About this vendor
Calandra’s Bakery is a company based in Caldwell, NJ that specializes in creating custom wedding cakes. Their experienced bakers are experts at understanding your vision and transforming it into your dream cake. This dedicated team will work with you throughout the experience to ensure a stress-free process and a one-of-a-kind cake for your special day.
Calandra’s Bakery was established in 1962 and is still a community favorite in Caldwell. This family-owned Italian business operates on a foundation of high-quality customer service and unforgettable, made-from-scratch goods. David, the executive pastry chef, oversees the preparation of each baked good to ensure it is up to their standard of quality.
Calandra’s Bakery specializes in crafting stunning wedding cakes that are sure to leave a lasting impression on all in attendance. They offer a complimentary consultation and tasting so you can sample your favorite flavors and discuss your ideas. You can bring photos of cakes that inspire you or incorporate your wedding color palette into your design. This team will then handcraft a custom cake that looks as good as it tastes.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
- Other Desserts
Awards and Affiliations
7-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2026.2025.2024.+4 more.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Hall of Fame
Earned by winning 'Best of Weddings' four or more times.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.090 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
We had a great experience with Calandra's Bakery for our wedding cake. The sales team was responsive, organized, and easy to work with throughout the planning process. Our cake loo...
ked beautiful, tasted delicious, and received many compliments from our guests. Everything went smoothly, and we were very happy with the final result. We'd gladly recommend them to other couples planning their wedding!
The cake was absolutely delicious and beautifully piped. Our cake ended up being included in our venue cost, so we didn't pay any additional money for it.
We used Calandra’s Bakery in Caldwell for our wedding cake in November 2025. They worked with us to pick the perfect cake for our celebration. Their tasting process was so easy and...
fun! Our guests we so impressed with the taste and appearance of the cake. We loved how it turned out, from the icing to the flowers and the filling, it was a perfect wedding cake for a perfect night. All photos credited to Brad Resnick Photography (https://bradresnick.com/)
Choosing our cake with Calandra’s bakery was a no-brainer! Their company was included in our package with Hudson House and we appreciated the in-person tasting and designing sessio...
n. Although we went with a classic vanilla cake and chocolate fudge, all of their cake flavors were delicious! The designing session was quick and easy and we were able to slightly edit an existing design with no issue! Since Calandra’s works regularly with Landmark locations, we knew there would be no problem with their collaboration. Our cake was beautiful on the day of and an even sweeter treat to enjoy! Definitely recommend Calandra’s for your wedding cake needs!
We used the Madison hotel connection of Calandra's Bakery, and received lots of compliments on the cake. We did not do a tasting. We picked out everything over a phone call / email...
. And, went with a standard option (no up-charge). It was difficult to get in touch with them, but I can assure you that everything worked out! So for those that are stressing, do not stress!
Our venue included a cake with one of their preferred bakeries and we chose Calandra’s. The tasting was great, it was in person and there were over 26 different variations to test ...
out. We chose a 3-tier cake: 1 layer of chocolate with chocolate mousse, 1 with vanilla and Italian custard, and 1 with chocolate with Italian custard. There were also many different style options to choose from! My husband and I of course only ate a bite or two during our reception, but according to our guests it was delicious 😅 our venue packed up the top tier for us to take home so can’t wait to eat it for our 1st anniversary!!
The most delicious cake ever!!!!! This process was so simple and fun! We went to calandras a few months prior to the wedding. They provide multiple flavors and options to taste tes...
t! I can’t wait until our one year anniversary to eat the rest of the cake!!
Ordering for our wedding was overly complicated. Asked for pricing and quantities for pastries and cookies, and even sent an itemized estimate myself, but couldn’t get a straight a...
nswer. Placed the order by phone and then they still had the wrong order written on the receipt. Then placed the order for 150 pastries and 4lbs of cookies and it did not all arrive. Additionally be careful about timing if doing delivery - my wedding cake and order arrived 2.5 hours after their stated delivery time. I had to spend time at my wedding reception tracking down the delivery. They didn’t even reach out to let us know it was going to be late. Honestly disappointing and uneccesarily stressful for such a reputable company. For a $1k+ order we expected better service.
Our cake was amazing! The communication with the bakery was a little difficult to schedule a tasting but overall we wouldn’t change a thing.
My husband & I loved how our wedding cake looked & tasted! Calandra's worked with us to create a floral design with purple & gold, that wasn't too flashy & looked like a spring wed...
ding cake. The raspberry mousse with cookies & cream in the separate tiers were delicious!
Our wedding cake was stunning! The cake tasting process was so fun, and the team was so easy to work with!
