1/25
2/25

Prairie Hill Cookie Company

5.0
(49)best-of-weddings

DFW - can ship nation-wide

About This Vendor

Best Gourmet Cookies

At Prairie Hill Cookie Company, we take the finest quality ingredients and carefully combine them to make delicious gourmet cookies that are packed with home-baked flavor. Let us add the personal touch to help make your wedding day memorably sweet. Message today for availability!

Details

Cakes & Desserts
Cupcakes, Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Gluten Free, Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
Hall of Fame2021 Best of Weddings Winner2020 Best of Weddings Winner2019 Best of Weddings Winner2018 Best of Weddings Winner

Prairie Hill Cookie Company Reviews

Reviewed On 10/26/2018 by Samantha T
Margaret the owner was prompt and got back to my emails right away! She was so sweet to work with and her cookies were the HIT of our wedding! We had prairie hill cookies as our wedding favor and everyone kept raving about how great they were! ...
We were super happy with how the presentation looked and how yummy they were!
Response from the Vendor on 10/26/2018
Thank you so much, Samantha! We were honored to help be a part of making your wedding all that you wanted it to be. Knowing you love cookies, the guest gift big Prairie Hill Cookie was a nice touch.
Reviewed On 10/29/2020 by Bethany T
These cookies were truly delicious!! They were not over sweet & simply perfect!! Prairie Hill Cookie Company is amazing! Margaret and her team are the best!! I highly recommend these at your wedding, you won't be disappointed!!
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2020
Thank you, Bethany! I remember how much you loved the cookies when you tasted them. You’re right!! They work so well for a wedding! As a guest gift or part of a dessert table....you won’t be disappointed!
Reviewed On 10/28/2020 by C A
Not JUST a cookie, but a cookie experience! Delicious, moist and baked to perfection. The owner Margaret is a one of a kind and so is Prairie Hill Cookie Company...I am not proud to say I fought off my kids for the last crumb! You will not disa...
ppointed.
Response from the Vendor on 10/28/2020
Oh thank you!! These cookies are memorable! I’m so glad you all loved them and that you got the last bite!!
Reviewed On 10/28/2020 by Dara L
These cookies are beyond delicious! These aren’t the cookies grandma used to make, they’re better!!! (Don’t tell grandma!) The quality and taste is incredible- you won’t find any better. I love the creative flavors Prairie Hill offers - truly a...
flavor for everyone (my favorite is the salted Carmel) If you have these cookies at your wedding, your guests will still be talking about them at your ten year anniversary.
Response from the Vendor on 10/28/2020
Oh thank you, Dara!! It’s so true! People have brought up weddings by what was served at the reception. I’ve seen a couple of comments about the cookies and I smile. Thank you for loving Prairie Hill Cookies!!
Reviewed On 2/19/2020 by Kali H
These cookies are the coolest! She makes BIG cookies and smaller versions that everyone was calling "muffin cookies" at the wedding. Margaret is super easy to work with and even sent us a box of full size samples prior to booking with two of th...
e most ordered flavors. She answered all my questions and talked me through my options to fit my budget. Cookies were delivered on time and in a professional manner, she even gave us an extra box of BIG cookies as a gift. Great company, would definitely order these cookies for any other event as well!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Kali!! It was so fun working with you. I loved the venue you chose for the wedding. It was beautiful! So glad you picked Prairie Hill Cookies for your wedding!!
Reviewed On 2/05/2020 by Caitlin C
These cookies are AMAZING!! Every single flavor is to die for! I especially love that they have gluten free options.... I highly recommend! As a guest, they were so delicious, I just had to come and review!
Response from the Vendor on 02/05/2020
Thank you, Caitlin!! I’m so glad you enjoyed our salted caramel cookie!! It’s definitely a top selling for the very reasons you described!! Thanks again so much!!
Reviewed On 11/16/2019 by Melinda H
Some of the best cookies I have ever tasted!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Melinda!!
Reviewed On 10/31/2019 by Melodee R
These cookies, and I've had every flavor, are AMAZING! It's hard to choose a favorite, but I'd have to say the sugar cookie does it for me. Decadent! Whether you just need a dessert at home, something for a special occasion, or a gift to send,...
