4.9 out of 5 stars and 261 reviews Best of Weddings (9x).
4.9
(261)194 W Church Street, Pickerington, OH
About this vendor
Serving the greater Columbus area! Our cakes are all about you, designed especially for you and your special day. Choose from a variety of delicious flavors to satisfy you and all of your guests. Take a look at our fantastic cupcakes, chocolates and favors to add a special touch!
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Stands
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
Dietary Options
- Nut Free
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.0261 reviews
The two-tier cake made for us was amazing! It was very moist and delicious! She also added flowers I brought to her to it and the final result looked beautiful! I highly recommend ...
getting your wedding cake from Crystal!!
The cake came out amazing. She’s definitely a bit slower to respond but she gets everything right and really came through for our wedding. Our guests loved the cake and it came out...
exactly as I wanted.
Crystal made the cake and cookies for my daughters wedding. The cake was not gorgeous and delicious, and the cookies were a hit with all ages. She played a huge role in making the...
day perfect!
Our wedding cake was DELICIOUS! I’m so thankful we were able to go through a local baker. Our friends picked it up the day of our and delivered it to our venue with no problems. Th...
e flowers I gave to Crystal to put on the cake turned out more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. Crystal is definitely a top-tier baker in the central Ohio area. I highly recommend reaching out to Crystal for your baked-goods needs! Mark and I love the coffee house she works out of too. Thanks for making our wedding day perfect!
Crystal did an amazing job with our wedding cake. Not only did she create a beautiful wedding cake just like we wanted but she also worked with me to create a custom grooms cake th...
at she helped me keep as a suprise for my husband. Both cakes were equally delicious. She is priced very well and always willing to help.
Thank you Crystal for the perfect cake on our big day! We asked for something simple for my husband and I and big sheet cakes for our guests. She delivered this simple request in t...
he most beautiful way - it shows her attention to detail and caring nature for every order. Crystal even delivered our cakes so we had one less thing to worry about on our day. Thank you again Crystal, we loved it!!
Crystal was able to make us a delicious cake - but it was gorgeous too! We opted for mini pies along with cupcakes and they were a huge hit! Thank you so much!
My husband and I didn’t have a strong vision for our wedding cake, but Crystal was very patient and provided us with tons of examples. She executed our final vision flawlessly, and...
the cake was delicious! The buttercream is to die for.
Cakes Creatively by Crystal was better than I could’ve dreamed! Not only was the cake AMAZING, everything was put together so professionally from the tasting to the delivery on our...
wedding day. Crystal knew exactly how much we needed and was able to help us decide on the design and table setting to tie into our vintage-travel theme. I couldn’t ask for anything or anyone better!
Crystal did an outstanding job on our wedding cake and cupcakes! Not only was the cake amazing but she decorated it and made the display gorgeous!
Crystal couldn't have been a better choice. We planned our wedding from across the country and she went out of her way to meet us for a little tasting when we were home. She worked...
with our vision and our florist to make the cake that we had always dreamed of. Even more, I am gluten free, so she worked with me to make one layer GF so that i could still enjoy the cake cutting part of the reception.
She has so many different delicious (husband approved) flavors that you can mix and match IN EACH LAYER! If you want a cake that people will talk about for years to come - Crystal is your girl!
Crystal did a phenomenal job on our cake!! It was exactly what we wanted and was beyond our expectations when it came to the flavor!! She is very professional and so easy to relate...
to I would recommend her for any occasion!
Wedding cakes can sometimes be great and other times mediocre but Crystals cakes (& cupcakes) were PERFECT!!! The flavor was delicious and they were dense, not dry, icing yummy! Ev...
eryone at our wedding loved the cupcakes! We had a wedding cake for us to cut and eat and then cupcakes for everyone else. Our flavors were lemon blueberry, cookies & cream, white chocolate raspberry, and coconut almond.
Crystal was amazing. She was super friendly, very accommodating, and she makes damn good cake!
Crystal was fantastic! We wanted a simple wedding cake with sheet cakes in the back and she was able to provide this. Her buttercream is to die for and everyone loved the peach cob...
bler and almond flavors that we picked. It was hard picking because she had so many good flavors to choose from! Her pricing is very reasonable and she made the cake look exactly how we described it. Would recommend Crystal in a heartbeat!
McIntyre
Crystal was amazing to work with from start to finish! Her attention to detail and flexibility will calm your little bridal heart! Not to mention her cakes are absolutely GORGEOUS ...
and DELICIOUS! We had sooooo many compliments! The delivery was painless, my beautiful cake just showed up in tip top shape! Couldn't have asked for a better experience! Thanks Crystal!
Absolutely loved the cake Crystal made for our wedding reception. Not only was it stunning to look at but it was delicious! In addition to the perfect wedding cake, Crystal was eas...
y to get in touch with and work with. I would highly recommend her cakes to anyone!
