About this vendor
We are a SCRATCH, custom bakery designing wedding menus for each couple! To meet with Sally directly (via video chat) she needs about a half hour of your time. That can be scheduled by emailing SallysSweetShoppe@yahoo.com.
Our website is full of pictures, menus, pricing, size charts, ideas, flavors, etc. www.SallysSweetShoppe.com
Details
Business Attributes
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
- Other Desserts
Popular with couples like you
Check out our featured vendors.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.022 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
Sally’s Sweet Shop was absolutely amazing for our wedding desserts! We had a beautiful cake table with eight cakes—four chocolate and four lemon raspberry—and every single one was ...
incredibly delicious and moist. We received so many compliments from our guests about how good the cakes were! Working with Sally was also such a great experience. She had wonderful ideas for cake styles, and the entire ordering and delivery process was easy and completely stress-free. We truly could not recommend Sally’s Sweet Shop more highly!
Sally was so easy to work with! She was very flexible with our plans and our cakes were getting compliments all night! Would highly recommend for future events. I’m already looking...
forward to eating our wedding cake on our anniversary!
We went through Sally for our wedding day dessert which included Red velvet cupcakes, chocolate caramel swirl brownies and snickerdoodle cookies! Sally was very responsive and help...
ful and clearly has plenty of experience in her industry! They were able to deliver our desserts day off, and Sally even let us add on a last-minute cake when our other option fell through! The cake and desserts were amazing!
We used Sally’s Sweet Shoppe to provide cake for our wedding on 9/21 and highly recommend! Sally was wonderful to work with. She clearly laid out what she needed from us and when a...
nd was quick to answer questions. We also were able to get our cakes delivered which was a big plus. At Sally’s advice, we opted to do a cake bar where we did a small couple’s cake and 5 8” round cakes of varying flavors and designs for our guests. It was a hit! The cakes all turned out beautiful and delicious, and our guests enjoyed being able to try the different flavors. We definitely plan to utilize Sally for our baking needs in the future.
We loved working with Sally’s Sweet Shoppe for our wedding desserts. We loved having the freedom to ask for specific flavors/desserts and not be limited to only certain options. We...
ordered a variety of desserts – mini vanilla cupcakes, chocolate/caramel shortbread bars, and snickerdoodle cookies – along with a small cutting cake. They all turned out excellent! They were delicious and there were plenty of desserts to go around. An added bonus, the pricing can’t be beat! We absolutely recommend working with Sally’s Sweet Shoppe.
We had their Dutch apple pie for our wedding and it was absolutely delicious. We got many compliments about it. Delivery times were a bit restrictive, but Sally was so sweet and co...
nsiderate of any bridal stress. We will definitely be returning- these are now my husband's favorite Dutch apple pies (and he's had many!)
Sally was so accommodating, friendly, and easy to work with. It was so wonderful to work with a small business that understood our specific needs and were flexible. The cake was be...
autiful and delicious and extremely cost effective!
Our 2tier cutting cake and sheet cakes were delicious. Sally was so easy to work with, responsive, provided great recommendations, and had very fair and honest pricing. So glad we ...
chose them for our Oct 2023 wedding! Our cake looked beautiful!
We booked Sally's Sweet Shoppe for our wedding! We did a big dessert table & a small wedding cake for our head table to enjoy! Sally was soooo sweet and helpful in our decision pro...
cess! She took facts about us as a couple to help make recommendations on what treats to choose!
We went with 2 mini cupcakes: RumChatta & Strawberries/Cream (real strawberries in the cake)
2 cookies: peanutbutter blossoms & caramel chip
2 bars: lemon bars & fudge brownies
HOLY AMAZING!!!!!!
the desserts were so good, I was eating the leftovers for a week after the wedding!
Thank you Sally!
Everyone loved our wedding cake made by Sally! Really easy to work with and affordable! Would highly recommend!
Sally did an amazing job on our wedding cake. She made it exactly how we wanted it! It tasted amazing!! We traveled our cake all the way to Copper Harbor MI. I would definitely re...
commend using Sally to anyone looking for a cake for a wedding or just a small celebration. She does an amazing job!!! If we ever need a cake for another occasion I will definitely be using Sally again!!! The best part is the pricing is very reasonable!!!
