5 out of 5 stars and 122 reviews
5
(122)Best of Weddings (5x).Seminole, Orange, Lake, Volusia counties
About this vendor
Welcome to my storefront!
My name is Michael Anthony the owner of Michael Anthony Cakes
Take a look around, Take your time, see the quality of work, feel free to ask questions, Google me, read my reviews across all social media.
I'm the only baker in Orlando that has a 40+ year culinary background that I bring to each & every cake.
You will taste the difference in the first bite
My cakes designs are determined by my meeting with my couples. To get to know them and the vision they have for their day. I will guide and suggest. Those may take us on a classic ride or a newfound journey.
This is your moment,
I look forward to working with the Knot couples to create their own Celebrated Cake Design
Details
Business Attributes
- Native American-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Stands
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Organic
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.0122 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
We are absolutely thrilled that we selected Michael Anthony's as the baker for our wedding on January 24th, 2025. Working with Michael has been an absolute delight; he truly went above and beyond to make our special day unforgettable. After our initial tasting, we instantly knew he was the perfect choice. Not only was the cake tasting an exquisite experience, with flavors that danced on our palates, but Michael's thoughtfulness shone through when he printed out inspiration photos for our wedding cake, allowing us to visualize our dream dessert. I can hardly wait to share more beautiful pictures of these stunning creations once we receive them from our wedding photographer. The desserts were a resounding hit—our guests couldn't stop raving about them throughout the night! Our elegant wedding cake was a decadent Buerre Noisette with a luscious apple filling that was simply heavenly. In addition, we delighted our guests with an array of mini cake flavors that included rich red velvet, whimsical Sunbathing Monkey, scrumptious 24 Karat, indulgent Moonshine Chocolate, and delightful biscotti and latte served in charming edible espresso cups. To top it all off, we had delightful extras like mouthwatering s'more pops, zesty key lime tarts, and delectable Cinnabon bread pudding. Each dessert was a little masterpiece that left our guests – and us – craving more!
Michael stepped in and assisted us when our original baker notified us they wouldn’t be able to make our cake just a few weeks before our wedding. From the moment I reached out to Michael, he was responsive, helpful, and so accommodating. He took time with my husband and I to really listen to us and help us achieve our vision for our wedding cake. The flavors he has available are unlike anything you’ll find elsewhere and are so incredibly delicious it’s hard to choose! We ended up loving all three flavors we tried so much, that we went with a three tier cake, one for each flavor, because leaving one out just wasn’t an option. I got so many compliments during and after our wedding as to how delicious the cake was which made us so happy to hear. Thank you Michael for stepping in and helping us out— I’m glad our original baker couldn’t work with us, we were in the best hands possible with you!
Michael Anthony is absolutely incredible at what he does. Not only are his cakes delicious, his customer service is just as lovely. He’s attentive, responsive and overall has an amazing demeanor. Michael was so pleasant to work with and we were honored to have him make our wedding cake. You can tell he truly loves what he does and my husband and I could not recommend him more.
Our wedding cake from Michael Anthony Cakes was absolutely perfect! Not only was it a beautiful work of art, but it was also incredibly delicious – every guest raved about the flavors. We couldn’t have asked for a more stunning and tasty centerpiece for our celebration!
PHENOMENAL. Just perfect. We had 50 guests and 80 servings and no cake left over, that’s how good the cake was.
We had 3 dozen cannolis, 3 dozen chocolate covered strawberries and 4 dozen carrot cakes.
The cake was 3 tiers. Top tier was Oreo, middle tier was limoncello, and the bottom tier was Frangipane. This was the best cake I have ever eaten at ANY wedding, and I wasn’t the only one that thought so since multiple people had more than 1 piece of cake. If you order from Michael Anthony, you need more servings than guests. Your guests WILL have more than the expected serving
The cannolis and strawberries were also gone by the end of the night.
We only had carrot cake left over which was still so delicious. Our guests were just full from the other sweets. The appearance was exactly like the picture we showed Michael, if not better. He has great attention to detail, and great communication. We will use him for ALL our cake needs!