We had a cake tasting with 2 places for my daughters wedding 2 weeks ago. Both were picked based on their reviews. After the tastings, Crystal was the clear choice, her flavors we...
re phenomiminal! My daughter had 3 flavors at her wedding, white chocolate raspberry, lemon blueberry, and pumpkin and they were all fabulous! (Highly recommend the pumpkin for a fall wedding!) Her cakes are so moist and her Swiss buttercream is delicious! We also had a family/ friends cookie table at the wedding with a couple thousand cookies. I honestly expected to have lots of cake left over with
all the desserts available, but it was almost all gone......everyone loved her cakes! Crystal was so easy to work with and her cakes speak for themselves. I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a wedding cake or cake for a special event!
Crystal was fantastic. We had cupcakes as well as a cake, both tasted great. We got SO many compliments. She came and set everything up and made it look so nice. I was so happy wit...
h how everything came out.
Our previous cake baker fell through and we were left having to find someone else. I had heard such great things about Crystal and her cakes, so we decided to set up a tasting. Her...
cakes are delicious and so beautiful! We wanted something very simple and tasty.. and she did just that. Prices were very reasonable as well, which is always a plus!! I would 100% recommend Cakes Creatively by Crystal!!!
Crystal did an amazing job! The cake looked and tasted amazing.
Crystal made such a beautiful cake and everyone loved the flavors and decoration in the cake. It was gorgeous and had such great details. She made a wonderful cake and made it so e...
asy to get in touch with her if needed and answered emails so quickly. If I had the chance to do it again I would pick her again to make my cake it was so wonderful.
Crystal is wonderful! Such a down-to-earth mom and amazing at what she does! Her work on our wedding cake was fabulous. She stayed in contact with me and showed up promptly before ...
the wedding to set the cake up and add the flowers we provided. Her prices are actually very reasonable, which was a huge bonus! I would highly recommend Cakes Creatively to anybody!
I was looking for a place that offered affordable and that I can still get everything I wanted. I can say crystal did that and more. With everything we have to worry about on the w...
onderful day my cake was not on that list. We met in public place. She was very professional. Everyone at the reception loves the quality of the cake. I am so happy I found her. She did an awesome job!!
We are still craving our wonderful wedding cake!We may break into our anniversary cake early! Cakes Creatively by Crystal truly makes the best cake we have ever had, and on our wed...
ding day our guests agreed! Crystal was extremely helpful during the planning process and let us do not one tasting, but two! When we couldn't decide on flavors she came up with creative ways to incorporate all of our favorites! Her designs are beautiful and the personalized service can not be beat! Thank you again Crystal for providing us with the most delicious and beautiful treat to seal the deal on our big day!
Our two-tiered wedding cake was beautiful, Crystal did a fantastic job! We had two different flavors and both were delicious and the buttercream was amazing. We are so pleased we w...
ent with her to make our wedding cake!
The cake was absolutely delicious and beautiful! We offered the almond, strawberry, chocolate (with raspberry filling), and lemon blueberry. The frosting was so good: tasty and ...
creamy, but not too rich. All of our guests told us that the cake was delicious! The decorating was gorgeous and we're so glad we went with Crystal!
Cakes Creatively by Crystal made me cupcakes, cake pops and a cake for our wedding! It was DELICIOUS and beautiful! People came up for seconds and we didn’t have any left overs!
I...
HIGHLY RECOMMEND Cakes Creatively by Crystal! She was great, her cakes/cupcakes/cake pops were great, and I would use her again in a heartbeat!
I loved the cake we got from Crystal. She let us do several different flavors and was happy to make the chocolate covered strawberries I requested. We got so many complements on bo...
th the look and taste of the cake. I would highly recommend her. She listened to what we wanted and made suggestions to help us achieve our vision. She was a pleasure to work with.
Cakes Creatively by Crystal is a wonderful choice. We had her make our wedding cake for a wedding at the Franklin Park Conservatory. She met with us in person letting us know all o...
f our option both for the cake and the design and she made us a three tier cake that she then placed flowers on as requested. The cake was delicious and it looked phenomenal. Crystal is a delight to work with. She is professional, pleasant, communicative, and helpful. And we could not have been happier with the final product. It was amazing and we were delighted. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a cake for a wedding or special event.
Cakes Creatively by Crystal was incredible!!! Crystal was so wonderful to work with and her cake is amazing!! She brought lots of options to the tasting so that we could be sure of...
what we wanted. She was also able to perfectly recreate the picture of the cake I showed her. She was very easy to get ahold of and schedule meetings with. I highly recommend her to any bride looking for a wedding cake!!
Cakes Creatively by Crystal was amazing! We tried several bakers and her icing and flavors were the best. The icing on her cakes were the best by far, not too grainy or sugary. She...
also did an amazing job on the decorations for our cake, it turned out so perfect based on what we wanted. All our guests loved the cake. It was amazing and I would defiantly get cake from Crystal again!
Beautiful! Crystal made the most perfect cake and it was absolutely as we had dreamed. Not only was it beautiful but it was delicious too!!! I would highly recommend her cakes for ...
any occasion!! Thank you for making our day brighter!