We chose Sally's to get cupcakes for our wedding! Sally was so sweet and gave great suggestions when we weren't sure what we wanted. Everyone loved the desserts and they were beaut...
iful. The quality for value can't be beat in lake country!
My wife and I hired Sally's Sweet Shoppe to bake over 600 cookies of six types for our wedding dessert. These cookies were amazing and the price was a bargain. Many guests came up ...
to us on our wedding night to give praise at what great cookies they had. Even the other vendors, who go to weddings every week, said these cookies were amazing and a great chance of pace from the traditional cake. You need to hire Sally's Sweet Shoppe for your dessert needs!
We used Sally's Sweet Shoppe for our wedding cakes. We loved the unique idea of a cake bar and offering different flavors for our guests to choose from. We received so many compl...
iments on how fun and delicious our cakes were!
We did a cake and donut bar for our wedding supplied by Sally's Sweet Shoppe, and we had a wonderful experience with them! The cakes were beautiful and delicious, and she offers a ...
wide variety of traditional and fun flavors. We had vanilla with strawberry filling and chocolate with fudge filling. We also had apple cider donuts, which were perfect for the fall wedding and a big hit with the kids. Her pricing is also very competitive.
We heard over and over again all night and weekend (for that matter) how amazing the desserts were at our wedding! Sally and her team were very helpful with helping us make decisio...
ns and there experience with weddings in the past. Everything turned out lovely and oh so delicious! Thank you so much Sally and Devon!!
We used Sally's Sweet Shoppe for our wedding. They made a small cake for us to cut and then two flavors of cupcakes. Everything was beautiful and delicious! We had so many complime...
nts from our guests. The price was very affordable as well.
We had a small wedding cake made at Sally’s for our June wedding! Sally was so easy to work with and very accommodating of our need for a dairy free cake. It was absolutely delicio...
us and looked exactly how we wanted it to look! We would highly recommend Sally’s Sweet Shoppe!
We used Sally's Sweet Shoppe for our wedding cakes and we were thrilled with our choice. We worked directly with Sally, the owner, which made us feel like she really cared about he...
r product. She was so kind and accommodating with our vision, and our cakes turned out even better than I expected. The actual flavor of the cake is phenomenal. We did cake tastings at a couple more expensive bakeries, and Sally's cakes blew those cakes away. We received beautiful cakes at a very reasonable price, and the flavor was better than any other cake we've had!
We ordered 3 different flavors of cupcakes for our wedding on 9/10/16. They were amazing! And all of our guests loved them too. Everything from consultation to delivery was easy an...
d Sally was very helpful. Any questions I had throughout the process were answered quickly and professionally. She also made a small cutting cake for us last minute! I was glad she could accomodate our request and it was just what we wanted. The price was also reasonable (for 6 dozen of each flavor and the cutting cake). I will definitely return to Sally's for any future cake/cupcake/tasty treat needs!
Sally's was AMAZING! We were stuck on what we wanted to have for dessert and with on call to Sally she had a plan for us. She helped us customize a dessert bar to our tastes and bu...
dget. Everything was absolutely amazing. I would highly recommend her for any type of dessert for any occasion! We will defiantly be going back!
We used Sally's Sweet Shoppe from Genesee Depot to do our desserts. We didn't want a traditional cake, we both prefer cheesecake and desserts to cake. My brother in law's cousin wo...
rks there, which is how we found out about her. We meet with Sally and discussed options we wanted, and decided on a peanut butter/chocolate cheesecake we cut, peanut butter swirl brownies, lemon bars, blueberry mini cheesecakes, tied dyed sugar cookies and white chocolate/cranberry cookies. I have heard nothing but great things from our guests about the desserts, including that people who normally aren't big lemon bar fans, trying them and loving them and the mini cheesecakes are "magical". I loved working with Sally and will definitely use her again, even if it is just for pastries for Sunday morning breakfast.
Contact
S42 W31238 Hwy 83, Genesee Depot, WI
Sally's Sweet Shoppe