Our name says it all - heavenly! One taste and you will agree. Real butter, real cane sugar, the finest ingredients, our signature butter cream frosting, our cakes taste and look amazing!
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories, Cake Tastings
Awards and Affiliations
Heavenly Sweets Cakes Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 5/24/2022 by Lynne W
I can’t begin to say how beautiful and delicious our daughter’s wedding cake was, I wish I could upload a photo! She had a clear vision of how she wanted her cake to look and Tanya at Heavenly Sweets more than delivered. Our guests remarked on ...
how moist and tasty the cake was, many expressed they wished they could have had another piece! We found Heavenly Sweets easy to work with, the cake delivery went off without a hitch, all in all an outstanding experience!
Reviewed On 2/20/2022 by Josh S
We had a lot of cake drama leading up to our wedding where we lost several vendors. When we walked into Heavenly Sweets and began interacting with the staff we knew we were dealing with professionals that were going to get the job done, do it w...
ell, and keep our wedding cake creation and delivery drama free!
The cake was incredible. It lasted perfectly throughout the day and everyone raved about how good it was. The cake we took home lasted quite a while too and never lost any of its original flavor.
Reviewed On 12/05/2021 by Kendall F
Tanya was a joy to work with and her cake was the best cake I have ever had. Multiple compliments were given about how delicious it was. It was decorated perfectly and she brought our vision to life.
Reviewed On 11/09/2021 by Lin K
The cake was beautiful and very delicious. Exactly as we picked it.
Reviewed On 11/02/2021 by Kate A
I absolutely loved our wedding cake from Heavenly Sweets! Our tasting was wonderful and the cake we decided on was a white cake with a raspberry filling and their superb frosting! I had multiple guests come up and tell me that they loved our ca...
ke! I am really traditional and had always planned to freeze our top tier, but with cake this good I gave in and my family and I enjoyed it throughout our wedding week!
Reviewed On 10/07/2021 by Elaine M
I can't explain how great this cake it. We did a blind taste test with 8 family members and 5 different bakeries around the Indianapolis area. Every single person picked Heavenly Sweets as their favorite! We were so glad we went with Heavenly S...
weets!! Our guests had nothing but incredible things to say as well!
Reviewed On 9/06/2021 by Julia Y
The. Cake. Is. Delicious. We received so many compliments on our cupcakes because of how delicious they were! Hands down the best cake that we tasted - do not pass this bakery up! We'll be going back every time we need cake or cupcakes from her...
e on out.
The one drawback is that Heavenly Sweets doesn't use online ordering or payments, it's all done in person or over the phone. That was a little difficult for us while planning during the pandemic, but they were communicative and easy to work with.
Reviewed On 8/10/2021 by Rachel B
The cake was beauty but more importantly it tasted amazing. Just like it tasted at the tasting. My mom and I went around and tasted all the popular wedding cake bakeries in the Indianapolis area. Heavenly sweets was the only place with moist, f...
lavorful, delicious cake. Everyone else was dry and a waste of our time. On my wedding day the cake was once again delicious and everyone talked about it and kept saying how good the cake was. I highly recommend the apricot creme filling!
Reviewed On 8/03/2021 by Stacey H
We were overjoyed with the cake for our daughters wedding! Tanya is so great to work with and made sure our daughter got exactly what she wanted, down to placing the flowers on the cake at the reception venue herself! The cake was not only beau...
tiful but was moist and rich as well. Our guests were raving about it! Thank you so much to Tanya and team!!
Reviewed On 5/04/2021 by Sara S
We hired Heavenly Sweets to make our wedding cake and it was absolutely fantastic! It looked great and tasted even better! All of our guests raved about how delicious the cake was all night. I would highly recommend this company if you are stil...
l looking for your wedding cake baker!
Reviewed On 11/21/2020 by Mallory D
I hired Heavenly Sweets to bake my wedding cake in early October and the cake could literally only be described as heavenly. To be completely honest, I'm not a huge cake person and had seriously considered going a more nontraditional route for ...
my wedding with either miniature pies or a big cheesecake. But after having a slice of their cake at a friend's wedding the year prior, I knew I had to have them for mine. The cake itself is perfectly moist and they have so many different flavors of buttercream, ganache, and fillings to make your wedding cake truly unique (and you get to try ALL of them at the tasting). Not to mention our three tiered cake looked absolutely stunning. We got countless compliments from guests and I couldn't recommend them more highly.
Reviewed On 11/08/2020 by Laura C
The cake was both beautiful and delicious! We knew as soon as we had the tasting that we had found the perfect cake. Heavenly Sweets was great to work with. Highly recommend!
