Dortoni Bakery

h.... The fondant had rips in it, tearing and visible cake board on one side, which you can see in some of the photos. When we went to cut our cake was when I could see the tearing the most. The cakes were all delicious, soft and fluffy, with great tasting filling. I would still recommend this shop, I just hope they are a little more careful for the next bride.

dding cake was layered with chantilly with berries and chocolate ganache. We also ordered a groom’s cake, a cake for the rehearsal dinner and my bridal shower cake from Dortoni’s. Each time they came out just as imagined and so delicious! My husband, family and I love Dortoni’s and they are our go to for all deserts!

150 which actually is a fair price compared to other bakery’s that wanted to charge us $200+ When we actually did the tasting and booked, the fee came out to only $50! The cake tasted amazing, not dry at all and was delivered on time in one piece. Very happy overall!!

d to us and made beautiful, simply-decorated cake. Price included with my metropolitan package. Several guests told us they don't usually like cake/dessert - but that they loved our cake. Highly recommend!

i!

th the upgraded design and came out fabulous!

x with all the fillings. When we decided our fillings (chocolate ganache and strawberries in custard), we emailed Candice how we wanted the fillings to be in the cake. We described it specifically with the Upper filling as Chocolate Ganache, and the Lower filling as Fresh Strawberries in Custard. We wanted BOTH fillings in each piece of cake. We never got a confirmation response from her. We emailed closer to the wedding to let them know how many guests we would be having so they can add the correct amount of tiers, which we were informed by the manager to do 2 weeks prior. Once again, no response. My husband called and they said they would let Candice know our guest count. We never got confirmation that they would be adding a 3rd tier. Panicking, we reached out to our wedding planner at our venue (the Inn at NHP) and she spoke to Dortoni’s and somehow she got a quick response. They made a beautiful cake with the design we wanted...on the outside. When I got my piece of cake, the filling was literally ICING, with neither filling visible. My husband’s piece was just custard, no strawberries. We went around and saw other tables with just Strawberries and Icing, no custard. We didn’t see any tables with the Ganache filling. My dad’s piece was just icing too. We were so confused and we spoke to our Maitre’D, who said he will let Dortoni’s know and advised we reach out to them too. We found out the next day when we looked in our leftovers boxes from NHP that they did have the chocolate ganache, but it was in the second tier of the cake. So, instead of stacking both fillings between each other, they were spread out between each tier of cake. this is not how we had expressed the cake to be made, and we were never told that it would wind up being different by Dortoni’s. We're disappointed with how our cake turned out.

nceled due to COVID) the girl who answered the phone said there was no record of my order and was in a panic so naturally I panicked! I heard back from the manager the next day who explained that the girl was mistaken, and all was well. I had also sent over photos of what I wanted (two figurines of our dogs sticking out of the bottom of the cake) and I dropped off the figurines well in advance. Well day of the wedding came, and our pups were nowhere to be found. Needless to say, that little hiccup did upset me, but the cake tasted and looked amazing. Just hoping someone else didn’t wind up with two little pups sticking out of their wedding cake! Our guests loved the cake and a number asked what bakery we used!

ple yet elegant, which was exactly what we wanted. Look no further, Dortoni’s is the right choice.

made it so easy! We still enjoyed the tasting from home- it was so hard to choose. Our cake on our wedding day was absolutely delicious! & it looked amazing! We got so many compliments & cant wait have it again for our 1 year anniversary! We will definitely use this bakery for any pastries or cake needs!

ecommend this vendor and since my wedding day I have used this bakery for my cake and pastry needs!

asking where it came from. I was surprised at how good it was myself because I normally hate fruit filling. They did a great job!

t care or remember the cake but, I can say going with Dortoni’s was an amazing decision! I will remember this cake and how delicious it was! I will be going back to them for future cakes.

the design my daughter-in-law asked for, asked if the layers could be different flavors, asked if they could change and add flowers to the top for decoration etc. everything was a”yes, we can do that”. Shockingly none of the changes incurred an up charge! Phenomenal bakery, phenomenal service, beautiful and delicious cake!!! There is another local bakery one town over I am still waiting to get my “appointment” from. You couldn’t walk in and just order nor speak over a phone to them. Not worth the effort-LaBonne is the clear choice!

