About this vendor
Paul Evans Catering has been executing flawless full service events in the Greater New York Area for over 40 years. Our menus are completely customizable to give each bride the opportunity to enjoy exceptional gourmet food while working within a specific budget. Give us a call today to speak with our knowledgeable staff. Your special requests for specific food, beverages, and rental equipment will always be fulfilled with professionalism and creativity. We look forward to working with you and cheers to a successful event!
Details
Guest Capacity
- 300+
Settings
- Backyard
- Ballroom
- Barn
- Farm & Ranch
- Beach
- Waterfront
Venue Service Offerings
- Bar & Drinks
- Cakes & Desserts
- Food & Catering
- Planning
- Rentals & Equipment
- Tents
Wedding Activities
- Getting Engaged
- Engagement Party
- Rehearsals & Parties
- After Party
- Bachelor Party
- Bachelorette Party
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.04 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 6
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
There aren’t enough stars to do justice to this truly exceptional catering company. Hiring Paul Evans Catering was the best wedding decision we made! Here’s why they stand out in four key areas: Food, Presentation, Professionalism, and Eric Rodriguez and his team’s sheer awesomeness.
First, the Food. The cuisine speaks for itself—delicious, creative, and prepared with care from the finest ingredients by a talented chef. Their menu is an elegant mix of comfort foods and elevated cuisine, offering a range of styles—exactly what you want from a wedding caterer. Our appetizers were a hit: jumbo shrimp cocktail, mini lobster rolls, tuna tartare on edible spoons (incredible!), sushi, sesame noodles in takeout boxes, mini Reuben sandwiches, spanakopita, scallops wrapped in bacon, fried chicken and waffles, and risotto balls. Every single one was delectable, and our guests couldn’t stop raving about them.
For entrees, we had a Mediterranean Feast and a Chinese-themed menu. Dishes like grilled salmon with dill yogurt sauce, filet mignon with horseradish crème, basmati rice, and layered Greek salad, along with General Tso’s chicken and beef with broccoli, were cooked to perfection. Even with a large guest count, every dish held up in flavor and texture—something truly impressive.
Presentation was equally flawless. Their creative and customizable displays made everything look as good as it tasted. It added a visual wow factor to the event.
In terms of Professionalism, the team at Paul Evans Catering is top-notch. Every staff member we met was courteous, hardworking, and had wonderful personalities. It was clear they’re hand-picked and treated with respect, which showed in their positive attitude and dedication. The bartender customized our drinks and even let us name them, which our guests loved! The team captain took care of us throughout the day, making sure all our needs were met. He was attentive, caring, and made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our big day.
Finally, the Awesomeness of Eric Rodriguez. Eric was the glue that held everything together. Not only is he an outstanding caterer, but he also became a supportive friend to my husband and me. When we faced last-minute curveballs, Eric was there to guide us with his expertise, putting our minds at ease. He’s kind, genuine, easy to work with, and incredibly knowledgeable. His collaboration with our vision made the wedding more than we ever dreamed possible
From start to finish, Paul Evans executed two seamless events for our corporate law firm. It was a pleasure working with Rachel from the Events Team - she was patient as we had many changes with the menu & budget up until the very last minute! She made amazing recommendations (the Tuna Skewers & Salmon Quesadillas among the faves!). The staff working the events were professional with great attention to detail. We can't wait to work with Paul Evans again!
Paul Evans Catering did an amazing job! Everything from the presentation of the food to the professionalism of the service was excellent. I loved how high quality the food tasted. All of our guests were raving about it. We will definitely be ordering for other occasions and checking out Sendthemcookies.com to send out holiday gifts and college care packages to our cousin!
We had a great experience with Paul Evans Catering. Rachel and everyone there were easy to work with and professional. The customer service was excellent throughout the ordering and delivery process. They were able to accommodate our special requests regarding the food and work within our budget. Most importantly, the guests raved about the food!
Contact
46B Saratoga Blvd, Island Park, NY
Paul Evans Catering's photos