This cake is the most talked about from our wedding.
I went to a wedding a few years ago and had the cake, it was absolutely amazing. I asked my friend if she can refer me to who made it for our upcoming wedding, and it was Michael! The taste alone is un matched. He took so much care and planning through the entire process. Our tasting was detailed, and delicious, he had a wide assortment of flavors for us to choose from. We ended up adding on cannolis last minute, he was very helpful and the guests loved them. I would recommend him to anyone who is in the area, absolutely amazing customer service, the cake was gorgeous and the taste was great!
Michael Anthony is a treasure that God blessed us with on our wedding day in March of 2010! He is now a part of all our greatest milestones for my whole family. His cakes and all baked goods are out of this world AMAZING!! I am gluten free and moist is difficult to come back with that dietary need but he nails it!! Not only is Michael Anthony incredible and talented, he is an AMAZING human, so caring and patient and passionate about his beautiful career and he puts the talents that God has blessed him with to the max! All of my best friends have also booked him for their weddings along with my MANY brides that I have introduced him to. You are making a HUGE mistake if you don’t chose a Michael Anthony cakes!!!!
Michael Anthony created the most amazing wedding cake for our daughter’s wedding in June. He was very professional and easy to work with. Such a kind person and he goes out of his way to help make the day perfect. But the best thing is that his cakes are the most delicious you have ever tasted. He also created small gluten free cakes for those guests we had that were gluten free and those were just as delicious. I look forward to using him again in 2025 as our next daughter will be getting married! Thank you Michael!
Michael not only made the most beautiful, mouth watering cake, but he was the one, non stressful, aspect to the day! Everything ran smoothly, and we never had to worry about the process. Communication was excellent, and he brought us ease at making any decisions when it came to our cake. Thank you for all you do Michael! We appreciate you.
Michael Anthony Cakes delivered with such professionalism! He made both my bachelorette cake, our wedding cake and the grooms cake with such amazing detail. He listened to our wishes and designs, and he delivered with such detail and beautiful artistry! I highly recommend!
Michael did our 3 tier wedding cake last September. Flavors were spot on and super moist! It was so perfectly done and he was always extremely communicative to make sure our cake was everything we could want! The tasting was also very helpful!
Michael made us a wedding cake that both looked and tasted amazing, and all of our guests loved it too. He was extremely kind and professional from the beginning and gave us a great personalized experience at our cake tasting. We gave him a vision for our cake and he executed it perfectly! And we didn't have to worry a single bit about whether everything would turn out well on the big day. Michael was sure to confirm the details for delivery and wanted to ensure the presentation of the cake was beautiful. We were so pleased with his service and the cake he made was one of the best contributions to our big day!
My fiance (now wife) joked leading up to our wedding that the thing she was most excited for was the wedding cake. Well, our wedding cake turned out to be one of our absolute favorite things about the entire day! Michael absolutely nailed it, down to the very last detail. Not only was it beautifully done, but it was delicious as well. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how much they loved the cake. My wife has severe food allergies to nuts and dairy, and Michael went above and beyond to make sure the cake was not only safe for her, but still every bit as delicious. He did such a wonderful job that we have gotten other cakes from him for other events, and they are just as wonderful every time. I cannot recommend Michael Anthony enough! If you want the wedding cake of your dreams - you've come to the right place.
I must say this is the BEST cake I ever had, hands down! Michael was very helpful and professional. Cake tasting was a blast. On our wedding day the cake was beautiful and it tasted just a good as it looked. Thank you for making our day extra special.
Michael's cakes are unparalleled in taste and quality. The sheer deliciousness of his creations is unparalleled. I've ordered the same flavor cake for three separate occasions—it's that good.
Michael Anthony did a superb job on every aspect of preparing a wedding cake for my family. He responded very quickly when we were searching for someone to meet our needs in a short time, and was able to customize the order perfectly. Delivered with care and a warm smile, it was beautiful and delicious!