the extra money I paid for the wedding cake design requested. My husband, when we were still boyfriend-girlfriend, carved our initials into a birch tree. I can't tell you how excited we were to have this cake at our wedding, and how I specifically told the photographer I want a photo of us cutting the wedding cake together because it is such a cute part of the wedding day. I received a cake that someone so CARELESSLY, and HEARTLESSLY, rushed through. They printed out a photo of what I wanted and attached it to the order, and told us it would be NO PROBLEM AT ALL, to do this RELATIVELY SIMPLE design. Instead, someone took a white cake, dipped a paintbrush in POOP-BROWN PAINT, and PAINTED WEIRD BROWN STROKES ON A WHITE CAKE. I was EMBARRASSED on my wedding day, something NO BRIDE SHOULD EVER FEEL on a ONCE IN A LIFETIME DAY. SHAME ON YOU. The manager was very nice, and very empathetic, but the owner could not be BOTHERED to even FULLY REFUND ME which would've been the VERY LEAST that he could do. I am absolutely heartbroken that my wedding day has permanent scar on it that I don't think I will be able to just "laugh about" in 10, 20, 50 years from now. Another reviewer said something very similar to me and was equally disappointed. The cake itself was of mediocre quality. We would have paid ANY AMOUNT OF MONEY for the cake we wanted, we assumed that's why we were charged an additional $450 for the design. The money is not the issue. The quality of work, IS. Stop using this bakery for weddings. They don't deserve the business.

lled with how it came out. We had 4 tiers, 2 rustic style and 2 plain and it looked beautiful. Highly recommend!

nt of filling and frosting. Not to mention, it was absolutely beautiful!!

nd strawberries. My guests were ravinggggg about how delicious and moist the cake was. I will 100% be recommending Dortoni and using them for all future events!!

day cake for my sister which happened to be the same weekend of our wedding. The birthday cake was beautifully decorated and tasted even better. Dortoni also provides a gift certificate to go back a year later for them to recreate the top layer of your wedding cake, so that it is as fresh as the day you had it on your wedding. No other bakery provider this special additional treat. I highly recommend the team at Dortoni for all your bakery needs, especially wedding cakes!

do not even know it's gluten free cake! My father in law questioned us that it was really gluten free because that's how good it tastes. My husband hates gluten free desserts but with their cakes, you really cannot tell and he ate it all! Angela at the East Norwich bakery was so accommodating and helpful for our cake tasting and designing of the cake. I would ask for her when you call!

years to come.

and the quality was so good. Our cake was funfetti— and the sprinkles were so vibrant! They weren’t light colored, but vivid and evident! We also chose the chantilly cream with berries as one of our filling— and the guests were so impressed with actual strawberries and blackberries in the cake. It was fresh fruit! We couldn’t have been happier with our wedding cake and would gladly recommend Dortoni Bakery!!

them ahead of time when you make the appointment. Everything was delicious and we had a hard time choosing which filling we wanted. One of the employees came by and then told us we could do 2 fillings, because each tier is 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling - perfect! We chose a vanilla cake with chocolate mousse and raspberry mousse. My venue handled all the design aspects with Dortoni, so I told my venue what I wanted and they passed it along. The cake was beautiful - exactly what I wanted. It was also delicious! Their buttercream icing is the perfect texture and isn't too sweet - the perfect balance. At our tasting, Dortoni even gave us a certificate so that one year from our wedding we can go back to the bakery and get a 6-inch version of our cake! That way, we didn't have to have the venue save the top tier of our cake to take home - if that's a tradition you like! Fresh cake is definitely better than frozen!

do 4 different tiers. The cake was amazing and beautifully decorated! It was even better than I pictured. Absolute perfection.

decorated exactly as we had discussed! It was delicious - we had 4 tiers, 2 different fillings which gave our guests a chance to try either one! We would definitely recommend Dortoni bakery for all events, especially Wedding cakes!

erous which goes a long way in this industry. Great experience with tasting!

