About this vendor
We just absolutely lovely helping couples make their vision for their wedding desserts a reality! From the initial emails, to consultations, to delivery and display--our goal is to do all we can to understand the image a coupe has in their minds and enable our incredible team to bring that to life.
We believe that wedding cakes shouldn't just be beautiful--they should leave your guests always remembering how amazing they tasted! We are probably best known for our cheesecake and our carrot cake, but we have a bunch of other options that are just as amazing and that will leave your guests wowed!
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Nut Free
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.059 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 3
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Our wedding was during the holidays, meaning Cheesy Edie’s was extremely busy already, but they took such good care of us that you would have thought we were their only customers. The dessert was exceptional, and gorgeous!
We have mixed feelings. As far as the quality of the cheesecake and appearance, it was excellent!! My husband and I loved the bourbon cheesecake we picked, it was delicious. The texture and taste were second to none, everyone loved it.
As for the professionalism of Kristi Cain, the only wedding coordinator, we were less than impressed. We had numerous phone calls to plan, as we live states away. She refused to give us a brochure/packet of information right away, and designed a cake out of our budget. We planned a wedding selection to taste, and had a variety of options she said were great. We picked our favorite, only to learn on a later phone call that we could not have that cake because it could not be frosted..why were we told it was a wedding option then, we don't know. When confronted about the lack of details and struggling to understand, she got snappy saying "they might not be able to work with us if we want this vision or that etc". My husband and I were extremely flexible, and had to repeatedly say we did not care about the details, a couple of flowers on a white frosted cheesecake would make us happy. She did not seem happy. Overall, we had the feeling this woman just wanted to take our money, she didn't want to help us on our wedding day.
Overall, if you're able to pick up a cake yourself, I say go for it. If you want a wedding cake, I'd go in person for an appointment with a clear vision, and demand pricing up front, because after much pushing, she does eventually give out the menu options with pricing.
I’ve always wanted a cheesy Eddie’s cheesecake at my wedding. They did not disappoint. All three cakes were deliciously excellent.
The folks at Cheesy Eddie’s were very easy to work with - we chose an assortment of cupcakes and cheesecake blooms in lieu of a cake for our wedding (~110 guests). They provided a lot of detail right at the outset about our options, and offered tasting boxes so that we could make informed decisions - these didn’t include our seasonal fall options (pumpkin, apple caramel, and s’mores) at the time, but it worked out great! They have many different offerings for flavors and it seems that you couldn’t go wrong choosing any of them. The cheesecake blooms were a huge hit. Guests raved about how delicious everything was. We were a little worried about having too many items leftover, but that proved not to be a problem!
This is where you go when you want the best, and they delivered!
Everything was great except that our cake was leaning for most of the night, so much so that we ended up cutting the cake earlier than planned. Cheesy Eddie's reminded us when we choose our flavors for the show cake tiers (we had 2) that one was heavier than the other (vanilla vs raspberry creme), we told them to make the lighter one on top, but I'm not sure if they did. I also know that the heat in our vendor may have been a little higher than it should so it's hard to say who's fault it was.
I knew I wanted Cheesy Eddie's carrot cake for our wedding as it's my favorite of all time. They were extremely professional and easy to work with. The cake turned out beautifully and was delicious!!
We had Cheesy Eddie's do our cake and desserts! we got a cutting cake, cupcakes, and cheesecake blooms and they were absolutely delicious! The design of the cake was exactly what I asked for, and the blooms were to die for!
My husband loves to bake, so desserts were an important part of our wedding. We tried a few bakeries around Rochester and were blown away by the cakes and cheesecakes at Cheesy Eddies. We went with a dessert table with several kinds of mini cheesecakes, mini cupcakes and cookie sandwiches. They were able to customize our order to give us exactly what we wanted and accommodate our gluten-free needs. They also had display stands for us to rent which made our lives SO much easier.
