We ended up using DeLuxe for our cake (even though they were our second choice our 1st choice was scheduled to have a baby the week of our wedding). Please note, we are not cake people, we're much more interested in savory foods, AND almost all... other major vendors were more important to us than cake.
Initially she tried to sell us on how the cake is the 2nd biggest thing people are going to look at after the bride & groom and we "didn't want people straining their necks to find the cake" - ridiculous. Also, EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. we talked to them we would be told about the type of baking she does, the way she bakes, the ingredients she will and will not use, etc. which made every conversation excruciating to the point that my (very involved) husband let me handle any correspondence and it ended up becoming a joke we shared with family & friends. And wanted so badly to share with her that..."We get that you are proud of your skill but we personally don't care, we already booked you so please just stop talking."
BUT I will say, the cake was delivered on time and we did hear from guests that the flavors we chose were delicious.
So was she obnoxious to work with YES. But she was also reliable, less expensive than the other person we spoke with AND most importantly we got positive reviews that everything was tasty from our guests.