Prairie Hill Cookies are the answer!! Salted Caramel and White Chocolate Macadamia are another 2 of my absolute favorites. If you need Gluten Free, you won't even know you're eating GF...that's how amazing they are. The new Snickerdoodles are going to be right up there with the other MUST HAVES!!!!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Melodee, you have tried all of them!! So thankful you are spreading the word about Prairie Hill Cookie Company!!
Reviewed On 10/31/2019 by Paul C
I have ordered the cookie “pie” and the boxes of the medium cookies and they were very moist and tasty. My whole family devoured the cookie pie picking at it bit by bit till it was nearly gone on that first evening, and the individual cookies ...
were great to share with my wife as we watched movies and indulged ourselves with a warm cookie and ice cream. These are amazing cookies.
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
I know that your whole family is crazy about the chocolate chip cookie. You have 4 weddings down the road so don’t forget how great these cookies are for weddings!
Reviewed On 10/31/2019 by Dolly C
These cookies are fabulous. They have the perfect balance of soft and crispy and a flavor unlike another. The owner has always been right on time for delivery and they are always fresh on arrival. What began as one flavor has evolved to many-al...
though the original is still my favorite!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Dolly!! Your whole family really likes the chocolate chip cookie!! I heard that they disappear rather quickly!
Reviewed On 10/30/2019 by Sarah B
These cookies are delicious. They have been a hit with my whole family. The gluten-free chocolate chip cookies are probably the best gluten-free cookie I've ever had. My kids love the sugar cookies and my husband loves the peanut butter cup coo...
kies. I've yet to taste a Prairie Hill Cookie that I didn't like.
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Sarah! I appreciate your kids loving these cookies every visit here in Texas! I agree with you about the gluten free chocolate chip cookie ...it’s not like any thing out there!! Thank you!!!
Reviewed On 10/30/2019 by Sarah W
Prairie Hill Cookies are hands down the best tasting cookies. We like to have extras on hand at home in our freezer at all times. They freeze wonderfully! That is, if you don't instantly eat them all upon arrival to your house ;) Our favori...
te way to eat them is warmed up with a generous scoop of Vanilla Bean Ice Cream on top. THE. BEST. EVER.
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Sarah!! You are correct! They do freeze incredibly well....and they are amazing heated up with a scoop of ice cream on top!!
Reviewed On 10/30/2019 by William S
These cookies are the best tasting cookies hands down and they can be shipped most anywhere and they are just as fresh as if you bought them in the store.
Reviewed On 10/29/2019 by Elizabeth T
These cookies are some of the best I’ve ever had! The owner is a joy to do business with- she makes your transaction easy! I highly recommend to anyone!
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2019
Thank you, Liz!!
Reviewed On 10/28/2019 by Kathy C
I met Margaret when she brought a basket of cookies into our store. She was helping to promote her business. From that day until now I have sent cookies to my son and all of his friends in college, have used as gifts, and have served at parties...
. They are out of this world yummy! My favorite is the salted caramel chocolate chip. To receive as a gift, couldn’t think of anything better. Just love Margaret!
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2019
Thank you so much, Kathy!! I love being a part of parties you throw and gift boxes you send! Thank you for loving and sharing our cookies!
Reviewed On 10/28/2019 by Mark B
Amazing company with the best product. The cookies are always fresh and delivered on time.
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2019
Thank you, Mark!! Glad you love our cookies!!
Reviewed On 10/28/2019 by Gayla B
Prairie Hill Cookie Company has the best cookies and with so many delicious cookies it is always hard to decide which is your favorite....I’ve ordered from this company several times and will continue to do so.. Customer service is profession...
al and always delivers on time..
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2019
Thank you so much, Gayla! I know your kids love them too!
Reviewed On 10/25/2019 by Teresa H
These cookies are the BEST!! I’ve been privileged to taste practical all the different varieties. Everyone is a keeper. There soft and chewy and delicious and wonderful. Don’t miss out!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2020
