No photos yet
About this vendor
We don‘t know Hoosier Mama Pie Company‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.6
out of 5.05 reviews
We used Hoosier Mama for pies at our wedding instead of a wedding cake, and it was amazing! Neither my husband or I like cake so we thought this was a fun way to incorporate food w...
e actually like and support one of our favorite local businesses in our neighborhood. The pies were delicious (as always!), and communication via phone/email to book our pies in advance was easy. We were given a massive list of pies to choose from and ended up with several different types. Hoosier Mama provided delivery day-of, which saved us a lot of stress running around on wedding day.
Our guests enjoyed it so much that several took it upon themselves to have multiple slices to compare flavors and report back to us the next day. Key lime and espresso creme were the guest favorites, but the cherry pie my husband and I choose for our "cake cutting" was absolutely divine. If you want pie at your wedding, we couldn't recommend Hoosier Mama enough!
The pies were, of course, incredible. They had most of the flavors that we were looking to have for our guests & everything was delivered on time. You only have to order 1 month in...
advance, which was nice, however their communication was really lacking. We were willing to spend hundreds of dollars and it seemed like our emails were never being responded to. Overall it worked out fine, but we were a little stressed out.
Working with Hoosier Mama Pie Company for pies for our wedding was a breeze. They were responsive to my constant questions about selections, delivery, etc., and made everything fro...
m our initial testing, to planning emails, to the day-of drop-off smooth and painless. Our guests loved the pies and I'm only disappointed I didn't get to try every one during the wedding! I highly recommend going with Hoosier Mama if you're interested in pie for your wedding.
We used Hoosier Mama Pie company to provide six different types of pie for our small wedding reception. The staff was very helpful, and I was able to do all the planning and orderi...
ng via email or phone. They did offer to provide a tasting, but we had already bought several pies from the local farmers market and loved the taste, so we skipped the tasting. A week before the wedding we settled on the fruit flavored, as we weren't sure earlier what would be in season. We had six scrumptious pies, all precut for our reception, it was easy to set up and they looked fabulous with the other desserts. They were so good there was hardly any left! I would recommend their maple pecan! Order in advance to save yourself a pie, so so so good.
We had apple and pumpkin pies instead of wedding cake at our Fall wedding. They tasted amazing and were a unique touch. Our guests raved about them!
Contact
1618 1/2 Chicago Avenue, Chicago, IL
Hoosier Mama Pie Company