About this vendor
Guilty Bakery is a wedding baking company based in Plymouth, MA. Owners Amy and Krista adore the opportunity to provide once-in-a-lifetime celebrations with their sensational selection of delicious baked goods. From classic tiered wedding cakes to delicious brownies, they craft every treat from scratch using only the finest ingredients for superior taste and flavor.
Amy and Krista met in 2010 while they were both working for the prestigious Boston-based company The Catered Affair. They quickly bonded over their shared love for baking and creativity, and in 2012, they opened Guilty Bakery on Main Street in downtown Plymouth. Since then, they have provided countless celebrations with one-of-a-kind baked goods that taste as good as they look.
Whatever your wedding dessert vision might look like, the Guilty Bakery team is ready to bring it to life. In your initial 30-minute tasting, you will be invited to outline your preferences and taste a delicious selection of cupcakes and cakes. From there, Ana and Krista will prepare your dream baked-good package, offering a selection of services including decoration, piping, airbrushing, delivery, and more.
Details
Awards and Affiliations
4-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2025.2023.2022.2021.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Hall of Fame
Earned by winning 'Best of Weddings' four or more times.
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.058 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 8
Guilty Bakery completely exceeded our expectations for our wedding desserts! We ordered a red velvet wedding cake that not only looked absolutely beautiful but was also extremely d...
elicious. In addition to the cake, we opted for their dessert bar, and our guests haven't stopped raving about the incredible variety of options, with the carrot cake cupcakes standing out as a massive fan favorite of the night. On top of the phenomenal food, working with them was a seamless experience. They were exceptionally responsive to our last-minute changes to the spread and patiently answered all our questions regarding dietary needs so we could easily share that information with our guests.
My wife and I are already looking forward to ordering some more treats from them for our next anniversary (and possibly the next ones after that)!
The wedding cake was delicious and although I missed out on the dessert bar, I have heard from guests that they were all very good!
The bakery they use was absolutely delicious! We decided to do a small cake along with a dessert bar, and it was one of the best decisions we made. There were so many great options...
to choose from, which made it easy to find desserts that fit us and our guests perfectly.
Everything tasted amazing, and our guests could not stop talking about how good the desserts were all night. By the end of the wedding, there was barely anything left because people were literally stuffing desserts into their purses to take home for later. That alone says how incredible everything was!
We booked Guilty Bakery through our venue, Barker House. We did the package of a small cutting cake and various desserts. Our carrot cake was delicious, and we received a ton of co...
mpliments on the various desserts, although we didn’t have any ourselves. One tip to future couples - it sounded like the desserts went quick, so think about ordering more than they offer in the package. I definitely recommend Guilty Bakery.
Absolutely incredible carrot cake - and they were so flexible with options for cupcakes to add on for our wedding guests. My family has severe allergies and they were extremely pro...
fessional and accomodating for them, ensuring they could eat everything without concern. We plan to return for desserts for our anniversary each year to celebrate!
We had the carrot cake for our wedding cake and everyone was LOVING it. They kept asking where we got it from because they thought it was so delicious. People still are bringing it...
up months later. Thank you Guilty Bakery! :)
We were really happy with our wedding cake from Guilty Bakery! They were easy to work with and helpful in bringing our vision to life. They paid close attention to the details, and...
the final cake looked beautiful and tasted great. We chose two flavors—Lemon Berry and Carrot Cake—and both were a hit with our guests. Overall, a great experience and choice for wedding cakes!
We loved working with the team at Guilty Bakery when looking to create our perfect wedding cake! The tasting process was professional, informative, and we walked out feeling like o...
ur voices were heard. We haven't gotten photos back yet, but the cake was gorgeous and delicious. Highly recommend!
Guilty Bakery surpassed our expectations when it came to the dessert chosen for our wedding a few weeks ago on Nov 1st. My husband and I chose to do a simple cutting cake (carrot c...
ake) featuring our dog! For our guests, we chose a variety of assorted desserts including cupcakes, hermits, cannolis, whoopie pies, apple pie bars, and key lime tartlettes. The desserts were delicious!!! We had a great experience working with Amy & Krista!
