Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Based out of Saint Augustine, FL, Kristen’s Cupcake Cafe is a bakery that creates showstopping cakes and pastries that are just as tasty as they are creatively designed. Owner Kristen can customize treats for your special moments, whether you’re celebrating your wedding day or organizing a birthday party for your loved ones. If you’re looking for a picture-worthy cake that will linger with you, Kristen’s creations will surpass your expectations.
Kristen has a flavor inventory of over 40 flavors to choose from, meaning your wedding cake will be tailored completely to your needs. Your personal taste and style will be incorporated into the recipe, whether you prefer traditional buttercream on three tiers or an artsy, abstract masterpiece to fit your wedding theme. The company also offers vegan and gluten-free options as well. Get in touch with the team at Kristen’s Cupcake Cafe to find out more information about their delicious offerings.
Hi, I’m Kristen! I’ve been running my baking business for over five years, and within the past years I discovered my true passion—creating wedding cakes. I love celebrating love stories, and it’s such an honor every time a couple chooses me to be part of their special day.
I graduated from Flagler College in 2019 and have called St. Augustine home for the past nine years. On December 2, 2022, I married my best friend, Austen. He’s not only my greatest supporter but also the reason so many of my baking dreams have come true—he’s often right there with me helping out on deliveries!
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.0
15 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Kristen’s Cupcakes Cafe receives high praise for creating stunning and delicious wedding cakes. Reviewers commend the exquisite designs and flavorful options, with guests raving about the moist cakes and detailed sugar cookies. Kristen's attention to detail, accommodating nature, and ability to bring visions to life have left couples thrilled with their cake choices. Additionally, her professionalism, excellent communication, accommodating dietary restrictions, and delicious offerings are highlighted, making Kristen’s Cupcakes Cafe a top recommendation for those seeking show-stopping and scrumptious wedding cakes.
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Kristen R
5.0
12/29/2025
Kristen’s Cupcakes Cafe was absolutely amazing, and our wedding cake was truly the talk of the wedding! Not only was it stunningly beautiful, but it was also incredibly delicious!!...
So moist and full of flavor. We had countless guests come up to us to rave about how amazing the cake was. Kristen’s attention to detail and talent really shine through in her work, and she made the entire process so easy and enjoyable. If you’re looking for a show-stopping cake that tastes just as good as it looks, Kristen’s Cupcakes Cafe is the perfect choice. Highly recommend!
Evan J
5.0
12/12/2025
Kristen is so incredibly talented in what she does. She made us a 3 tier wedding cake, and sugar cookies for our wedding last week. Everything so turned out so beautifully! I gave ...
her the most picked apart details of how I wanted our cake designed, and it was almost as if she was able to see into my mind! The sugar cookies were so detailed and cute, that we just had to take a little box of them home with us after the wedding!
If you are looking for a wedding cake baker you need to go with Kristen. (And make sure to check out her other available desserts as well!) ✨✨✨
Any questions?
Kristin K
5.0
11/16/2025
We are so thrilled we chose Kristen’s Cupcake Café for our wedding cake! It was honestly the most delicious cake I’ve ever had. We loved that we were able to sample everything ahea...
d of time — from the cake flavors to the fillings — which made choosing our perfect combination so easy. The cookies and cream filling was absolutely incredible.
The design came out exactly like the photo I sent, down to every detail. It looked beautiful and tasted even better. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about it!
We would 1000% recommend Kristen’s Cupcake Café to anyone looking for a stunning, delicious wedding cake made with true skill and care.
Delaney F
5.0
6/05/2025
Kristen was one of the first people I reached out to on the Knot when looking for options wedding planning over a year ago! She was beyond patient with my bombardment of questions,...
and absolutely flexible with my six or seven quote changes I asked for when I could not decide what I wanted! She helped me make a sustainable and gorgeous pick for our wedding, with a partially fake cake so no food went to waste. She has gluten free and vegetarian options, and is very allergy-conscious. She makes an excellent tasting box set up, so you can mix and match the types you want to try. Our advice? GET HER GOLDEN OREO SPECIALTY. The fresh strawberry icing is so delicious and fun, but our cake pops in this flavor by far were the hit of all.
She came and handled all set up and tear down before and after our event, which made it such a breeze and a weight off us as we wound up such a fairytale day. Will be using her again for other celebrations!!