They did our wedding in July! They were incredible to work with in planning, and have a great tasting box setup. Delivery was seamless and the desserts were incredible. They have displays available for rental though we opted to buy our own. For a 200 person wedding, we did the two tier carrot cutting cake (kept the top for anniversary and sliced up the bottom for guests), and 400 total mini desserts (100 each of bourbon caramel cheesecake, red velvet, original cheesecake, and peanut butter ganache brownie). I wish we had done about 50 more, they were so popular!
Everyone I know LOVES Cheesy Eddie’s, people at our wedding were so impressed with the plain cheesecake we had, and it was overall a big hit! They also did very well with the designs we chose, it was perfect for us!
A Rochester classic! Our guests loved the cheesecake and chocolate cake. So many people told me they had both- I’m glad we ordered extra because there was not one slice left! Our cake was beautiful as well, exactly as discussed.
Cheesy Eddie's did an excellent job working with us on a unique design for our cake. Not only was the cake stunning, it was also delicious (style and substance, as Paul Hollywood would say)! Their whole team was very easy to work with. I'd recommend them highly!
From the tasting to the day of the event, the staff was so helpful in helping us pick flavors and decide on displays. The cupcakes and cake we got were out of this world and were a huge hit with our guests. All of our desserts were gone by the end of the night and my guests are still raving over the pumpkin cheesecake blooms!
We went with Cheesy Eddie’s for our wedding cake, as well as cupcakes and dessert trays for the reception. Our guests loved the cupcakes and treats, we received so many compliments! Cheesy Eddie’s was very easy to work with, with great price points and quality. Our wedding cake was beautiful, and everything was delicious!
Cheesy Eddie's is one of my wife's favorite bakeries, so it was an easy choice when we decided to get our wedding cake. They certainly didn't disappoint! The cakes we had were both beautiful and delicious. We got a lot of compliments from our guests.
My husband and I aren’t fans of typical wedding cakes, so we used Cheesy Eddie’s for our dessert at our wedding and they were by far the least stressful part of my wedding planning. Lindsy was so incredibly helpful at getting us exactly what we wanted for our main cake and the mini desserts that we had for our guests. I can’t recommend them enough!
I honestly don't know where to begin...from the first email to schedule a tasting until the end of our wedding we had nothing but the best experience. Lindsy was beyond amazing, my husband and I fell in love with her warm and caring personality immediately. She guided us through the process of picking out the perfect cakes for our wedding. We went with a 3 tier naked cake, 2 tiers were carrot and the other chocolate with a cream cheese frosting. In addition we had a cheese cake kitchen cake that was amazing. Lindsy and her husband saw to it that our wedding cake made it to our farm (where we had our wedding) in one piece :). At our request Lindsy and her husband stuck around most of the night to help our guest, cut and serve cake and to be a part of our family that night. The professionalism that Lindsy upheld was just phenomenal. If you have the pleasure of her being your day of coordinator, then you're in for a real treat.
As for the cakes themselves; the taste of the carrot and cheese cake is like no other. I honestly don't think there is a bakery in town that can even come close. The frosting is sweet and full of flavor but not too heavy either. The carrot, chocolate and cheese cake are just amazing. The presentation of all of it, the way Lindsy decorated my cake, the complements from all of our guest was just outstanding.
Should you choose Cheesy Eddie's? 1000% YES!
Two words: OMG YUM. Cheesy Eddie’s was incredible to work with. Lindsy is the sweetest & most genuine person you’ll talk to, in hopes of only making your dream cake come to life. After our original cake was put on hold until next year, she helped us craft a smaller cake for this year and it was absolutely stunning and incredibly delicious. We had carrot cake, cheesecake, very vanilla, & chocolate and every single bite of everyone was amazing. Our guests ate every last bite and each one commented on how beautiful it all looked! Thank you Lindsy for being so accommodating, helping us craft the perfect scenarios for both years, & for being there for us during this time! We cannot wait to work with you again next year ❤️
Cheesy Eddies did a phenomenal job understanding our vision for the wedding. Lindsy is amazing and really understands how to make a dream a reality and get things done on time and making us feel comfortable in the process. We started by thinking we wanted minis but ended up with classic cakes. ALL of their options are great and the hardest part was narrowing down all the great flavors. I would recommend Cheesy Eddies to anyone and rave about them any chance I get. They really made our day.
