Voted Long Island's Best Wedding Cake 2023 & 2022!
Serving all of Long Island
Service area
The Messina Family
OWNER
Typically responds within 24h
AWARD WINNER (8X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
As Long Island's most awarded and sought-after creator of wedding cakes since 1976, we view ourselves as your partner throughout the entire process of bringing your dream wedding cake to life! As the preferred vendor to over 30 of Long Island’s finest catering halls, you can rest assured knowing that your wedding cake will be made fresh on the day of your wedding, using only the highest quality ingredients. Our award-winning master bakers and pastry artists are skilled in all cake decorating techniques to ensure that every detail of your wedding cake is as memorable as your special day!
No business details yet
No team details yet
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Sugar Free
Vegan
Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
The Messina Family
Owner
The Messina Family has owned Long Island's infamous Dortoni Bakery Since 1976. Brothers, Corey & Daniele Messina owned & operated sister bakeries La Boulangerie in Port Jefferson and East Norwich, as well as Messina Market, & Red Tomato Pizza for over 25 years. In 2020, they decided to grow the beloved Dortoni brand throughout Long Island, opening Dortoni Commack, as well as bringing La Bonne into the Dortoni brand. Dortoni makes award-winning special occasion cakes for any event. Combining amazing quality, freshness, & artistic skills, Dortoni Bakery creates award-winning masterpieces.
Reviews
4.6
out of 5.0405 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Dortoni Bakery is highly praised for fun, accommodating cake tastings, professional and responsive staff, and beautiful, on-time cake deliveries. Cakes are consistently moist, well-balanced (not overly sweet), customizable (including vegan options), and crowd-pleasers. The process is easy and many recommend them and appreciate the complimentary anniversary cake.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Artem G
5.0
5/05/2026
Dortoni was great at organizing and building our cakes to accommodate everyone. The cake was exactly as we planned - it tasted amazing and looked beautiful. Everyone loved it!
Sylvia N J
5.0
5/03/2026
My fiancé and I enjoyed our cake tasting with Dortoni Bakery in Commack on the afternoon of Saturday 5/2/2026. The cake tasting experience was so much fun and one of our favorite p...
arts of wedding planning. The cake and fillings we tried were delicious, and we are confident the cake will be absolutely delicious on the day of. We customized the layers with our vision and it was amazing! We will post a picture of the cake from the day of end of July.
Any questions?
Cynthia N
5.0
5/01/2026
We loved using Dortoni Bakery! The cake tasting experience was so much fun and one of our favorite parts of wedding planning. The cake was delicious and we didn’t have to worry abo...
ut any of it on the day of. We customized the layers and it was amazing!
Marissa M
5.0
4/22/2026
Our wedding cake from Dortoni was absolutely INCREDIBLE! Not only was it stunning, but it tasted even better than it looked. The biggest testament to how delicious it was? My grand...
ma actually ate five pieces! Thank you for making our day so sweet and memorable.
Nicole S
5.0
3/10/2026
Dortoni Bakery was incredibly helpful and made our experience unforgettable! From our cake tasting to our stunning wedding cake, everything was absolutely delicious. We highly re...
commend using Dortoni for any event you're planning!
Emily E
5.0
12/30/2025
Definitely go with Dortoni for your wedding cake! We chose a delicious nutella filling with vanilla cake, and our cake was STUNNING. We had our florist adorn it with our wedding fl...
orals, and chose a cute cake topper. It was a centerpiece in and of itself. They were so easy to work with and professional, truly made such a great experience for us. And the tasting was so much fun!
Edward L
5.0
12/22/2025
We loved working with Dortoni for our wedding. The quilted cake came exactly as pictured on the day of, our cake tasting was so fun and the bakery went above and beyond to walk us ...
through the entire process and pricing. Everything was transparent and so easy. Thanks Dortoni!!
Lisa T
5.0
12/10/2025
We had Dortoni dessert before, so we knew the cake was going to be great. Our tasting at the Levittown location was a lot of fun, and they were easy to work with. We also ordered a...
small Anniversary cake for my parents, which they were happy to add! We ended up getting chocolate cake with one layer being strawberries & cream, and the other being vanilla moose. Our guests said that the cake was delicious!
Carmen L
5.0
12/05/2025
Dortoni Bakery was an absolute dream to work with! Out of all the bakeries I reached out to in the area, they were by far the most responsive and easiest to communicate with. From ...
the very beginning, the staff made us feel so welcome—and even the customers we met during our cake tasting treated everyone like family. That says so much about the kind of place Dortoni is!
The tasting experience was incredible. A sweet and knowledgeable team member walked us through all the flavors and options, even sharing her personal favorites. What really stood out was how balanced the cakes were—not overly sweet, which was perfect for us. (My husband and I are Chinese and prefer lighter cakes with delicate fillings.) Dortoni nailed it!
