina, HI | Serving All Of Maui
Cake Fanatics's photos