Custom invitations and paperie as unique as you
Erica
OWNER
Typically responds within 24h
AWARD WINNER (6X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Pickle Prints Custom Paper Creations is a wedding stationery business based in Fishers, IN. Taking inspiration from the vision you have of your special day, this company produces one-of-a-kind, fully customized designs specifically made for you. The Owner, Erica, is honored to craft the perfect design that welcomes your guests to your celebration with stylish invitation suites and other coordinating paper products.
This experienced, family-owned business has over twelve years of experience in the industry. Erica aspires to create a partnership with you through her collaborative process. She adds the personal touches necessary to design truly unique products while working hard to alleviate any stress you may feel while planning your occasion with her award-winning customer care.
Examples of her past work include simple and clean designs, vibrant floral invitations, chic modern menu cards, elegant seating charts displayed on mirrors, wood, and acrylic.
Pickle Prints Custom Paper Creations specializes in handmade stationery. Whether you desire elegant, rustic, or classic paper goods, this company takes pride in their original works of art. They craft save-the-date cards, invitation suites, menus, programs, seating charts, signs, table numbers, and thank-you cards that align with your event’s aesthetic. With their services, they can manage the printing, postage stamping, assembly, and mailing of their products.
Woman-owned Business
Details
Invitations & Paper Goods
Calligraphy
Custom Invitations
Paper Goods
Coasters
Escort & Place Cards
Guest Books
Menus
Programs
Seating Charts
Signs
Table Numbers
Thank You Cards
Printing
Embossing
Letterpress
Save-The-Dates
Shower & Party Invitations
Wedding Invitations
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
Erica
Owner
Hi! My name is Erica and I am the Owner of Pickle Prints. I am a self-proclaimed lover of all things having to do with someone's big day! While I've been known to swoon over pictures of gorgeous flowers and magazine-ready venues, my main passion resides in stationery design. I have been conceptualizing, and designing, the perfect invitation suites, individually for each client, for the past 14 years. We are a full-service stationer that manages the entire design, printing, and production processes all in-house so your stationery never leaves our critical eyes. Perfection at its best!
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.0128 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Pickle Prints delivers beautiful, high-quality custom wedding stationery with exceptional creativity, attention to detail, and professional, responsive service. Clients praise timely production, thoughtful packaging, and helpful guidance through design, etiquette, and vendor coordination. Highly recommended.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Brooke K
5.0
4/21/2026
Erica at Pickle Prints was absolutely amazing to work with! She helped me design my invitations, menus and seating chart and they all exceeded my expectations. I'd absolutely recom...
mend her to anyone! We loved working with her!
Laura D
5.0
2/23/2026
I cannot say enough wonderful things about our experience with Erica at Pickle Prints. She was truly amazing to work with and played a huge role in making my daughter’s wedding exp...
erience beyond our wildest dreams. She added the perfect 'little touches' that made my daughter’s wedding dreams a reality. She really listened to her vision, nailed every detail, and—best of all—stayed right on budget. Erica is the best!
Any questions?
Lilly R
5.0
1/09/2026
Pickle Prints Custom Paper Creations is absolutely wonderful! From start to finish, the experience was smooth, creative, and professional. The attention to detail in every piece is...
outstanding, and it’s clear that each item is made with care and high-quality materials.
Christina F
5.0
10/10/2025
Erica was a delight to work with! She was responsive, quick, open to feedback and great to collaborate with. She was able to incorporate all of my edits and asks seamlessly into my...
design. And also, she was just really kind and didn’t apply any pressure - a treat when you’re in the midst of wedding planning.
Lisa K
5.0
8/13/2025
I Love all of the Wedding Paper that Erica created for my daughter’s wedding. It all turned out beautiful. Erica is great to work with and makes an extra effort to make sure she s...
ees the brides vision. She is always ready to communicate quickly. We could not have done this without her
Alyssa K
5.0
8/12/2025
Erica with Pickle Prints makes wedding stationary so special, fun, and personal. She has such a lovely touch and really made the experience more than I had hoped or expected for ou...
r wedding paper. From the invitations to the day of paper, she goes above and beyond to make things exactly what you dream (and more). She cares and she really understood the look/feel we wanted. I can't recommend working with her enough! I really enjoyed our experience with Pickle Prints and LOVED the paper creations.
Madison M
5.0
7/31/2025
Erica is an expert on all things stationary and etiquette. She guided us through every decision with professionalism and ease. She took all of our ideas, added her own creative tou...
ch, and brought it all to life! Having Erica to guide us made the wedding process smooth and fun!