Reviewed On 11/05/2020 by Breanna F
The cake was absolutely delicious, and our guests loved every last bit of it. However, it wasn’t exactly what we ordered or paid for. We upgraded the cake filling at time of order and purchase, but it arrived at the venue with the basic filling...
. We were disappointed, as we loved what we picked during the tasting. It took a few tries to contact someone at the store (and at first they didn’t believe us!), but after pointing out the price didn’t add up for what we got, they apologized and said they’d send us a check for the difference. Customer service wasn’t great, and they are not flexible on delivery times, but the cake is amazing and they did what they could to right the situation. I suppose just double check with the shop that they fill out their order form correctly...
Reviewed On 10/03/2020 by Katie S
Working with the wonderful ladies at Heavenly Sweets is really a personal experience. I did not feel like this was a transaction but a light hearted work experience is giving us the wedding cake we wanted. Our tasting was very personalized and ...
they made sure I knew exactly what the cake would look like!
Not to mention off the chart flavors! Really sad I had no leftover cake at our wedding..because everyone kept asking for more! But we did get a free Anniversary cake in our promo deal!
And with a COVID wedding that had to be cut short, they worked with us very easily and made a smaller cake..next year we will be having a big make-up reception with the larger real cake! Think I will stash a separate tier for us only! Ha
If I recommend one thing, it is to get a bigger cake than you think if you can. I did not realize how small the slices are cut by the venue to serve what the cake says it serves
Reviewed On 8/22/2020 by Jasmine C
Heavenly Sweets is amazing! We ordered a cake and cupcakes for our wedding and our guests couldn't get enough of them that we literally had zero left! Everyone was great to work with, very reasonable and flexible. Highly recommend!
Reviewed On 5/03/2020 by Eleni S
My husband and I used Heavenly Sweets for our wedding cake on 12/28/19. Our cake was beautiful and looked exactly like the pictures I provided for reference. In addition, it was absolutely delicious! Our guests raved about the buttercream frost...
ing and how tasty the cake was even after our wedding! Finally, Heavenly Sweets went above and beyond to ensure that all the details were perfect for the wedding day and provided a beautiful gold cake stand that matched our decor! We were very happy with how accommodating and easy to work with Heavenly Sweets was throughout the planning process and would definitely recommend their delicious cakes!
Reviewed On 4/20/2020 by Amanda B
We loved everything about Heavenly Sweets. After being unimpressed by the taste of cakes at other tastings, I immediately told my fiancé after one taste, this was our cake. The cake was one of the most important items for me at our wedding. It...
was so delicious. It was also beautiful! I ordered extra cake on purpose and we still went through it all. All I hear all night and for the weeks after was how amazing our cake was.
I loved the option of a free cake stand to use at our wedding or a replica top tier for our first anniversary as well. We did the cake stand and saved our top tier. We just celebrated our one year anniversary and we had no idea how it would taste when we unthawed it. Let me just say, it was as good as I remembered!
The owner was so informative and helpful in guiding us through the entire process. Highly recommend!!
Reviewed On 2/13/2020 by Ellicia H
The best experience I have had! Best tasting cake! Looked exactly as I wanted it to look! I recommend Heavenly Sweets to everyone looking for a cake or cupcake snack. I even went back and got my son’s birthday cake there. Everyone thought it wa...
s the best tasting cake they have ever had! Everyone was very nice and responsive and on time!
Reviewed On 2/02/2020 by Nicole N
Our wedding cake and cupcakes from Heavenly Sweets was amazing! It was the best cake I have ever had and it looked great too! I would highly recommend them to anyone and I can't wait to go back for more of their delicious cupcakes.
Reviewed On 1/30/2020 by Kelly J
Tanya is a true craftsman and she KNOWS her stuff! We thought we knew what would be best walking in, and we are so happy we listened to Tanya (and not our original plan) for our wedding cake. Excellent service, fair pricing, absolutely superb q...
Reviewed On 1/30/2020 by Caitlin C
This was one of the best cakes I have every had. We had two flavors Pumpkin Spice, and her butter flavor, and every person I've talked to who ate the cake LOVED them! I've had multiple people tell me they were going to show up at my house on ou...
r anniversary (as she offers an anniversary cake with the purchase of a wedding cake instead of having to freeze the top) so they can have more! Not only did the cake taste absolutely AMAZING, her decorating skills are awesome. My cake was absolutely stunning, I will just stare are the pictures of it. I could not recommend Heavenly Sweets more! Writing this makes me want to go there now and get more cake or any of her delicious deserts! :)
Reviewed On 1/30/2020 by Kristina H
Heavenly Sweets provided the best tasting cake I have ever eaten in my life! The tasting was so much fun and we got exactly what we dreamed of! The vendors did not have any last minute questions or hassle for me, the bride, the day of the weddi...
ng or even the days leading up to. They had a plan and stuck to it :)
Reviewed On 1/30/2020 by Marissa M
We live in Cleveland but were getting married in Indianapolis. Heavenly Sweets worked with us over the phone and with the assistance of our local friends to make sure that our cake was exactly what we were looking for! In a day full of stress, ...