Our guests were thrilled to try the different flavors, and the crowd favorite was definitely the cookies and cream filling—thankfully, we had two tiers of that! Every bite was delicious, and the cake looked absolutely stunning.
Thank you so much, Dortoni, for making one of the biggest items on our wedding checklist the easiest and most enjoyable. You truly went above and beyond, and we couldn’t recommend you more highly!
Paige M
5.0
11/21/2025
Loved working with Dortoni! The cake tasting was a great experience and they ensured we had the most perfect & DELICIOUS wedding cake. Highly recommend for special events!
jacqueline l
5.0
11/19/2025
This past November we had our wedding cake made from Dortoni in Port Jefferson. The staff was so friendly and made the cake testing experience wonderful. We ended up going with a m...
arble cake, with a chocolate whipped cream filling. The butter cream frosting on the outside had a great flavor and was not overly sweet. Multiple guest commented on how much they enjoyed the cake. We ended up going with a simple design, however we were also given the option to have flowers added to the cake, which we declined. We would choose dortoni's all over and over again !
Stephanie K
5.0
11/16/2025
This is the bakery that my venue uses and I must say they know how to make cakes. I typically don't eat cake but when I tried the vanilla cake with fresh strawberries and cream fil...
ling, I knew we had to pay a little extra for that. We ended up doing half oreo buttercream and half strawberries with cream. If you have the choice, I highly recommend picking Dortoni's. They have quite a few locations across the island. We chose the Port Jeff location.
Darby D
5.0
10/31/2025
The responsiveness and helpfulness of this bakery made the process of selecting our cake effortless. The cake was so good that our guests were absolutely raving out it after. We've...
highly recommended Dortoni to all of our recently engaged friends and choosing them as our wedding cake vendor was one of the best wedding planning decisions we made.
Kristina D
5.0
10/23/2025
We ordered our wedding cake from Dortoni and it was absolutely amazing! From start to finish, the experience was wonderful. The team was friendly, professional, and truly cared abo...
ut making our vision come to life. They helped us choose the perfect flavor and design, and the final result was even better than we imagined.
The cake itself was stunning—beautifully decorated and so delicious! Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how good it tasted, and we’re still getting compliments almost a year later. Every bite was moist, flavorful, and perfectly balanced.
Thank you to everyone at Dortoni for being part of our special day. You made our wedding even sweeter, and we couldn’t be happier!
Stacy T
5.0
10/13/2025
Dortoni was great from the start. It was very easy to set up a tasting at a time that was convenient - including from multiple locations. They were ready for us when we arrived and...
had the selections we wanted to taste ready to go. Each one was truly delicious and it was tough choice - but we finally picked one and couldn't have been happier. The cake designs were beautiful too, and all delivered and arrived to our venue as expected. Highly recommend.
Ashleigh K
5.0
10/09/2025
One word... AMAZING! From our tasting with Casey—who was so attentive and patient while helping us choose the perfect cake flavors, fillings, and design—to the moment we received e...
xactly what we envisioned on our wedding day, everything was flawless. Not only did our cake look stunning, but it was also incredibly moist and flavorful. My husband and I were beyond pleased and can’t wait to relive the experience next year with the complimentary anniversary cake that Dortoni provides!
Robin K
5.0
10/08/2025
My daughter’s wedding was 7/12/2025. The cake we ordered from Dortoni was wonderful. We enjoyed going to the cake tasting prior to the wedding. Michele at the Huntington location w...
as so pleasant and easy to work with. The cake was delivered on time and everything was perfect. Thank you Dortoni
Taylor P
5.0
9/19/2025
Our wedding cake exceeded every expectation. The design was elegant, the flavors were exceptional, and our guests couldn’t stop raving about it. We are so grateful for such a flawl...
ess experience and highly recommend their work.
Pamela H
5.0
9/05/2025
From cake tasting months in advance to my guest's reactions, Dortoni's was the best! The staff at the bakery were absolutely lovely. My fiance and I struggled to choose just two fi...
lling as they were all delicious. We ended up deciding on raspberry mousse and Italian custard with a vanilla cake. It was a massive success! We had guests ask us where our cake was from because they loved it so much. We highly recommend Dortoni's!
Marissa S
5.0
9/02/2025
Had a great experience with Dortini! The cake was included with my venue and I got to pick the flavor and fillings I liked best. I loved that they let me submit a design photo and ...
nailed it. Went for the Pinterest “vintage” look. Tasting was easy to schedule and cake was delicious. I recommend!
Kendra M
5.0
8/13/2025
We had some initial confusion with our wedding cake order. The design we had carefully chosen was not going to be honored, which caused some last-minute stress. That said, the vend...
or went above and beyond to make things right.
On our wedding day, the cake was absolutely stunning. It was clear that a lot of care and effort went into it, and it turned out even more beautiful than we expected. Guests could not stop raving about both the design and the flavor.
