About this vendor
Celebrating 48 years in business!
We are proud to bake fresh cakes, cookies and pastries from scratch.
Most of our recipes go back to our parent's and grandparent's bakery, 'Bachtel's Bakery' circa 1920. We bake each order fresh using the finest ingredients. Because we bake from scratch we are able adapt our recipes for some food allergies, including gluten free and dairy free options. We take pride in making your cake as beautiful as it is delicious.
Please stop in anytime to visit our Wedding and Party Cake Showroom and visit us at our next Open House Cake Tasting to sample some of our most popular flavors.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
Dietary Options
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Vegan
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.070 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 3
We went to a taste testing at Reeves Cake Shop back in the winter of 25 and after tasting how delicious their cakes were decided to utilize them for our wedding. We went with their...
wedding package which included cupcake trays, cookie trays, and a small wedding cake. They were very nice to work with through the entire process. Everything was VERY DELICIOUS!! Infact, the cookies were sooo good our guests had eaten them all before I even had a chance to try them!! Everything was very moist and fresh. I would highly recommend them for a wedding or any occasion!
Reeves was quick at responding, clear on expectations, set reasonable prices and made the wedding day worry free.
We used Reeves for our wedding cake. They were so easy to work with. I showed some inspiration photos and they were able to make my vision come to life. We went with the almond cak...
e with raspberry filling and whipped cream icing. We also had them make sheet cakes to serve to the guests. They delivered the cake to the reception hall, so I did not have to worry about transporting it. I will be using Reeves for other cake needs in the future.
Photo credits to Eagle Vision Photography
The cake was delicious and all of our guests raved about it! Our cake was white almond with rasperry and chocolate with chocolate mousse. The cake was delivered early in the day, s...
o no stress about it's arrival, and it looked absolutely beautiful.
Old School Excellent Bakery!!!
Go to the open house to taste all their flavors!
We ordered the two tier white whipped icing apple spice cake for our wedding. So light and fluffy!...
Cookie trays were fabulous!
Reeves was fantastic! We got three cakes to sample and they were all delicious, so we ended up getting two flavors for our wedding cake: spice cake with cream cheese filling and ch...
ocolate cake with raspberry filling. It was just as good on the wedding day! We sent them a couple pictures for inspiration and the design turned out even better than we hoped for. They were incredible professional and easy to work with - highly recommend!
Reeves Cake Shop is AMAZING!!!! In all the excitement, I forgot to order a cake! Three weeks before the wedding, I contacted them and they made it happen. I didn't do a cake tas...
ting, because we had their cake for my bridal shower and it was delicious. Our cake was GORGEOUS. I left the cake topper at the venue and they put it on for us. The guests are still talking about all the flavors, but the favorite was the dark chocolate cake with mint! Their whipped cream icing is THE BEST!!! If you have them make your cake (for anything, not just weddings!) - you will not be disappointed!
Our cakes were gorgeous and tasted so good!! The grooms cake was spectacular and everyone loved the custom design. The flavors and fillings are beyond compare. Looking forward to o...
rdering a cake every year for our anniversary!!
Reeve's Cake Shop was easy to work with and produced a beautiful wedding cake made exactly as we ordered. They also delivered to our reception hall which made our lives much easier...
on wedding day. The cake was delicious and guests raved about how tasty it was. We are grateful for the entire Reeve's staff for the part that they played in allowing our wedding day to go off without a hitch!
When we put a down payment down for our cake, there was a promotion going on for a free groom's cake. (which is a wonderful deal.) The day of our wedding, our 3 tier main cake was ...
beautiful. They did such a great job with the sugarpaste flowers running down the side. However, the groom's cake which we gave ideas for prior was very sloppy and poorly put together. Even though it was free, they made it sound like they would put a little more effort into it. It was just a white cake with black words on it. Kind of plain.
the cake was very pretty and tasted really good their cakes are amazing and lots of sample cakes to look at and get ideas
We had pies for our main dessert, but my husband and I wanted a small cake to cut and eat too. We got a small three layer cake. It was super easy to order and we were able to do tw...
o different fillings. Since we weren't getting tiers, we didn't have to pay wedding prices and they did a nice smooth buttercream icing with dots on the border. Simple and elegant. It was really delicious too!
Reeve's offers great cakes at a great price. We were very pleased with their service, and our cake was delicious and beautiful! Highly recommended.
Our wedding cake was beautiful and was the best tasting...at least the one bite that I got. We did 3 flavor combinations and all of the cake was gone before the end of the night. M...
y husband and I are looking forward to trying our cake topper in a year and if it tastes bad after being frozen a year, we will have them make us a fresh one.
We went to several cake tastings all at different locations but ones we went to Reeves we knew this was the place we would be ordering our wedding cake from. During their tastings...
they provide so many cakes to try its amazing
I had the opportunity to taste Reeve's cake samples back in high school, and the impact really stuck. We attended one of the tasting events which was great to allow my husband and ...
family to try the great flavors. They even had a great deal going where we would get a free groom's cake if we booked during the event. The cake was gorgeous, and was exactly how I had envisioned it looking when the topped and ribbon was added. I'm telling you, try Reeves!