Heavenly Sweets made sure that we had one less thing to worry about! The cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious!
Reviewed On 1/06/2020 by Brittany U
The cake was beautiful and exactly what I wanted. It was also the most delicious cake I have ever had! Customer service was great through the whole process. The tasting experience was so helpful. She had all the parts separate and walking us t...
hrough tasting the various combinations. We ended up with the golden butter cake with caramel filling and chocolate cake with raspberry filling. We will definitely be getting an anniversary cake from here!
Reviewed On 10/17/2019 by Angie J
The cake was not only beautiful but tasted amazing! So many people asked where we got the cake. We will use them in the future for other celebrations!
Reviewed On 10/17/2019 by JESSICA H
The only thing I knew 100% when beginning to plan for our wedding, was what I wanted the cake to look like. Although our cake was simple- THEY NAILED IT!!! I have never tasted a better cake in my life- it was moist and delicious and looked exa...
ctly like what I asked for. The cakes are quite expensive- but so worth it. Highly recommend!!!
Reviewed On 8/18/2019 by Ellie H
Our cake has been RAVED about ever since our wedding! We got Butter Golden cake and so many people asked that day and ever since about where we got it from. Heavenly Sweets was so accommodating and easy to work with when I had questions and nee...
ded to make changes. One of our emails back and forth was ended with "We're here for you!" and I truly felt that. The cake was beautiful, exactly what I wanted. We couldn't be more pleased with the way it turned out. We will be ordering our upcoming birthday cake from there, we liked it so much!
Reviewed On 6/13/2019 by Lauren C
By far the best cake I've ever had, it was beautiful and Heavenly Sweets went above and beyond to make the process and tasting smooth and wonderful. We had so many compliments on our cake, absolutely stunning and delicious! They also provide yo...
u a one year anniversary cake which is so awesome- not a lot of places do that!
Reviewed On 6/03/2019 by Sarah F
I first had Heavenly Sweets at a local bridal show a year before our wedding. I went to the bridal show being 98% sure I already knew who I was going to have bake my cake, but I was obviously going to accept all free cake samples I came across...
Thank goodness I did, because wow, Heavenly Sweets was AMAZING. Every sample I tried was amazing! There was one with apricot and white chocolate - and you know what I don't normally like? Apricot and white chocolate! You know what cake was delicious? Apricot and white chocolate!!
So when it came time to get our wedding cake, our first and only stop was to Heavenly Sweets.
I'm going to be honest here: I'm a difficult person. I am very picky when it comes to wedding cakes. I hate going to weddings and seeing the exact same styles on every single cake - we get it, you know how to pipe a rose/ruffles/drip/etc. and I knew that I wanted something different.
And so Tonya patiently worked with me and my husband to design a cake that was everything I wanted - she walked through many different size/shape combinations until I was happy, and then walked through ideas on designing all of the decorations.
When I saw my cake, I was in besotted. When I ate the cake, I was in love.
I have heard from so many guests that the cake was the best wedding cake they had ever had - and wished that I had enough for two slices per guest!
I'm thinking every cake occasion from here on out will involve a cake from Heavenly Sweets.
Reviewed On 5/28/2019 by Grace L
Our guests were all unanimous - best wedding cake ever! We knew we didn't want any fondant on our cake, and with our unique theme our cake needed to match that; Heavenly Sweets worked with us every step of the way to make sure we were happy wit...
h our final design, and even with the tight timeline everything went perfectly. It was another detail that helped our wedding rank near the top of everyone's "best wedding ever" list!
Reviewed On 5/12/2019 by Vanessa S
The Best Cake Ever!!!!
Heavenly Sweets was the best cake we have ever had!!! All of our 114 wedding guests raved at how delicious the cake was....even going as far to say it was the best piece of cake they EVER had! Heavenly Sweets was also gr...
eat to work with- after we made our choices, they handled everything with no worry. The consultation on flavors, design, and suggestions were spot on and truly made the final product the best.
