No photos yet
About this vendor
We don‘t know Main Street Sweets‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.037 reviews
Snickerdoodle Wedding Cake. That is all…my husband and I are obsessed. We loved that in the tasting, there were SO many options included- and everything was amazing. Peanut butter/...
chocolate, lemon blueberry, strawberry and raspberry and so many others…Jenn even found a pumpkin-flavored cupcake in her fridge for us to try. She was so accommodating, and we knew she cared about her work. Flash forward to the wedding - the cake was even more beautiful than we imagined, and everyone finally got to taste the cupcakes (6 different flavors!) that we raved about. Would absolutely order cupcakes from her again!
We used Main Street Sweets Cakes for our wedding at the Lodges at Gettysburg this past May 2024 and they were absolutely DELICIOUS! So much so that after doing the tasting, I order...
ed 4 dozen cupcakes of our wedding flavors on two separate occasions leading up to the wedding and took them into work to share because I just wanted to keep eating them! We had a subtle Star Wars themed wedding (it was May 4th - we had to lol) and asked for "classy" cupcakes that matched the theme, since we wanted Star Wars incorporated without it feeling like a 6-year-old's birthday party and Main Street Sweets did not disappoint! The cupcakes were adorable, delicious, and our guests couldn't stop raving about them! I would highly recommend Main Street Sweets to anyone looking!
Highly recommend! The cake design was something she had never done before and it was PERFECT! Every flavor we tried was delicious. She also has a great selection of other desserts ...
that were also SO good. Very easy to work with and very reasonably priced.
Wow! Working with Main Street Sweets was so fun, not only was the cake so delicious but there were so many great flavors to choose from! Everyone at my wedding LOVED the cupcakes a...
nd have been talking about them for weeks. The cake was so fluffy, the icing was just the right amount of sweetness and the fillings were divine, overall they were perfect! Also, the way Main Street Sweets displayed the cupcakes was so thought out and beautiful. They truly listened to my vision and displayed the cake with wooden crates and more rustic decor! I cannot say enough great things about Main Street Sweets if you are looking for your wedding baker!!
Main Street Sweets provided us with the most beautiful dessert table with assorted mini cheesecakes and assorted mini cupcakes. I was expecting the assortment to only include a few...
flavors, but there must've been at least 10 different flavors of each - probably more (chocolate, vanilla, blueberry, raspberry, snickerdoodle, cherry, butterscotch, pumpkin, etc.)! In addition they provided a tasting cake for us, and a separate anniversary cake for us to take home. Everything tasted amazing and the stands they used to setup the dessert table were beautiful. It was very easy to work with the staff to plan ahead of time, they were accessible by both phone and email. Everyone was incredibly professional, courteous, and helped make our day perfect.
We worked with Jennifer on our wedding cake. We met with her in advance of the wedding and she gave us a variety of flavor and icing samples to try so we could decide what we wante...
d.
On our cake, she used a really classic design but added green touches to incorporate our wedding colors as well. We had three different flavor layers (yellow, snickerdoodle, and almond) and each one was really tasty.
For our wedding, we served an assortment of mini desserts for our guests and had a smaller, separate cake for just us. Our guests raved about it! We had mini cheesecakes, pies, cup...
cakes, cookies, and they were absolutely fantastic. The cake for us was incredible as well. Jennifer was very easy to work with and was extremely helpful in putting together our dessert menu. My husband and I would 100% recommend Main Street Sweets!
Everyone absolutely loved the bite-sized desserts we had! Mini cupcakes, cheesecakes, and cannolis. Jennifer was great to work with. I would absolutely recommend her for your weddi...
ng!
