Skip to Main Content
Stroudsburg Wedding Cakes

Just Like Magic Bakery

A little bit of love and magic into every bite!
5 out of 5 stars and 2 reviews
·
Stroudsburg, PA
Pennsylvania
Service area
5.0
Verified reviews from real couples
Our wedding cake and cupcakes were absolutely fantastic!! We can’t recommend Just Like Magic enough!Thank you!!
Alex K.
5.0
BEST WEDDING CAKE!! They made a custom flavor, "naked" cake based on our request, and it was PERFECT! On top of that, the cupcakes we had went SO FAST. Everyone loved them!! We didn't have any left by the end of then night. This place was so friendly and helpful. Way better pricing than other places too. Definitely recommend!
Amanda S.
5.0
Deals
OfferPermanent
Free Consultation
Claim Deal
Exclusive discountPermanent
3% discount for The Knot couples
Claim Deal

About this vendor

Operating out of Stroudsburg, PA, Just Like Magic Bakery is a business that caters to wedding receptions and ceremonies. Owner, Paula Nagle and her team, create beautiful cakes and desserts in a wide range of flavors. These flavors include : - Brownie Overload (chocolate brownie cake with chocolate icing) - Blissfuls (vanilla cake with cookie butter frosting) - Butterscotch - Mint chocolate chip - Chocolate-covered pretzel - Triple Chocolate - Chocolate with vanilla frosting - Cookies and cream - Funfetti - Maple walnut - Mellow yellows (yellow cake with chocolate buttercream) - Peanut butter explosion (chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting) - Ruby reds (red velvet cake) - Salted caramel - Nuts for coconut (vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream frosting topped with coconut and pecans) - Vanilla with vanilla buttercream - Vanilla with chocolate buttercream For more information about Just Like Magic Bakery and its scrumptious products, you can contact the team by phone, email, or social media.
Woman-owned Business
3+ years in business
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Vegan
Circle Message
Any questions?
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.0
2 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
AvatarA
Highlighted review.
10/09/2023
BEST WEDDING CAKE!! They made a custom flavor, "naked" cake based on our request, and it was PERFECT! On top of that, the cupcakes we had went SO FAST. Everyone loved them!! We did...
n't have any left by the end of then night. This place was so friendly and helpful. Way better pricing than other places too. Definitely recommend!
Circle Message
Any questions?
AvatarA
6/14/2024
Our wedding cake and cupcakes were absolutely fantastic!! We can’t recommend Just Like Magic enough!Thank you!!

Service area & Contact info

727 Main Street, Stroudsburg, PA
727 Main Street, Stroudsburg, PA
Open map
Pennsylvania
Typically included in the starting cost
Vendor Logo
Circle Message
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
My wedding date is flexible

Wedding vendors in Stroudsburg

Stroudsburg Bridal Salons
Stroudsburg Beauty Salons
Stroudsburg Caterers
Stroudsburg DJs
Stroudsburg Florists
Stroudsburg Reception Venues
Stroudsburg Videographers
Stroudsburg Wedding Bands
Stroudsburg Wedding Photographers
Stroudsburg Wedding Planners
  1. Wedding Vendors
    /
  2. Wedding Cakes
    /
  3. Pennsylvania Wedding Cakes
    /
  4. Stroudsburg Wedding Cakes
    /
Just Like Magic Bakery
Just Like Magic Bakery's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

  • Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
  • Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
  • Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
  • For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.