Super friendly and easy to work with. Flavors were fantastic
Michael Anthony is a true artist! Very patient and professional. He created our vision to the T all while staying within budget. We are so grateful to have met such a talented and kind soul! We will be back for our anniversary cake!
Simply delicious and considerate I loved the cake he made for our wedding.
My wedding cake was a dream! I requested for it to be made vegan to accommodate to every one of my guests, and people were shocked that it was actually vegan when they tasted it! We got the Boston cream (our favorite) and Persian love cake. The cake tasting was incredible as well- Michael Anthony was incredibly hospitable and provided a memorable tasting experience for my fiancé and I. I highly recommend him for any event!
Michael Anthony Cakes did an amazing job with our wedding cake! He was extremely attentive to the exact design and flavors we wanted. His pricing is extremely affordable, and his product is top of the line. Everyone at the wedding absolutely loved the cake, it was not only beautifully decorated but had the most amazing flavor! If you are looking for a great design, amazing taste, and wonderful person who truly cares about his craft and your special day, look no further than Michael Anthony Cakes!
I was nervous about using a new bakery for my wedding cake, I was desperate because we had a destination wedding. I called last minute bearly was able to make my payment in full because it was so last minute. Guess what My cake was sooo good & pretty! I can't wait to eat my saved piece for my Anniversary!!!! It was 3 different flavors 😋 too. Thank you so much I will definitely be back anytime I'm in the area.
Michael Anthony is a spectacular baker, or shall I say artist! He is passionate about his cakes and is a pleasure to work with. He baked the cake for my bridal shower and wedding. Both were absolutely delicious and beautiful works of art! In addition, he baked a delicious array of Italian pastries for each table at my wedding reception and they were enjoyed by everyone. The pastries were beautifully displayed and we had comments all evening about how yummy and authentic they were! Can't say enough about Michael Anthony and I will without a doubt use him again in the future.
The professionalism and care that Michael Anthony took in creating our cake vision was beyond measure. We had a fresh cake that our guests complimented us on and the presentation was exquisite. And the taste was amazing.
When it comes to indulging in a slice of heaven, I have discovered a true culinary gem. The best cake maker I have ever encountered has elevated the art of cake baking to a whole new level. From the first bite to the last crumb, every experience with his delectable creations is nothing short of extraordinary. Michael Anthony has been creating cakes for me and my family for every special occasion for several years now. More recently we had the pleasure of working with Michael for my daughters wedding. Her cake was not only visually spectacular but absolutely scrumptious tasting. Everyone raved about the cake! Michael Anthony also provides vegan options as we had many vegan guests. We had a custom desert room where Michael Anthony provided several flavors of vegan cupcakes and they were absolutely to die for! I highly recommend Michael Anthony for your wedding as well as birthdays and special celebratory occasions he is absolutely amazing and very wonderful to work with. I can’t say enough good things about how professional he is and what a joy to work with.
The experience my wife and I had with Michael Anthony Cakes was amazing. He gave us an in depth consultation with tastings and we talked through the design in depth with photos. It was a very fun experience meeting him. The cake turned out even better than the photos and all of our guests were raving over the unique flavors! He was the perfect choice for the wedding cake, I couldn't imagine using someone else's services.
When it comes to indulging in a slice of heaven, I have discovered a true culinary gem. The best cake maker I have ever encountered has elevated the art of cake baking to a whole new level. From the first bite to the last crumb, every experience with his delectable creations is nothing short of extraordinary. Michael Anthony has been creating cakes for me and my family for every special occasion for several years now. More recently we had the pleasure of working with Michael for my daughters wedding. Her cake was not only visually spectacular but absolutely scrumptious tasting. Everyone raved about the cake! Michael Anthony also provides vegan options as we had many vegan guests. We had a custom desert room where Michael Anthony provided several flavors of vegan cupcakes and they were absolutely to die for! I highly recommend Michael Anthony for your wedding as well as birthdays and special celebratory occasions he is absolutely amazing and very wonderful to work with. I can’t say enough good things about how professional he is and what a joy to work with.