Beautiful,,, and it took us 8 months to find a cake place we liked. The grooms cake was peanut butter and chocolate the bomb. And the wedding cake was everything I wanted!!!!
Reeve's cake shop did my wedding cake, grooms cake and cookies for the reception! They were all so good and we received many many compliments on how good everything was. The cake l...
ooked exactly how I had pictured it too! Awesome bakery!
What a beautiful cake! They decorated exactly as we had asked- making sure the get the colors exact. The cake itself was delicious...I want to break our our anniversary cake alread...
y. We loved all of the options on flavors as well.
we customized thier.full-size castle cake to fit our theme. Very easy to work with, the cake was delicious!
We did cupcakes instead of a cake (with a little cake on top that we could cut into) and we were so happy with Reeves. The cupcakes looked great and they tasted delicious!
Our cake turned out beautifully! Reeves did an amazing job. I would highly recommend them.
I was rather disappointed with the service from Reeves. I had heard wonderful things about them and went to a couple of their cake tasting events prior to signing a contract with t...
hem and their cake was always wonderful.
We ordered a four tier red velvet cake with cream cheese icing. It was square tiers with pillars in between and they were supposed to be twisted (offset).
When ordering they told us we would be called early in the week of the wedding to set up a delivery time. We called late in the day on the Thursday before my Saturday wedding and they still didn’t know when they would be dropping it off because they “didn’t know when someone would be at the venue,” which I figured could have easily been solved by them calling and asking. During that phone call it was decided that they would deliver between 2-3pm.
They did not deliver the cake until 3:45 (without a call saying that they would be late), at which point the flowers still needed to be put on by our friend of the family that was handling our food prep and she was busy getting the cocktail appetizers ready for when guests arrived at 4:15. Also, when they set up the cake, they set it up straight, instead of twisted (which was the whole reason I fell in love with this design in the first place and the primary reason I chose Reeves over another shop that was less expensive but could not do this design).
Now for the positives: The cake tasted as expected (My husband did say that he thought it seemed a little stale compared to the samples at the cake tasting). It was beautifully decorated. I had numerous compliments on the beautiful design (even if it wasn’t what I had wanted). Also, after calling Reeve’s the week after the wedding (and playing some telephone tag) I did receive a check for 15% of my bill as compensation for the cake being set up wrong. It does not fix the problem or the fact that all photographs of my cake are of something that I had not wanted, but I am glad that they tried to make retribution.
Overall, I was disappointed with Reeves, but we had a very beautiful cake that the guests seemed to really like.
allowed me to make changed two weeks before wedding, cake tasted great and met all expectations.
Unfortunately, I didn't get a piece of cake! :( The night went so fast and I was so busy, I didn't get a piece...but everyone says that it was delicious. We decided to go with R...
eeves, because they worked closely with the hall where we had the reception and I'm not upset that we did. They weren't overly friendly- but they got the job done!
The best!
Working with Reeves was simple and easy. We were able to order a cake for us to cut and sheet cakes to keep the cost down. They were so yummy and easy to work with. I did not wo...
rry working with Reeves
Let me first start off by saying We loved our wedding cake that Reeves did!! We had our wedding in Sandusky which is a drive from Akron and they got our cake and pastries there saf...
ely. The cake tasted and looked amazing. Rick worked with us to make sure the design was perfect and what we wanted. Our castle cake was amazing and went with our theme perfectly. Everyone loved our cake!! I would definitely recommend them for any event!! I cannot wait to go back there!
Everyone at Reeves was helpful and their cakes at the tastings were amazing, but the cake did not turn out the way I pictured it or how it was discussed with the employee. Also the...
grooms cake looked like I could have made it on my own, not the professional design I was going for (or paid top dollar for)! Needless to say I was less than impressed. I would not recommend reeves to other potential customers.
Although this shop did a pretty nice job for a really great price, their shop is in the GHETTO. We went for a cake tasting and were afraid to get out of our cars!!! They did a pret...
ty good job on the cake, though... and they were fairly inexpensive. They made a custom cake for us and cupcakes. We got a small cake to cut and two large cakes to serve, too. All in all I was pleased, but I don't think I would use them again if I had the chance... it was too much of a risk.
When we were looking for cakes, we went to a cake tasting at Reeves & fell in love with the "Bumble-Bee" cake - we chose that for our wedding cake & everyone loved it! I t...
ook a picture of a cake that I wanted & they made it happen. Everything was great & what friendly people to work with.
