4.5 out of 5 stars and 20 reviews
4.5
(20)254 36th Street, Suite 106, Brooklyn, NY
About this vendor
Whether it's one of our classic designs or something special you have in mind, we would be honored to work with you! As a local Brooklyn bakery with three locations, we value our client relationships and love meeting new couples that choose us to celebrate with them. We offer wedding cakes, dessert tables, and custom favors (our whoopie pies have a cult following!), and love working with you to create that perfect sweet addition to your big day. We look forward to hearing from you!
What You'll Love About One Girl Cookies
Couples love working with them and how they make the whole process feel like a breeze. They also love their affordable rates and how the cakes are both pretty and delicious. To learn more, check out the reviews.
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
- Other Desserts
Awards and Affiliations
3-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2021.2013.2011.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.5
out of 5.020 reviews
I am giving them 3 stars because the cake was not the best, unfortunately. It was too sweet and dry. However, the customer service was great. We worked with Annamarie and she was v...
ery professional throughout the process. She helped us figure out the right size of the cake for our guest because we didn’t want too much to be leftover as we are not big cake people. Maybe the flavors we chose didn’t work well together that’s why it came out too sweet/dry. Give them a shot, they are really nice to work with
Our guests loved the treats from One Girl at our wedding! Everyone especially raved about the whoopie pies--they were gone in an instant. Working with One Girl Cookies was a breeze...
and we highly recommend them!
One Girl Cookies has been one of our neighborhood favorites for years now! And, from our first cake tasting at the Cobble Hill location, we knew that we had made a great decision b...
y choosing One Girl Cookies for our wedding. The entire process of tasting and working through the flavor profiles still stands as one of our unique memories leading up to our wedding. We had dozens of emails with Jennifer changing our specifications, week after week, and through it all, Jennifer was so helpful and produced a dazzling cake for our wedding. We were thankful that we chose One Girl - it's one of those decisions we look back on and wouldn't do it differently. Incredible quality, professionalism, and one tasty cake! (And, furthermore, this coming from someone that isn't even much of a "cake person!")
One Girl was super easy to work with--from the tasting to coordinating logistics for our wedding. We got tons of compliments on our delicious (and beautiful) cake and are excited t...
o have some leftover to freeze for ourselves! Also worth mentioning that a lot of wedding cakes are insanely expensive and One Girl's cakes are both a bit more reasonable AND delicious and pretty. :)
Stop, halt, you've found your cake vendor! One Girl has been one of my favorite Brooklyn bakeries since I was a kid. I had no idea they did event cakes, and was thrilled to see tha...
t they do. Jennifer from One Girl made it SO easy to taste cakes (even though I live across the country and only visited New York for short stints). She worked with the venue to arrange drop-off and I barely needed to do anything to get our cake set up.
Highly recommend One Girl for a great cake for your New York wedding!
We’ve been eating at One Girl Cookies for years, so we knew they were the cake to beat! No other bakery came close in terms of flavor and texture. Jennifer and the team were wonder...
ful – they agreed to make an old favorite of ours that was no longer on the menu, and it was beyond delicious. We ordered brownies for the guest gift bags, which were such a hit that one guest wants me to send her more via mail, and we were able to design a custom sticker for the cellophane bags. We were also able to customize the design for our sugar cookie plaques that we used as favors, which looked stunning, tasted great, and were a big hit. With their wonderful combination of professionalism, beauty, and absolutely scrumptious products, you can’t go wrong if you pick One Girl Cookies!
We were overall very happy with our experience for our wedding cake. The tasting process was a lot of fun, where we went to the store and got to try different combinations of cakes...
, frostings, and fillings. We fell in love with the chocolate cake and raspberry curd filling. For the wedding, we decided to do a smaller display cake with sheet cakes for our guests. The cake looked beautiful, and our guests said it was delicious. Our only concern was that when my husband and I did the cake cutting, we didn’t really taste the raspberry. However, when we brought the rest of the cake home and ate it over the next week, we realized that it didn’t quite go all the way to the edges, so the flavor was stronger in the center of the cake. I would have liked the filling flavor to come through a little more, but the cake was still delicious.
One Girl Cookies delivers delightful cakes and makes the process incredibly easy. Highly recommend them!
Working with One Girl Cookies was wonderful. It was easy to scheduled a tasting and the tasting was fun and stress free. Ordering my cake was also stress free and I was helped alon...
g the way. The delivery and set up went very smoothly. The cake was absolutely delicious and I am so sad I have to wait a year to eat what is waiting for me in my freezer!
This small, Brooklyn bakery which makes the most delicious cookies and cakes, made a big hit with our guests! Not only did they love the cookies, but the presentation—little white...
boxes with silver band and ribbon, with an attached “thank you” note to our guests— was a lovely and festive addition to the tables.