We chose Guilty Bakery to create our wedding cake, and we couldn't be happier with our decision. From the initial taste testing to the delivery on our wedding day, their team was i...
ncredibly helpful and accommodating. They took the time to go over every detail to ensure that our cake was perfect for our special day. When the cake arrived, it was not only stunning but also tasted just as delicious as we remembered from the tasting months prior. We highly recommend Guilty Bakery for anyone looking for a wedding cake that is not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. Our experience with them was truly amazing, and we are so grateful for their expertise and attention to detail.
Guilty Bakery was amazing for our wedding. We got a cake, which was delicious, but the highlights were the cookie sandwiches and party bars.
We loved the desserts so much we will...
be coming back to the bakery just to pick up some more treats when we are in the area.
The cake tasting was a lot of fun and tasty at their Hanover location.
The wedding cake was so yummy and beautiful.
Would highly recommend. For any special or not so special even...
t 😋
They also accommodated our gluten free guests with some very yummy cup cakes.
I will definitely call on them again 🥰
We worked with Guilty via our venue; Barker House by Wedgewood weddings. They were great in communicating and enthusiastic about our inspiration and ideas. They were able to bring ...
our ideas to life so simply and I'd use them 100x over again! The cake pops were delicious and a huge hit for our guests.
Guilty Bakery was a pleasure to work with, even when we scaled back some of our choices with them for our wedding. The staff are friendly and personable, and at the bakery when I w...
as picking up my cake samples they helped me get some vegan and gluten-free choices to try for some of our guests! Their pricing is incredibly reasonable for a small bakery, and I would definitely pick up some vegan and gluten-free treats from them again for our next gathering!
We loved working with Guilty Bakery for our wedding cake at our reception at Granite Links. We went with something really simple and then had our florist add fresh flowers. Everyon...
e raved about the vanilla with blonde Oreos flavor we picked. We worked with them to have Gf/DF cupcakes available as well. Would recommend!
Guilty Bakery was incredible! We had our tasting many months before the wedding as we were planning from out of state, and they were so accommodating with our tight schedule. On to...
p of their top class professionalism, our cake and cupcake combination was all I could've asked for and more. They took my inspiration and made it better than I could've imagined. The flavors were truly outstanding - the talk of all of guests! I couldn't have asked for a better bakery to make my simple and flavor filled wedding cake dreams come true. We highly recommend them :)
My husband and I found Guilty Bakery through the preferred vendors list at our reception venue and they did not disappoint!
The team was so friendly at the initial tasting and al...
l of the cake options were delicious! We knew from the moment that we met Amy that we wanted to give Guilty Bakery our business.
They are a growing team so they definitely seem busy, but when I called to check in a week ahead of the event they had everything in line (right in the Christmas rush too!) and the execution for the day of our wedding was 10/10. Thank you to the Guilty Bakery team for baking and designing our beautiful floral pattern cake and being so fantastic to work with!!
Where do I start?! From our tasting to the delivery on the day of our wedding, I have nothing but amazing things to say about this bakery. Our tasting was very relaxed and personab...
le and all of the cake flavors were so wonderful, it was so hard to choose! We booked a 2-tier cake and various other desserts for our sweets table at our wedding. Every single thing was PERFECT. People are still talking about the maple bacon donut holes! They took my cake inspiration photos and made my vision better that I even imagined. They needed no direction the day of the wedding and were always super professional in any communication we had leading up to. If you’re considering Guilty Bakery for your wedding cake/desserts- DO IT!
We ordered a 4 tier wedding cake from Guilty Bakery with 4 flavors. The tasting at their kitchen was so much fun! We got to try a good assortment and the team was really helpful wi...
th our questions. We were happy and surprised to realize that a larger cake was in our budget! Our guests loved the cake, and it was very beautiful! I highly recommend Guilty Bakery for your wedding cake!