Karen M
5.0
6/01/2025
We could not have been happier with our wedding cake. Kristen really listened to our ideas and the end result was exactly what we had envisioned. The cake was so yummy - definitely...
the best lemon cake I have ever tasted. I highly recommend Kristen’s Cupcake Cafe for your wedding cake!
Amilyn K
5.0
4/14/2025
We ordered cupcakes for our guests and a small cake for us to cut for our wedding. Our guests were raving about the cupcakes all night, and we were able to pass on Kristen’s Cupcak...
e Cafe info to the vendors working there that day because they also loved the cupcakes. We even ordered a few gluten free/vegan cupcakes and they were so good! I thought the cake tasting was amazing, but the real deal cupcakes/cake were even better. We highly recommend Kristen’s Cupcakes, and will definitely be requesting cakes or cupcakes for future events.
Claire D
5.0
3/07/2025
Kristen was so helpful in the entire process of us ordering our wedding cake. She makes the most beautiful vintage heart cakes and it was so perfect for what we wanted! She was ver...
y kind in all of her communications and was very helpful when we had questions. The cake tasted amazing and looked incredible. Highly recommend if you are anywhere near the St. Augustine area!!!
Kelsey C
5.0
1/05/2025
Kristen creates the most beautiful wedding cakes! But I truly think what differs her from everyone else is the taste and flavor of her cakes! Her German chocolate cake was seriousl...
y the best I have ever had. I wish I could have taken more home with me, but we went straight into honeymoon mode after our wedding! You tell her your vision and she delivers 110%. I definitely will order from her again for other occasions in the future! Thank you so much Kristen for making the bakery side of wedding planning completely painless, but also super tasty!!!
Sarah L
5.0
11/06/2024
Kristen is very professional and easy to work with. Our cake was beautiful and delicious! Not only did we love it, but our guests raved about how amazing our cake was!
Hope A
5.0
4/12/2024
Wow — Kristen's desserts are absolutely phenomenal. We had her make a small two-tier cake and 350 mini cupcakes (four flavors) for our wedding, and each one knocked it out of the p...
ark! The cake was beautiful, exactly how we described our vision to her, and, most importantly, also delicious. If we ever have an opportunity to book with Kristen again, we absolutely will. (And, we highly recommend getting the tasting set! Such a fun time.)
Response from Kristen's Cupcake Cafe on 04/12/2024
I am so happy to have been a part of your special day!! Thank you so much! Congratulations...
to the both of you. :)
-Kristen
Helen J
5.0
2/13/2024
We had the best experience working with Kristen on our wedding day! She was so receptive and friendly, and her cake and cupcakes were beautiful and delicious. Everyone at the weddi...
ng was raving about how delicious they were! Thank you for making my vision come to life!
Response from Kristen's Cupcake Cafe on 04/12/2024
Helen,
Thank you for sharing your experience with us. It was an honor being a part of you...
r special day! Congratulations!!
-Kristen
Sarah T
5.0
8/07/2023
Wow wow wow!! Kristen did such an amazing job!! The cake tasting was one of my favorite parts of the wedding planning process!! She gave us all these options with mix and matching ...
fillings. Soo amazing, each one! We wound up going with a half and half wedding cake because we couldn’t decide between our two favorites! Golden Oreo cake with golden Oreo filling, and double chocolate cake with mocha chocolate chip filling!! Best cake ever! And the decorations were incredible!! Better than we had hoped for! I highly recommend Kristen!
Kathryn N
5.0
4/19/2023
Kristen is the absolute sweetest and she was SO much fun to work with! She gave us so many options (our tasting was AMAZING) and she was so accommodating with dietary restrictions!...
Everything was delicious and I cannot recommend her enough!
Karlee R
5.0
4/04/2023
Kristen was amazing! From the tasting to the wedding, everything was perfect and tasted delicious! I highly recommend.
Caitlin H
5.0
3/30/2023
Kristen was fabulous to work with and the cake was not only stunning but absolutely delicious! Kristen fully understood the vision and nailed the colors, design, and decorations. ...
She is also very responsive and friendly, it was a pleasure to work with her. We cannot recommend Kristen enough for your wedding cake!
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Kristen's Cupcake Cafe
Kristen Morgan
|
Owner
Typically responds within 24h
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking "Request quote," you accept our Terms of Use and agree to The Knot creating an account for you. Your messages may be monitored for quality, safety, and security according to our Acceptable Content Policy. See our Privacy Policy to learn how we handle your data.