We were able to choose between Calandra’s and another bakery for our cake included with our venue- it was a no brainer for us. We’ve had Calandra’s wedding cakes a number of times-...
each time it’s beyond fresh and absolutely delicious. We did one layer chocolate cake with fresh strawberries and custard filling and two layers vanilla cake with cannoli filling. Both were beyond amazing. It was also so beautiful and exactly what we asked for!
We got our wedding cake from Calandra's Bakery. They have so many flavors to choose from, and their cakes are magnificent works of art! We got a four tier cake to feed 250 people...
. We had such a good time at our tasting, sampling all the different flavor combinations, and enjoying some complimentary coffee. The flavors we chose were vanilla cake with chocolate pudding, chocolate and vanilla cake with Italian custard and strawberries, and chocolate cake with dulce de leche. Their dulce de leche is the best I have ever tasted! Designing the cake was super easy and so fun! If you want a cake that not only looks spectacular, but tastes just as good, Calandra's is it!
The bakery was very easy to work with and the cake tasted amazing. We chose different flavors for each tier and felt they were all amazing. Our venue has a partnership with Calan...
dra's Bakery so most of the cost of the cake was covered by our contract with the venue. We only separately paid for the flowers and the strawberries in our bottom tier.
Calandra's was excellent. Their cake tasting was easy and fun with a lot of variety. The cake turned out beautiful and the process was seamless.
Calandra’s wedding cake tasting was easy & fun. They offer a variety of flavors to choose from, giving you a lot of ideas. We went with a vanilla cake with custard and fresh strawb...
erries for our wedding day & it was the cake of our dreams! The cake was delicious, and we received so many compliments on it. Ayla was great to work with and answered all questions in a timely manner. We cannot wait to enjoy our cake on our first anniversary next year, too!
Out cake was so good I could eat it every day. Normally wedding cake is just eh, but EVERY ONE said ours was so good. We ordered vanilla cake with Italian custard, strawberries, an...
d vanilla buttercream. The tasting was awesome because you get to try so many flavors (we didn't finish, we were so full) and there are so many standard cake design options to choose from. Calandra's was better than any other bakery we tried by far - you cannot beat their flavor!
We couldn’t be happier with the cake from Calandra's! From start to finish, the experience was wonderful. They were incredibly responsive, easy to work with, and really helped us b...
ring our vision to life. We wanted a cake that was not only beautiful but also reflected our style and taste, and they absolutely delivered. It was exactly what we dreamed of!
Our guests were raving about both how gorgeous the cake was and how delicious it tasted. So many of them said it was the best wedding cake they’ve ever had!
Additionally, we had a bit of a mishap on the day of our cake trial—we got lost and ended up arriving 30 minutes late. We felt awful, but they were so kind and gracious about it, and still gave us a warm, welcoming experience. The cake tasting itself was a highlight of the process, and the service was top-notch.
We highly recommend Calandra's for anyone looking for not only a stunning cake but also a wonderful experience from start to finish!
I tried a cake tasting with my other bride friend and I couldn't help but use them for my cake tasting. Just like the first it was mesmerizing with the flavors they had to offer! T...
hey made our cake just as we wanted and delivered all the way from jersey. Everyone RAVED about the cake and is still talking about it! Thank you so much! You guys are life savers!
Daniel and I had the best time cake testing at Calandras! It was a fun experience and filling to say the least. We worked with a great team who was so detailed to capture a beautif...
ul wedding cake, tasty too!
Thank you for designing our wedding cake!
K & D 08.10.24
We had our cake tasting at Calandra's which was so much fun! They had so many flavors to choose from. We ultimately just picked the chocolate mouse and vanilla whipped cream to b...
e neutral for our guests but we were very happy with our cake overall. They delivered on time and were very easy to work with.
We loved every part of our cake tasting experience. From the hot coffee to the cake tasting platter, we enjoyed sampling every single offering. Once we were ready to discuss, we sa...
t down with an event coordinator to plan out our cake. We were given helpful ideas and lots of time to decide. Our wedding was at Nanina’s in the Park and the cake sat beautifully on the gold cake platter in the ballroom. It was the perfect addition to our wedding day. Just remember to book your appointment early, there is a reason they book up fast!
We were absolutely delighted with the wedding cake from Calandra’s Bakery. From the initial consultation to the final product, Calandra’s was professional, creative, and attentive ...
to our vision. The cake exceeded all our expectations. It was a stunning centerpiece that perfectly matched our wedding theme and decor. The attention to detail was remarkable, from the intricate sugar flowers to the flawless icing. Our guests were in awe of its beauty and elegance.
We received countless compliments from our guests, many of whom said it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted. The cake was not only a visual masterpiece but also a culinary delight that added a special touch to our celebration.