We got our wedding cake through Guilty Bakery and absolutely loved it! We went to their Hanover location for our cake tasting where we got to try 6 of their most popular event cake...
flavors and they were all absolutely delicious - it was very hard to decide what to choose! We talked through design options and ended up going with a 4 tier lemon raspberry cake. They were even able to incorporate some extra faux florals that we were using as decorations for our wedding so it visually fit in very naturally at the venue. Our guests were raving about the cake all night and we were so lucky our venue partnered with Guilty Bakery to ensure we had the best night ever!
Literally the best funfetti wedding cake I have ever had. Guilty bakery crushed it and were so easy to work with! Our cake was stunning and exactly what we envisioned.
💜Mary-Kat...
e & Derek Kademian
The best wedding cake and deserts soooooooo good. The team at Guilty are the best
I would highly recommend Guilty Bakery. So very professional and the best tasting cakes and deserts ever. If you are around Plymouth Ma, make a stop at the retail bakery. You w...
on't be disappointed.
Guilty bakery NAILED my wedding cake dreams! They were able to make EXACTLY what I asked for. I wanted glazed donuts on tiers with a 6 inch cake on top for the sake of "cutting the...
cake". I supplied the tiers to my wedding venue, and they showed up to set up the entire thing include the intertwinement of baby breathes. It was absolutely perfect. Thank you Guilty Bakery Plymouth!
Overall had an exceptional experience with Guilty Bakery. Most of our wedding planning was done from out of state and we decided to go with the vendor based off the reviews alone, ...
without even trying the cake flavors first! When we finally did a tasting, we were given a to-go box of a bunch of different flavors of our choosing and they ended up all being delicious, which certainly made the decision more difficult. We ended up going with the lemon berry cake and it did not disappoint. Throughout the whole design process they were flexible with our decisions and upfront about pricing. The cake was delivered on time and it was so beautiful and delicious. Would recommend to anyone looking for a great wedding cake vendor.
Two words: PARTY BARS! We ordered enough dessert for 150 people... long story short we only had about a 50 person wedding and the desserts were almost all gone!! With a last minute...
delivery address change and the power out days leading up to the wedding, Guilty Bakery did not miss a beat! The cupcakes and party bars were to die for and we were so happy with everything!
This bakery is amazing. When we were deciding what cake flavor to choose, we could not decide because they were all so good. We even did a ranking system with multiple people invol...
ved but everyone favored a different flavor. Therefore, instead of a cake, we decided to do a bunch of cupcakes in different flavors and our guests loved them. There were more than enough to go around. Additionally, we got a small cake that was gorgeous! We did not give much design direction so were pleasantly surprised by how beautiful the cake was (and also delicious)!
Krista and Amy at Guilty Bakery were so wonderful to work with. From tasting to booking and selecting desserts, Guilty Bakery made the process so easy and fun. They delivered exact...
ly what I was looking for with my cake design, and worked with my florist in the day of the wedding to decorate the cake. Most important, the desserts were DELICIOUS. Our guests were raving about the cake, party bars, and cookie sandwiches. I highly recommend Guilty Bakery!
We did a dessert bar and small wedding cake for our wedding day and Guilty Bakery went above and beyond. The desserts were fantastic and everyone could not stop raving about them. ...
Our cake, was so beautiful I almost did not want to cut into it, but when I remembered there was the delicious funfetti inside, we just had to! From the amazing customer service and the extraordinary attention to detail and taste, we are so incredibly happy that Guilty Bakery was the "sweetest" part of our wedding day!
Our cake was fantastic! It was delicious and looked amazing!
We are so incredibly happy we chose Guilty Bakery! From the day we did our tasting all the way up to our big day, Amy & Krista were extremely supportive and helpful in making our c...
ake dreams come to life. We were absolutely thrilled at the way it turned out. More importantly - it was DELICIOUS!! We went for classic Vanilla Raspberry and it was perfect. So perfect that I had a cousin immediately reach out so that she could order one for a birthday party! We saved our top tier, so we are so looking forward to getting to taste it again. You will not regret using Guilty Bakery - thank you Amy & Krista!!