Thank you, Teresa!! I’m pretty sure you like the sugar the most?!
Reviewed On 5/20/2019 by Suzanne J
Loved these cookies! Bought as gifts for others. I ordered my chocolate chip salted caramel cookies and the owners were quick with a response on when the cookies could be delivered to a desired location. The cookies are moist, delicious and...
reasonably priced for their size.
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2019
Thank you, Suzanne! So glad you love our cookies! The salted caramel is my favorite too!
Reviewed On 1/01/2019 by Katrina J
I love this company so much! I have used them to send cookies to my now husband on deployment and he loved them! We love them so much we incorporated them into our wedding! Our intention was to give them as gifts but the guests couldn’t wait to...
try them! It’s a gourmet spin on the classic treat everyone loves. The packaging is beautiful and convienient to give out to people. They taste delicious! So thankful for Margaret. She’s awesome!
Reviewed On 10/31/2018 by Sasha B
I knBeing an event planner it was hard for me to stay out of the planning for baby shower. I successfully was able to stay out of the weeds with the exception of my one requirement...Prairie Hill Cookies MUST be present! Only the best for my sw...
eet friends who were loving on my little miracle baby. I have been a fan of these cookies for years and an even bigger fan of Margaret and her heart to make life a little sweeter for people. She makes a point to get to know people and remembering I was diagnosed gluten free recently (ugh) she made a small batch of cookies just for me and a delicious variety for my guests. It was so thoughtful! Oh and a little insider tip...buy more than you “need” and freeze the rest! I can’t wait for my next excuse to have these cookies.
Response from the Vendor on 10/31/2018
Thank you, Sasha!! Your baby shower was amazing. It was so fun to watch your guests eyes light up when they tasted the cookies.
Reviewed On 10/27/2018 by Shirley M
Amazing cookies ! Prairie Hill Cookie Company offers the freshest, BEST TASTING cookies ever. They are unique in the size but the cookie itself cannot be beat. Anyone who hasn't tried them is missing out on pure "wonderful". And having them at...
weddings is a new and fresh idea. I just do not think anyone can compete with any of these cookies. Cookies can be used in so many occasions too !
Response from the Vendor on 10/29/2018
Thank you, Shirley!!!
Reviewed On 10/27/2018 by Marie W
Prairie hill cookies are the best! I've been able to have them multiple times including at my best friends wedding where they were a huge hit! These cookies are great for any occasion or just to fill a sweet tooth desire 😀
Response from the Vendor on 10/27/2018
Thank you, Marie!! I know you’ve tasted several but peanut butter is your favorite!
Reviewed On 10/26/2018 by Synthia D
My daughter had these at her wedding and passed out to people as they left the venue. The chocolate chip is the best !!
Response from the Vendor on 10/26/2018
Thank you, Synthia. So glad you all were pleased with our cookies!!
Reviewed On 10/26/2018 by Barbi S
My sister had these at her Wedding!! They are VERY good!
Response from the Vendor on 10/26/2018
Thank you, Barbi!!
Reviewed On 10/25/2018 by Stewart K
These cookies are decadent, moist, and packed with sensational sweetness. Baked with the finest ingredients, they are a family favorite. Seriously, one bite entices you to eat the entire cookie! They also make great gifts.
Response from the Vendor on 10/25/2018
Thank you, Stewart! Your family loves them, I know!! We’ve done a bridal shower and a baby shower for your daughter. You and your family are frequent Prairie Hill Cookie eaters!! We love that!!
Reviewed On 10/25/2018 by Paula B
This company’s customer service is unparalleled. The owner is completely committed to pleasing her customers and making their experience “world class.” And you won’t find a treat anywhere that compares to these “deep dish” cookies. They are ama...
zingly delicious!!
Response from the Vendor on 10/25/2018
Thank you, Paula!! We definitely take care of our customers!! So glad you’ve experienced and enjoyed Prairie Hill Cookies!!
Reviewed On 10/18/2018 by Rebecca C
Wow! If you are looking for a safe, gluten free cookie that tastes amazing, you have found it with Prairie Hill Cookie Company. The large cookies arrived fresh and the taste is home baked goodness. I highly recommend the baking product and t...
he company. You will find fantastic customer service and communication at Prairie Hill Cookie Company. This is the perfect allergy friendly cookie for your party, event, or simply a fresh treat at the end of the day.
Response from the Vendor on 10/18/2018
