About this vendor
We specialize in making your wedding desserts unique and delicious. Offering two tier cutting cakes, individual cakes, mini cupcakes filled sheet cakes as well as an assortment of whoopie pies and cookies. Contact us to set up your tasting!
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
Dietary Options
- Vegan
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.019 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
We loved Kittie's Cakes! We ordered their mini-cupcakes and loved them. They had a great selection and were delicious. They were also very communicative and easy to work with. We h...
ighly recommend Kittie's Cakes, especially for a German Village wedding.
I had a brunch wedding and I don’t really want cake so early in the day. So I got a tiered cinnamon roll. That was the best decision ever. And I know that they say that they have t...
he best cinnamon rolls in Columbus, but they REALLY do have the best cinnamon rolls! Like please go try them. I did not get tired of eating my leftovers every morning until it was gone and everyone was asking me where I got them. Even if you’re not getting married, go to one of their locations and get a cinnamon roll. I beg of you.
Working with Diane at Kittie's was an easy and straightforward experience. Diane was very helpful when we were trying to decide how many cupcakes we should order for the number of ...
guests attending our reception. We ordered a small cutting cut just for my husband and I to share, then had cupcakes in two flavors (cookies & cream and lemon meringue) for our guests. Diane delivered our order right on time directly to our reception space. Everyone loved our flavor choices!
Lovely experience with having our wedding cake made by Kitties! Taste was exceptional (we did candy bar) and it looked amazing. Not to mention the price was extremely fair compared...
to other bakers. Highly recommend!
We decided to do mini cupcakes instead of traditional wedding cake for our guests. We contacted Kittie's cakes to set up a tasing and met Diane at the Worthington Kittie's. She bro...
ught a sample of 4 of their most popular cupcakes and talked to us about our different options. We ultimately decided to do a small round cake for the traditional cake cutting for us, and multiple dozens of six different flavors of cupcakes. They were such a hit! Our guests loved having different options and every one of the flavors was delicious. We provided little boxes for guests to take some home at the end of the night and there were only a handful left for us to take home (which was great!). In addition to having delicious cupcakes, Diane was wonderful to work with. She answered all of our emails in a timely manner and made suggestions about the amount of cupcakes to purchase for the number of guests we were expecting. Delivery was on time, and all the different flavors looked so pretty all together. I'll add a picture once we get them back from the photographer. 10/10 would recommend!
Kittie's Cakes was amazing to work with! We decided on a two tier cake (we did white lavender) and an assortment of mini cupcakes, which our guests loved. They were very responsive...
to us and made the whole process easy!
We ordered a variety of mini cupcakes for our wedding. We didn't want to do a big cake and wanted to give guests multiple options, so this was the perfect choice and we and our gu...
ests loved them!
We ended up getting just a small cake for cutting because both my husband and I prefer ice cream to cake, but the cake we got made my husband want to go back for seconds! It was d...
elicious and beautiful, and they were very easy to work with--would recommend!
We are so happy we found Kittie’s Cakes!! We waited until the last minute (2 weeks beforehand) to look into wedding cakes. Kittie’s brought us in for a free tasting immediately and...
helped us pick out a lavender 2 tiered wedding cake. It is a great size for a cutting cake and looked perfect on our cake table. After much searching, we truly believe Kittie’s is reasonably priced, while also being DELICIOUS.
The team at Kittie’s was perfect. From the tasting, to execution on the big day - everything was perfect. They are professional who know how to make one delicious cake & cupcakes! ...
Our family members are still talking about how delicious everything was and can’t wait to come back to Columbus to visit the bakery!
We had Kitties make our two tiered cake along with 200 mini cupcakes for our dessert table and WOW they were a hit! Their quality is the best! They also delivered to our venue fo...
r us which was super convenient. We chose the cookies and cream flavor for our cake and it was amazing!!! I also ordered cinnamon rolls, breakfast cake and scones for my bridesmaids in the morning and they were sooo good!! Highly recommend Kitties for your event!!!
Yum!! Kitties made our two tiered white lavender wedding cake which was perfect! We also had an assortment of delicious mini cupcakes. Such unique flavors and they were beautiful. ...
They made the process super simple. A tasting, a phone call, and delivery to our venue! Highly recommend!
Mollie and Kelly! So awesome! For our wedding, Kittie's provided our cake, as well as cupcakes and Micky-O's (my husband's favorite!). They were so easy to work with during the pla...
nning process and perfectly delivered all the goodies to our venue. Everything was adored and promptly devoured by our guests! We would use them again for any event (or for our weekly snack) in a heartbeat!
My husband and I cannot express how amazing our wedding cake was from Kittie's! We wanted something simple but delicious, and their 2-tier "white out" cake was perfection. It was s...
o good we are the entire thing and didn't even freeze any for our first anniversary! We will be back on our first anniversary to get some cupcakes instead. We highly recommend Kittie's!!
My husband and I got married on September 27th, 2015. We chose Kittie's Cakes because of the positive reviews on theknot.
Kittie's Cakes has amazing desserts. They have tried an...
d true flavors that are beloved by all. We got 75 cupcakes (they are mini, but so tasty). We chose "Classic Buckeye", "Whiteout", and the fall flavor "Pumpkin Ale". There were none left! :-)
For our cake, we ordered a two tier cake that was "black and white". Very, very good!
I only have two issues about this vendor. First, they do not deliver on Sundays, which was not a huge deal. We had two friends go and pick up the desserts the day of.
Second, I was never offered my complimentary tasting and had to pay for every cupcake I tried in the store. I mean, they were all tasty, but I was a bride on a budget and felt like it could have been easier to meet with the owner/bakers and talk through my likes/dislikes in a more formal setting.
So yes, chose Kittie's Cakes. Just be upfront about getting a tasting!
My husband and I knew that we wanted to serve cupcakes at our wedding because we wanted a variety of flavors for our guests instead of just one big cake. We saw Kitties when we wer...
e trying Pistacia Vera macarons down the road (which we also had at our wedding). After looking at their website, we knew we had to set up a tasting. We had actually attended another tasting right before going to Kitties for our tasting, but after one bite we knew that we would be going with Kitties.
Selecting our flavors was the most difficult part since they are all so delicious. We returned many times to try all of the flavors. Mollie and Kelly were always so friendly. It was clear to us that they make an effort to get to know their customers.
We ended up going with lavender vanilla for our two tier cake and s'more, cookies & cream, banana cream and stout mocha as our cupcakes. Mollie personally set up our display and it looked wonderful. We are so glad to have had Kitties at our wedding and to have found such a delicious bakery owned by such great people to return to often for cupcakes and scones!
Kitties Cakes blew our mind how good ALL of their products were! We got multiple wedding cakes as well as their cupcakes and a bunch of their other signature cookies and cream pies...
. We were so pleased with the look and flavor of EVERYTHING! They have very unique cake flavors that are different than your "normal" wedding cake which is what we were looking for! They were phenomenal ladies to work with and they have us as customers for life! The quality of the ingredients is what makes them stand out from other bakeries in my opinion. You won't be disappointed!
From the time we had our scheduled tasting through our reception, Kittie's was wonderful. Mollie worked with us even when we had changes to the amount we needed. They were very fle...
xible. Their set up was beautiful! We had several compliments about the dessert table. The cupcakes and desserts were a hit! We would recommend them to anyone throwing a party!
Molly and Kelly were just awesome. I have gotten so many comments on how incredible the assortment of cupcakes were and how beautiful the display looked! You can tell they are very...
passionate and good at what they do! Thank you!
Contact
495 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH
Kittie's Cakes