About this vendor
We’re a local bakery who specializes in custom cakes and wedding cakes. We believe in fresh, from scratch cakes. All of our cakes and buttercream are made in store by our own team.
It’s important to us that your wedding cake experience be as easy and pleasant as possible. You will have an in-person consultation and tasting with the owner in our storefront. You will receive a quote on the spot. We believe in clear communication and a personalized experience. Also, laughter and photos are welcome!
Feel free to reach out to us with any questions and we’ll be happy to schedule your consultation asap. We look forward to working with you!
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
- Other Desserts
Awards and Affiliations
3-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2025.2024.2023.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.055 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Mindi was amazing throughout the entire process! She made us feel so comfortable and welcomed from the start. She listened to every detail and absolutely nailed it — from the beaut...
iful design to the incredible taste. The cake was stunning and tasted even better! We received so many compliments from our guests about how delicious it was. It was everything we imagined and more. We even saved the top tier for our anniversary next year.
Thank you for helping make our special day perfect. We couldn’t have chosen a better person. Highly recommend
Mindi Odell is SO AMAZING!!! Her cakes are absolutely gorgeous, and she spends so much time making sure your cake is everything you want and more. 100% recommend Cake That to any b...
ride looking to have the perfect cake on their wedding day!!!
Cake That made our bride and grooms' cakes for our wedding in June 2024. I cannot recommend them enough!! They were incredibly easy to work with, and they were very professional an...
d timely. Our cakes not only looked gorgeous, but they tasted AMAZING! Their ability to make every layer a different flavor/filling was especially a hit among our guests! We had close to no cake leftover because it was such a hit!
I highly recommend Cake That as your wedding cake vendor. We live in California and have to fly back to BR to meet our vendors. Compared to other cake vendors, Mindi is warm and we...
lcoming. She shows her experience and skills in her specialties and provides us with many useful suggestions. We had a great experience at her store when doing cake tasting. When the big day approached, I changed my cake design about a week before. Mindi and her team pulled up a wonderful wedding cake that exceeded my vision and expectations, despite that the cake picture I gave her was smaller and one layer less than our cake. Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and amazingly, and our guests tasted every flavor that we did not have any left! I do not have a picture of the cake at this moment but I will be happy to share it once I receive it from our photographer.
Cake That was an amazing bakery to work with!! All of their cake flavors were sooo good it was hard to pick! Both the bride's cake and groom's cake looked amazing and had the guest...
s raving about the taste! 10/10
We used Cake That for our wedding cakes, and both of our cakes were phenomenal! The decorations on both cakes exceeded our expectations, and the flavors were out of this world! We ...
almost had ALL of the cake gone by the end of the night...it was just that good! I cannot recommend Cake That enough!
Very professional and fast service! The cake was great and the guest raved about it!
Cake That did an amazing job on our wedding cake! It came out so beautiful and tasted like heaven. There was barely enough for me and my husband to take home because it was such a ...
hit! We even had several inquiries from guests about who made it so they could order something too. Not only that, but the staff were so kind and quick to respond if we had any questions. They actually listened to what we wanted and made an already stressful time for this bride that much easier. 10/10 would recommend!
My wedding cake looked like it was straight out of a magazine! And it tasted as good as it looked! The groom cake was exactly what we asked for and tasted even better than the main...
cake! lol! I could not have asked for a better wedding cake experience. Everyone was so nice and helpful, made everything so easy, and more than delivered on the product. If there were more than 5 stars they would get them all!
Cake That is such an amazing business!
The team sure did make a girls heart happy❤️
And any future sweets I may need will definitely come from them!
Easiest decision we made was choosing Cake That for our wedding after we tried their cake at the bridal show at White Oak. We couldn’t believe how delicious and moist the cake was...
. We used Cake That for our Couple’s Shower cake and both cakes at our wedding. Everyone talked about how delicious each flavor of the cakes were (We had 3 different flavors). You will not regret choosing Cake That for your wedding. We plan to always use Cake That for any future cake needs!
Mindi and her crew were fantastic to work with. They helped to bring our vision to life. Our cakes were not only beautiful but so delicious! With both a 3 tiered cake and a groom’s...
cake not one slice was left by the end of our wedding. Could not recommend the Cake That crew more!
My wife and I got married on Oct. 13th of 2023, and our experience with Cake That was immaculate! The entire team was more than helpful in creating our vision for our three cakes, ...
and they really went above and beyond. Our cakes not only looked good, but they were easily the tasiest cakes we have ever had. Don't even get me started on how budget friendly it was, too! Seriously, shout out to the entire team for making our dreams come true!!
We loved our experience with Cake That!
Our wedding cake and grooms cake turned out so beautiful and sooooo yummy! Cannot recommend them enough!
AMAZING! My wedding cake was a three tier almond with strawberry filling and the grooms cake was a two tier red vevlet with cream cheese filling. The decor on the cake was spectaul...
ar - the flavor was even better! We had amazing reviews all night long from our guest.