We had such a wonderful experience with Reeves. We tasted many cakes through the whole wedding planning process and Reeves Cake Shop had THE best tasting cake. I made sure to grab ...
a few pieces to eat later that night. And they did a wonderful job of making our vision come to life
We chose Reeves Cake Shop for our wedding this past October 22nd, and could not be more thrilled with the cakes they provided! We went to at least 3 different bridal shows this pa...
st January, and Reeves had the best displays by far - both in taste and in their beautiful sample cakes on display. When we signed them up to do our wedding cake, they had a special that offered a free groom's cake, too (which we chose to use for our rehearsal dinner). They were incredibly helpful, creative, and professional throughout the design process. They even worked with us to expand the size of the groom's cake a little, and put a very creative design on the top. :) The groom's cake was like triple chocolate fudge something or other, and our wedding cake was red velvet with raspberry filling and whipped cream frosting. Both cakes were phenomenal to look at, and even better to eat!! Reeves also offers a huge cake-tasting event every January where they have every single type of cake, filling frosting, etc. available for tasting. (I think they do smaller versions of this throughout the year as well.) My husband and I brought our parents and one set of my grandparents to the tasting (to get different opinions from the generations), and we got there early so we could go through the line, each grab different flavors of everything, and gathered together to sample a little bit of everything! :)
I went to a cake tasting there, and they had me! The shop is not much on the outside, but the beautiful displays inside, and their very professional service went a long way!
Had a two tiered round cake for 50 guests. Got the cassata torte specialty cake and it was delicious! Everyone loved it. Didn't hear one complaint. I also was very specific wit...
h my design requests (sent and mockup and colors in the mail) and they nailed it to the tee. PERFECT!
My wedding cake was perfect. Beautiful and delicious. Exactly what I asked for. The staff is easy to work with and so creative.
I was very pleased with Reeves Cake Shop. They did my grooms cake and my wedding cake. The cake was very good and they had a lot of sample cake layouts for me to look at and to cho...
ose from. The day of the wedding they dropped it off right on time and it looked amazing. I would definitely recommend.
Everyone at the reception LOVED the cake! So many times you go to a wedding and dont even hear anything about the cake - we put a sign up with the cake to describe the flavor (bum...
ble bee) and people loved it! The cake tastings they do every other month are free and a MUST DO! More than once if you can - they have 17 flavors to try so go hungry!
I had Reeve's cake shop do my cupcakes for my fall wedding. I wanted cupcakes for ease, but I still wanted an elegant style. While I heard wonderful feedback on the taste from my ...
guests (I never got a chance to eat one!) I wasn't 100% pleased with the look of it. The frosting was sort of just a blob on top, and didn't cover the whole top of the cup cake. I would just be sure to be very specific on the details when discussing the design with them.
Reeves Cake shop did an excellent job with our wedding cake! They were able to make my vision (which I can be scattered at times) come to life! And not only did the cake look perfe...
ct, it tasted so very yummy! We got lots of compliments on the taste and the look. Excellent Job! Recommend them to anyone who is still looking for a wedding cake vendor. They have tastings too!
After visiting other bakeries, this place had the best prices and came highly recommended. They've received awards for their fondant designed cakes too. We ended up going to a ta...
sting and got to try a ton of flavors. AS part of that deal, if you put money down towards a cake, you received a grooms cake free! We ended up having 3 different cake flavors and fillings for our wedding day. They allow you to change flavors on each tier which was nice. I took a picture in for them and they copied it perfectly.
My cake disappeared. We had a cake for 200 people and had just over 200 guests. My husband LOVES peanut butter, so we decided to get the chocolate cake with peanut butter filling...
. SO GOOD. The other part of our cake was almond with raspberry. I felt like we needed a fruit option. Well people loved that one too. As for the design, it was terrific.
Brides really do decided to spend their money on different things, and cake was one of mine. We didn't drop a ton of money on it, but I wanted my cake to look good. It is something that will never be forgotten. We loved our cake.
Thank you so much to Reeves Cake Shop.
Our cake was beautiful! We had so many compliments about how great it tasted. I can't wait to eat our top tier on our anniversary!
pricing is average,not alot of choices of filling or cake flavors,they do work to try and create want you want
Cake and service were top notch!
Reeves is wonderful. The cake was delicious!! And to me that's all that matters. But...when planning a wedding, that's not all that matters. You have to have more than that. Decidi...
ng on a cake can be a big pain - what kind to get, how many people, do we get a sheet cake or a kitchen cake? Reeves was very helpful in answering all these questions. And many more. It was wonderful to work with them. They decorated the cake beautifully; delivered it on time; were very friendly to work with. Great experience all around!!
I used them for a party I threw it was a hawaiian carnival, the cake was beautifully designed it was yellow cake with butter creme icing and pineapple filling, i dida good job with...
the description of the cake ad they did a great jb delivering!! It was delicious!! Ad it was inexpensive.
Perfect tastes great
The cake was absolutely delicious and looked exactly how we wanted it! We had about 4 different flavors and they were all good! They were wonderful about getting back to us very qu...
ickly when we had questions. Very great service! I would definitely recommend Reeve's!
Our cake was beautiful. We had a yellow cake with a lemon filling and buttercream frosting. The cake wasn't as moist as I like but it was pretty good.
Contact
2770 Cory Ave, Akron, OH
Reeves Cake Shop