Olivia S
5.0
7/21/2025
Working with Erica for our wedding stationery was an absolute dream! From the very beginning, her communication was exceptional—prompt, clear, and always thoughtful. She truly went...
above and beyond to bring our vision to life, and her attention to detail was incredible every step of the way. It’s clear that Erica genuinely cares about her clients. She was so thorough, patient, and creative, making the entire process not only stress-free but actually enjoyable. From our invitations to the day-of paper items, everything was absolutely perfect and beautifully done. We are beyond happy with how everything turned out and honestly can’t thank her enough. If you're looking for someone who will pour their heart into your wedding paper goods, Erica is the one!
Maria M
5.0
7/19/2025
Everything turned out beautifully and Erica was a dream to work with! We couldn’t have asked for anything more!!
Madelynn B
5.0
7/18/2025
I worked with Erica at Pickled Printing in summer of 2025. She was absolutely incredible!
First, I live in Austin, Texas but am getting married in Indianapolis. She was more than...
happy to work with me over Zoom and email to be sure every detail was perfect even when I couldn't be there in person.
Once we got the shipment of invitations they were truly breathtaking! They came in extremely thoughtful packaging, included steps on how to make sure you have the right number of stamps, and packaged extra invites for the photographer on the big day.
I had multiple different people tell me that my invitation suite was the prettiest invitation set they have ever seen. I certainly would not have been able to do that without working with Erica! She is attentive, detail oriented, and helped me navigate through the process of designing an invitation. HIGHLY recommend her work if you are looking for beautiful custom invitations. She is THE BEST!
Lucy L
5.0
7/18/2025
Erica O'Hara does an exceptional job with personalizing your wedding custom paper creations. She has a positive spirit and willingness to address feedback. Our custom gifts, progra...
ms displayed on fans for a beach wedding, water color designs for the reception table assignments and signature drinks signs turned out better than we imagined. She's timely with her production schedule. I would 100% recommend Erica and encourage you to work with her for special occasions that mean a lot to you like a wedding.
Jeanine L
5.0
7/01/2025
I have 4 daughters and used Pickle Prints for all of our weddings. From the first visit with owner, Erica O’Hara, I knew I was in the right place and in perfect hands to make our v...
ision come to fruition. Erica’s creativity, kindness, attention to detail, listening skills and responsiveness exceeded our expectations. Wedding stationery is not “just an invitation” it sets the tone for your whole day! Beyond the invitation is the escort cards, menus, seating charts, welcome signs, rehearsal dinner invitations, thank you notes and more. Each element creates your story for “your special day.”
I would 1000% recommend Pickle Prints for all of your wedding paper elements. We now have a friend for life!
Emily C
5.0
5/21/2025
From the moment we connected with Erica Ohara/Pickle Prints, we knew we were in amazing hands. Erica didn't just design an invitation—she crafted a piece of art that perfectly capt...
ured the spirit of our wedding day. Every detail was thoughtfully executed, from the elegant typography to the luxurious paper quality. Our guests couldn't stop raving about how beautiful and unique our invitations were! Multiple times we heard “I thought we were attending a royal wedding when opening your invitation”.
Communication was seamless, timelines were respected, and revisions (though hardly needed! Seriously after thinking back I think we only revised wording) were handled with professionalism and care. Pickle Prints brought our vision to life better than we ever imagined. If you're looking for a vendor who combines creativity, precision, and genuine passion for their work, look no further!!!!! This was hands-down one of the best decisions we made for our wedding!
Thank you for making our first impression unforgettable.
maureen C
5.0
5/14/2025
The Werner's can't thank Erica O'Hara/Pickle Prints enough for her professionalism and attention to detail. Erica listens to you and brings your vision to life. We can't say enough...
about her service, the invitations were all put together and ready to mail. The quality is superb!!!!!!!!
Kelly B
5.0
10/06/2024
Erica was wonderful to work with. She had so many designs/colors/options to work with for any ideas we had and was so willing to do anything customary. She was fast with responses ...
and her stationery came out beautifully. Erica is creative, fast to respond, and flexible. She was accommodating with unforeseeable last-minute changes to the seating chart. Pickle Prints had a quick turnaround and provided us with unique, lovely stationery. We are so happy with how everything turned out. Highly recommend!
Sabrina K
5.0
9/03/2024
Pickle Prints was everything we hoped for as we began planning for my daughter's wedding. Erica and her team are talented designers who bring professionalism and knowledge to their...
clients. Erica is an excellent listener who brought my daughter's vision to life with stunning designs and attention to detail. I couldn't be happier with her work, as well as the process of working with her.