immediately called us to apologize for the scheduling mistake and wanted to rectify the situation. We were able to do our tasting at Dortoni’s in Levittown since the location was more accommodating for us. From that point on, I dealt directly with Corey, he gave me his cell phone and personal email and I was able to meet with him at one of his other locations which was located 20 minutes from our house. Corey was truly fantastic. My husband and I wanted a simple and elegant cake. Corey took the time to go all the choices we had for wedding cakes and designs as well as the differences in whip cream, buttercream and fondant. I showed him a few pictures for both our wedding and grooms cake and he said they were definitely able to do all of them. From that point, I can say we had a great experience with La Bonne Boulangerie. We really enjoyed going to our cake tasting and Jen at Dortoni’s was a doll. She brought us different flavors of cake even ones we didn’t pre-pick, which was perfect!! For our wedding cake, we went with a 3 tiered white cake with white ganache and chocolate mousse filling . It was exactly what we wanted and absolutely delicious. For the groom's cake, I picked whip cream with Oreos and chocolate buttercream as I knew my husband liked those. I did a Caddy Shack themed cake for my husband, he and his groomsmen are big into golf and I was excited to surprise him with it. The cake looked incredible, the cake designer is not only talented but knocked it out of the park, we were so glad we used La Bonne Boulangerie for both our cakes. They did an outstanding job and I highly recommend using them for any event.

e was a focal point at our wedding and is still being talked about by friends and family!

photo i sent them. Fresh and delicious!

s along with some coffee. The cake at the wedding was so fresh and delicious. That was one of the main comments we received from people; how good the cake was! Highly recommended!

rm any information so I had to go in myself and confirm that all would be taken care of. Seems like they could benefit from a CRM or some type of computer system that could remind them rather than a stack of receipts with different peoples chicken scratch on them. However, the cake was wonderful and designed as beautifully as we imagined and it tasted great as well. We asked them to use an ingredient that they never used before and they accommodated is and used it. I think they were afraid to use more elderflower syrup so we didn’t really taste it all that much but it was there and it was wonderful. All in all they are a solid place to order from for any event. I would not hesitate to use them again.

went for my tasting they weren't ready for me. if I wanted flowers for the cake it was quite expensive. they nailed the duplication of the cake from the pic I sent them. they also misplaced my order but it was found quickly . delivery went smooth. I would book again

with us to pick our perfect decoration. With our wedding, we were able to get a 4 tier cake, we decided on a classic decoration. After that, they took care of everything. We gave them a cake topper to use and they added it while at the venue. It was gorgeous and they were so helpful and professional. We would definitely work with them again.

hey enjoyed our cake.

at a cute little table for tastings--we chose the strawberry shortcake and the chantilly berry fillings with a vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream icing for our July 6, 2018 wedding. We got to taste at least 6 different fillings and types of cake along with complimentary coffee. Rony (possibly Rudy!) helped us, and made the process quick, painless, easy, and fun! We are so glad that we went with Dortoni, and we will definitely be back if we need any other cakes for special occasions! They have great prices, and delicious offerings. Thank you for making our wedding cake dreams come true!

of what we were leaning towards and on the day of the wedding it was EXACTLY what we wanted. Everything was perfect!

dding, cuz they’d misplaced my order paper (which had the date on it) The final product was very good though

cake topper with them and on the day of the wedding, our beautiful cake was there, exactly how I had imagined it. And it was delicious! I would definitely recommend them.

re huge critics. When we first told our families we chose Italian cake they did not know what to expect. All I can say is that Maggie absolutely blew their minds as well as ours. We could not have asked for a better cake and a better baker in Maggie. If you want to experience the same joy that we all did ask for Maggie and try the fresh strawberries in chantilly, you will not regret it. Again, Thanks Maggie!!

Both were equally tasty! After our wedding I had a few people tell me how delicious the cake was! Not only did our cake taste amazing, it was beautiful! We chose to have a "naked" style cake, so there was minimal frosting and parts of the cake could be seen. We added fresh flowers on the cake and it was truly gorgeous! I wish I could add a picture for you all to see. Again, not being much of a cake fan, I wasn't too worried about the cake that day. When my groom and I had a look at the room before our guests entered, it was one of the first things we noticed. It really was beautiful! We will definitely be using Dortoni's in the future for our events!

e what you want. They also gave me a certificate for a 1 year anniversary cake so I don't have to save the topper. How great is that!? The lemon mousse filling is my favorite- refreshing and different. I also showed them a photo of what I wanted and they make it exactly as I had it pictured. Also very friendly and helpful staff. I would definitely recommend them for your big day, they won't let you down.