I have had the privilege of enjoying Michael Anthony's delightful cakes for many years now, and he never fails to impress! The flavors he crafts are truly exceptional, offering a unique richness that remains consistent with each and every creation. What sets Michael apart is his exceptional communication skills throughout the entire process.
Most notably, Michael had the honor of designing our wedding cake, a true four-tier masterpiece. It was everything we had envisioned and more. Each tier boasted a different flavor, adding an exciting element to the overall experience. Michael made the entire process effortless by organizing a tasting session where we could provide examples and discuss our preferences in detail. His enthusiasm and attention to detail were truly remarkable.
One of the standout aspects of our wedding cake was the intricate gold foil ornate monogram that he flawlessly recreated. It added a touch of elegance and personalization that exceeded our expectations. Additionally, Michael even went above and beyond by creating vegan cupcake versions of each tier, which were just as delectable as their non-vegan counterparts. I'm still amazed at how he manages to achieve such incredible taste and texture in his vegan creations.
Without hesitation, I wholeheartedly recommend Michael Anthony for all your cake needs. His talent, professionalism, and dedication to delivering exceptional results are unmatched. Whether it's a small gathering or a grand event like a wedding, you can trust him to create a memorable masterpiece that will leave everyone in awe.
My wife and I read some reviews about Michael Anthony Cakes and wanted to come and do a tasting. The tasting absolutely blew us away. Michael Anthony is very professionall first of all and also the quality of the cake was absolutely superb. He is a master of his craft. We wanted the cake to look a specific way as well and he was able to replicate the design that we found online perfectly. I can't emphasize enough on the flavors as well. It was perfectly made. I will definitely recommend him for not just weddings but any event where you want an amazing cake.
Michael made us the most beautiful wedding cake. He was very professional and always communicated with us. His cake flavors are so unique and rich in taste. He was able to create such a beautiful cake design even though we had a small wedding. He is a true artist.
When we were planning our wedding, we wanted to go with a local business with some unique flavors. Michael has previously done some cakes for birthdays and it was a no brainer we had to hire him for our wedding cake. He was extremely responsive and helped guide us on what to do. He has a list of flavors that you won't find anywhere else! It was hard to choose so we ended up going with having a different flavor for each tier for our cake and it was a HUGE hit. The cake design was exactly what we wanted, and it was just absolutely delicious!
Michael Anthony did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake and dessert services! Michael was extremely helpful, and always provided quick responses and high quality service throughout the entire process. Our wedding cake and desserts turned out to be beautiful and our wedding guests loved the variety of flavors and dessert options. Thank you, Michael Anthony Cakes, for providing a wonderful experience for us and for everything you did to make our wedding day special!
Michael Anthony did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake and dessert services! Michael was extremely helpful, and always provided quick responses and high quality service throughout the entire process. Our wedding cake and desserts turned out to be beautiful and our wedding guests loved the variety of flavors and dessert options. Thank you, Michael Anthony Cakes, for providing a wonderful experience for us and for everything you did to make our wedding day special!
Hands-down, the most amazing cake and flavor ever! Michael was so attentive and super helpful, amazing customer service he made our wedding day spectacular. Our guests were so pleased with the decor of our cake and most importantly the flavor. I recommend him for any event that you have, you will not be disappointed.
Michael Anthony cakes are THE BEST! We had two cakes made for our wedding on September 29, 2018 and we are now wanting to order another cake to celebrate our five years Anniversary! Time flies! You want your day as memorable as it can be, you won’t ever forget about Michael Anthony’s cakes!!!
The Best Cake Vendor Ever! Highly recommend, Michael Anthony Cakes. Over the top cake appearances and the taste was delicious!
Michael Anthony is the cake artist you want to create your custom dream wedding cake.
Michael is a custom cake artist who delivers his brides dreams in cake form, pays attention to every detail, a joy to work with, arrives and sets up everything seamlessly.
We love and appreciate you and your excellence Michael.
Thank you once again for making our daughter Sarah’s wedding cake dreams come true.
