4.8 out of 5 stars and 32 reviews
4.8
(32)Serving Surrounding Counties/Towns-Call!
About this vendor
Since 2001, Kristina Taylor has crafted thousands upon thousands of exquisite wedding cakes, specialty cakes, cupcakes, and treats for countless celebrations. Her passion for creating delicious, moist, and beautiful desserts continues as she brings her artistry from her prior location in Brown County, Indiana to a new location in Columbus, Indiana. Whether you’re dreaming of a wedding cake, a birthday masterpiece, or a special occasion treat, Icing On The Cake By Kristina remains dedicated to making your cake dreams come true! After all, it's LOVE you can taste!
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Stands
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
2-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2022.2013.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.032 reviews
Kristina was fantastic to work with. She really made sure that our cake was personalized for our needs and fit our theme. It was beautiful, and the white almond flavor was deliciou...
s.
Kristina came highly recommended by a friend and was easy to work with even with my traveling in from out of town, making times work for our tastings, and was willing to go beyond ...
her normal flavors to make the cake of our dreams. Her flavors were so good we even used her for cupcakes for our Welcome Night dinner. She even customized the designs of the cake and cupcakes just how we envisioned for both events. Our family and guests couldn't stop raving about our wedding cake and even said that it might be one of the best cakes they'd had. We can't recommend her enough!
Kristina was so easy to work with, and her rates are incredibly reasonable. We gave her a photo of our vision, and the cake we got was a perfect match - not to mention yummy! If yo...
u’re looking for a baker in south-central Indiana, go to Kristina
Kristina is so WONDERFUL and easy to work with. Being a bride, I wanted everything to go perfectly and it did. She is so sweet and genuinely cares about her customers. We went for ...
a tasting and the cake was so moist and delicious. We were so impressed. We didn’t even look at other people or companies to make our cake and cupcakes. Her cakes are probably THE best I’ve ever heard. It doesn’t taste like nasty wedding cake, it was just absolutely amazing. Our guest were in love with the flavors we choose. Everyone kept coming up to us asking where we got our cake from! Our wedding cake was very simple, but it was so beautiful. It was everything we had wished for. She delivered the cake to the venue and set everything up! THANK YOU KRISTINA!
-The Robertsons
My guests loved the cake and cupcakes! Kristina was great to work with, highly recommend!
We absolultey loved the flavor to start! I gave Kristina a general vibe I was going for and some key elements and she created a beautiful cakescape for our wedding. Guests had an a...
mazing time checking out all the different styles of cakes. Red wine chocolate was our favorite flavor the the pumpkin was divine!
Kristina was easy to work with, the cake was amazing, and the icing is phenomenal! So glad we chose her!
Kristina was easy to work with, responded quickly to emails, and bakes the absolute BEST cakes I have ever tasted. I really liked another baker when I was going on tastings, but Kr...
istina was the last tasting I went to and WOW. Her cakes are so incredibly moist, flavorful, and light. I am really picky about frosting, but hers is awesome. If you are considering Kristina, at least go for a tasting. You definitely won't regret it!
Kristina was great to work with for our wedding. I had seen a photograph of cupcake she had some with succulents on top and I knew she was the baker for us! We met with her and her...
cakes tasted as amazing as they look! She also made a last second change by adding a layer to each of our tiers to help our cake fit in a cake stand we had purchased. Kristina is a great baker and her work fit right into our wedding!
Kristina's cake was the DIE for at our wedding! For a great price, she gave us a 4-tier, double-flavored cake, and included delivery. Though we initially chose a very simple design...
, we latered asked her to place a couple silk flowers on it when she arrived, and it looked perfect! The cake was sturdy, and we LOVE the icing she used! We chose to have two layers french vanilla and the other two pumpkin spice. The guests loved both flavors, as did we!
We loved our cakes! We got a beautiful wedding cake and a cute grooms cake and cupcakes, and her pricing is perfect. Everything looked beautiful and tasted amazing. Kristina is a j...
oy to work with and her work is exemplary. I would definitely reccomend her!
My sister (and several friends) used Kristina for their wedding cakes, so I already knew I wanted to use her! She's creative and we knew she would be able to execute our vision (s...
he even helped us a little to make it more creative!). The cake itself is DELICIOUS and beautiful. It's hard to find someone that can do both! We did a split dessert plate with one piece of vanilla almond layered cake and one piece of red velvet. It was comical, all night long guests were coming up to the Groom and I to tell us what their favorite was! (split down the middle, both were seriously so good).
I think our cake-tasting with Kristina was my
Husband’s favorite part of our wedding. We got Lemon, Marble, and French Vanilla, and they were all SO GOOD. The cake was beautiful...
, and delivered to the venue early without a hitch! Her affordability compared to other vendors and the quality of cake she provided cannot be beat. We loved our cake and working with Kristina.
Starting off, Kristina seemed to be one of the best options to go with in terms of wedding cakes. After looking online and reading reviews I was EXTREMELY disappointed in the cake ...
we received. The cake did not look like what we had planned and was missing many details. The only thing that was correct was the flavors and how many tiers. The design was completely wrong, and the cake looked VERY different from the elaborate ones she had shown us in her studio.
Kristina is immensely talented and easy to work with! My husband and I were married in May 2019 and she created a beautiful, small 2-tiered cake and lots of cupcakes for us. We wer...
en't entirely sure what we wanted when we met with her, but she showed us several different design options and helped us figure out what would match the style of our day. Everything was beautiful and delicious! We had a hard time picking only a few flavors! And she was always very quick to email back to settle details after the initial meeting. We can't recommend Kristina enough!