It was a pleasure to work with Jennifer Hughes, Event Coordinator for One Girl. She was very helpful in placing the order, insuring its accuracy, and delivering them to our wedding venue. Jennifer also took the time to email me after the wedding to congratulate us.
The entire process was easy and seamless, and it was delightful to see the boxes on the tables at the reception. Best of all, everyone loved the cookies!
One Girl Cookies; events@onegirlcookies.com
Highly recommend One Girl Cookies! After being unable to get the cake that we wanted (from a vendor outside of NYC at the Jersey shore that closed for the season before our wedding...
), One Girl Cookies offered to make their version of our dream cake. It was fantastic! They were so accommodating and helpful with the planning, as I changed my mind about having one cake or a cake bar or a dessert bar a few times. The cake was a big hit, and we can't wait to eat it on our anniversary!
We wanted for a dessert bar in lieu of a traditional cake and One Girl Cookies was wonderful in bringing that idea to life. The tasting was really fun and filling. With the dessert...
bar option, we were able to choose eight desserts and the glass and paper products used in the table decoration. They also provided favor bags so that guests can take some goodies home (which our guests fully took advantage of!). Everything tasted delicious and looked beautiful. The only negative thing I can think of was longer than usual delays in response to emails, but we planned far enough in advance that this didn't really effect anything.
Our wedding cake from One Girl Cookie is still being talked about by our guests, almost 2 months later! OGC executed our cake beautifully, and were easy to work with. Most of all,...
and I say this as an intense lover of all baked goods, it tasted AMAZING. We had a four-tier vanilla cake with vanilla frosting on the outside, and raspberry jam and cream cheese frosting (!!) on the inside. They are competitively priced, and were down the street from our wedding venue, Deity.
We highly recommend One Girl Cookie and plan on ordering cakes for special occas in the future!
My favourite part was attending the tasting. It was a fun experience seeing the shop, walking through their kitchen, and of course tasting various flavours. In the end we chose a r...
aspberry and lemon flavoured cake.
DELICIOUS!!! And beautiful!! We ordered a small 3 tier cutting cake, a mix of mini and full size cupcakes, and our favors from One Girl Cookies for our wedding and we were defin...
itely not disappointed. Out cake was stunning – it was red velvet with cream cheese buttercream frosting – but the red velvet cake was ombre – going from red to light pink. Just so pretty and special! We had a mix of both full size and mini cupcakes with either flowers or glitter sprinkles decorating them. We also did mixed flavors of cupcakes – red velvet, lemon, chocolate, and vanilla. We are still getting compliments on the cupcakes!
Our favors were mini pink and white cookies to match the color scheme of our wedding which were also delicious and were packaged in cellophane with a printed ribbon. Rebecca was so easy to work with and so helpful. I highly recommend One Girl Cookies – so yummy and pretty!!!
Rebecca at One Girl Cookies was great to work with. We did not want a typical tall, multi-tiered cake covered in fondant. We wanted a simply styled cake that actually tasted good a...
nd that's exactly what they delivered. We decided to have one small, multi-tiered cake that we cut and 4 other single tiered cakes that were all different flavors so guests had a variety of options. We didn't get to have much cake the night of the wedding but had our catering package some for us to take home and enjoyed it for breakfast the next day!
We loved their cupcakes and wanted to use them, but the manager wouldn't give us a tasting! We thought that was very unusual. We have only tried 2 of their flavors and wanted at le...
ast 4 flavors for the cupcakes and maybe a slicing cake. NO WAY we would place an order without a tasting.
We didn't do much in the way of a traditional wedding, no religious ceremony, no bridal party and almost no cake. However we were at One Girl Cookies one fine early summer afterno...
on and decided to try a piece of their chocolate-dulce-de-leche cake. So tasty we decided that was going to be our wedding cake. So no white traditional cake but who cares when it tastes this good. Rave revues from everyone at the wedding too. And Dawn and her crew at One Girl worked with us too so we did have one tiered, 3 layered, traditional cake but then were able to purchase two regular 1 layered cakes to cut down on cost. Delicious, I wish I had more...
We ordered my American wedding cake from One Girl Cookies. We worked with a few different members of the One Girl Team and everyone was pleasant and easy to work with. We went with...
a vanilla cake with mocha espresso fillings and vanilla swiss meringue buttercream with a simple color band and floral design. It was absolutely delicious! We had a little misunderstanding about the design but One Girl was more than willing to work things out with me. Wonderful bakery!
Everything! The owner of the bakery and her pastry chef were absolutely wonderful to work with. They had excellent flavors to choose from gave me the best tasting by far that I ha...
d anywhere the designs that they did were simple (what I wanted) but SO cute and clever. The price was OUTSTANDING and they were always accessible and accommodating. Best of all it was the most delicious cake that my husband or I have ever had (and everyone at our reception said it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had by far)!;They don't work with fondant but if you're not set on this (pretty flavorless) option they're wonderful!
Contact
254 36th Street, Suite 106, Brooklyn, NY
One Girl Cookies