I have been fond of Cheesy Eddie’s for quite some time and they were an easy choice when it came to deserts for our wedding. We went with our favorite options: raspberry swirl and original cheesecake, and the miniature jillian’s delight cookies. For our cutting cake, we chose the white raspberry torte cake. Lindsy, the wedding consultant at Cheesy Eddie’s, is lovely, creative, helpful, and knowledgeable about all things wedding. For example, we had a hard time deciding between two different designs for the cutting cake. Lindsy was able to incorporate both ideas to make a beautiful and unique design. The team there executed the idea flawlessly and every bite was delicious. Additionally, Lindsy was cautious of our budget and the vision we had for our day. This all being said, I was a “covid bride” and Lindsy handled the last minute changes, alterations, and ever evolving protocols with grace and without placing any pressure on me. Lindsy also handled the set-up and instruction to vendor staff flawlessly on the day of. We are so grateful for all that Lindsy and the Cheesy Eddie’s team did to make our wedding day wonderful.
When our original pastry chef had to back out because she was having health issues, Cheesy Eddies really saved the day! We ended up going with a small cutting cheesecake and 40 assorted cupcakes. The cupcakes were a huge hit!! Everyone raved over them (especially the s’mores one)! Our cheesecake was chocolate raspberry swirl and it was the best cheesecake I’ve ever had! We rented cake stands through them and overall their pricing is extremely reasonable.
Ever since the wedding we keep going back and trying new amazing desserts!
We LOVE Cheesy Eddie’s! They were so accommodating and helpful! Lindsay walked us through the whole process and really made us feel heard and respected.
We now buy all our cakes from Cheesy Eddie’s! They are seriously the best!
We were so happy we chose Cheesy Eddie's for our wedding desserts! The cutting cake and cupcakes we had were delicious - our guests loved them! Lindsy was fantastic to work with planning the order for our special day. We will definitely be using Cheesy Eddie's for other events in the future!
Lindsy was very helpful! She saw our vision and was able to give us exactly what we wanted on our wedding day! Everything was beautiful and delicious! Would definitely recommend!
I had Cheesy Eddie's make my wedding cake and cupcakes! They were fantastic! Everyone kept commenting on how amazing they tasted! The staff is so sweet and helpful. It was a great stress reliever to know my wedding day was in good hands. Thank you for being awesome!
Cheesy Eddie's made my wedding cake and it was absolutely perfect! Lindsy made the entire process a lot easier for me by helping me to find design ideas and sending options for decor pieces. The cake ended up more beautiful than I had imagined and I received so many compliments on how it looked and tasted. Cheesy Eddie's is by far the most delicious bakery in town!
My husband and I chose Cheesy Eddie's to make our wedding cake for our wedding on August 10, 2019. We first lived together in the South Wedge of Rochester and we wanted all aspects of our wedding to be very meaningful and close to home, so choosing Cheesy Eddie's was a no brainer - not to mention all of their cakes and desserts are AMAZING!!
Working with Lindsy was easy from the get go. She is friendly, professional, supportive, and responsive. I was able to make changes after our initial meeting very easily and communication via email was seamless. Our four tier cake was beautiful and just what I had envisioned. The cake was of course delicious and we received many comments from guests along the lines of "This was the best wedding cake ever".
I want to give Cheesy Eddie's a five star review so badly but unfortunately I can not because of one unfortunate mishap that occurred on our wedding day (that I luckily did not know about until afterwards). Lindsay was sadly out of town for a family emergency on the weekend of our wedding so her assistants were in charge of our wedding. We had ordered a four tier cake and one and a half kitchen cakes based on our number of guests - the tier cake being three different flavors and the kitchen cakes being a fourth. However, they forget to make and/or deliver the kitchen cakes. Luckily our wedding coordinator noticed before cutting the tier cake and cut our cake in very small pieces to feed all of our guests. It all worked out, however we were very disappointed to learn of this afterwards. Cheesy Eddie's and Lindsy were very upset to learn of this as well - they contacted me multiple times to apologize and quickly gave me a refund for my cakes as well as a gift card which was very nice. Although this was unfortunate and should not have happened, I do not have anything bad to say about Cheesy Eddie's and will definitely do business there again!