I HIGHLY recommend Guilty Bakery! Amy & Krista were so supportive & easy to communicate with throughout our planning process! Our cake was absolutely stunning & beyond delicious ...
:)
Responsive and professional. The cake was delicious and everyone raved about it! They even made cake tasting possible during a pandemic with a take home option!
We decided not to let the pandemic get the best of us, and opted for a somewhat last minute, intimate wedding celebration on NYE. We live on the South Shore and I follow a gluten ...
sensitive diet. In searching for a wedding cake we wanted to include both a traditional and GS tier without compromising taste. Guilty Bakery was an obvious option for us, having enjoyed their treats before. They offered us a take home, pandemic friendly, tasting of 6 flavor options. Choosing Guilty Bakery was an easy decision, even if choosing flavors was tough! We were very happy with the beautiful design and quality of our delicious cake, and also ordered a small take home anniversary cake in red velvet. We also opted to utilize a specialty of Guilty Bakery, and ordered french macarons packaged as favors. Our guests were delighted with them. The ladies of Guilty Bakery were very easy to work with. I would not hesitate to recommend Guilty Bakery for celebration cakes or tasty treats anytime!
Highly recommend for your wedding cake! We had a small cake for our ceremony this year, and it was so light and delicious that even our diet-friendly family members were raving abo...
ut the cake. The quality of their cake and frosting is truly distinct in its freshness and flavor, and the presentation of the cake was beautiful as well. The team was incredibly easy to work with both pre-COVID and during COVID. While we were not able to have an in-person tasting due to COVID guidelines, it was incredibly easy to set up a take-home tasting and such a great idea to present the cakes and frostings separately so that we could try a variety of combinations. Overall I would highly recommend for your wedding cake and can't wait to have some more cake for our 2021 reception!
We used Guilty Bakery for our wedding cake - and needless to say, we were not disappointed!! From our very first email, the team was extremely responsive and so easy to work with. ...
Because of the pandemic we couldn’t do anything “in person” but from the tasting to all my emails with questions about sizes and flavors and changing delivery locations and times - they were extremely accommodating and so friendly. And most importantly the cake was delicious and all of our guests were raving about it. Will definitely use this bakery whenever we are in the area and in need of something yummy!
We used Guilty Bakery for our wedding in Newport, RI in September!! I had eaten their desserts before but never had wedding cakes. I gave them pretty much free range on design and ...
they made the most BEAUTIFUL cakes I had ever seen. They decided on 3 smaller instead of 1 large cake and they all were so beautiful and went with out entire theme. Not only were they gorgeous but hands down the best funfetti cake I have ever had in my life. I still think about how delicious the cakes were and cannot wait to order from them again!!
Guilty Bakery was an absolute joy to work with! We had so much fun at the tasting - so hard to pick a flavor because they were all delicious. We ended up choosing two flavors and t...
he cake turned out perfect. It looked beautiful and tasted even better :) Thank you, ladies, for doing such a great job!
Amy & Krista were a joy to work with and they are exceptionally talented. They took our random collection of ideas for a unique theme and delivered a gorgeous wedding cake beyond o...
ur imagination. Every detail was perfect and the cake was delicious! Especially the gluten-free top tier for me. We will definitely be ordering from them for other occasions.
I was so pleased to work with this adorable women-owned business for my wedding! My fiance and I met with Krista for our tasting, and she was always very responsive to our emails a...
nd questions. Krista and her team were able to accommodate our ask for a gluten-free cake with no problem, and we chose a chocolate cake with vanilla mousse and French macarons. The result was absolutely fantastic! I would definitely work with Guilty Bakery again and highly recommend their treats!!
Absolutely delicious cakes and cookies! We had the best time at our cake tasting. We chose the funfetti, coffee Oreo, and red velvet. We also got chocolate chip, double chocolate a...
nd oatmeal raisin cookies! I will 100% be going back whenever I am feeling reminiscent about the wedding!
