Hometown Desserts

Custom Cakes & Delicious Desserts

5.0

Verified reviews from real couples

Hometown Desserts made a beautiful wedding cake and a stunning array of bite-sized desserts for our wedding reception that were a huge hit! The beach-themed cake and shell-shaped cookies were simply beautiful - and delicious. Cindy is so easy to work with, and even made our cake and special cupcakes gluten free as my stepdaughter has celiac.

Debbie E.

5.0

Hometown Desserts made planning an absolute breeze!! They were the sweetest people and made the vision that was stuck in my head, come to life! Their recommendations were spot on and the cake was GORGEOUS!! She was so flexible and made me a little less stressed! She worked with our florist (Blooms by the beach) to get flowers that matched our floral arrangements without us having to do anything! Our guests were RAVING about the cake and are already saving the info to pop in on their next visit to the island! We had key lime (bottom), Chocolate (middle) and strawberry (top) with buttercream frosting. She also made me a raspberry cheese cake since I don't actually care for cake in general that way I also had dessert! :) Phenomenal service.

Courtney C.

5.0

Hometown Desserts is a professional wedding cake bakery based in Anna Maria, FL. Offering custom bakes, the team guarantees show-stopping designs that taste as good as they look. The company was established as a home-based business in 2007. Since then, it has grown and expanded, opening a retail space in 2012 and offering baked goods to complement life's cherished occasions. The team at Hometown Desserts operates with a goal of creating special, delicious treats for every customer, helping them honor life's milestones with exquisite bakes. You and your beloved are invited to browse the extensive menu, selecting fabulous desserts for your special day. Hometown offers standard and premium cake options in a variety of sizes, styles, and flavors. Whether you prefer classic chocolate and vanilla or more adventurous options like Oreo, Kahlua, or raspberry truffle, the bakers will be delighted to craft your ideal dessert. What's more, Hometown Desserts provides a variety of other options, including cheesecake, cupcakes, cookies, pies, and gluten-free bakes.

19+ years in business

Speaks English

Details

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Accessories

Cake Stands

Cake Toppers

Cake Delivery & Setup

Other Desserts

Dietary Options

Gluten Free

Any questions?

5.0

out of 5.0

10 reviews

Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Search reviews

Debbie E

Highlighted review.

4/15/2025

Hometown Desserts made a beautiful wedding cake and a stunning array of bite-sized desserts for our wedding reception that were a huge hit! The beach-themed cake and shell-shaped c...

ookies were simply beautiful - and delicious. Cindy is so easy to work with, and even made our cake and special cupcakes gluten free as my stepdaughter has celiac.

Courtney C

7/09/2024

Hometown Desserts made planning an absolute breeze!! They were the sweetest people and made the vision that was stuck in my head, come to life! Their recommendations were spot on a...

nd the cake was GORGEOUS!! She was so flexible and made me a little less stressed! She worked with our florist (Blooms by the beach) to get flowers that matched our floral arrangements without us having to do anything! Our guests were RAVING about the cake and are already saving the info to pop in on their next visit to the island! We had key lime (bottom), Chocolate (middle) and strawberry (top) with buttercream frosting. She also made me a raspberry cheese cake since I don't actually care for cake in general that way I also had dessert! :) Phenomenal service.

Any questions?

Gina S

5/11/2024

Our cake was beautiful and very yummy! We highly recommend this bakery!!

Sarah T

4/26/2023

Hometown Desserts is the most delicious cake you could ever ask for on your wedding day! Cindy is the sweetest person ever, and was so thorough in making sure we had the perfect ca...

ke for our day. She hand delivered to our venue and used flowers from our florist to add the final touches. We did a small, simple cake to cut, and two different flavors of sheet cake to serve alongside. All of the flavors were absolute HITS! Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious the cake was. (We got Lemon, Carrot, and Chocolate!) Thank you so much Cindy!!!

Allison Z

11/09/2022

Hometown Desserts is the best cake around. Cindy makes the tastiest/moistest cakes, and I can't get enough of them. Everytime I'm in Anna Maria, I have to stop by and get some. Th...

at's exactly why we hired Hometown Desserts for our wedding weekend. We had cookies and cupcakes for our rehearsal dinner, a hilarious Family Guy cake for the welcome reception, and of course, the most stunning multi-tiered cake for our wedding. Everything was devoured, and people were coming back for more. Can't recommend Hometown Desserts enough for your next event, or just a regular evening when you need something sweet. Thank you thank you!!!

Lillian B

4/30/2022

Cindy was amazing and so helpful! This was my first large event and my wedding so I was at a loss on how much to order and what I should even buy. She made time to do a cake tastin...

g for my maid of honor and me while we were down for a weekend. She delivered the cake, cookies, and cupcakes to the venue and saved my husband from the stress of trying to drive that very important cargo across the island. Everyone loved the cake and the decoration so much, and the seashell and starfish cookies were just the beachy touch we wanted.

Stephanie S

1/17/2021

Cindy was an absolute pleasure to work with and created a beautiful, delicious cake for our wedding. We will definitely visit Cindy (and hometown desserts) on our next trip to Anna...

Maria island and check out more of her sweet treats

Stephanie S

8/10/2019

My cake was simply beautiful! It tasted amazing and it was gluten-free for me and my husband. I couldn't be happier with how the cake looked for our beach theme. It came out exac...

tly how I asked, and we are so happy! It was just so perfect for our wedding!!!

Morgan F

5/11/2018

Cindy did a fabulous job on the cake and cupcakes. We had a wonderful variety and all looked beautiful and tasted yummy!

Kristi P

9/07/2017

Cindy is amazing. We gave her an idea and her ideas turned into exactly what we wanted! We got a small 6" round to cut with mini cupcakes of every flavor. Reasonably priced, Cindy ...

is such a friendly caring person and is very accommodating and has a lot of patience. Plus her cakes taste beyond amazing!!! Highly recommended! She is the best!

Service area & Contact info

507b Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL

Open map

(941) 896-3167

Want to book a visit?

Start the convo

*=Required

Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.

Hometown Desserts's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.

Hometown Desserts

About this vendor

Service area & Contact info

Wedding vendors in Anna Maria

Why use The Knot to message vendors?