Thank you, Calandra’s Bakery for creating a wedding cake that we will always remember with joy and gratitude.
Choosing Calandra's Bakery for our wedding was one of our best decisions! From start to finish, their professionalism and attention to detail were outstanding. They went above and ...
beyond to make our special day perfect. The quality of their cake exceeded our expectations, and their team's friendly demeanor made working with them a joy. Our guests were thoroughly impressed, and we couldn't be happier with the results. Thank you, for helping to make our wedding dreams come true!
Calandra's made the wedding cake process so easy. Their cakes are absolutely delicious and not overly sweet. As a couple who aren't big cake people we wanted something that wouldn'...
t be too sweet and Calandra's cakes were perfect. Our cake was absolutely stunning. I knew exactly what design I wanted going into our meeting and they brought it to life. Not only was the cake beautiful but I have heard from multiple people that it was delicious and it was the first time that they had a wedding cake that wasn't dry. Looking forward to our one year anniversary so we can eat our top tier!
Our cake was included with our venue, but we couldn't have been happier with Calandra's Bakery! From the tasting to the final product, they were incredibly accommodating and profes...
sional. We didn't have a solid plan on cake design but they guided us to something we absolutely adored. Our cake ended up coming out so beautiful and delicious!
My wedding cake was delicious and decorated beautifully by them. It was 3 tiers and we chose cannoli flavor. It was fun to come in person to do the cake tasting with my husband as ...
well.
we had two bakeries to choose from that was included with our venue and we’re so happy we went with Calandras! First of all, driving up to their bakery is like a dream! They have t...
heir own little plaza because they also have a restaurant side. We booked the Sweet Suite for our tasting (which was not expensive at all!). It’s a private area for you and your partner to enjoy the cake tasting and it also includes champagne, or wine! Ohhh so many cakes to taste and all delicious! We went with chocolate cake and cannoli filling. We didn’t want to go to crazy with the design, and they were so understanding and helped designed the cake how WE wanted it, not the other way around. I would suggest just stopping by there to get pastries because it’s that good!!
Going to our cake tasting we didn't really know what flavor we wanted. There were so many options and they all tasted so good! I'm normally not a caramel fan but the chocolate cake...
with caramel filling really won me over. My husband and I were in the reception space when the cake got delivered and it looked better than I imagined! While at the cake tasting we sent them pictures of my bouquet and cake inspiration we found online, and they really gave us exactly what we wanted. The cake tasted so fresh and I could not be happier!
Calandra’s Bakery was great with the cake tasting and helping me create the cake I wanted for my wedding. I was so happy with how the cake turned out, it looked beautiful and taste...
d amazing. Guests were telling me how good the cake was. I am looking forward to having the top tier at our 1 year anniversary!
Calandras bakery did a phenomenal job with our cake! We had a three tier wedding cake with our three favorite flavors from the cake tasting. The cake tasting platter was awesome an...
d they were patient with us while we decided how to design our cake. We gave them two custom figurines of our dogs and they were more than happy to include them on our cake! If you hire them for your wedding cake needs, then you can trust that you are in talented and capable hands! Thanks again!
Delicious wedding cake! The cake tasting was so fun.
This is the cake company of venue works with so we didn’t search through other vendors to find them. The cake the day of was lovely and delicious! We had 3 tiered cake a different ...
filling in each tier. They offer a tasting which I highly recommend to taste all of the flavors. Any add one and custom fillings like berries were a lot more expensive so we went with a plain cake design and got extra flowers from the florist. Delivered on time and in perfect shape, couldn’t have asked for anything better!
Our wedding cake was delicious! They made the process really easy and fun for us. Each layer of our cake was a different flavor and people remarked that the flavors were tasty and ...
the cake itself was really good.
We used Calandra’s to bake our wedding cake and it was delicious! About 4 months out from our wedding date we went to their bakery for a tasting. We tried almost 20 different combi...
nations of cake/icing! Calandra’s partners with our venue and had a book of cake designs for us to choose from. We went with white cake/buttercream for two of the layers and red velvet with cream cheese frosting for the middle layer. The process was seamless and the cake was delicious! Highly recommend!
Oh my gosh! Finally a wedding cake that looks and tastes amazing! We used Calandra’s for our wedding cake which was chocolate with cannoli filling (amazing) and also for a grooms c...
ake at our rehearsal dinner. The grooms cake was outrageous! An amazing Darth Vader cake (red velvet) that looked incredible and tasted even better. My husband was so surprised and loved his special cake. I find it to be rare when a cake looks AND tastes great and they accomplished it! We are looking forward to visiting on our anniversary for some more cake!
