About this vendor
Award-winning small town bake shoppe! We provide full-service options from decadent tiered cakes, gourmet cupcakes, dessert bars, to donut weddings
Based in Milwaukee, WI, Neat-O’s Bake Shoppe is a popular professional cake baker who makes tasty works of art that will be a stunning centerpiece for your wedding.
Owner Amanda began baking when she was only 15 years old and fell in love. Her passion for creating tasty treats led her to start decorating cakes for weddings and other special occasions. She has been working in the industry for over 12 years and has gained plenty of experience from the hundreds of cakes she has designed.
Neat-O’s Bake Shoppe creates something special for your big day whether you would like an elegant, traditional tiered cake or a fun display of donuts or cookies. Amanda provides a cake-tasting service so you can find out your favorite flavors. She can also make delicious gluten-free cakes for every guest to enjoy.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.024 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
We selected Neat O's for our wedding cake and we are so happy we did! The cake was beautiful and SO tasty! We received compliments on it. Neat O's also provided some GF cupcakes to...
have for our guests - I heard they were fantastic. We appreciated the delivery service to our venue very much! Thank you Neat O's! We can't wait to have our leftover cake on our 1 year anniversary!
We did three sheet cakes for our wedding (7/14/23) and they were delicious! Our guests loved them and they were very reasonably priced and delivered! The cake tasting was also a lo...
t of fun!
The best cupcakes we've ever had! Our guests raved about them for days. They were so friendly and accommodating through the whole wedding process. I would highly recommend using Ne...
at-O's for all of your bakery needs!
The cake was so tasty and it arrived on time. They were great for the whole process.
They did an amazing job with our cake! Tasted amazing (great buttercream frosting) and looked absolutely stunning. Also priced very reasonably and the staff was great to work with!...
Highly recommend!
Neat O’s Bake Shoppe was amazing. With planning a new wedding in three months due to our venue closing permanently, we were able to do a cake tasting to go. Everything we tried wa...
s delicious. They were very responsive with emails. The final product looked exactly how we wanted it to and it still tasted just as delicious! Thank you for making it so easy!!
The wedding cake was pure perfection! Delicious and beautiful.... most of the wedding party sampled all three kinds. Highly recommend! 💞
Neat-O's did our wedding and truly made our vision come to life! I made an out of the ordinary request, a giant two-tiered cinnamon roll cake, and they knocked it out of the park! ...
You name it, and they can do it. Amanda was professional and great to work with as well! Definitely check them out for any of your sweet treat needs!
If I could give them more then 5 stars I would. They did the cake for my wedding and I couldn’t have been happier with the result. Not only was the cake beautiful but more importan...
tly, it was delicious! We received so many compliments on how tasty the cake was from guests and everyone wanted seconds! We had the almond cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream frosting but I would recommend any of their flavor combinations as everything was excellent when we did our tasting. This is a family owned and operated business and I would strongly recommend them - you will not be disappointed!
Working with Neat-Os for our wedding was one of the absolute best decisions we made for our big day! From our initial tasting all the way up to our wedding, Neat-Os was kind, helpf...
ul, and accomodating. They had such a variety of wonderful cake and frosting flavors it was tough for us to decide on our favorites. Our cake turned out more stunning than we ever could have envisioned, and my husband and I were eager to show all of our guests. We will definitely make continued trips to Neat-Os whenever we are in town!
If you are looking for a bake shop for your wedding needs (or any need if that!), look no further! We chose Neato’s for our wedding day and it was one of the best decisions we made...
. When we did a tasting, we came in with our family and we had one of the staff members sit with us and bring out all of their flavors of cake/cupcakes as well as the fillings/frostings and go through them with us. We took forever to decide what cake and cupcakes we wanted as everything was just THAT good. We decided on a bunch of options for cupcakes (we just couldn’t decide) that included almond, red velvet, carrot, etc. and a 8 inch yellow cake. We ordered about 260 cupcakes for 140 guests – for awhile, we thought we would have a lot of leftovers as we wanted to order more than less. The day of, we were wrong. We had guests eating 4-5 cupcakes because they could not get enough! We took home a couple of boxes and we had our family members and friends eating them within the day. Neato’s staff and product left a lasting impression on us – we will be back to visit every time we are in Wisconsin!
