My experience with Eldon was good. He helped me narrow down what I wanted, and from experience of doing the opposite ;), I would trust him when he says "please choose your bridesmaids' dresses and colors first"...that definitely changes things..., even if you decide on some great ideas in the initial visit before finalzing dresses! I had no idea what I wanted when I went in, so I guess what I got was a product of that...
I will say that I love what he ended up doing with my bridal bouquet! It was gorgeous. The bridesmaids were supposed to have rounds, but ended up with cascades the day of, which was actually a pleasant surprise b/c they were gorgeous as well. :) Boutineers were nice and my mom loved her coursage.
The toss bouquet was obviously something he forgot until probably the day of, as it was supposed to be similar to mine/bridesmaids full bouquets only smaller, but ended up being about 5 flowers tied together at the stems with a bow. I was actually embarrased to display/throw it, but ya know, who cares in the end I guess. The flower arrangements I wanted for the altar were supposed to flow down the columns on which they sat, but ended up just being large arrangements that sat on top of the pillars. They were ok and I'm sure they will look nice in photos...I had planned on taking them to the reception after the ceremony, but I ended up just leaving them at the church since they weren't quite what I'd pictured.
All in all, with the very little communication Eldon and I had, things turned out pretty well. I assumed the job he did would be outstanding and utterly perfect due to his reputation and pricing, and I'd say I got about 85% of what I expected. I do recommend them, and I would make sure you control the # of times you meet (more is better though his team sort of discourages more times than the 'usual' bride takes, i.e. 2), be sure there is a very clear outline of what you want down on paper, and show him pictures of what you like. I think if we'd been sitting in front of the photos I based my description on instead of talking about it on the phone, I may have gotten more of what I envisioned.
I will add this...I was blown away by an arrangement Eldon came up with for a family funeral the week prior to the wedding--he is very creative!! He also did a very nice job of advising me during the wedding planning, about how the light in my ceremony venue would change what flowers stood out in my bouquet, etc. I wouldn't trust anyone else with those details and couldn't have expected anyone to give me that education since you don't know what you don't know. :) My experience was a positive one, and Eldon and his team are very talented, so check them out!