Michael did an outstanding job from start to finish! We had such an enjoyable experience, tasting our cakes and discussing design. When it came to the wedding day, our ideas were executed so beautifully. We cannot thank Michael enough for his work.
Michael Anthony did our wedding cake and it was absolutely BEAUTIFUL. The flavor was delicious and the design was exactly what we were looking for. Michael was amazing throughout the whole process and we wouldn't have wanted anyone else in charge of our cake! 100% recommend using Michael Anthony Cakes for any cake needs you may have in the future.
Michael did a fantastic job creating the cake of our dreams! It not only looked fantastic but it tasted great as well! We went through way too many meetings and taste tests with various bakers around town but he was the only one we found that made great tasting cakes and could also bring to life our unique design! Everyone raved about our cake and by the next day there wasn't a drop left. He was also able to make mini gluten free cakes for my guests who couldn't partake in our main cake and they said it was the best tasting dessert they ever had and they felt so special to have a separate dessert made just for them!
Michael is the best in the business. He made my sisters wedding cake over 10 years ago, and since then has made all of the cakes for all of our families occasions. He designed and crafted us the best wedding cake of our dreams for our wedding and we could have not been any more satisfied. The flavors and attention to detail, set him apart from any other cake vendor in the industry.
Michael is the BAKER IN FL hands down! His cakes taste divine and his artistry is beautiful! Michael puts a lot of care and love into each cake. I recommend him to all my friends and family!
Michael is really kind and very professional. He made a very delicious vegan wedding cake and he even gave us a gluten free side cake to my mother in law since she's allergic to gluten. 100% recommended!
I can talk about how beautiful these cakes are, truly a work of art. However, it will come short on how delicious and truly phenomenal they are. You can never go wrong with Michael Anthony. A true professional and artist!
Micheal Anthony did the cake for my daughters wedding, and let me say that in a world that lacks customer service, Micheal went above and beyond. He went above and beyond to produce a cake that was not only delicious, but just like the image we gave him to replicate. Micheal is passionate about what he does. Weddings are stressful, so make sure to pick Micheal Anthony Cakes so that you can be assured that your cake will be perfect!
Michael Anthony did a great job at bringing our wedding cake dream to life! The flavors were also delicious and I received very positive feedback from the guests at my wedding! I highly recommend him for future events!
Michael Anthony Cakes provided excellent customer service throughout our entire engagement and wedding planning process. He was able to meet with us very last minute and delivered a beautiful delicious cake- loved by all of our guests. We highly recommend his cakes at any and all events!! 5/5 Stars
If you’re looking for the best tasting cake, a true kind profesional to handle your needs from tasting to set up. Michael is your guy, 5 star service and 10 star cakes. Thank you Michael for delivering a beautiful cake to our wedding. Recommended 100 percent!!
Michael Anthony made us such an amazing cake for our wedding day. All of our guests LOVED it! We had an initial tasting and my husband and I melted with the first bite. Seriously some of the best cake I've had in my life. He gave us exactly what we were looking for with decoration. Amazing quality and wonderful to work with. Highly recommend!
Michael Anthony Cakes was the very best wedding cake we have ever taste and the experience was so wonderful from the cake tasting to our actual wedding day. So many times you go to weddings and the cake looks beautiful but taste dry, pastey, or like it sat in the cooler for 4 days.
I very much appreciate the great customer service and how personable and friendly Michael was. He understood the Tiffany’s design we imagined and not only brought to life my dream wedding cake visually, but he was also able to provide us with three terrific layers, chocolate, tiramisu, and red velvet; it was divine!
Our wedding was 11/27/21 and despite our wedding being so close to Thanksgiving, our cake was moist, soft, and every layer taste amazing. Ironically our guest thought the cake was better than dinner and they raved about the red velvet cake!
We would recommend Michael Anthony Cake’s for any occasion and you can trust that your cake isn’t going to be prepared a week ahead and stuck in a cooler to dry out.
Taste the difference of a Michael Anthony Cake!