Two weeks ago Kristina made a 3 tier cake and cupcakes for my wedding and she did an amazing job! We had 3 different flavors that everyone loved! Everything was gone by the end of ...
the night! She’s super sweet to work with and affordable!
We had a country wedding and wanted a rustic yet brightly-colored cake. Kristina delivered and then some! She baked us four of the most gorgeous cakes, all in different flavors, ...
and allowed us to borrow her multi-tiered cake stand to decorate ourselves to accompany the cakes. She was incredibly communicative and flexible through the entire process. The cakes were easily the best I've ever tasted, and were SO beautiful! I can't imagine how we could've asked for a better baker!
Kristina catered our wedding cake and made us the most beautiful cake. We were amazed at the detail! And the flavor was incredible. Not a bite was left over (aside of our topper ...
which we can't wait to eat).
Our wedding cake was beautiful and tasted great! We also did cupcakes and got so many compliments on how delicious they were!
Best cake ever! Kristina made cupcakes and a small cake for our wedding a few weeks ago. We went with red wine chocolate, spice cake, and champagne for our flavors. They we're abso...
lutely delicious and a hit with our guests! Her sugar flowers are also beautiful!
Fabulous service, cupcakes and presentation for our daughters wedding! Couldn't be happier!!!
OH MY GOD, this cake. My mouth is watering just thinking about it! We got very vanilla cardamom and red wine chocolate for our flavors and they were just to die for. All our guests...
were so pleased. Kristina was very easy to work with and very friendly. Her little shop is SO CUTE! and it shows off her talent. We were worried when we went to find a cake vendor that we wouldn't get what we wanted (our theme was kinda dark and creepy - lots of skulls and crows) but she was thrilled with our ideas and excited to try something a little odd. The cake was beautiful and we got so many compliments from our guests. It was a wonderful experience working with Kristina!
Everything was great, and exactly how I imagined. We ordered cupcakes, a grooms cake and then our wedding cake. All the flavors were great but our favorite by far was the double ...
chocolate mocha. It was so moist, and all the cakes held up great in the heat! It was 95 and we had an outside wedding.
We recently used Kristina from Icing on the Cake for our wedding cake and cupcakes. She was very easy to work with and helped to come up with different ideas for what we were pict...
uring to fit with our wedding and colors. Not to mention her flavors are amazing! We also found a flavor at a bridal show that my husband and I really liked. We asked if she could try to make this in ours and it tasted great. Would definitely recommend to to future brides.
We had the most beautiful & delicious cupcake creation for our wedding. Kristina was prompt at arriving to our venue and got the elaborate creation placed before guests arrived so ...
they could all see the delicious work she does.
My guests asked if there were any extras if they could have one to take with them because they were so good. All in all I can't say enough about her or her cakes! I highly recommend her
Not what was promised. The color of our cake was suppose to be a sapphire blue and it actually was closer to a faded blue. The only reason we went with this vendor was because our ...
planner said she was the best in the area. Also, the only reason we went with fondant was because we were told it would not color anyone's mouth. Needless to say, peoples mouths were tinted blue. Also, the fondant looked old and dry! I was ready to cry when I first saw the cake!! The cake had to be cut immediately and taken to the back so no one else would see the cake! When we paid more than $750, I would have expected perfection!
I went in to Kristina really having no idea what I wanted for my cake other than that I wanted it to go with the general theme of my wedding and taste good. Let me tell you, it's b...
een hard not to open up my freezer and go in for our first anniversary slice! She was so fun to design my wedding cake with, and to this day the beauty of the cake she created takes my breath away- it was a simple, rustic elegant design with rafia and ribbon, old printed stamp, and live anna and garden roses. She has lots of untraditional flavors, which we loved- since we had a fall wedding, we had pumpkin and chocolate- so good!
I requested an ivory cake with coral, pale yellow, and gray cascading lace and "hippie chick" flowers. Oh my goodness... it was the most beautiful cake I have ever seen and the bes...
t part.... DELICIOUS!!!! I went with layers of lemon and vanilla cake... so so good!
We had one meeting with Kristina and she could tell exactly what I wanted. The cake turned out beautiful and classy. Her detail work was wonderful and it was exactly what I had pic...
tured in my head as my "dream cake"! I was sad because the only slice I got to eat was the one my husband stuffed in my face! Although, that bit was very tasty.
We met with Kristina months before the wedding to sample her different flavors. It was very hard to make a decision because every flavor we loved! She has a variety of different st...
yle cakes you can browse through in a binder. You can take a look at some model cakes in her office as well. The cake was beautifully decorated by hand made (and painted) lillies, roses, stems and fall leaves. The cake was delicious!!!! Highly Reccommend!
beautiful cake and wonderful tastes. all my guests loved the orange and so did we. would recommend her to anyone! thank you!
Kristina made a beautiful cake. She had several flavors to offer, and two I tried were delicious. I decided on pumpkin spice, which my guests loved, and vanilla, the best vanilla...
cake I have tasted.
She decorated with sugar flowers, fondant ribbons and branches. It was gorgeous.
The only drawback was that we had to pay cash or check, no credit.
Contact
426 Tipton Lane, Columbus, IN | Serving Surrounding Counties/Towns-Call!
Icing on the Cake by Kristina