Reviews
Have you booked this vendor?
Be the first couple to share your thoughts!
11/02/25
My girlfriend and I are regulars and always have a great time here. The pizza, salads, and salmon are outstanding, every time! Cocktails and wine are top notch. And the servers seem to really enjoy their work- always with a smile 🥰
9/29/25
Came here on the weekend to celebrate my sister’s white coat ceremony at Marquette. The team at Pizza Man made it really special. They were able to accommodate a large group of 17 people with very late notice and made sure we were well taken ca...
re of with delicious food (the spicy rigatoni a la vodka was a hit) and attentive service. We were also pleasantly surprised to be treated with a free dessert and a card and gift card from the staff! Truly exceptional customer service and the very definition of going above and beyond to take care of your guests. We will certainly be back!
7/19/25
My girlfriend and I came in for dinner and a drink. The truffle fries were good, would definitely get again. The pizza was also good, some of the best in Milwaukee. The only thing that was better than the food was the service! Megan took care o...
f us and it was the best service I have gotten in Milwaukee. I will definitely be back and will ask for Megan to be our server again!
9/21/25
A lovely and delicious meal at Pizza Man. This was our first time dining in since they closed this location and moved back. The ambiance is very relaxing, with mood lighting and live jazz. The service was exceptional. My apple salad was perfect...
as was my wine selection. I'm very happy Pizza Man is back in the neighborhood and will be back soon!
8/23/25
It's been a minute since we've eaten at the reknown Pizza Man. The 2025 experience was mixed with a renovated interior really keeping this business relevant. The food was simply not worth the price, or maybe I'm just just not a fan of the ingre...
dients on the atomico pizza. The crust was crispy and the pizza did feel light which I appreciate but the sopressata, Calabrian pepper combo just didn't quite balance itself out and tasted a bit off. The carbonara pasta was also out of balance, tasting a bit too salty but maybe I'm not a huge pancetta fan after all. I suspect we would have enjoyed other items on the menu like the Topher or the ravioli. But who knows! The grilled calamari was good, but quite portions were small. I would recommend visiting for the upstairs patio deck alone, which overlooks Downer Ave. You could tell that everyone sitting there was really lingering and enjoying every moment of a beautiful summer evening.
See all Google reviews
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Wedding vendors in Milwaukee
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.