While we wish the communication had been clearer earlier in the process, we are truly grateful for how the vendor delivered when it mattered most. In the end, the cake was a memorable part of our celebration.
Alex S
5.0
8/11/2025
Our cake was included in the cost of our wedding venue, The Lannin. We had 225 people and Dortoni helped use create a beautiful 3 tier cake. There were great designs to choose fro...
m. Our florist brought flowers that were added to the cake upon delivery. The tasting experience was so great. We were able to choose from the delicious fillings. Everyone at the bakery was kind and helpful, making sure we selected exactly what we wanted. Our guests keep asking about where the cake came from!
Brigid R
5.0
8/05/2025
Loved everything about our wedding cake! It was super simple to go and do our tasting and they gave us a coupon to return on our anniversary day next year for a personal cake to ha...
ve to celebrate!
Kevin W
5.0
8/04/2025
Working with Dortoni was just as wonderful. Their team was professional, responsive, and clearly passionate about their craft. They listened closely to what we wanted, offered thou...
ghtful suggestions, and delivered a cake that exceeded all expectations.Working with Dortoni was just as wonderful. Their team was professional, responsive, and clearly passionate about their craft. They listened closely to what we wanted, offered thoughtful suggestions, and come wedding day did not need any direction from us to deliver and set up the cake at our venue.
Not only was the cake stunning to look at—elegant, detailed, and perfectly matched to our theme—but it was also absolutely delicious. Every layer was moist, flavorful, and beautifully balanced. Guests were raving about it all night
Cathy C
5.0
8/02/2025
Dortoni bakery is wonderful! They allowed my husband and I to go in for a tasting. All the flavors were so good! We finally chose a 4-tier cake and alternated different flavors. Ou...
r guests really enjoyed the cake!
Mikey S
5.0
8/02/2025
Every step working with dortoni was so easy and smooth. We went and tried a bunch of samples and fillings with them and they even let us try more than what was technically allowed ...
under our contract. We had our eyes set in fresh strawberrries and cream as our filler but our venue wouldn’t let us choose that for some reason, but dortoni worked with us to get the next best thing and it turned out amazing. The design of the cake was beautiful and everyone at the wedding was raving about the cake and how good it was. The whole process was so easy
Samantha L
5.0
7/31/2025
Dortoni was a pleasure to work with. The staff is professional and knowledgeable. Most importantly, our cake was delicious and beautiful!!!
Emily L
5.0
7/31/2025
The cake was delicious even though we only had time for a few bites! We had so many compliments from our guests how good the cake was. Cake tasting was a fun process. They were eas...
y to keep in contact with.
Meghan M
5.0
7/31/2025
We absolutely loved our experience with Dortoni’s bakery! The cake tasting was incredible. They gave us plenty of time to decide what flavors we wanted. The day of the wedding, the...
cake was more than I expected. It was beautiful and was a huge hit with our guests!
Marissa G
5.0
7/30/2025
Our cake from Dortoni was amazing!! We had a vanilla cake with chocolate pudding and Oreo buttercream layers. It was absolutely delicious. Usually I don’t eat wedding cakes because...
I find them dry, however our cake was incredibly moist and delicious!
Amanda M
5.0
7/06/2025
From start to finish Dortoni was an absolute dream! Everything about the process was so smooth and easy! The finished product turned out absolutely beautiful. It was exactly what w...
e envisioned. Our guests raved about the dulche de leche filling! Highly recommend this bakery this any future couple. :)
Tiffany M
5.0
7/02/2025
Let me just say- this was our favorite part of planning our wedding! They are so accommodating & kind! I work a lot of hours and long days at the hospital- they put us in no proble...
m! The taste testing was so fun & tasted soooo good !! THE CAKE WAS DELICIOUS !! I don’t have many photos yet unfortunately because we are still waiting on them from our photographer- but this is what I have currently. We are so happy how everything came out ! Cake was beautiful and literally everyone at our wedding ate it !
Michael B
5.0
6/23/2025
Part of booking the Fox Hollow included a Dortoni cake, they blew away all of my expectations and everyone LOVED the cake. Looking forward to our anniversary cake!!
Ashlyn L
5.0
6/20/2025
We loved getting our wedding cake from Dortoni! The tasting was lovely and communication was easy. Everyone loved the cake and it was beautiful. We’ll definitely use them for famil...
y events in the future as well.
Neha A
5.0
6/19/2025
Absolutely delicious cake. Our friends and family loved it. Also it looked incredible, just how i asked for it
Amanda W
5.0
6/11/2025
We had a lovely experience with Dortoni Bakery! A wedding cake was included in our venue package and we were very happy to work with them. We had a vanilla cake with strawberries a...
nd whipped cream filling and it was so tasty! We also had frosting flowers cascading down the entire cake. It was beautiful! We can't thank Dortoni Bakery enough!
