I was going to use Frosted Cakery for my wedding cake, but they did not want to make my cake. At least that is how my husband and I felt.
Our consultation for the cake lasted l...ess than 15 minutes, and did not have anything to do with the cake flavors. The wedding being on a Monday meant that we would have to pick up the cake Saturday. Ok that would be fine.
I told the lady I wanted a naked cake, and she told me it would be ugly, and she would not make it. We had a back up plan of a triforce cake, we had a themed wedding. The lady asked us if our guests would get it, because a cake like that would not look good in her opinion. She was more concerned with us having a cake that she approved of, and not what we wanted.
At this point she said she would call us wit h a price for the cake. There was not talk of flavors. That was the point that was most important to me. When we asked about the cake flavors we were told to just by cupcakes. That we did, and I was not impressed. I have been baking since I was able to walk, and have won many awards for my cakes so I know a thing or two about baking. These cupcakes, we tried 4, were overcooked and had an excessive amount of frosting. I had them with my in-laws and they agreed that it was like they used the frosting to cover up the poor cake.
Again the cakes were pretty, and if that is all you want this is your place.