The cake is always a topic of discussion at a wedding and many times we have been to other wedding with stale, dry or cheap cake. The presentation was also amazing! Heavenly Sweets is well worth the extra spend and will make you an amazing cake that your guests will love!
Reviewed On 5/06/2019 by Jessica D
Our cake for our wedding not only looked gorgeous, but tasted amazing! I am so happy with everything Heavenly Sweets did! We were able to give our guests multiple flavor choices. Our guests liked it so much they asked for additional servings. I...
f you are getting married I strongly recommend Heavenly Sweets for a beautiful cake that is everything you could imagine on your big day!
Reviewed On 2/18/2019 by Julie K
I knew I wanted a Heavenly Sweets cake for my wedding, but shopped around a bit to compare taste and price just to make sure I was making the right decision—and I was! Tanya and the team were wonderful to work with from our initial consultation...
through our wedding day. Our cake looked exactly as I had planned, and tasted even better than I had expected. I highly recommend Heavenly Sweets!
Reviewed On 2/18/2019 by Krissy G
I use to work at Heavenly Sweets before moving back to Kansas City, MO. This was one of the best small businesses I have ever worked for the employees are truly like a family and treat their clients with the same thoughtfulness. The flavor an...
d creativity of the cakes and cupcake are hands down the best in the Indianapolis area and beyond! If you are looking for a special occasion cake or just a sweet treat you have got to stop in!
Reviewed On 1/10/2019 by Lindsey S
Our wedding cake turned out absolutely perfect and was so delicious! Their buttercream frosting and fillings are to die for. We couldn't be happier with our decision to go with Tanya and the team from Heavenly Sweets!
Reviewed On 1/06/2019 by Emily L
Our wedding cake was both delicious and beautiful! So many people have told us how much they enjoyed the cake. We definitely recommend the apricot jam - we had it in both the white and chocolate cake layers and it was a hit!
Reviewed On 12/18/2018 by Christie G
When I was searching of a bakery to make my wedding cake I was more concerned about taste instead of what it looked like. My cake was amazing!! My husband loved the white chocolate mousse and the caramel fillings that I had originally wanted! S...
o that’s what we went with! The only issue I had was the glitter that I wanted on the cake was more sugar then glitter. It looked more like grey rice. So if you want glitter they have it at Joann’s. I would pick it up and ask them to apply it for you. But Like I said before I wanted Tonya and her amazing team for the taste more then the look. And they did an awesome job!
Reviewed On 12/01/2018 by Molly L
I didn't want to spend the money on the cake but I realized it was worth it! I went with a simply classic cake. It turned out exactly how I pictured. My florist added flowers to it. I had a lot of guests says wow I've had a lot of cake but this...
one is amazing! It was amazing and I wish I eat more of it! Thanks so much!!
Reviewed On 11/30/2018 by Brianna W
When I went to Heavenly Sweets for my first tasting I was very impressed! The cake was delicious and they worked so hard to make sure my vision came to life for the cake design. We had so many compliments from our guests on how great the cake w...
as! We can't wait to enjoy our one year anniversary cake next summer :)
Reviewed On 11/22/2018 by Meridith B
After the first bite of cake at our tasting, we both knew this would be the spot where we would get our wedding cake. We absolutely loved our cake and so did our guests! Taryn helped us in the process and the vision that we discussed on paper ...
was perfectly reflected on the end product. We loved the flavors, we had both almond and chocolate, and the butter cream is truly amazing. We're getting a small anniversary cake because we didn't save our topper and we can't wait to dig in again!
Reviewed On 11/19/2018 by Courtney A
Heavenly Sweets did an absolutely amazing job with our two-tier and cupcakes for our wedding. We received SO many compliments on both! The cake was just beautiful, and it was exactly what we wanted. We could not be happier that we chose to work...
with Heavenly sweets!
Reviewed On 11/18/2018 by Keri S
Simply delicious! Heavenly Sweets did a fantastic job on our wedding cakes. They were absolutely beautiful and delicious. In my opinion, Heavenly Sweets has the best tasting cakes in the greater surrounding Indianapolis area.
Reviewed On 9/17/2018 by Kayla R
We could not have asked for a more incredible wedding cake! Tanya and her staff at Heavenly Sweets definitely have perfected their name in the form of the most phenomenal cakes. My husband and I ordered a four tier white cake with buttercream f...
rosting. We had grecian lace frosted on alternating tiers (yes, the "lace" was actually frosting placed on the cake) and a simple navy ribbon on the bottom of each tier. To say that the cake was perfect in presentation and taste would be an understatement. The staff at Heavenly Sweets were absolutely wonderful to work with and I would highly recommend them to any bride in search of her dream wedding cake!