Our cake was beautiful and delicious! 3 tier wedding cake with two layers of vanilla cake with vanilla custard and fresh strawberry filling and one layer chocolcate cake with raspb...
erry preserves filling. The cake tasting at their bakery was out of this world. This is top notch. Don't miss out!!
The cake was a huge hit! The tasting was great and everyone at Calandra's was responsive, professional, and friendly. Made the process super easy, and we are happy to recommend the...
m for any event. Our wedding wouldn't have been the same without their cake!!
Honestly I think the tasting was better than the cake the day of. The price was included in my venue cost so that was nice. I did have to pay $75 for fresh strawberries to be added...
to the bottom layer of my cake. It was just average. I probably should’ve gone with Palermo’s (the other bakery included with my venue).
From the scheduling of our tasting to the day of our event, I was so thrilled to have Calandra’s make our wedding cake!! Aisha and Maria were so easy to work with! Our tasting was ...
so enjoyable, and it was more than we ever expected!! Our selection was loved by all of our guests and it was so fresh and delicious!! The icing on the cake was that Calandra’s included an anniversary cake for our first anniversary!! I would absolutely get another cake from Calandra’s!!!!
We loved our wedding cake from Calandra's! They hosted a wonderful in-person tasting and were so friendly and kind from the moment we walked in the door. The cake was fresh and so ...
delicious! Many of our guests mentioned the cake and how much they enjoyed it. We upgraded to funfetti (amazing decision) and alternated tiers with vanilla & caramel custard. So yummy!
Our venue gave us the choice between Calandra's and Palermo's. We chose Calandra's over Palermo's given the fact that Palermo's has discontinued in-person tastings. We definitely ...
made a solid choice! Aisha and Maria were very welcoming and knowledgeable! From the minute we walked in, they greeted us with unlimited coffee. They had a private table set up for us and gave us all of the time in the world to sample. All of the cakes were so delicious, we had a hard time choosing! In addition, we were not pressured into adding additional items to the cake.
We totally recommend Calandra's!
Jeff and I made an appointment for a cake tasting for our wedding and everything tasted amazing! For our cake, we choose a three tiered cake with vanilla frosting and chocolate fud...
ge frosting! It was the best wedding cake I ever tasted and our wedding guests couldn't stop complimenting on how great our cake was! We had our florist add real flowers to the cake too and it was so beautiful! For our wedding favor, we choose big chocolate chip cookies and they were amazing and a huge hit with all our guests! I highly recommend Calandra's as your wedding cake vendor!
The raspberry preservative filling in our wedding cake was so delicious !!! I’m excited our wedding cake looked just like the inspo picture I showed them and tasted great as well
From the cake tasting to the actual cake on wedding day I could not be happier.
Cake looked and tasted fantastic.
Our wedding cake not only looked magical, but it was absolutely delicious!!!
We booked Calandra's as part of our wedding package through the venue. The tasting experience was wonderful, we went in person and had time to taste and reflect on all the options...
. Working with the staff was simple and easy. Our cake was two flavors with two different fillings (price was all inclusive to our wedding package). We chose a simple design and our florist decorated with flowers. The cake tasted fresh and delicious the day of (and day after) our wedding! Definitely recommend!
Calandra's Bakery made our wedding cake experience both delightful and delicious! Our tasting appointment was very fun - my husband and I brought my dad with us, who enjoyed the va...
riety of cake samples (all of which were very generous portions!). Once we were done tasting the different flavors, we talked through layers and design with Aisha, who made the process so seamless and practically mindless (which we appreciated since our heads were in a million other directions with wedding planning). We ended up with three great layers (cannoli, red velvet and strawberries w/ custard) decorated with cascading sugar flowers, and it was a show-stopper!
Nothing but great things to say about Calandra's Bakery!
Calandra's made two cakes for us - a "Groom's" cake for the rehearsal dinner, and our wedding day cake.
The Groom's cake w...
as perfect! My husband was so excited to see a cake that was designed just for him! He was even more thrilled to see that Calandra's made a mini version of his boat as a cake topper!
Our wedding cake was also stunning! It was the perfect representation of our gold, black, and ivory, "Gatsby" wedding. Both cakes were designed beautifully, and most importantly they were delicious and fresh. Our guests could not believe how great the cake tasted.
Thank you to the Calandra's team for designing the best cakes! We cannot wait to use you guys for all of our future cake needs!
The cake was absolutely delicious!! They made the cake fresh that morning and since they were a vendor included with my venue I didn't have to take care of anything after we went f...
or the tasting which was really nice. If you go for a tasting, go to dinner at their restaurant afterwards or buy some delicious goodies from their market.
Contact
234 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell, NJ
Calandra's Bakery