Dortoni Bakery

Our wedding cake came out absolutely beautiful. Exactly how we wanted it! The cake itself tasted delicious and ordering it was seamless! Delivered on time and looked gorgeous !

Our cake through Dortoni’s (Levittown) was included with our package at our wedding venue, but we were truly blown away when we went for our tasting (we previously had such low expectations for wedding cake, but Dortoni’s proved us wrong). We are chocoholics but decided on a vanilla cake with cannoli cream and chocolate ganache; we are still dreaming about it. We did wind up paying extra to get a specific design I fell in love with, but they did a great job replicating our vision—it was beautiful. They also gave us a voucher at the tasting for a complimentary first-anniversary cake —we can’t wait. Make sure to ask for it! PC: @jeanettejoyphoto

Our wedding cake was perfect. So delicious! We upgraded for a specific design which was probably overpriced, but worth it because it made me happy. The cake tasting experience was also so fun. So excited for our one year anniversary cake next year. I think you can’t go wrong with Dortoni!

We had our cake through Dortoni as it was part of our package at Villa Lombardi’s. We had our tasting in Levittown. It was busy but the staff were attentive and helpful. Our cake looked beautiful and tasted even better. Highly recommend!

I have known Dortoni for many years and I enjoyed working with them on my wedding cake. They have the tasting process down to a science and made the selection process easy. I would definitely work with them again for any future cake needs and highly recommend the Nutella filling.

My husband and I went to Dortoni in Levittown for our cake tasting and had such a great experience. Everyone was so nice and checked on us throughout the tasting. Everything was delicious which made it hard to pick which cake. We ended up doing alternating layers with marble cake and chocolate dobash and then vanilla cake with strawberries and fresh whipped cream. The cake came out gorgeous and all of my guests raved how delicious it was! I highly recommend Dortoni Bakery for your wedding.

We had an excellent experience working with Dortoni in Levittown for our wedding cake. The tasting process was seamless, and they offer excellent customer service. Their staff was available to answer all of our questions via email and in person at the tasting. We liked getting to pick the design of our cake from the many photo examples they had on hand. Our wedding cake was delicious and gorgeous, our guests are still raving about it!

We were a bit restricted due to the contract with Fox Hollow, when it came to picking out the cake from here but we made it work. We paid extra for the design once again the contract was restrictive. This isn't the reason why I gave 3 stars. The reason for it was because we were told by the bakery that they would put the cake topper on for us and charged us a fee which we paid for this service, only to find out on the day of our wedding that the toppers were not on the cake. I don't know how but the Maitre'd got in contact with the store after hours and was able to recover them for us. It was so disappointing. They are so quick to upcharge for any changes and then they do things like this. There was nothing that stood out for when it came to cake flavor. We went with them simply because we did not have the time to shop around for another bakery since the wedding was planned in 3 months.

I was a little skeptical of ordering my wedding cake from Dortoni. I have read many poor reviews and I have ordered cakes there myself the past few years and it has not been the same since they switched owners. We went to the one in Commack to do our tasting because the Fox Hollow now only works with Dortoni (which I was not thrilled with at first). It was a little difficult to make an appointment at first they seemed a little confused as to what I was looking for and the manager was only there on certain days so we had to go on a day she was working. But when we met her she was lovely and let us try 3 different cakes and 6 different fillings. Unfortunately the contract with Dortoni through the Fox Hollow does not allow cake flavors other than vanilla and chocolate or there’s an extra charge (again, not Dortoni’s fault) and Fox Hollow only allows one filling, where most venues will allow 2 (again, not Dortoni’s doing). So if you plan to use Fox Hollow for your venue take that in mind you will have to pay extra per head for anything extra you may like in your dream wedding cake. They were as accommodating as they could be with giving us a slight discount since we were already paying for a different cake flavor that when we picked a second filling they gave us half off, they did what they could to make our cost less of a burden. They even gave us a voucher for our 1 year anniversary top tier cake. The cake was delicious and I can’t wait to eat it again next year on our anniversary!

Our venue works with Dortoni's so a cake was included in our contract. I've seen some negative reviews of Dortoni's recently, but I have nothing but positive things to say about them. Our tasting was a very nice experience, and I was easily able to communicate with them via email leading up to it. We went with a oreo buttercream filling and a vanilla sponge cake. It was SO good and it looked so beautiful. All of our guests loved the cake, I don't remember seeing a full piece left on any tables. We also get a small round cake on our 1 year anniversary at no cost. Love them!

Our vanilla cake with lemon buttercream was beautiful and absolutely delicious! We received many compliments on it. We would have given them 5 stars but this company was very difficult to communicate with. We would still recommend them though!

Thank you Dortoni for making an amazing wedding cake for our wedding! We used Dortoni's through our wedding venue (Crest Hollow) and were communicating with Dortoni's manager, Ang, throughout the process of scheduling tasting to finalizing/confirming to getting our cake on the day of. Ang was great to work with and easy to communicate with! Our cake, chocolate with strawberry filling, was delicious.