Reviewed On 9/13/2018 by Kara V
Heavenly Sweets was AMAZING! From the tasting to the leftover cake we brought home. Tanya is such a professional & with her, anything is possible! My cake looked identical to the perfect pinterest picture that I picked out & I could not have...
had more compliments on how delicious it was. The process was seamless & we will definitely be making a trip to Noblesville soon for some treats :)
Reviewed On 9/12/2018 by Emily H
We absolutely LOVED our cake! Heavenly Sweets worked with us to get exactly the look we wanted and of course the taste! Best wedding cake I have every tasted, and all our guests agreed!
Reviewed On 9/01/2018 by Lauren C
Our cake was unbelievable!! So delicious!! We had so many compliments on our cake. Not only was it beautiful but it was so good! We cannot wait for our anniversary cake!
Reviewed On 9/01/2018 by Brae M
Amazing!!!!! Such a great cake.
Reviewed On 8/28/2018 by Deborah M
Our cake was phenomenal! I highly recommend Heavenly Sweets to anyone looking for an amazing tasting and looking Wedding Cake. Tanya was so wonderful to work with and made the process so easy. Everyone loved our cake. It looked amazing and ...
tasted even better. I can't wait to get our anniversary cake! Thank you Tanya and Heavenly Sweets for helping make our day so incredibly wonderful!
Reviewed On 8/17/2018 by Elizabeth Corder
If you want amazing cake that people will remember... book Heavenly Sweets. They work with exactly what you want and their cakes are simply delicious in all aspects. I cannot wait to get my anniversary cake from them, I’ve been thinking about i...
t ever since our wedding day!
Reviewed On 8/14/2018 by Katie K
When my fiance and I started looking for a bakery for our wedding cake we decided to try Heavenly Sweets. My folks came along for the tasting. Tanya helped us so much during the tasting. We all loved the cake and frostings. The bakery was a fai...
ry land of sweet treats.
I can't get over how amazing the whole tasting was. We were led by Tanya to try each piece of cake with each frosting, fruit compote and each flavor combination. We all had a wonderful time, eating, laughing and talking. Tanya really helped my fiance John and I keep to budget and narrow down our style choices.
After the wedding my new husband and I went back to our hotel suite and our weding planner and clumbia club staff had set up two pieces of wedding cake, chocolate covered strawberries, decorated like brides and grooms, and two glasses of champagne for us to enjoy.
Our wedding was perfect! And nearly two years later people are still talking about our wedding cake! It was the best!
Reviewed On 8/06/2018 by Alexandria S
Best wedding cake ever! My guests are still talking about how good it was! They were so easy to work with and their cake really does taste incredible! They even make you a free cake on your 1 year anniversary! Such a great place and love suppor...
ting small businesses!
Reviewed On 8/04/2018 by Sarah S
We love Heavenly Sweets; they truly have the best cake in town. We had a wedding cake and a groom's cake for our day in June. Both of them were absolutely gorgeous, and tasted even better. Almost half of our guests commented on how great the we...
dding cake was, or asked where we got the cake. When the choice came to select a wedding cake, we only went to Heavenly Sweets because they are phenomenal in every way.
Reviewed On 8/01/2018 by Traci F
My Husband and I decided to go with Heavenly Sweets Cakes for our wedding after trying a sample of their cake at a wedding show. We met with the owner Tanya Marshall for our cake tasting. This was one of our favorite vendor meetings. The proces...
s of tasting and selecting a cake we wanted for our wedding was a breeze. Prior to our meeting, Tanya made sure to have the cake flavors and fillings that we wanted to try for our tasting. During our tasting, we were able to see many different cake designs that helped us make a decision on the colors, design and number of tiers we wanted for our wedding. In the end we ended up going with a gold and white four tier cake with two layers filled with apricot and the remaining layers filled with caramel.
Fast forward to our wedding day, our guests were in love with the cake. We had several guests ask for seconds and thirds. The butter cream frosting on the cake is absolutely amazing. It is always a great feeling knowing that your guests enjoyed the cake and wanted more. Needless to say we didn't have any cake left over by the end of the night.
If you want a cake that tastes Heavenly that both you, your spouse and guests will enjoy then your best bet is to go with Heavenly Sweets Cake.
Reviewed On 7/28/2018 by Taylor H
It seriously is the best cake I’ve ever had in my entire life!
