Voted Long Island's Best Wedding Cake 2023 & 2022!
Serving all of Long Island
Service area
The Messina Family
OWNER
Typically responds within 24h
AWARD WINNER (7X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
As Long Island's most awarded and sought-after creator of wedding cakes since 1976, we view ourselves as your partner throughout the entire process of bringing your dream wedding cake to life! As the preferred vendor to over 30 of Long Island’s finest catering halls, you can rest assured knowing that your wedding cake will be made fresh on the day of your wedding, using only the highest quality ingredients. Our award-winning master bakers and pastry artists are skilled in all cake decorating techniques to ensure that every detail of your wedding cake is as memorable as your special day!
No business details yet
No team details yet
Prices & packages
No pricing details yet
We’re here to help! Find other vendors that suit your budget.
Continue browsing vendors
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Sugar Free
Vegan
Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
The Messina Family
Owner
The Messina Family has owned Long Island's infamous Dortoni Bakery Since 1976. Brothers, Corey & Daniele Messina owned & operated sister bakeries La Boulangerie in Port Jefferson and East Norwich, as well as Messina Market, & Red Tomato Pizza for over 25 years. In 2020, they decided to grow the beloved Dortoni brand throughout Long Island, opening Dortoni Commack, as well as bringing La Bonne into the Dortoni brand. Dortoni makes award-winning special occasion cakes for any event. Combining amazing quality, freshness, & artistic skills, Dortoni Bakery creates award-winning masterpieces.
Availability
Reviews
4.6
out of 5.0369 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Dortoni Bakery in Port Jeff offers top-quality wedding cakes that are both beautiful and delicious, providing a seamless process from tastings to delivery. Guests rave about the various flavorful options like vanilla, dulce de leche, cannoli, and more, as well as the professional and friendly staff. The cakes are visually appealing and receive a lot of compliments, making Dortoni a highly recommended choice for couples looking for exquisite and tasty wedding cakes in Long Island.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Abigail R
5.0
4/30/2025
Dortoni in Port Jeff was perfect! We had such a hard time picking a cake flavor and filling because everything was so delicious, but they let us pick 2 flavors (Dulce De Leche and Cannoli) with vanilla cake. On wedding day everything was DECLICIOUS and our cake was gorgeous!
Alexis H
5.0
4/28/2025
We had such a good time during our tasting!! All of our guests absolutely loved the cake!!
Any questions?
Erin R
5.0
4/27/2025
Dortinoi’s We were so impressed with our cake from Dotorni’s. The cake itself was beautiful and delicious. We opted for a white cake with Italian custard & vanilla buttercream. We enjoyed the cake tasting process. The staff was helpful & attentive. The cake was so fresh & received a lot of complements.
Gabriela S
5.0
4/24/2025
A great experience! From our cake testing to the actual wedding day. Our Cake was moist and delicious and exactly as we pictured. The chocolate ganache was delish!
Richard T
5.0
4/09/2025
I was referred to Dortoni by my wedding venue. We got to do a tasting and it gave us a very good idea of what we were signing up for. The process was so simple and service was excellent. The cakes were delicious! We also bought some cookies to go which were amazing. The wedding cake turned out absolutely beautiful and majestic even without a wedding topper
Marisa R
5.0
3/30/2025
Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful. Exactly how we wanted it! The cake itself tasted delicious and ordering it was seamless! Delivered on time and looked gorgeous !
Fredrika C
5.0
3/17/2025
We got married two months ago and we are STILL getting compliments from our guests about how amazing our wedding cake was, and rightfully so!! We had a complimentary tasting to decide what flavors would best represent us in cake form and it was such a cute experience. We decided on a quilted 4 tier cake with white buttercream filled with vanilla mousse and dulce de leche. The flavors were beyond perfect and the cake was so visually appealing. I'm drooling just thinking about it lol. Thank you for creating such an unforgettably delicious and truly beautiful cake for our winter wonderland wedding!
Ariel K
5.0
3/15/2025
Our cake through Dortoni’s (Levittown) was included with our package at our wedding venue, but we were truly blown away when we went for our tasting (we previously had such low expectations for wedding cake, but Dortoni’s proved us wrong). We are chocoholics but decided on a vanilla cake with cannoli cream and chocolate ganache; we are still dreaming about it. We did wind up paying extra to get a specific design I fell in love with, but they did a great job replicating our vision—it was beautiful. They also gave us a voucher at the tasting for a complimentary first-anniversary cake —we can’t wait. Make sure to ask for it!