Michael Anthony Cakes was absolutely delicious and BEAUTIFUL. He was wonderfully sweet and made all our cake and dessert wishes come true. Highly recommend to all.
Working with Michael Anthony Cakes was a wonderful and easy experience. From the few vendors we reached out to, Michael followed up within the day and we were able to schedule a cake tasting in the same week. We chose 3 flavors to try out and it was absolutely delicious that we used the same in our wedding cake. One thing that stood out was that the cake was light and not too sweet (as we preferred). Flavors were great especially the strawberry lemonade. We were also able to ask for adjustments like more coffee in the tiramisu layer. We brought screenshots of a few design ideas to the tasting and Michael discussed more details on each style. I was able to email questions at any time and Michael was quick to reply or set up a quick call. Cake was delivered on time and many guests complimented the look and taste.
We ordered our cake from Michael and was blown away. It was so stunning. Everyone was raving about his cake. People from our wedding were asking for seconds. He is professional and a master at his craft. We will be ordering from him again for future events.
Michael Anthony Cakes was a perfect addition to our wedding day!
My husband and I sometimes can have extremely different tastes in food and decor so finding someone we both knew we couldn't pass on for cake was extremely hard!
We tried three different flavors of cakes during our tasting and it was so incredibly hard to decide which one we liked best - they were all delicious.
Michael worked with us to make a few slight changes to the flavors we selected to make them more customized to our tastes and the design we showed him and asked for came to like PERFECTLY!
All of our family and friends loved the cake and it was an absolutely STUNNING piece of decor for our reception as well. Not only do they look gorgeous it truly is some of the best cake we've ever had in our life.
You won't be disappointed with a cake for any occasion with Michael Anthony Cakes!
Michael Anthony is so attentive and caring! There isn't a lot people in this area that do Hispanic cakes, I can 5o him and my heart was set on Puerto Rican wedding cake it wasn't on his menu and He looked at me and said I'll do it for you. He made it and tasted amazing he truly cared about what we needed and wanted for our special wedding day!
Michaels cakes are simply the best! And he is great to work with. I had 4 cakes at my wedding and all of them were beautiful and delicious. We also had over 100 mini pastries for our dessert table. All of them so cute and just as delicious. Highly recommend!
Not only was the cake delicious, but working with Michael was such a great experience! He was so patient with us as we had to delay our wedding several times (COVID related) and seemed so genuinely enthusiastic to be working with us. The cake was the hit of the party with multiple people coming up to us to ask the baker - and everyone had a different favorite flavor! (Mine was the Biscoff cookie) We were so lucky to have him as our baker and highly recommend!
Michael,
I just want to say how much we are grateful for you making our cake! There are not enough words to express our happiness and appreciation!
You nailed the design of the cake, it was exactly what we wanted! You are amazing, Michael, and we are super thankful! It tasted fabulous too! ❤️❤️
We will HIGHLY recommend you to everyone! 🥰
Michael Anthony made us the literal best wedding cake!! I'm a great baker and I know what a good and quality cake is. When I tell you that this man is IT he is the real deal!!! Our guest RAVED about his cake, and the layout/decore of the table was more than I could ask for. He will truly be our only cake artist (he's truly an artist of his craft) for any and all of our family events. I had 6 different flavors for my wedding (3 for the cakes and 3 for the mini cakes). This man is truly a genius when it comes to creating flavor profiles and getting the cake to the ideal texture. His cakes are full of flavor, moist, and you'll get that perfect bite everytime!! We sampled many cakes and his by far beat the competition everytime!!! Don't hesitate, but RUN to book him!!! Also he's a super great guy!! My husband and I are still trying to figure out a way to make him a part of our best friend's group lol.
Beautiful cake on a lovely wooden cake stand. we enjoyed every bite. he came early and had it all set up with the flowers and decorations. easy to work with. yummy cake. you can't go wrong.
Contact
1540 International Parkway, Lake Mary, FL | Seminole, Orange, Lake, Volusia counties
michael anthony cakes
michael anthony cakes's photos