Cheesy Eddie's did the cupcakes and small cake for our wedding. Not only were they absolutely delicious, everything looked GORGEOUS. They were a pleasure to work with and very accommodating to some last minute changes. They captured what I envisioned for our dessert table perfectly. I would highly recommend!!
Their desserts were a huge hit at our wedding and we loved our carrot cake wedding cake! We could not have asked for a better dessert vendor!
Cheesy eddies was so easy to work with and so delicious! We got a bunch of “minis” and they were a HIT. The jack and Jill sandwich cookies are to die for and people are still talking about them to this day!
Very high quality desserts were the perfect compliment to our wedding cake. Our guests enjoyed them so much there were none left over. It was great working with such friendly and professional people.
Cheesy Eddies was amazing for our small wedding! Lindsy went above and beyond for us, we definitely recommend them to anyone and everyone!
We decided not to go with the traditional wedding cake at our wedding and chose Cheesy Eddie's instead. We ordered their large carrot cake and lots and lots of mini cheesecakes and pastries. All were delicious and our guests were ecstatic. Cheesy Eddie's was also able to provide non-crust alternatives (gluten free) for some pastries which allowed all the guest to partake in the goodies. Lindsy was a pleasure to deal with and everything was perfect (including the delivery to our event).
The best cake I have ever tasted! So many flavors to choose from and they were all delicious. I submitted a photo of a simple cake that I envisioned and they recreated it perfectly!
We did not go with a huge, multi-tiered cake, but rather something simpler. Cheesy Eddies worked with us to have the perfect cake options for our needs and budget. We had a gorgeous 2 tired cake for cutting and then some extra kitchen cakes to get extra servings. Everything was beautiful and delicious. All of our guests raved about how good the cake was!
Cheesy Eddie's was very easy to work with when choosing our wedding cake. They designed our cake exactly how we asked, and each layer (which was a differently flavor) was DELICIOUS! We received so many compliments from guests. They also provide you with a coupon for a fresh cake on your one year anniversary, which is so thoughtful. I would highly recommend choosing Cheesy Eddie's if you are planning a wedding in the Rochester area!!
I have loved Cheesy Eddie's cheesecake for as long as I can remember so it made sense to have it at my wedding! They made an incredible cake! We had their famous chocolate cake and original cheesecake with extra "kitchen" cakes of their carrot cake. My guests could not get enough of it! Not to mention how gorgeous the cake looked!
We were a bit last minute with booking as well but they made sure that all of our wishes were met! Would recommend them to anyone who wants delicious cake that their guests will be talking about!
The cheesecakes were super delicious and beautiful! We loved having these treats from our favorite bakery in the area. They were also willing to work with us and allowed us to pick up the cakes the day before the wedding to reduce the amount of running around on the day of.
Best carrot cake in town. They also served chocolate and white cake which was also delicious. Staff was very professional and executed my vision!
Our guests raved about our cake, everyone loved it so much and it was delicious. There are no words to describe what a great experience it was working with Cheesy Eddie's! Lindsy is the wedding coordinator and made the process completely seamless and even set up the cake perfectly with flowers and it looked absolutely beautiful.
If you have tasted Cheesy Eddie's, then you know it's absolutely delicious. The best carrot cake ever!! The first decision we made for our wedding was to book Cheesy Eddie's and we literally signed our contract with them first, before we even officially signed with our venue! So many people said they didn't realize they did Wedding cakes. Best. wedding. cake. ever!!!
We had an amazing experience with Cheesy Eddie's. Their wedding coordinator was so nice and thorough. We had a small cake and a variety of mini desserts which were fantastic. We are never disappointed with Cheesy Eddie's and would recommend them to anyone.
BEST CARROT CAKE IN ROCHESTER. Worth the price!