PC: @jeanettejoyphoto
Alyssa B
5.0
1/09/2025
Our cake came out great. As a vegan I was anxious about finding a vendor that could do a vegan cake and they did a wonderful job. It was the main food I ate all day haha. I was getting asked about this cake days after.
Melissa F
5.0
1/02/2025
Our wedding cake was perfect. So delicious! We upgraded for a specific design which was probably overpriced, but worth it because it made me happy. The cake tasting experience was also so fun. So excited for our one year anniversary cake next year. I think you can’t go wrong with Dortoni!
Deana L
5.0
12/27/2024
We had our cake through Dortoni as it was part of our package at Villa Lombardi’s. We had our tasting in Levittown. It was busy but the staff were attentive and helpful. Our cake looked beautiful and tasted even better. Highly recommend!
Kellie M
5.0
12/18/2024
I have known Dortoni for many years and I enjoyed working with them on my wedding cake. They have the tasting process down to a science and made the selection process easy. I would definitely work with them again for any future cake needs and highly recommend the Nutella filling.
Alyssa O
5.0
12/07/2024
My husband and I went to Dortoni in Levittown for our cake tasting and had such a great experience. Everyone was so nice and checked on us throughout the tasting. Everything was delicious which made it hard to pick which cake. We ended up doing alternating layers with marble cake and chocolate dobash and then vanilla cake with strawberries and fresh whipped cream. The cake came out gorgeous and all of my guests raved how delicious it was! I highly recommend Dortoni Bakery for your wedding.
Chris R
5.0
11/25/2024
Beautiful cake. We had our tasting in Levittown, as part of our package with Fox Hollow. We were allowed to try four cake fillings with two base (vanilla and chocolate). We chose to go with a speciality design, so there was an additional fee, but it was minimal, and ultimately worth it. At our reception, everyone loved the cake. And it looked beautiful, exactly how my wife envisioned. After enjoying their cake, we cannot wait to go back for future occasions.
Amanda F
5.0
11/25/2024
Angela at Dortoni was so helpful when it came to deciding on our wedding cake. We tried multiple delicious types of cakes/fillings, and they made the process super easy and seamless. Definitely recommend this bakery to anyone!
Post-wedding update: Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious and so beautiful. It was exactly what we picked out. They accommodated our requests very easily. Wonderful experience working with Dortoni!
Marissa L
5.0
11/14/2024
We are thrilled to have had Dortoni Bakery make our wedding cake. The process of tasting the options and discussing our vision with them was seamless and fun. And the end result was fantastic. Highly recommend.
Elizabeth D
5.0
11/13/2024
We had the best experience here! The tasting was well organized and the woman working was incredibly helpful in explaining our options, what was included, what would be an additional fee, etc. We did our tasting on the earlier end just because it was an easy thing to check off the to-do list. We were a little worried it may have been TOO early, but when we called the week of the wedding to confirm everything, Dortoni's didn't miss a beat and quickly confirmed all of the info and even sent us a copy of our order form. The cake was absolutely delicious (I wish the chocolate cannoli cream was a standard filling in any of the ready-to-buy cakes or even in actual cannolis!). We opted to to a plane cake and our florist added flowers to match the rest of the wedding florals.
Thomas Z
5.0
11/09/2024
We’re so grateful to Dortoni Bakery for creating the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake! From start to finish, the team was professional, helpful, and truly brought our vision to life. The design was stunning, and the cake tasted amazing—moist, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We received so many compliments from our guests! Highly recommend Dortoni Bakery for anyone looking for a show-stopping cake for their special day!
Emily S
5.0
11/07/2024
Our guests raved about how delicious our cake was, and that says a lot because my family typically doesn't go for the cake at dessert! lol Dortonis did such a wonderful job. They were a vendor we never had to worry about. From the beginning, the cake tasting was so good it was difficult to choose which flavors to go with! We ended up with vanilla/cannoli and chocolate/raspberry. Both were a hit! I highly recommend them.
Robert M
5.0
10/27/2024
Dortoni delivered a cake that was exactly what we wanted. We went with vanilla icing, vanilla cake, and chocolate ganache, and it was incredible. Everyone commented about how great it was too! I’ve had a lot of subpar wedding cakes and I was beginning to feel like that was the norm. Dortoni absolutely made me see they’re just a cut above the rest. Unreal cake, can’t wait to get more from them in the future!
Jordane M
5.0
10/25/2024
Dortonis made the best wedding cake ever! I worked with Ang through the entire process, she was so kind, easy to communicate with, professional and did an amazing job on our wedding cake. The cake was delicious, not too expensive4 and so beautiful! I can't recommend them enough!