My husband and I were so impressed with Main Street Sweets! From the tasting all the way to the wedding day communication was easy and quick and she was super accommodating with an...
y changes I wanted. The cake turned out better than expected and it was SUPER delicious. I highly recommend
The cake and cupcakes were gorgeous and so delicious! They looked exactly like the photos we shared. Jennifer was great to work with; responsive, professional and adaptive. I’m a h...
ome baker known for my flavors, and Jennifer wow’ed my fiancée (now husband) with the flavors. I will certainly be ordering from her again for other events!
Jennifer did an amazing job on our wedding cake & cupcakes! We had 5 different flavors and each of them were to die for.
1) lemon with raspberry filling
2)chocolate with peanut bu...
tter mousse filling
3) red velvet with cream cheese filling
4) pumpkin with cream cheese filling
5) vanilla with buttercream frosting
She even threw in an anniversary cake!
Amazing ! The cake was beautiful and the cupcakes were beautifully arranged with the wooden crates she provided. Highly recommend!
Our cake was gorgeous! Just as I dreamed it to be. Better yet it was so delicious. Everyone loved our cake. We ordered more cake then our guest count… so glad we did there was only...
3 pieces left at the end of the night! From the tasting experience of getting to try all the flavors and a bunch of fillings, getting to deciding our own combinations after trying them, to getting a separate anniversary cake.. jennifer talked the cake!!
I’m still getting compliments on our cake- not the typical wedding cake, it tastes like heaven!
Insta worthy, flavorful, and customized to perfection, Jennifer works magic to crea...
te more than just a wedding cake! Schedule a tasting, and take your ideas. Your guests will thank you!
I love Main Street Sweets! With my wedding venue, Main Street Sweets is a preferred vendor, so the cake/cupcakes were included. I had 3 or 4 total bakeries I could choose from. I t...
ried her cupcakes two years in a row at the venues bridal show and absolutely loved them! I honestly don’t feel as if anyone else even came close to how good her cupcakes are. Jennifer is so easy to work with and she put everything together exactly how I wanted. They turned out beautiful and yummy! I highly recommend giving her a try!
Main Street Sweets was recommended to me randomly by my Florist and I am so thankful we used Jennifer Wisner for our wedding. She invited us to her home and had many desserts prepa...
red for us to see and try. Her prices were very reasonable, which can be hard to come across during wedding planning. Not only were the prices reasonable, but her desserts were DELICIOUS. We decided to get a 2 tier naked cake and also have a dessert bar. She had so many dessert options and our guests were raving about them! She also created pretzel stick favors for our wedding and even provided the bags and ribbon. She let us mail stickers and she put them on and also placed the favors out at guests seats for the wedding. We are so happy with how everything turned out & we appreciated Main Street Sweets responsiveness, professionalism and kindness throughout the whole process!
We met with three different companies for our wedding cake and dessert bar. I was set with having a mini dessert bar at my wedding. Jennifer at Main Street Sweets was the third c...
ompany we met with and we were sold. Our tasting was incredible and we seriously couldn't stop eating the cupcakes! My husband doesn't even like cake at all and he went home and just kept eating the cake! Her variety for desserts was crazy; my dessert bar had mini cupcakes, chocolate covered oreos, chocolate covered pretzels, pies, and brownies. My guests loved the idea and most of the desserts were gone at the end of the night! Usually at wedding i see so many cupcakes or dessert left over, but I think because these were the perfect mini size, people more thoroughly enjoyed them! Jennfier was even kind enough to pack a to-go box for my husband and I to enjoy when we got home since we were so busy throughout the night and didn't get a chance to grab any sweets! Oh, I almost forgot to mention that she made us the cutest 6 inch round wedding cake just for the two of us. Believe me when I say we went right home and devoured that cake with a fork straight from the box!
Jennifer from Main St Sweets was awesome to work with. Her cakes were awesome. Everyone kept telling me after the wedding how much they loved the cake and cupcakes. And not only di...
d they taste great, but she made them look beautiful too!