The cake was delicious and beautiful. It was decorated just as we had discussed and Crystal worked well with our florist to incorporate the flowers into the decoration. We had mult...
iple compliments on the flavors of cake that we had!
From the very first time we met Crystal, she was so personable and attentive. We knew we were looking for someone like her to make our wedding cake...and that was before we tried h...
er delicious cakes. The European buttercream was exactly the right amount of sweet and it truly made Crystal’s cakes stand out from the other ones we tried. We ended up doing a 3 tiered cake with a mix of flavors and fillings since we loved so many of the flavors. I wanted our cake to tie in with the rest of the fall themed wedding decor and so, Crystal decorated the cake beautifully with fresh flowers—it was a huge hit!
Crystal did an awesome job with our cake. It was exactly what we wanted and tasted great. She was easy to communicate with and made sure our cake was set up and ready to for our re...
ception.
Crystal worked with us from the day of the cake tasting to the day of the wedding to make our cakes a perfect execution of our vision.
Crystal was easy to work with and was respons...
ive to all of our questions. Her cakes were a big hit at our wedding! The flavors of cake that she offers are unique and delicious. The bridal cake turned out beautifully. And she even created a personalized Groom's cake that made our special day that much more special.
Crystal was so easy to work with and she made my cake look gorgeous! Not to mention it was delicious and my guests loved it and asked for leftovers :)
Crystal was great to work with and the cake turned out amazing! Tasted great and looked just as good, we got comments all night about it and several people asking who did for their...
own events. Definitely recommend!
Everyone of our guests at our wedding kept raving about the cake! Rick and myself loved it from the tasting and on the day of the wedding it was perfect! Crystal made the cake that...
Rick and I envisioned and it was everything we could have asked for and more!!
Our Mocha wedding cake with Chocolate buttercream was so moist and chocolaty. We had so many compliments from our guests. Crystal was so easy to work with too. Worth every penny, a...
nd it didn't break the bank either!!!
Crystal did a fantastic job for our wedding. She was very helpful and provided us with a ton of options when we were looking into the cakes for our wedding. We had five awesome fla...
vors and it's also important to state how amazing the buttercream frosting was. Pretty much the best frosting ever.
amazing all around!
crystal was such a pleasure to work with and the cake was exactly what we wanted. the flavors we’re outstanding & our guest loved everything about the cake. hi...
ghly recommend for any event!
We absolutely LOVED working with Crystal. We taste tested numerous cakes at bakeries all around the Columbus area and Crystal was hands down the best. The flavors were amazing and ...
she was able to bring our vision to life. She had so many photos of different cakes to help us narrow down the design we wanted and we couldn't have been happier with the end result. Our guests raved about the cake and I still have dreams about it! It was so good we couldn't wait until our 1 year anniversary to eat the topper...we ate it that night in our hotel room and the following day! Seriously, best decision ever. LOVE Crystal!
My husband and I had a wonderful experience using Cakes Creatively by Crystal for our wedding. We got married on 9/8/17 and were over the moon with how great the cake turned out. C...
rystal is very personable and accommodating. We had our wedding outdoors, and many of the big-name or chain bakeries we had tastings with would not allow us to use buttercream icing. They said since the reception will be outdoors, the buttercream would not hold up in the potential heat. However, Crystal was very accommodating and stated that she could deliver the cake and it could be stored in the kitchen of the venue, if necessary, so that I would be able to have the icing I wanted. Also, her icing is to die for!! It is so light like whipped icing but has all the flavor of buttercream and just melts in your mouth. Even my brother who claims to dislike cake was surprised to find that he really liked the one we had made by Crystal. I highly recommend this small business that has a really big taste!! Cakes Creatively by Crystal helped make our special day perfect!
Crystal did an amazing job with our cake. We live in Oregon and she was very flexible in working with us online and doing tastings with our family members instead of us. We asked h...
er to create a new design for us and she did it flawlessly, with a beautiful cake stand. The cake tasted delicious too! She also gave us tasty mini cheesecakes with strawberries. Best bang for your buck.
Crystal was wonderful, she made my dream wedding cake come to life! Our guests loved it & even though we didnt get to eat much of it, it was so tasty!
Crystal was super amazing! She was so helpful to me through the wedding planning process and did a fantastic job on our cake! It was beautiful, delicious, and we received tons of c...
ompliments! Would definitely recommend to anyone planning their wedding! :)
We were extremely pleased with Crystal's beautiful work. Not only was our cake very tasty but perfectly made. She offered a great suggestion that included cupcakes with different f...
lavors--which was a HIT at our wedding. We met once for a tasting; then, Crystal sent us a link to a website to help with planning how many cupcakes we needed. (We live about 2 hrs away and work the night shift, so this type of planning/communication worked perfect for us). We appreciated her professionalism and efficiency VERY MUCH, considering we planned our wedding in just 3 months! I'd highly recommend her to any of our closest friends and family.
Contact
194 W Church Street, Pickerington, OH
Cakes Creatively by Crystal