We used Guilty Bakery for our wedding cake and cupcakes - and it was amazing. We went in for a tasting and sampled a number of different flavors, every one of which was SO good. Am...
y and Krista listened to everything we were thinking of doing, asked great questions and showed us what they could do to meet our budget and preferences. The two-tier funfetti cake was delicious and looked exactly like what I was imagining. The mini cupcakes were a huge hit with our guests and flew off the table! Thank you guys! We’ll be back soon for sure!
We LOVED working with the ladies of Guilty Bakery. They created a beautiful three tier semi-naked cake for us for our wedding day which our florist then decorated with fresh flower...
s - it fit our rustic wedding theme perfectly. They were also able to make the top two layers a chocolate vegan flavor with vegan vanilla frosting, which allowed me to enjoy our cake! Guests raved about the cake (and had no idea it was vegan). The petite desserts they provided for our dessert table were also beautiful and went very quickly! In addition, the ladies were SO easy and professional to communicate with - they answered every question we had, and were so nice to meet in person during our tasting. We can't wait to work with them for another event in the future!
Excellent! Amy and Krista are always a pleasure to work with. I first had Amy and Krista make a custom birthday cake and it was so good that I knew they would be the ones for our w...
edding cake. The cake was done beautifully, arrived in perfect condition, and the flavors of their cakes are my favorite. The signature flavor is sweet but not too sweet, and we had a custom made mississippi mud pie flavor that was spot on!
We will definitely use them for many future events!
We chose Guilty Bakery on the recommendation of our venue, and good thing we did because our wedding cake was possibly our favorite part of our day!
Not only was it super delici...
ous (light, not too sweet, the perfect amount of frosting), but it was so gorgeous. I couldn't stop looking at it all night!
We only wish we got to eat more of it, but we will definitely be going back to Guilty Bakery again and again. Amy and Krista were so easy to work and completely understood what we were looking for. They went above and beyond, and they were so responsive via email which was great, and really put us at ease.
Can't recommend Guilty Bakery enough!
We chose Guilty Bakery for our November 3, 2018 wedding and was so happy that we did. Our vision was simple, a small naked type cake with greenery around the base. Upon contactin...
g Guilty Bakery, they did not have any openings for a cake tasting but the great thing was you can actually choose your own flavors via e-mail, and pick them up and do a taste testing in your own home! We went with a vanilla cake, with coffee Oreo filling, and buttercream frosting. Not only did the actual cake not disappoint, the look of the cake was so simple but they made it appear so elegant, which was our vision. We then also added their apple cider doughnuts, which our guests continue to rave about. We would highly recommend Guilty Bakery for any occasion, as they are super professional, easy to work with, and overall spectacular.
Amy and Krista were wonderful to work with. The cake was beautiful. I got the signature cake; which was very good but the taste of the cake I’d give it 4/5 stars. Very happy wi...
th them!
Guilty Bakery was incredible! Their cake was delicious and they were able to customize it exactly as we wanted! They truly made our wedding day even more perfect! You will not be d...
isappointed!
Amy and Krista of Guilty Bakery made the wedding cake process so easy and fun! From the moment I met them at the cake tasting to the day of the wedding, they made everything run so...
smoothly. The cake they made for my wedding was absolutely beautiful! It was also wildly delicious. They were able to give us 4 tiers and 4 different flavors. Our guests are still raving about how yummy each slice was. I did not have to worry about one thing while working with them. They are both very professional and easy to work with. I highly recommend using Guilty Bakery.
Choosing a cake vendor was one of the most difficult parts of the wedding planning process for me (the bride :)). Guilty ended up being our top choice because of their many flavors...
(ALL super delicious), willingness to work with us to create our dream design (all via email and phone, as we were planning out of state and unable to sit down together in-person), and great value. Communication was sometimes a bit difficult (but I understood this a bit better when my family and I visited their small, busy shop in-person). I also wish the groom and I had had the opportunity to taste more of the different layers (each was a different flavor) but we look forward to enjoying our topper on our first anniversary!
Contact
54 Main St., Plymouth, MA
