About this vendor
Cottage Cake Witch is a bakery based in Bushwick, NY, that can bring a little magic and artistry to your wedding cake design. Owner Paige, or the Cake Witch as many know her, believes that cakes can serve as the centerpiece of many of life's most cherished occasions. This belief inspires her approach to her work, with every detail meticulously curated to reflect the people being celebrated and the memories being made.
Paige has always had a passion for art, having studied color theory and illustration for many years. Today, cake is her canvas, and buttercream is her paint, as she produces intricate designs without any fondant, gum paste, or inedible elements in sight! Ensuring her cakes taste as good as they look is important to Paige, so she uses only the finest ingredients and baking techniques in all of her creations.
At Cottage Cake Witch, couples can be involved in every stage of the cake design process, customizing everything from the flavors to the decorations to fit their vision. Paige prepares all her baked goods in her home-based kitchen, giving every cake from Cottage Cake Witch a homemade, utterly personalized feel.
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
Awards and Affiliations
2025 'Best of Weddings'
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.012 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
My jaw dropped when I saw the gorgeous wedding cake Paige made for us! It was so beautiful and tasted so delicious. She incorporated all of my requests, but added a creative flare ...
that made the cake even better than I’d pictured. Her cakes are works of art and I am so glad I stumbled upon her bakery in my wedding cake search. Highly recommend!
The cake was delicious and beautiful. All of the guests were so impressed with the quality, detail and ofcourse the taste. Paige was so helpful and understood exactly what we neede...
d.
The most important thing to me for my wedding was a cake that tasted DELICIOUS. I was perfectly willing to sacrifice appearance for it. But with Paige at Cottage Cake Witch, you ca...
n have both! Her cakes are absolutely GORGEOUS and every single bite is drool-worthy. Highly recommend!
We had a cake that was beyond our expectations. The design was romantic, cascading with pearls and flowers of mauves and pinks, the petals were astonishingly lifelike and intricate...
with
amazing detail. The cake was not only beautiful but moist and delicious. Highly recommend for that special occasion.
Amazing work! The detail
Put into every cake and cupcake is absolute perfection. The cakes and cupcakes not only look good but are delicious too! I’ve used Cottage Cake Witch...
for at least 5 special occasions and I’m never disappointed!!! Highly recommended!
I was so happy to see this baker on your site! We were guests at a Shower where her cupcakes were party favors and honestly, I didn’t want to eat mine. It was waaaaaay too pretty....
But wow was it delicious. Our friend who had hired her raved about working with her. Her cakes are truly edible ART!
Paige is my go-to for all my big occasions. Her cakes are not only delicious, but they are artful, creative, detailed and personalized to my requests. She is incredible to work wit...
h and creates cakes that really make my celebrations more special.
I have ordered from Cottage Cake Witch on several occasions, both the cakes and cupcakes have exceeded my expectations! They are truly edible art. I have used them in place of tra...
dition centerpieces and party favors.
Paige makes both cakes and cupcakes according to your specifications: flowers, colors, and flavors. Each one is unique and one of a kind. She only uses the best ingredients, our fruit filings were made from real fruit.
The cakes and cupcakes are as devious as they are beautiful.
I have have really enjoyed delicious and beautifully decorated and innovative cakes and cupcakes from the Cottage Cake Witch at several events. The cakes are decorated as only a sk...
illed artist can. The flowers are extraordinary and the range in types of cakes are as well. I highly recommend it!!
Paige was incredibly easy to work with, delivered on time, and very professional. Her cake was absolutely delicious and a true work of art. We had a vanilla cake, raspberry filling...
with a Swiss buttercream. AMAZING!!!
For your special day, Paige will deliver delectable and beautiful desserts that will dazzle your guests. She is a true artist. They will also rave about the taste, texture and qual...
ity of her creations. You will be beyond pleased!
Excellent!!
I have enjoyed both cakes and cupcakes from the Cottage Cake Witch, and each has been divine. Not only were the desserts striking in presentation, but they taste fresh ...
and delicious! You may be reluctant to eat one, because of the spectacular artistry, but when you do, the delightful taste will have you ordering again for your next occasion.
Contact
Outer boroughs, Manhattan, Long Island
Cottage Cake Witch