We planned for over 200 guests and we had so much cake left over! It was more than enough!
My husband and I ordered our cake for our wedding from Cake That. We had a very good experience from beginning to end. They were very professional and tried to accommodate us in ev...
ery way possible. When we had questions they responded timely. We had the opportunity to taste a sample of each flavor before making our choice, each flavor was delicious. I highly recommend Cake That!!
Cake That is absolutely spectacular. From the moment we left our consultation, I knew we were in great hands! She took our vision and brought it to life so perfectly. Their cakes a...
re so fresh, and the flavor options are outside the ordinary. We went with the almond cake with chantilly filling. It is so light and delicious... and out guests agreed. Their prices are shockingly reasonable, considering how delicious and beautiful the cakes were. We will definitely be back for future cakes!
Everything about Cake That was amazing. The initial consultation was so great, we were able to taste so many great flavors and were able to show pictures of what we wanted. The day...
of the wedding it was amazing to see exactly what we chose on the tables and everything tasted phenomenal. I will definitely be ordering a cake for our anniversary and any other milestones in the future from Cake That!
Our cake was gorgeous and tasted SO good!! Highly recommended!
Cake That was a pleasure to work with! From the cake tasting to the day of the wedding everything was a breeze. The staff made my vision come to light. The custom grooms cake looke...
d absolutely amazing! We had so many compliments from our guests saying “that was the best cake I’ve ever eaten”. Cake That checked all the boxes and exceeded my expectations. Thank you a ton!!
Cake That is exceptional, from the level of service from all the workers to the beautiful and delicious cakes they produce. Our wedding cake and grooms cake were to die for. She cr...
eated exactly what we had asked for. The best part… they tasted even better than they looked, seriously, the most moist and delicious cakes! Everyone at our wedding was raving about them. You are truly getting the most high quality service at Cake That and that’s a blessing to not have to worry about anything for your wedding! Highly recommend!!
Cake That’s cake they created for my wedding was delicious!!!! It was the talk of the night! The initial tasting session was very informative, customizable, and not to mention deli...
cious! Will be using Cake That in the future.
From the initial taste testing/consult to the wedding day, Cake That was the easiest vendor to work with. They made our vision come to life with special attention to detail on both...
the wedding cake and grooms cake. I cannot rave enough on how amazing the cakes turned out for my son and DIL’s wedding. Oh, and did I mention how delicious they were? Perfection!! This momma is truly grateful to you guys for helping to make a beautiful day even more special. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!♥️
Cake that is amazing. We had originally gone with another vendor for our cake however this vendor could not make the cake that I had been dreaming about. I met Cake That at a brida...
l show and showed them the cake that I was hoping for. They told me that they could make the cake I was wanting and for a cheaper price than the other vendor was charging me for a cake that I didn’t even want. Needless to say, I immediately scheduled an appointment with Mindy and Karina so that they could make my dream cake. The staff at Cake That is so wonderful, genuine, and care alot about making sure your cake is everything you could ever want and delicious. If I had to choose a cake vendor again, I would without a doubt choose Cake That.
Ms. Mindi and her staff were very professional and amazing. No question went unanswered. My wedding cake was everything I could have dreamed of. I gave her the idea of what I wante...
d and she went above and beyond to make it happen. My cake was beautiful and delicious. I got so many compliments on my wedding cake. I highly recommend Cake That.
Cake That made all of my wedding cake dreams come true!! They were so kind, fun and easy to work with! My husband loved his Grooms cake, too!! Not only were both of the cakes gorge...
ous but they were also insanely delicious! All of our wedding guests were raving about it!!
We LOVED both our wedding and grooms cake! It was very moist and so good. We had a lot of compliments from our guest! Definitely recommend
Cake That went above and beyond my expectations for our wedding cake and grooms cake! Both cakes were absolutely delicious and they were beautiful! I highly recommend using Cake Th...
at for your wedding! You will not be disappointed!
Mindi, with Cake That, was absolutely incredible! She was very accommodating on such short notice for our wedding cake! The flavors were delicious! The cakes were gorgeous! Defin...
itely recommend Cake That if you are searching for a beautiful and heavenly wedding cake and grooms cake!
We are continuously getting compliments and some say it was the best they’ve ever had!
Cake That did an AMAZING job on our wedding cake. The flavors were so good and tye cake looked absolutely beautiful. All our guests enjoyed it so much, we didn't have much left o...
ver. We will forever recommend them to anyone.
Cake that made the most delicious and beautiful cake for my reception! I do not really like cake that much, but this was soooo good! The cupcakes for the grooms table were absolute...
ly adorable! I had multiple guests ask for her information. I cannot recommend enough!
Our cakes were beautiful and tastes VERY good! Amazing quality! Thank you!
Absolutely amazing! Couldn’t have ask for better wedding cakes!