I can't say enough wonderful things about this bakery! From the planning process to the finished product and great prices, this will always be my recommendation to everyone from now on!!!!!!!!!! Thank you, Cheesy Eddies!
I love Cheesy Eddie's. My husband and I were looking around to find some cake places to try and Cheesy Eddie's won from the list. I love the carrot cake the best! We had a three tiered cake for display and two kitchen cakes. We chose a vanilla cheesecake, carrot cake, and a chocolate cake. Everyone who attended said they enjoyed the desserts so much! I highly recommend.
Best cake I have ever had. Getting a wedding cake was a last minute decision and they didn't miss a beer. It was absolutely perfect.
I have had Cheesy Eddie's and have loved their Carrot Cake for years, so it was a no brainer when we decided to go with carrot cake cupcakes as our dessert for the wedding. We also had a small cutting cake, and everything was perfect as always!
We got the carrot cake as our wedding cake. It was delicious as always but they weren't very helpful with decorating. They were very limited as to what they were willing to do - we even had to supply our own sprinkles. I asked them if they could make cake balls and they said they didn't do anything so trendy - a little snobby if you ask me. Our cake was tasty and pretty, and tiny.
My husband insisted on Cheesy Eddie's doing our cake because their cake tastes amazing. Dealing with the staff is a headache that I don't want to wish on anyone. The consultant we spoke with clearly didn't grasp our vision. Then it was pulling teeth to talk to the decorator directly. She also had trouble with our vision, so I tried to make it really simple. Then, a third person yelled at me two days before the wedding because she had not yet received my check in the mail...although I was the one who had to initiate the final payment (i.e., where do I send it, to whom). Their buttercream frosting and decorations were tasty and natural, but the space was so hot that many of the flowers melted off the cake by the time cake cutting came around. It was tasty though!
We didn't want anything too fancy for our wedding cake. All we wanted was for it to taste amazing. Our white chocolate raspberry cheesecakes and carrot cakes with cheesecake frosting were SO good!! And the three display cakes looked simple and beautiful (We had the rest in the back in larger portions.) Cheesy Eddie's did an excellent job!
I am born and raised in Rochester, NY. I was raised on Cheesy Eddie's Cheesecake and have grown to know the baker's as customer's of my family business and am proud to call them friends. About 80% of my guests were from out of town and I received countless compliments on our wedding cake. I needed a cake to feed 200 people and the cake I had dreamed of had never been done before. The baker's took a chance on making the 4 tiered, square cheesecake that I had envisioned. They called to keep me posted on their progress of the attempts and they succeeded.
My cake was absolutely STUNNING. I had a 4 tiered cheescake with 4 different flavors to feed 200, a carrott cake to feed 50 and chocolate covered strawberries as our cake toppers that resembled a bride and groom. The cose was $765 total. Very impressed, VERY PLESAED
I was looking for something different and I got it! The cake decorating was unbelievable and everyone talked about how delicious the cake was!
Cheesy Eddie's was great to work with. The quality of the product was fantastic and they take great pride in their work. Not only did the cakes look great, they tasted amazing. The cream cheese frosting was a welcome change. Our guests loved the cakes.
ALL I CAN SAY IS WOW!!!!
Cheesy Eddie's did a great job. Please note that they do not make traditional wedding cakes, so if you want that please look else where. Our cake was amazing. Guests are still talking about it! Everyone at Cheesy Eddie's did a great job communicating with me and making me feel very comfortable!! Oh and the cake was delicious.
Everyone LOVED our cake. It was just the right choice for a NY wedding. There was not a crumb to be found.
We had Cheesy Eddie's cheesecake for our wedding. First of all, Colleen was super accomodating and great to work with. The cake was the best cheesecake we have ever had, so good that instead of saving the top layer for our anniversary, we took it on our honeymoon and ate it then. Looking forward to buying another for our first anniversary!
The cheese cake we got for the wedding was amazing. Colleen did a wonderful job of displaying it, it looked beautiful. All the flavors of the cake were delicious and our guests really enjoyed our different type of wedding cake. Plates were cleared
Contact
602 South Ave, Rochester, NY
Cheesy Eddie's's photos