Reviewed On 7/26/2018 by jeanne s
Heavenly Sweets made us a beautiful and more importantly an absolutely delicious wedding cake! The cake design that we wanted was completed and delivered perfectly. We had two flavors of cake - almond with buttercream filling and chocolate with...
raspberry filling and they were both divine.
This cake is as close to heaven as you’ll get!
Reviewed On 7/25/2018 by Kristen L
Our wedding cake was AMAZING!! after the tasting, we could not wait to eat Tanya’s cake again! She and Kris were very easy to work with and the cake turned out exactly how we envisioned it. We went with white almond and chocolate. This was perf...
ect for our wedding and the guests cannot stop talking about the cake! We would highly recommend Heavenly Sweets for any event! We will be getting our anniversary cake even though we will have to drive 3 hours to pick it up from out of state-it’s that good!!
Reviewed On 7/13/2018 by Katelyn P
The cake was beautiful and delicious! Our guests raved over it!
Reviewed On 7/10/2018 by Alyssa S
One word I would describe Heavenly Sweets was perfect. Everyone raved that our cake was the best wedding cake they ever had, and the cake turned out exactly as I imagined. The icing was to die for and the cake was moist. The only hiccup was I a...
sked for a cupcake to sing happy birthday to my dad and it was forgotten, but out of everything, the cake was perfect and delivered on time. I would go back to them no questions asked.
Reviewed On 7/03/2018 by Nicole W
Heavenly Sweets did an outstanding job. Our cake was just as beautiful as I had dreamed it would be. AND it tasted amazing.
Reviewed On 6/13/2018 by Rashauna H
I don’t know where to start !! My wedding cake was EVERYTHING !!! Everyone told me not to worry to much about cake because no one eats it at weddings ! And when I say there was not one drop left there wasn’t. My guest devoured that cake !!! The...
y wanted the top tier we save for our 1 year anniversary! It was sooo good !
Reviewed On 6/09/2018 by Kellie H
Wow. Delicious. Our cake was beautiful and tasted even better. We still are talking about how good the cake was. Go try the cake here, and you will for sure want this to be where your wedding cake is made.
Reviewed On 5/11/2018 by Ellen B
Oh. My. Goodness. Our guests are STILL talking about how delicious (and beautiful) our cake was at our April 2018 wedding. I even heard from several guests who said they "aren't a cake person" that they even snagged additional slices because it...
was that good. Tanya and her team are incredible, and their cakes can't compare with anyone else we looked into in the area. Looking forward to our one-year anniversary already so we can have more cake!
Reviewed On 2/10/2018 by Kathryn F
Our wedding cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious. Our guests raved and several succeeded in getting extra pieces. Heavenly Sweets was accommodating in providing a fresh product with on-time delivery. I would highly recommend them to anyo...
ne for any ocassion.
Reviewed On 12/02/2017 by Emily W
Our cake for our September wedding looked great and tasted great!
Reviewed On 11/21/2017 by Allyson B
Our guests are still talking about how good our cake was at our July wedding! Tanya and her crew were so nice to work with. The cake arrived as scheduled, looking exactly as we discussed. It was beautiful and delicious- can't wait to eat the...
top tier we froze for our 1yr anniversary!
Reviewed On 11/21/2017 by Kayci W
Working with Heavenly Cakes was a joy from start to finish. We loved our tasting experience and the cake tasted as good as it looked on wedding day! It was superb. It was even fantastic the next day when we ate our cake topper with family. Our ...
guests could not stop talking about it! Heavenly Sweets is simply the BEST!
Reviewed On 11/19/2017 by Alli K
Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! We can't wait to eat the top tier on our first anniversary!
Reviewed On 11/15/2017 by Ashley P
My husband and I are thrilled with the choice of having had Heavenly Sweets for our wedding. We got a small cake for us to cut and cupcakes for the wedding guests. We were worried that we had more cupcakes than actual guest, but by the end of i...
t we were almost out of cupcakes because the guests were taking two or three themselves! Let me tell you, these cupcakes are not bite sized either. They are fairly large. Our guests continually asked where we got our cupcakes from as they said it was some of the best treats they have ever had and my husband and I couldn't agree more! They looked as good as they tasted and I cannot wait to dive into the cake for our one year anniversary! (11/11/17)
Reviewed On 11/09/2017 by Taylor H
My husband Ryan and I could not have been more pleased with our experience with Heavenly Sweets. Their bakery is in the cutest little house in downtown Noblesville. We walked in and spent about an hour with Tanya who let us sample all of her di...
fferent types of cakes, fillings and frostings. We custom designed each tier of our cake with the artistic help of Tanya and pictures we had found on Pinterest. The cake turned out more beautiful than we could have ever expected. The cake was beyond the most delicious we have ever tasted. It is dense, but moist and the flavor was to die for. We did our largest tier in almond with cheesecake buttercream and the other 3 tiers in chocolate with a raspberry buttercream filling. Pricing was a little more than we expected to spend but we couldn't resist after tasting the incredible flavors. I could not believe how beautiful it was when we walked into the reception hall. Thank you so much for all that you did to make our cake and our day so special!