They were so great to work with! Amanda helped walk us through the process and made it easy and fun to pick the perfect cake for our wedding. The cake was absolutely beautiful and ...
exceeded our expectations! We received many compliments on the design of the cake as well as how delicious all the flavors were. Guests went back for second and third servings because the cakes were so delicious!
If you are trying to plan your wedding in any reasonable amount of time, I would avoid using Neat-O's. I originally contacted her in November and have received a sum total of 2 res...
ponses within 2 months. Completely unresponsive - which for someone who advertises as doing wedding baking is completely unacceptable, in my opinion.
We got our Wedding Cupcakes as well as a smaller cake for us to cut from Neat-O's and we were so happy with everything we got. We got 5 different flavors of cupcakes and it worked ...
out so well. Neat-o's also worked with our florist Wild Apples and for our cake topper Wild Apples added a floral topper. Our tasting experience was so great, it is such a neat shop and all the employees were so friendly and helpful. We were recommended to this bakery by our venue and I'm so glad that we were. I'd definitely recommend Neat-o's.
We were more than impressed with this awesome bakery in Baraboo. We are not from the area but got married there and chose them based off other reviews and recommendations and we we...
re so pleased. The cake tasting was with Cheri and she was so great! So sweet and willing to answer any question. So accommodating. Such delicious cake right from the start! Amanda did an amazing job on our wedding cake and it looked just like we had a pictured. The cake itself tasted so great and so many guests are still talking about the great flavor of the cake! We will definitely be back for more when we are in the area!
The cake was amazing just like the day we taste tested it. Such a wonderful shop to work with and excellent service!
Neat-O's made cake donuts for our wedding. They were AMAZING. We got so many compliments on the flavors and presentation. They delivered the donuts to our venue and arranged the...
m on the platters we had there. It was so fun and they were so good!!! When we went for our tasting everyone was extremely nice and professional. I would totally recommend this place to anyone looking for any sort of sweet treats for a wedding.
The cake was beautiful and very reasonably priced! Everything tastes great, and they made it look even better than I had envisioned. They were also very prompt with delivery, and t...
he cake actually haf already been delivered when I arrived to the venue to get ready.
Working with Neat-O's was very easy and fun. Everything from our cake tasting appointment to the wedding day was easy and enjoyable. Our guests raved about the cupcakes!
We loved our wedding cake from Neat-Os! It was delicious and beautiful. We really enjoyed the tasting experience too, and chose almond cake with raspberry filling. I sent in two pi...
ctures of cakes and asked for part of each, and it turned out exactly how I wanted!
Our experience with Neat-O's Bake Shoppe is nothing but amazing!! It all started with the awesome experience we had with the cake tasting! They brought out full cup cakes for us to...
sample along with all the fillings so we could mix and match cakes and fillings! We were able to do 3 different flavors of cake!
They made the cake look exactly like it did in the picture and I was in love with it, it was perfect!!
Everyone loved the cake and there wasn't very much left at the end of the night!
Tony and Amanda are a great team! They can do anything you request, and it all turns out beautiful and delicious! We ordered a bunch of mini desserts... they went in the night befo...
re to bake them all so they were fresh - great service! Everything is very reasonably priced and the tasting alone was wonderful! I have since made all of my bakery orders through them. You can't go wrong with Neat-O's!
Holy cow! Neato's has the most amazing cakes. Amanda and her husband are really creative and know how to bake a mean pastry/cake.
Our cake was the first thing we picked out fo...
r our wedding. We had so much fun choosing the cake and frosting flavors. Amanda was very accommodating and listened to everything we asked for. While the cake was outstanding, the highlight for me was our piepops! Neato's had never done anything like that, but Amanda created little cherry and lemon meringue (?!) pies on a stick. We wanted these to be a surprise for our guests, and ended up adding extra piepops in the last week leading up to wedding. They turned out great and were such a hit at the reception!
The day of our wedding my mom went to get pastries and donuts from Neato's for the bridesmaids and me while we were getting ready. They were so delicious and there was so much variety that everyone had something to choose.
I would highly recommend Neato's for ANY occasion. Their sweets are to die for, and everyone at the shop is just lovely.
A great wedding cake
Contact
420 Oak St, Baraboo, WI | Baraboo, Wisconsin Dells, Mauston, Spring Green to Madison
Neat-O's Bake Shoppe