Alison S
5.0
11/14/2023
Erica was great! We got so many compliments on all of our wedding stationery, and everything looked amazing!
Adrianna B
5.0
11/13/2023
Erica is truly a master at her craft. Being able to meet in person to touch the different types of paper, see the color swatches, and compile different options was such a game-ch...
anger. Erica listened to my mother's vision and mine to come up with a beautiful invitation that was a hybrid of traditional and modern. We also purchased our bar signage through Erica. It didn't come out perfect right away. Erica recognized that immediately and held her vendors accountable to make it right in time for our wedding. In the end, everything was perfect because of her attention to detail and eye for design. I can't recommend Erica enough!!
Alyssa H
5.0
11/11/2023
Erica did an amazing job on every single piece of our wedding stationary! She did our save-the-dates, our full invitation suite, and every piece of our wedding day stationary. Ever...
ything was incredible and made our wedding feel so cohesive! We got so many compliments on how great everything was. People cannot stop talking about how fun it was to open our invitstions. And these custom wax seals? Perfect!
Madeline B
5.0
11/06/2023
Erica was SUCH a pleasure to work with! She was professional, attentive to detail and nailed our vision. Simply put, she made the process enjoyable. I would highly recommend any...
couple work with her for wedding stationary and paper needs!
Lydia K
5.0
11/03/2023
Erica was timely, creative, and very easy to work with to develop perfect printed products for our day. We received so many complements on the bold colors and styling of everything...
Erica worked on!
Matt R
5.0
11/03/2023
Couldn't rate Erica more highly. She brought our vision to life perfectly ahead of our special day, even suggesting some proactive solutions when original parts of our vision were ...
not going to work out as hoped. 10/10. Thanks Erica!
Paola T
5.0
11/02/2023
Erica and her team were incredible and made my experience with choosing stationary items super easy. From our very first meeting Erica made me feel very comfortable with my options...
and not once did I feel overwhelmed or uncertain about my options. During the process of completing my order, pickle prints kept very close communications with me and made sure I was in the loop with the entire process. I also had a vision for a grand seating chart for my guest and PP executed my vision so perfectly! Without a doubt I recommend Erica and pickle prints!
Evan G
5.0
11/01/2023
Erica was INCREDIBLE. Our save the dates and invitations turned out exactly how we wanted them. We still get compliments on how nice our invitations were. We 100% would recommend u...
sing her services.
Megan K
5.0
10/22/2023
Erica helped create the most perfect invitations, seating chart and thank you cards for our most perfect day! She was so amazing and kind to work with. Everything was completed in ...
a timely manner perfect for our schedule. We thank her so much! Highly recommend!
Morgan T
5.0
8/11/2023
Erica did an amazing job with our invitations and signage. She spent multiple meetings with us to discuss our vision and she executed perfectly. We loved our experience with Erica ...
and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Kathy R
5.0
11/15/2022
We cannot say enough about Erica and Pickle Prints. If I could give more stars I would! Her professionalism, creativity and attention to detail is unmatched. She made this proce...
ss fun from start to finish and our guests raved about the Escort mirror!! Erica has gained a lifelong client and can't wait to work with her again in the future.
Macy C
5.0
10/24/2022
Erica was an absolute joy to work with! She was an excellent communicator throughout the process, flexible, organized, and made sure everything was perfect. I could not have been h...
appier with the quality of the material that I received from Erica. I was told numerous times by our guests that our invitation was the nicest/fanciest invitation they have EVER received. I could not recommend Erica (Pickle Prints) enough!
Maddie C
5.0
10/20/2022
Erica was an instrumental part of our wedding day vision by designing custom, beautiful paper products including: gorgeous deckle edged wedding invites with monogrammed wax seals, ...
handmade paper menus that were personalized with our guest names, cloth hung welcome sign with picture of our venue printed on it, ceremony pamphlets, cocktail napkins and more.
Erica practiced strong communication and was prompt in her email responses, flexible with the various iterations of our ideas as they continued to develop & be fine tuned, available to meet with us whenever it was requested of her, consultative in timeline and design recommendations, prepared, organized, patient, friendly...I could go on and on but will leave you all with the final words of, do yourself the service of partnering with Erica to bring a unique, personalized style to your wedding day that your guests will remember! She's the best!
al w
5.0
10/18/2022
Erica was fantastic to work with. Truly appreciate her willingness to make several tweaks we wanted. She has a great attitude and was quick with responses and changes. All of ou...
r print material for our wedding looked great. Would recommend her for anything needed in the print world of your event!