Reviewed On 11/04/2017 by Lexi M
This might have been the best cake I've ever had in my life! We decided to go with the butter golden cake with white chocolate mousse filling and the lightest most delicious buttercream ever frosting. I got SO many compliments on it, it was unr...
eal! My husband and I only got a bite of cake at the wedding because we were so busy talking with everyone and being whisked away for pictures, but that one bite was pure heaven. It was decorated beautifully and was exactly what I had in mind for my wedding. I just recently ordered a small cake of the same type so that we can have more than just one bite! I also love that we get a fresh 1 year anniversary cake rather than having to freeze and our top tier. This bakery is amazing!
Reviewed On 10/12/2017 by Kim K
My daughter recently held her wedding reception at the Alexander downtown Indianapolis! She had tasted Heavenly Sweets wedding cake samples at a wedding fair and loved it. The cake was the best we have ever tasted. The Alexander said they usu...
ally have cake left over but this was the first time so many people asked for seconds that there was none left. The cake designer, Chris, really designed a beautiful cake. It was just what my daughter had envisioned!
Reviewed On 9/16/2017 by Allison C
Hands down the best wedding cake I have ever had - EVER - and we tried lots of wedding cake! Heavenly Sweets was easy to work with and would highly recommend them!!!
Reviewed On 9/14/2017 by Kaley G
The BEST wedding cake I have ever had and I am not just being biased! All of our guests loved it and said it was amazing! They were so easy to work with and laid everything out in front of you so you could see everything you were paying for. We...
're just sad there was none left over after the wedding!
Reviewed On 9/08/2017 by Keyana R
our wedding cake was simply amazing, the decorations were on point. Even more stunning then I expected, the cake has small details that were brought out which made a big bang. I can simply add making a 7 tier cake with 6 satellites cakes around...
was not easy but she pulled it off, not to mention I was a bling bride and O' my my, our cake matched to the T. again I thank you heavenly sweets you brought out my day completely. On time delivery cake was fresh as ever I'm adored with the entire company. I you desire a show cake with quality and taste let this be your first and last choice.
Reviewed On 7/02/2017 by Laura W
We went around Indianapolis and tried about six different top rated bakeries for our cake. Heavenly Sweets was hands down the best!! The only reason I'm giving them four stars is because of a mix up with our design. Heavenly Sweets made it righ...
t though and I would work with them again. The cake was still beautiful and of course delicious!
Reviewed On 6/26/2017 by Kimberly E
I tasted cake samples from them at a wedding show ten years ago with my mother. When I started planning my wedding ten years later, the only thing I knew was I wanted that cake! My mom called to remind me of this cake as well! We both vividl...
y remembered how fantastic it was over a decade later! It was delicious with so many options to choose from.
Reviewed On 6/19/2017 by Julie P
Wow... just wow! Our cake was beautiful, and it tasted AMAZING! We knew it would be good from the tasting, and it was even better! The best part, instead of having you save your top-tier in the freezer, they'll bake you a fresh one on your one-...
year anniversary! We're out of state, and they're even giving us a 6-month swing to come in and claim the cake, so we don't miss out! Worth every penny we spent. Also--be sure to grab a cupcake or two when you visit, because they're delightful!
Reviewed On 4/02/2017 by Jordan G
Many guests said it was the best cake they'd ever had. I thought they were just being nice, until my husband and I went back to our honeymoon sweet and ate the leftovers in bed. Ate, ALL, the leftovers in bed. It was amazing... truly "Heavenly"...
. Guests were definitely not just being nice. 100% recommend to other brides.
Reviewed On 3/19/2017 by Jana S
The cake was fantasic and tasted sooo good! The team was able to execute our vision for the cake design and it was just what we were hoping for! We received many compliments from our guests on how beautiful and delicious our cake was! Thank ...
you Heavenly Sweets!
Reviewed On 2/19/2017 by Morgan M
The cake was gorgeous, and looked as good as it tasted. They worked with us to keep the cake reasonably priced, but still matching with what we truly dreamed it would look like. We can't wait for our anniversary so we can pick up our anniversar...