Delores C
5.0
10/15/2024
We had an excellent experience working with Dortoni in Levittown for our wedding cake. The tasting process was seamless, and they offer excellent customer service. Their staff was available to answer all of our questions via email and in person at the tasting. We liked getting to pick the design of our cake from the many photo examples they had on hand. Our wedding cake was delicious and gorgeous, our guests are still raving about it!
Patricia B
3.0
10/12/2024
We were a bit restricted due to the contract with Fox Hollow, when it came to picking out the cake from here but we made it work. We paid extra for the design once again the contract was restrictive. This isn't the reason why I gave 3 stars. The reason for it was because we were told by the bakery that they would put the cake topper on for us and charged us a fee which we paid for this service, only to find out on the day of our wedding that the toppers were not on the cake. I don't know how but the Maitre'd got in contact with the store after hours and was able to recover them for us. It was so disappointing. They are so quick to upcharge for any changes and then they do things like this. There was nothing that stood out for when it came to cake flavor. We went with them simply because we did not have the time to shop around for another bakery since the wedding was planned in 3 months.
Aimeelee G
5.0
10/09/2024
Dortoni made our cake tasting so easy and pleasant! They did exactly what we wished and the cake tasted even better on our special day. Absolutely delicious!! We got so many compliments by our guests on how decadent and rich the cake was
Lauren R
4.0
10/04/2024
I was a little skeptical of ordering my wedding cake from Dortoni. I have read many poor reviews and I have ordered cakes there myself the past few years and it has not been the same since they switched owners. We went to the one in Commack to do our tasting because the Fox Hollow now only works with Dortoni (which I was not thrilled with at first). It was a little difficult to make an appointment at first they seemed a little confused as to what I was looking for and the manager was only there on certain days so we had to go on a day she was working. But when we met her she was lovely and let us try 3 different cakes and 6 different fillings. Unfortunately the contract with Dortoni through the Fox Hollow does not allow cake flavors other than vanilla and chocolate or there’s an extra charge (again, not Dortoni’s fault) and Fox Hollow only allows one filling, where most venues will allow 2 (again, not Dortoni’s doing). So if you plan to use Fox Hollow for your venue take that in mind you will have to pay extra per head for anything extra you may like in your dream wedding cake. They were as accommodating as they could be with giving us a slight discount since we were already paying for a different cake flavor that when we picked a second filling they gave us half off, they did what they could to make our cost less of a burden. They even gave us a voucher for our 1 year anniversary top tier cake. The cake was delicious and I can’t wait to eat it again next year on our anniversary!
Emily M
5.0
10/01/2024
Our venue works with Dortoni's so a cake was included in our contract. I've seen some negative reviews of Dortoni's recently, but I have nothing but positive things to say about them. Our tasting was a very nice experience, and I was easily able to communicate with them via email leading up to it. We went with a oreo buttercream filling and a vanilla sponge cake. It was SO good and it looked so beautiful. All of our guests loved the cake, I don't remember seeing a full piece left on any tables. We also get a small round cake on our 1 year anniversary at no cost. Love them!
Valerie A
5.0
9/29/2024
We ordered our wedding cake from Dortoni and it was delicious & beautiful. They made the whole process super easy and enjoyable. Thanks for the wonderful wedding cake!
Lauren R
4.0
9/21/2024
Our vanilla cake with lemon buttercream was beautiful and absolutely delicious! We received many compliments on it. We would have given them 5 stars but this company was very difficult to communicate with. We would still recommend them though!
Brittany B
5.0
9/18/2024
October 2023 wedding so this is long overdue. Great selection of choices for tastings, and our wedding cake was delish and beautiful!
Nicole N
5.0
9/04/2024
quality of service was amazing! had a great cake tasting and an even better wedding cake, delicious!
Alex M
5.0
9/02/2024
Perfect Design & Flavour!