Kristen G
5.0
10/14/2022
Erica EXCEEDED our expectations and brought all our ideas to life. We had so many compliments from our guests about her work. She is very detail oriented and double, triple checks ...
everything. Strongly suggest you hire her! She made us our gorgeous invitations, service cards, table numbers, menus, specialty cocktail menus (including our pets on glass - they were EXACTLY our pets and not replicas of them), welcome sign, and seating chart. Everyone was blown away! I can't imagine hiring anyone else!!
Lindsay P
5.0
10/14/2022
Pickle prints did an amazing job! They were so easy to work with and I’m so glad we chose them for our wedding stationary. They helped make our dreams come true!!
Abigail B
5.0
10/13/2022
There are no words to fully describe Pickle Prints and their work. From the first meeting with Erica, she was so helpful and tuned into our wedding needs. I had a vision and thing...
s that I had to have and Erica took that and ran with it. The communication during the entire process was great and kept the printing portion of wedding planning, stressless. They helped with the layout of how we should have our info cards and talked through certain invite etiquette. Erica and Lindsay thought of things I never would have thought to include in the invite suite.
When we went to pick up our invites, they were better than anything I could have imagine. They were beautiful! I was speechless. The monogram they came up with and the gold printing was flawless.
When it came to wedding day printing it was the same story. It was perfect. I showed Erica picture of party favors that I wanted for my reception and, again, they nailed it. They were beautiful. We had a mirror seating chart and it looked perfect!
I would HIGHLY recommend Erica, Lindsay and her growing team at Pickle Prints were a dream to work with! All of my printing needs were fulfilled above and beyond! I hope to have something else to work with PP on again!
Samantha M
5.0
10/12/2022
I used Erica with Pickle Prints for my day of stationary - and I am so glad I did! Everything from the initial meeting was seamless and easy and she nailed down the aesthetic I was...
going for. There was a tiny hiccup and she was immediate in correcting the problem, taking accountability and providing us with what we had initially asked for, free of charge without any questions asked. Couldn’t recommend her more - thank you Erica for making this part of the wedding planning process so enjoyable and easy!
Abby M
5.0
10/12/2022
Erica and Lindsay with Pickle Prints were amazing to work with! Very responsive and involved from the start of our wedding planning. Any time I required adjustments or had a questi...
on they would always have an answer. They brought our wedding inspiration to life, which was so fun to see! They were one of my easiest vendors to work with and I highly recommend using them if you have a wedding coming up!
Megan H
5.0
10/11/2022
Literally the best vendor to work with for wedding day paper. Her prices and work are amazing. Super friendly, organized and punctual! We are so happy with how everything turned ou...
t for our big day.
Danielle S
5.0
10/11/2022
Erica was extremely friendly and easy to work with! I had so much fun working with her to create our invitations suite, as well as day of stationery. She created the seating chart ...
of our dreams by putting the names and table numbers in vinyl on mirrors, and guests are still complimenting us on them to this day. Erica also designed napkins with our dog's face on it, menus, programs, and especially the monogram crest for continuity across our stationery. Highly recommend using Erica and Pickle Prints for your invitations and day of stationery needs!
Jennifer H
5.0
10/11/2022
I have never worked with someone so detailed, thorough and accommodating! Erica exceeds expectations. Her talent amazes me and we could not have been happier with the quality of he...
r work. She's also able to do so many things beyond invitations! Signage on acrylic, individual names in acrylic, menus and more. I highly recommend her as she is the best of the best!
Jadyn D
5.0
8/23/2022
Pickle prints was so amazing to work with! Wedding invitations are the first things that guests see from your wedding, and they helped us make a great first impression! Pickle pr...
ints helped us with all of our paper and design needs from welcome bags and programs, to seating cards, menus, and thank you notes. All of their work was consistent, clean, and beautifully put together! We would definitely recommend Pickle Prints! A big thank you to Erica and her team!
Alice K
5.0
11/08/2021
Highly recommend! Ericka was amazing to work with. She created wonderful save the dates, wedding invitation and a mirror seating chart for our wedding. Everything was perfect and t...
imely.
Erynne B
5.0
10/28/2021
Erica was so helpful throughout the invitation process, she designed a formal invitation including information map, and even personalize the addresses for me making the process so ...
easy! I cannot thank you enough for all of her hard work and giving us the best invitations we could’ve asked for. She was so patient and responded to every email and took every request I had and made it into something magical! I would totally recommend her to every single person I know getting married!