Jennifer is absolutely wonderful to work with. She is professional, creative and went above and beyond to design the perfect cake for our special day. In addition to our tiered wed...
ding cake, I requested a custom groom's cake. Jennifer worked with me to create one of the best cake designs I have ever seen. I was completely blown away when I walked into our rehearsal dinner to see the beautiful cake displayed exactly how I had envisioned it to be. Our wedding cake was equally wonderful and tasted delicious. We highly recommend Main Street Sweets for any event.
I have nothing but great things to say about Jennifer with Main Street Sweets. I ordered both a tiered cake as well as many different mini desserts from her to make a grand dessert...
table at my wedding. She was wonderful to work with, great with communication, and all her desserts were delicious! She was very helpful in helping set all the desserts up at the venue the day of the wedding. The dessert was the talk of the night and I couldn't have been happier with how it all went!
We had 5 types of cheesecake and all were amazing!
We got a 3-tiered wedding cake and lot of desserts for our wedding! Everyone loved our cake! It was delicious!! Jennifer was sweet during the consultation we had and I loved that s...
he runs her entire business from her home. There are so many things to taste, so many options of fillings it was so hard to come down to a choice! Our cake design looked amazing! I could not have been more pleased with how our desserts came out!
I am the kind of person who does their research before doing anything. I met with at least two vendors for every aspect of my wedding. I can confidently say that I made the right c...
hoice with Jennifer. She was communicative, flexible, and knowledgeable! She took my vision and turned it into a beautiful and delicious reality! I would highly recommend her!
We decided to do a 2 tiered, small cake with cupcakes for our wedding. We had yellow cake with vanilla buttercream, chocolate with chocolate buttercream, strawberry cake with vanil...
la buttercream, and red velvet with cream cheese filling and vanilla buttercream. The hardest part about this vendor was trying to narrow down the flavors! All of the samples were absolutely delicious, flavorful, and moist. Also, Main Street Sweets did an awesome job with setting up our display at our venue to make it look so perfect. We had tons of compliments on the cupcakes and would recommend Main Street Sweets to everyone!
Main Street Sweets did an amazing job on our wedding cupcakes. The flavors were absolutely amazing and the set up was perfect. It’s so nice to find someone that will deliver the cu...
pcakes and take the time to make sure that your cake table looks amazing. We are thrilled that we chose Main Street Sweets as our baker for
our special day! Thank you!
We were so in love with our cake from main street sweets! It was exactly what we envisioned and absolutely delicious too! They have so many flavors and fillings to choose from and ...
you get to sample all of them (which might have been my husband's favorite part of the entire wedding experience). Main Street Sweets was also so organized and easy to work with. I highly recommend!
Fantastic cake and great flavors! We had our tasting and were impressed with the variety of flavors and fillings. Jennifer was very patient and helpful when it came to picking a de...
sign for our two-tiered cake. She was communicative and quick to respond. HIGHLY recommend!
These guys were perfect! My husband and I wanted a variety of specialty cakes and pies for our wedding. They made us one small two tier cake to cut, and then 4 cakes and 5 pies to ...
feed out guests. Everyone loved them! They were a big hit. We also had vintage crystal cake stands for each pie and cake and they were very accommodating to make sure these were displayed beautifully! They are extremely responsive to emails and very patient with deposits and payments. A++++ Highly recommended from this bride <3
Main Street Sweets made a 3 tier wedding cake and 200 cupcakes for our July 2 wedding in Gettysburg. My husband and I had a free taste-testing where we were able to tastes 12+ cake...
flavors, fillings, and icings. We mixed and matched and tried it all! It was so much fun and really allowed us to make a good decision. After choosing a cake flavor and 3 types of cupcake flavors, Wendy sat down with us and I showed her pictures and told her ideas of what I had in mind. She drew up a sketch and wrote out notes.
When I finally saw the cake on my wedding day, I was so pleased. It was everything I had wanted- absolutely beautiful! We had tons of wedding guests compliment the cake and cupcakes. I would recommend Main Street Sweets to anyone looking for a wedding cake vendor!