Dortoni Bakery delivered a wedding cake that was as beautiful as it was tasty. The design was absolutely perfect, and the cake was incredibly fresh. Their professionalism and quality of service made the entire experience a joy! Thanks
Scott F
5.0
9/02/2024
The quality of service at Dortoni Bakery is unparalleled. They communicated with us every step of the way to ensure the cake matched our vision. The design was flawless, and the cake itself was fresh ,moist, and delicious .we couldn't have asked for more
Joann C
5.0
8/31/2024
Planning a wedding can be stressful, but Dortoni Bakery made the cake process completely stress-free. They were organized, communicative, and delivered a stunning cake that tasted amazing. We couldn’t be happier. Ty dortoni bakery
Mark A
5.0
8/31/2024
Dortoni bakery provided personalized service that made us feel like Their only client. The wedding cake was stunning, and the taste was divine. Their team's attention to our needs and preference was truly appreciated
Harry W
5.0
8/31/2024
Dortoni bakery's attention to detail is incredible. They Crafted a wedding cake that was exactly what we wanted, down to the smallest detail.the service was friendly and efficient, making our wedding day more and more special
Sarah R
5.0
8/30/2024
Creative and Delicious!
The creativity at Dortoni Bakery is unmatched. They designed a wedding cake that was both unique and Delicious. professional staff throughout the process. Price was reasonable. We couldn't have asked for more. thanks
Linda T
5.0
8/28/2024
Choosing Dortoni bakery for our wedding cake was the best decision we made ! The cake was stunning, and the taste was unforgivable. Friendly and professional staff. They made the entire experience wonderful
Taylor J
5.0
8/27/2024
Our wedding cake from Dortoni Bakery was a dream come true! The design was exactly what we envisioned, and it tasted amazing. The staff’s professionalism and kindness made the experience even better. Thanks again
William H
5.0
8/26/2024
Dortoni bakery delivered a wedding cake that was both stunning and delicious. The staff was so friendly and accommodating, making sure every detail was perfect. Thanks dortoni
Camelia J
5.0
8/26/2024
Dortoni Bakery is the best choice for wedding cakes in Long Island! The cake was gorgeous, fresh and the flavor was incredible. The staff was friendly and professional. Highly recommend!
Christiana R
5.0
8/26/2024
We had an amazing experience with Dortoni. The wedding cake was both beautiful and delicious. Their attention to detail and customer service were top-notch. Highly recommend them for your big day! Thanks Dortoni
James l
5.0
8/24/2024
Dortoni Bakery really cared about us and our event. The cake was beautiful and really delicious. friendly staff. Can’t wait for another occasion to use their services
Donna C
5.0
8/24/2024
We used Dortoni Bakery for our wedding cake. We were referred to Dortoni Bakery through one of my friend, and were so pleased with how everything turned out! They not only made the most delicious wedding cake for us, but it was absolutely stunning as well
Cindy A
5.0
8/21/2024
My wedding cake was gorgeous!!! The cake tasted amazing!!! My guests would not stop raving about the cake. Dortoni did not disappoint! Thank you soooo much!!!!
Mariam N
5.0
8/10/2024
Thank you Dortoni for making an amazing wedding cake for our wedding! We used Dortoni's through our wedding venue (Crest Hollow) and were communicating with Dortoni's manager, Ang, throughout the process of scheduling tasting to finalizing/confirming to getting our cake on the day of. Ang was great to work with and easy to communicate with! Our cake, chocolate with strawberry filling, was delicious.
Jameila D
5.0
8/09/2024
Our venue (Fox Hollow) included our cake from Dortoni Bakery we were so happy they did! The entire process from the tasting to design was excellent! Thank you!!!
Meagan L
5.0
7/19/2024
We had a great experience with using Dortoni for our wedding cake! Our cake was contracted with our venue, Harbor Club at Prime, in which we got a 4 tier cake. We went for a cake tasting and were able to choose 1 cake flavor and 2 fillings for our cake. We went with funfetti, chocolate ganache and cannoli and our cake was DELICIOUS. We used their design book to pick out the design and it came out exactly how we envisioned it.
Taylor C
5.0
7/17/2024
The cake was beyond beautiful on the dance floor of our wedding day. It also tastes delicious! Very happy with this company
P N
5.0
6/26/2024
We used Dortoni's for our wedding cake through our venue. We got to taste their delicious cake flavors and decided on chocolate and vanilla with cannoli cream. Delicious! And their decorations and frosting design were on point too. We highly recommend them for Long Island weddings!
Julia L
5.0
6/06/2024
Dortoni Bakery is to die for! We got our wedding cake here. We got the dulce de leche and cannoli cream fillings with vanilla cake, and we could not have gotten more compliments on it. Everyone loved it! The tasting was well organized and they were very accommodating with the cake design. They even gave a gift card for a little six inch cake for our 1st anniversary so we don’t have to freeze cake. Such a neat idea! We highly recommend Dortoni!
Contact
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Dortoni Bakery
The Messina Family
|
Owner
Typically responds within 24h
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.
Wedding vendors in Levittown
Dortoni Bakery's photos
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.