Ali M
5.0
10/24/2021
I never knew I cared about paper as much as I do, but one meeting with Erica and her passion for her work just spills over! She perfectly captured our vision for unique, elegant, a...
nd timeless wedding invitation suites, day of paper, and signage! Erica was more than willing to make any changes and send over multiple proofs so we could get everything just right. I loved her attention to detail and her honest opinions. I couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out and we received so many compliments from our guests! I cannot recommend Erica highly enough!!!
Molly L
5.0
10/15/2021
Erica is amazing and there are not enough words to describe just how amazing she is! She is such a great listener and really takes your ideas/vision to life but adds a whole other ...
level of creativity to it. At every meeting I had no idea what I wanted but tried to describe the vibe I was looking for and she hit the nail on the head every.dang.time. I would choose her over and over again!!
Morgan W
5.0
10/14/2021
All I can say is WOW! Erica, was an absolute dream vendor to work with! From our first zoom meeting she nailed the look I was going for (modern chic) and absolutely blew me away wi...
th beautiful save the dates & invitations! She is ALL about the detail and I couldn't be happier with how everything turned out. It has only been a week since I have sent my invitations and I have already received SO many texts and calls about how elegant, classy and beautiful! I will be using her for all of my important events in the future!
Maria W
5.0
10/07/2021
Erica was amazing! She is so creative and her designs were so thoughtfully planned. From our invitations to our wedding welcome sign to our menus, Erica prepared the best wedding p...
aper I could have dreamed of! On top of great design, Erica is very kind and a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!
Katie E
5.0
9/19/2021
As soon as I met with Erica, I knew we had to work with her. She is so creative, kind, and has the ability to come up with an even BETTER version of what you had in mind! She creat...
ed everything — our save the dates, invitation suite with a beautiful hand tied chiffon ribbon and wax seal, programs, seating cards, signage, and gorgeous vellum menus with matching hand tied ribbon. We loved everything so much that we also had her make us some custom blank cards with our monogram, that way we can have them for thank you notes and more. Erica’s passion for what she does really shines through, and we’ve received SO many compliments on her work! She will say that she’s a small part of your wedding day, but in reality I couldn’t imagine our wedding without her gorgeous creations. I’ve recommended her already and will continue to do so!
Sarah C
5.0
7/13/2021
Our guests are still raving about the details that Erica with Pickle Prints created for our daughter’s wedding! It all started with our elegant invitations that set the tone for t...
he event. Then...she created the MOST beautiful acrylic seating chart that was a huge wow factor as guests arrived! The signage, custom napkins, table numbers, and place cards were all beyond our expectations! Everything Erica does is done with an incredible eye for detail and creativity. An added bonus is that she’s so fun to work with!
Emily C
5.0
7/11/2021
Erica at Pickle Prints was absolutely amazing to work with. The amount of work that she put into every single detail was incredible. She did everything from our invitations, place ...
cards, table numbers, personalized napkins, welcome signs, and the list goes on. I showed her a picture of a large acrylic seating chart I was in love with and she was able to recreate it exactly how I envisioned. Our guests were in awe of her work not only at the wedding, but beforehand as well with the beautiful invitations she created. I’m not a very creative person, but she was able to articulate every detail with me in a way that made me understand. She really made such a difference with our entire wedding experience!
Janette N
4.0
7/01/2021
Let Pickleprints create your wedding invitation dream! Knowing only that we wanted our invitations in our wedding colors, Erica invited us into her world of colors, fonts, shades, ...
papers, and creation on our terms easily. While we didn’t opt for the full supply of menus and signage, Erica helped us choose a gorgeous collection of items to introduce our nuptials. She’s professional, extremely knowledgeable, and helpful, and ensures your order is spot-on perfect. I recommend her highly for that personal touch!
Dru S
5.0
5/06/2021
Erica was absolutely wonderful to work with. She helped guide us through the invitation design process and also made some really great recommendations. On top of that, I gave her a...
general idea of what I envisioned and what she created was better than what I could have even imagined. She is a pro and I’m so grateful to her for the perfect invitation suite.
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Pickle Prints Custom Paper Creations
Erica
|
Owner
Typically responds within 24h
Wedding vendors in Fishers
- Wedding Vendors/
- Invitations + Paper Goods/
- Indiana Invitations + Paper Goods/
- Fishers Invitations + Paper Goods/
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.