We cannot say enough about the service and the great care that was given to the event for our wedding. Cake That made an unbelievable wedding cake and grooms cake. Not only was it ...
beautiful and everything that we wanted, but the flavor and the freshness was amazing. The fillings were all handmade, and we were able to go in taste every filling that was available to us to make our choices and then we were able to put the fillings in each layer according to which ones we wanted. Everyone went on and on about the cake, and we will use them for many many more events
Amazing and delicious! The groom’s cake was a perfect replica of the groom’s drum set. It was almost too pretty to eat.
The attention to detail that was displayed by Cake That was nothing short of amazing. When we sat down for our consultation, I could tell it was going to be great! My husband works...
with heavy equipment and Cake That took down every measurement to ensure his excavator looked as realistic as possible for his grooms cake! Every guest at our wedding has not stopped talking about our cakes and how amazing it was to try so many different flavors! Cake That is hands down the best!
We used Cake That for our daughter’s wedding cake. The moment I met the owner, I knew this was the place we would order from. From the taste testing to the delivery and set up- eve...
rything was wonderful. Not only was the cake beautiful, but every tier- each a different flavor- was amazing. Our wedding venue coordinator said that it was the first time she can remember everyone eating that much cake, and still wanting more! Thank you for such an incredible experience and helping make our daughter’s wedding the best day ever!
Cake That was such a great company to work with for my bridal cake and my husbands groom cake! They wanted to make it unique to each of us and they did such an amazing job!!!
I highly recommend Cake That! Both our wedding cake and our groom’s cake were perfect! She worked with us to make a car engine cake, something she’s never done before. And it could...
n’t have come out any better. Plus all the flavors are so good!
We got our wedding cake and groomsmen cake and all I can say is I absolutely loved the cakes!! Not only did they taste wonderful but they also did exactly what I wanted when it cam...
e to decorating!! The staff was super nice and helpful and will definitely be using/recommending them!!
The wedding cake and groom’s cake were wonderful! They were very delicious and the highlight of the reception! Highly recommend Cake That! She worked with us closely to make sure w...
e had our favorite flavors and the cakes came out exactly how we imagined!
We got our Groom Cake from them it was beautiful as well as delicious. I would highly recommend not just was wedding but for any cake needs.. lemon cake and the lemon cupcakes are ...
our favorites ..
Mindi at Cake That was amazing to work with. She took her time to understand what our daughter and her fiancé wanted. Her cake testing was amazing! She answered any and all que...
stions in a timely manner. The cake was set up and decorated on time as scheduled at the venue.
The bride and groom had a 5 layer cake with each layer having a different filling and cake flavor. Each layer more wonderful than the other! We could not have had a better experience with Mindi and Cake That!!!!!!
The owner of cake that is nothing short of amazing! She has such a kind heart and she helps to plan the perfect wedding cake. She is very down to earth and helps you to find someth...
ing to fit your budget! Her cakes are not only beautiful but taste amazing! Highly recommend!!
Cake That is amazing!! We had someone else lined up to do our cakes and last minute they dropped out. A month before our wedding we called Cake That and they got us in so fast to d...
o cake testing and get everything booked. Every flavor was amazing and it was so hard to choose! Our wedding cake was almond with cream cheese buttercream and the grooms cake was strawberry with cookies and cream buttercream. The grooms cake was so detailed and exactly what he wanted, and the wedding cake was beautiful! Both were delicious and there was almost none left after our wedding! I definitely will be using them for other special events!
Tasted great, looked perfect! I couldn’t find anyone available in the Baton Rouge area that had already done a wedding geode cake. After looking at the work of Cake That, we did a ...
tasting and I was convinced they could bring our vision to reality. My geode cake was absolutely perfect. My husband’s groom cake was a Texas shaped LSU tiger eye and it was flawless. We were so happy with our cakes and got tons of compliments on the look and the taste. Thank you Cake That!
Our cakes turned out absolutely amazing!
The cakes were exactly what we wanted design wise. Also, cakes tasted PHENOMENAL!! I highly recommend using Cake That!
I just HAVE to share about our wonderful experience with cake that! From the very beginning, they were nothing short of amazing. I spent months cake testing and meeting with differ...
ent bakeries and they were hands down the best all around. Their cakes are to die for!! I used them for my wedding cake and the cake for my bridal shower.
Most importantly, the owner and staff are so genuine and personable. They are so great to work with. I live over an hour away (New Roads) but I will continue to use & recommend them for any & every occasion!
Cake That did an amazing job on our cakes! We had so many compliments over the way they looked and how they taste, we didn’t have any left! The team at Cake That treats everyone li...
ke family with their hospitality and professionalism. Thank you so much for making our day even more special! I 100% recommend Cake That for any occasion!
Cake That made all of my wedding cake dreams come true! She was flexible with meeting and easy to communicate with. Cake that was able to create two beautiful cakes that had not be...
en made before! She turned our dreams into a reality and we are still receiving compliments on the beauty and taste of both cakes at our wedding! Will definitely be back for many anniversaries to come!
Contact
16113 Hwy 44, Prairieville, LA