nnoli cake, and it was absolutely amazing. The cake was one of the things we were most excited for and Dortoni's delivered!

ream and they completely wow'ed everyone!! We have gotten so many compliments on our cake! We were lucky enough to have some packed up for us to take home since we were so busy and were glad we did! They also gave us a certificate so in 1 year they will bake us a new small cake just like our wedding cake so we dont have to freeze it and eat the old one!

r Corey tried upcharging us several hundred dollars because it was not one of the 5 standard options. He said he had 2 different shops to make the cakes and this would have to go to their outside shop. We were incredibly disappointed. You would figure that with the amount of business they received through Giorgio’s they would be willing to do this simple cake design. Corey came off very arrogant and didn’t want to be bothered. Also the pictures of the designs they offered were extremely unprofessional, they were pictures taken of another picture on an iPad and were all pixely and blurry making it difficult to even see designs We also wanted flowers to put on the cake. We offered to bring the flowers to them the day before and they said that Giorgio’s has to do that. Long story short, Giorgio’s told us we could use Campbell’s bakery in Brentwood and they did the design without a problem and also put the flowers on for us. If you have a wedding at Giorgio’s, ask what other vendors that you can use for cakes.

se it’s either too sweet or too dry. Our cake was neither. It was so moist and delicious and the fresh strawberries and blueberries in chantilly were so full of flavor and brightness. They nailed the design of our cake and the color of it and even made a miniature vegan version for our guests as well. We were a little put off by the presentation of their cake tasting (there was only 2 small pieces of the two cake flavors we picked to sample the 6 toppings with). And when I called up to finalize the order, after going over it all with one of the girls at our tasting, the girl on the other end told me my cake was a buttercream cake and not a fondant cake (which was incorrect as the girl helping us at the tasting had checked with the manager and was told it would need fondant for the design we wanted). However, I was put at ease when I went in person and the original girl who had helped us out was there and my cake order was placed correctly. Everyone loved the cake and we can’t wait to have it again on our 1 year anniversary!

odating of our changes and putting together exactly what we wanted. We were so pleased with how it came out and received so many compliments on it. We sneak back to Dortoni any time we're in Long Island just to taste their treats!

e cake when they clearly hadn't even had it started. It arrived on time and in perfect condition

ferent combinations while letting us explore independently. Once the cake flavor was locked in, Candice sat with us and showed us examples of other cakes. We added a medallion to the outside of the top tier and Candice figured out a way to perfectly attach it. Our cake looked amazing and tasted even better! Guest keep telling us it was the best wedding cake they ever had and we just have to agree with them! We highly recommend Dortoni for any event. I know we will be back for future celebrations! Thank you so much Dortoni!

ribed it. We left the final touches up to our florist who added beautiful roses and macaron cookies supplied by the baker. All and all a delicious cake. The chantilly cream filling with fresh berries was so so good! Cake was drizzles with gold fit for a king and queen!!

uld look. Pulling for cakes the bakery had already done. The cake not only had a giant bubble on the side of the cake but the flowers did not look like they were suppose to and the lettering on the cake was wrong. When I called to discuss the issues after my wedding I was told on three occasions that Cory could call me back which he didn’t. I was finally told to send an email. In that email I included all the photos of how the cake was suppose to look and what the cake ended up looking like. I then had to keep following up and finally one of the women who answers the phone tells me Cory said I would be getting a refund. After a month of waiting for the check is was only 1/2 of what I paid. All of my wedding photos with the cake are ruined and mind you the cake was included but I paid extra for the specific things I wanted that I did not get. They have since refused to issued me the remainder of what I paid. Avoid this bakery at all cost they do not deliver on what they promise.

as easy and as busy as the bakery was, everyone was so helpful and attentive. They made our cake exactly like the picture we sent them. Excellent job :)

dropped when I saw our cake during the reception, it was definitely the prettiest wedding cake I've ever seen. I'm also not a cake person, but it was really delicious! We got vanilla cake with the chocolate whipped cream filling. It was so light and not overly sweet at all. Our cake was just perfect and I couldn't have asked for anything more. Thank you so much, Dortoni! We're excited to cut into our top tier on our first anniversary!