Abigail R
5.0
4/30/2025
Dortoni in Port Jeff was perfect! We had such a hard time picking a cake flavor and filling because everything was so delicious, but they let us pick 2 flavors (Dulce De Leche and ...
Cannoli) with vanilla cake. On wedding day everything was DECLICIOUS and our cake was gorgeous!
Alexis H
5.0
4/28/2025
We had such a good time during our tasting!! All of our guests absolutely loved the cake!!
Erin R
5.0
4/27/2025
Dortinoi’s We were so impressed with our cake from Dotorni’s. The cake itself was beautiful and delicious. We opted for a white cake with Italian custard & vanilla buttercream. We ...
enjoyed the cake tasting process. The staff was helpful & attentive. The cake was so fresh & received a lot of complements.
Gabriela S
5.0
4/24/2025
A great experience! From our cake testing to the actual wedding day. Our Cake was moist and delicious and exactly as we pictured. The chocolate ganache was delish!
Richard T
5.0
4/09/2025
I was referred to Dortoni by my wedding venue. We got to do a tasting and it gave us a very good idea of what we were signing up for. The process was so simple and service was exce...
llent. The cakes were delicious! We also bought some cookies to go which were amazing. The wedding cake turned out absolutely beautiful and majestic even without a wedding topper
Marisa R
5.0
3/30/2025
Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful. Exactly how we wanted it! The cake itself tasted delicious and ordering it was seamless! Delivered on time and looked gorgeous !
Fredrika C
5.0
3/17/2025
We got married two months ago and we are STILL getting compliments from our guests about how amazing our wedding cake was, and rightfully so!! We had a complimentary tasting to dec...
ide what flavors would best represent us in cake form and it was such a cute experience. We decided on a quilted 4 tier cake with white buttercream filled with vanilla mousse and dulce de leche. The flavors were beyond perfect and the cake was so visually appealing. I'm drooling just thinking about it lol. Thank you for creating such an unforgettably delicious and truly beautiful cake for our winter wonderland wedding!
Ariel K
5.0
3/15/2025
Our cake through Dortoni’s (Levittown) was included with our package at our wedding venue, but we were truly blown away when we went for our tasting (we previously had such low exp...
ectations for wedding cake, but Dortoni’s proved us wrong). We are chocoholics but decided on a vanilla cake with cannoli cream and chocolate ganache; we are still dreaming about it. We did wind up paying extra to get a specific design I fell in love with, but they did a great job replicating our vision—it was beautiful. They also gave us a voucher at the tasting for a complimentary first-anniversary cake —we can’t wait. Make sure to ask for it!
PC: @jeanettejoyphoto
Alyssa B
5.0
1/09/2025
Our cake came out great. As a vegan I was anxious about finding a vendor that could do a vegan cake and they did a wonderful job. It was the main food I ate all day haha. I was get...
ting asked about this cake days after.
Melissa F
5.0
1/02/2025
Our wedding cake was perfect. So delicious! We upgraded for a specific design which was probably overpriced, but worth it because it made me happy. The cake tasting experience was ...
also so fun. So excited for our one year anniversary cake next year. I think you can’t go wrong with Dortoni!
Deana L
5.0
12/27/2024
We had our cake through Dortoni as it was part of our package at Villa Lombardi’s. We had our tasting in Levittown. It was busy but the staff were attentive and helpful. Our cake l...
ooked beautiful and tasted even better. Highly recommend!
Kellie M
5.0
12/18/2024
I have known Dortoni for many years and I enjoyed working with them on my wedding cake. They have the tasting process down to a science and made the selection process easy. I would...
definitely work with them again for any future cake needs and highly recommend the Nutella filling.
Alyssa O
5.0
12/07/2024
My husband and I went to Dortoni in Levittown for our cake tasting and had such a great experience. Everyone was so nice and checked on us throughout the tasting. Everything was de...
licious which made it hard to pick which cake. We ended up doing alternating layers with marble cake and chocolate dobash and then vanilla cake with strawberries and fresh whipped cream. The cake came out gorgeous and all of my guests raved how delicious it was! I highly recommend Dortoni Bakery for your wedding.
Chris R
5.0
11/25/2024
Beautiful cake. We had our tasting in Levittown, as part of our package with Fox Hollow. We were allowed to try four cake fillings with two base (vanilla and chocolate). We chose t...
o go with a speciality design, so there was an additional fee, but it was minimal, and ultimately worth it. At our reception, everyone loved the cake. And it looked beautiful, exactly how my wife envisioned. After enjoying their cake, we cannot wait to go back for future occasions.
Service area & Contact info
Serving all of Long Island
Typically included in the starting cost
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Dortoni Bakery
The Messina Family
|
Owner
Typically responds within 24h
Wedding vendors in Levittown
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.