Thank you, Rebecca!! Your experience with gluten free foods makes your review so meaningful to me!! We are so excited we can help brides with gluten free and dairy free cookies for their wedding!!
Reviewed On 10/18/2018 by Patty M
These cookies are awesome! They make a great treat for any occasion. I sent them to my son across the country for his birthday and he shared them with his friends at his birthday gathering. They loved them! I also sent them on Valentine's D...
ay to several friends in my neighborhood. They were so surprised and loved these cookies. I would LOVE to go to a wedding reception and find these cookies in place of or addition to a wedding cake! Yum!!!
Response from the Vendor on 10/18/2018
Thank you, Patty!! The weddings where we’ve delivered cookies had many positive comments and very happy people!!! So glad we could help you celebrate people so dear to you!!
Reviewed On 9/15/2018 by Maureen E
You can't get much better than these cookies for taste and appearance. I tried samples of the gluten free chocolate chip cookies and you honestly could not tell that they were gluten free! The texture is incredible - it breaks apart perfectly...
, which means the timing and flour mix are the best. The chocolate is definitely high-quality, as are the other ingredients. All in all, these make for a great experience in a cookie. Of course, the taste is unbeatable. Keep it up, Prarie Hill! We'll be back for more!
Response from the Vendor on 10/10/2018
Thank you, Maureen!! We are so excited that we have incredible options for gluten free and dairy free diet needs!
Reviewed On 9/08/2018 by Angela N
Wow! I took one look and smiled, I took one bite and went to heaven. The peanut butter cup and salted caramel were so yummy. I found the perfect 🍪 cookie with Prairie Hill Cookies. Every bite was filled with great tasty goodness.
Response from the Vendor on 09/08/2018
Angela, I’m so happy you love our cookies. Thank you for tasting! Remember Prairie Hill Cookie Company for any cookie need...huge party or wedding or just for yourself..now that you’ve experienced Prairie Hill Cookie Heaven!!!
Reviewed On 9/06/2018 by Alexis A
In complete and total love with these cookies. Must have these at any and all events. I tried the peanut butter cup chocolate chip cookie and it is to die for. Cannot wait to get my hands on the other flavors. Definitely homemade with love. La...
rge portions for sharing, looks like you can find them on Instagram to view a few pictures and they have a link to their website. Thanks so much prairie cookie makers. You are amazing!
Response from the Vendor on 09/08/2018
Alexis, thank you for tasting Prairie Hill Cookies. We’re so glad you loved our cookies! Our Peanut Butter Cup cookie is a very popular cookie. Let us know when you are needing cookies for your next party!!
Reviewed On 9/06/2018 by Erica A
Definitely Need to try these cookies. I was able to enjoy the chocolate chip cookie with a peanut butter cup in the middle of it. Hands down amazing. If you are a cookie lover, this is definitely a must have. The portions are large enough to fe...
ed 2, If you're willing to share. Thanks prairie cookies. You have definitely put a smile on my face.
Response from the Vendor on 09/08/2018
Erica, thank you so much for tasting Prairie Hill Cookies. Thanks, too, for telling people about the great taste of our cookies. Let us know when you’ve decided on your cookie needs for your celebration!!
Reviewed On 9/02/2018 by Erin L
You won’t go wrong with these! We ordered them to put in gift bags that awaited our wedding guests at their hotels. They were the hit of the bag! I love the salted caramel and my husband is a big fan of the chocolate chip. They’re delicious and...
loved by everyone.
Response from the Vendor on 09/08/2018
Erin, I was so happy when you chose Prairie Hill Cookie Company to make delicious cookies for your wedding guests who were staying at the hotel. What a great treat for your guests! Thank you so much for letting us help make your wedding sweete...
r!!
Reviewed On 9/01/2018 by Jarren R
Prairie Hill Cookie Company makes the best cookies! Not only do I enjoy these year round but they hold a special place in my heart. These cookies make up the Groom's cake at my wedding and I couldn't think of a more delicious way to celebrate! ...
All it takes is one bite to convince you that these cookies top all other cookies. My favorite is Salted Carmel Chocolate Chip. You won't regret allowing Prairie Hill Cookie Company to cater your next event or fill your home with joy!
Response from the Vendor on 09/01/2018