Reviewed On 1/10/2017 by Chrissy L
Heavenly Sweets was one of the first vendors my husband and I hired - and we're so happy we did! I work at a reception venue and I always recommend Heavenly Sweets to my brides due to their great customer service and absolutely delicious cake. ...
Our cake was gorgeous (exactly what we wanted) and our guests couldn't stop talking about how good it was!
Reviewed On 10/26/2016 by Lisa H
This cake was so great! It looked beautiful (especially with flowers added by our florist), and it was devoured at our wedding. The owner, Tanya, sat down with us for the cake tasting and we didn't feel pressured by her at all. The manager, ...
Kris, was also very easy to work with- would recommend!
Reviewed On 9/27/2016 by Elsie G
We sampled cakes from numerous bakeries around the Indianapolis area and were ready to give up the idea of wedding cake until we tried Heavenly Sweets. They have the best cake and frosting, hands down. In addition to delicious cake, it was be...
autifully decorated and delivered without incident. We had a custom cake with 3 different custom flavors and fillings. It was more expensive than other bakeries that we tried, but the quality of cake was well worth it.
Reviewed On 9/11/2016 by Leslie H
Simple and elegant and matched our exact specifications and idea for our wedding cake. Perfection!
Reviewed On 8/08/2016 by Kara T
They were a lifesaver! After our previous bakery wasn't able to make our cake, we called them 3 weeks before the wedding and they were able to add us in. Their cake was delicious and moist, and we got so many compliments on it! Their pricing i...
s comparable to other bakeries in the Hamilton County area. We can't wait for our anniversary cake next year!
Reviewed On 7/18/2016 by Colbi M
We only went to one cake vendor during our planning process. We had read some really good reviews for Heavenly Sweets, so we made our first and only appointment with them. My fiancé was focused on taste, while I was focused on price/design, He...
avenly Sweets knocked it out of the park on it all. We met with Tanya who was just the nicest person, and we were able to taste three delicious cake flavors. They were all seriously amazing, we ended up going with the traditional white cake. Tanya made sure that we talked through the design choices and logistical information. It was probably the easiest choice of the entire wedding planning process. The cake was delivered without any issues, and early enough to where my florist was able to put the finishing touches on. It was beautiful and absolutely delicious. People gushed over the cake all night. Since ordering our wedding cake, we have traveled up to Noblesville (about 30 minutes from our house) to order cupcakes/cakes for other occasions. We will definitely continue using their services!
Reviewed On 6/20/2016 by Sara H
Cake for our wedding and my dad's birthday cake was delicious! Heavenly Sweets delivered both on time with no issues. Noblesville is very lucky to have such a great bakery!
They also brought delicious gluten free cupcakes too, yum!
Reviewed On 6/15/2016 by Jenna L
ABSOLUTELY LOVED our wedding cake from heavenly sweets! We chose a white bark cake which fit perfectly with our rustic theme! Guests raved! THANK YOU!
Reviewed On 1/26/2016 by Michelle W
Our wedding cake was to die for! It was so delicious and we got so many compliments on it. The owner was very accommodating and so easy to work with. Everything arrived perfectly on the day of - I would 100% recommend Heavenly Sweets!!
Reviewed On 9/05/2015 by Stephanie M
i was in heaven eating this cake!!! I'm all about frosting and their buttercream is to die for. I don't remember the price but I remember thinking it was very fair and reasonable for the size of cake. We also rented a lovely cake stand from the...
m. The owner was very accommodating since I don't live in town and we called the same day to see if we could check out their prices and they set up a full tasting for us within an hour of calling. Was very impressed by that. Delivery the day of was on time and they live up to their name! It's gonna be hard to not eat the top of our cake before our anniversary!!
Reviewed On 6/15/2015 by Lindsay C
We used Heavenly Sweets for our "photo cake" and the cake my husband and I cut and will keep for our 1 year anniversary. We each had a piece on our wedding night and it was delicious. In order to save on costs, we used Costco cakes for the re...
st of the wedding. The guests raved about the cake….it was the best and most cost effective decision we made!
Reviewed On 2/15/2015 by Knottie0304413
Beautiful, delicious cupcakes for my daughter's wedding reception!! Everyone commented on how delicious they were! I made a mistake in the amount of cupcakes I ordered for the reception, and when I discovered the mistake, the reception was in...
4 hrs...Heavenly Sweets whipped up 3 dozen cupcakes and got them delivered to the venue all within 2 1/2 hrs (and they were officially closed)!! They saved the day!! Can not recommend them highly enough!!
Contact Info for Heavenly Sweets Cakes
293 South 8th Street, NOBLESVILLE, IN(317) 770-9399