Main Street Sweets was amazing!! From the time we met them at the tasting (which was so fun!) all the way up until my wedding day, they were a great team to work with. Very afforda...
ble and the cupcakes tasted delicious! All of our guests loved the different flavors we provided and the way they decorated my cupcake cake looked great!! Very pleased :)
We used Main Street Sweets for our April wedding in Gettysburg. Being out of town, we had limited availability to schedule a consultation. From the beginning, they were so responsi...
ve and flexible. We met with Jennifer at her home for the tasting and consult. There were so many wonderful choices and we took home a huge box of cupcakes for the ride home! With our venue, we received a cake credit which was included with the venue cost. Jennifer was so helpful explaining all of our choices and helped make the choice of our 3-tiered cake effortless. We decided on different flavors for each tier, which all were amazing. Main Street was there for the whole process and was able to answer all of our questions quickly and efficiently. One of our cake toppers was a sword inserted in the middle of the cake. We were all nervous about how it would work out, but it turned out great and was a highlight of the reception!
I would highly recommend Main Street Sweets to anyone getting married in the area. They were friendly, easy to work with, and helped make an out-of-town wedding much less stressful. The delivery was on-time and they made sure everything was perfect before leaving. All of our guests loved the cake and we have an awesome anniversary cake waiting in the freezer for us this time next year!
We were thrilled with the cakes that Main Street Sweets provided us for our wedding. First and foremost: everything was delicious! I also really appreciated the flexibility of choo...
sing different flavors for each layer. Second, both cakes (a groom's cake for the rehearsal dinner and the wedding cake) were beautiful. The groom's cake had the specialized design we asked for and looked great. The wedding cake was simple but absolutely stunning. Finally, the prices were very fair and Jennifer and Wendy were willing to supply part of the wedding cake as a sheet cake (that was served but not displayed) to help us manage our budget even better. I highly recommend Main Street Sweets!
We got our wedding cake from Main Street Sweets. It was absolutely amazing! We met them for our tasting and were so impressed with the flavors. We had a very hard time deciding....
We ended up going with the Almond flavored cake with Raspberry mousse filling and vanilla butter cream frosting. It was one of the best cakes I have ever had. Our guests raved about the cake, even those not too fond of cake! We did have a guest with a peanut allergy and Main Street Sweets gave us the option of having peanut free cupcakes for that guest. The design of the cake was wonderful and absolutely beautiful. They delivered and set the cake up. I did not see it till it was time to cut it because we were pulled in different directions the whole night but it took my breath away! I was very impressed and will recommend Main Street Sweets to my friends!
I got my tiered wedding cake and my grooms cake from here and they were both great! The grooms cake was a suprise for my husband and it ended up being a suprise to both of us! i kn...
ew what the layout was going to be and it still went beyond my expectations! The wedding cake was amazing as well! it was exactly like the picture I showed them! All of the cake tasted great too!
We decided to go with cupcakes for our wedding day. They were delicious! I especially loved that they could do fillings for each! We also had a 6" round to cut into which was also ...
so good! They delivered and set up everything so one less thing to worry about. We got many compliments on them.
The ladies at Main Street Sweets were very sweet and efficient, getting me a quote and picture of the planned cake only a few days after our first meeting and taste-test. They deli...
vered the cake promptly, and also efficiently bundled up our separate top tier for us to take home. The cake design was gorgeous, just what I asked for, and the colors were fairly close to what I wanted. The flavors were delicious, and everybody was raving about them! I would recommend to brides in the area to use them!
Main Street Sweets was really easy to work with.
We met w/ Wendy, and she was awesome!
They made our cake look just like the picture,(we found it on the knot) and actually I like...
d ours better. I highly suggest the almond cake w/ raspberry filling. YUM!
Contact
19 Woodland Trail, Fairfield, PA
Main Street Sweets