Jarren, I still remember the look on your face the first time you tasted a Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip cookie! It was also so fun to hear how you shared the cookies with everyone you knew! So when Annie told me she wanted them in place of a ...
groom cake I totally agreed that it was perfect for you! Your wedding was beautiful! We were so happy to help you celebrate! Congratulations Annie and Jarren!!
Reviewed On 7/19/2018 by Katie G
Words cannot describe how amazing these cookies are, you just have to taste one! Every single cookie was snatched up at our wedding, there was not one left! People are still talking about how amazing they were. Thank you so much, Margaret, for ...
helping make our special day all the more special with your delicious cookie creations!
Response from the Vendor on 07/19/2018
Katie, We were honored to be a part of your wedding celebration. Your wedding was absolutely beautiful! So glad that the cookies were a huge success. Thank you so much for choosing Prairie Hill Cookies!!❤️❤️
Reviewed On 11/01/2017 by Ricky T
Simply put - these cookies are incredible! They arrived fresh and delicious. I immediately opened the box and tried a salted caramel chocolate chip cookie. It was heavenly! I highly recommend these cookies for your home, workplace or any ot...
her time when you need high quality, fresh-baked, incredible cookies!
Response from the Vendor on 10/10/2018
Thank you, Ricky!
Reviewed On 10/23/2017 by Matt A
These cookies are AMAZING!!! Would highly recommend them to anyone. The Reeses peanut butter cup and salted caramel are the best cookies I've ever had
Reviewed On 10/17/2017 by Kris B
These cookies are amazing! I especially love the white chocolate macadamia oatmeal.
Reviewed On 10/17/2017 by Annie T
These are by far the best cookies I've ever had. My fiance absolutely loves them, so as a surprise, I'm using Prairie Hill cookies in our wedding for the groom's cake. Everyone who's had them can't stop eating them!
Reviewed On 10/17/2017 by Cathy F
Love these cookies!!!
Reviewed On 10/17/2017 by Doris E
These are the best. cookies. ever! My cookies arrived fresh, in perfect condition, and absolutely delicious! I have ordered numerous times, and get the same fantastic cookies and service every time. Everyone I have shared them with has rave...
d about them!
Reviewed On 10/16/2017 by Kate P
Oh my goodness these cookies are so amazing! I have never had anything like them. The salted caramel is my absolute favorite! There is SO much care and love that goes into every aspect of these cookies. From ingredients to the package and deliv...
ery. You will love sharing them at your next event, wedding or party! Or just order some for yourself....you won't regret it ❤
Reviewed On 10/16/2017 by Melodee R
These cookies are amazing! I've had the Chocolate Chip, Sea Salt Caramel & the Peanut Butter Chocolate. I'm very picky about my cookies & these are the best! Very moist & very rich. Love them!
Reviewed On 10/16/2017 by Katie C
My sister bought me a variety box for Valentine's day and man, as a cookie lover, I REALLY loved these. You can tell they are freshly baked with the best ingredients. They're soft already, but if you heat them up they're even better. Have them ...
with a glass of milk or put a scoop of ice cream on top for an especially good time. I'm torn between classic chocolate chip and peanut butter chocolate chip for my favorite, but all of them were darn tasty! I can't wait to buy more.
Reviewed On 9/28/2017 by Leah W
If you are a cookie person you won't be able to resist these! Sea Salt Carmel is my absolute favorite. Soft, moist, and absolutely delicious I have never had a cookie I didn't love.
Reviewed On 9/28/2017 by Rick D
Really rich. Chewy. I can't keep them in my office. Love them.
Reviewed On 9/27/2017 by Jill O
The best cookies you will ever eat! They were the center of attention at my event! Prairie Hill is the best!
Reviewed On 9/27/2017 by Sandy R
Not only are the cookies fabulous, but the owner is so personable and helpful. Sure to be a hit at ANY event.

Contact Info for Prairie Hill Cookie Company

Vendor Logo
DFW - can ship nation-wide

Meet the Team

meet the owner
Margaret Wahlen
Owner
I discovered my love of baking in Junior High School and have been at it ever since. As a career music teacher, I did not always have a need to be baking, but I was in need of creative ways to reward students for doing well in class and learning music theory. Before long parents were seeking me out to buy them for birthday parties and Christmas gifts. When I received feedback like “This is the best thing I’ve ever eaten in my life!!” I decided to start the Prairie Hill Cookie Company. Named after the town where my dad was born, Prairie Hill Cookie Company is rooted in family, faith and love.
$$ Affordable
Starting Cost