Custom Wedding Cakes, Dessert and Cupcakes
Nicole Keeven
WEDDING COORDINATOR/CAKE ARTIST
Typically responds within 24h
AWARD WINNER (13X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Sarah’s Cake Shop is a locally owned business in the greater St. Louis area. We provide St. Louis area brides with custom wedding cakes, desserts and cupcakes. Contact Sarah our wedding coordinator today to set up a consultation or tasting.
Woman-owned Business
Prices & packages
No pricing details yet
Reach out to get a customized quote from this vendor.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Sugar Free
Vegan
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
Nicole Keeven
Wedding Coordinator/Cake Artist
I studied at The French Pastry School of Chicago in 2013-2014. After graduation, I started my long career here at Sarah's Cake Shop as a cake artist.
Since 2020, I have taken on the role of wedding coordinating, as well as creating wedding cakes. This role lets me be part of every couple's journey from start to finish. I love creating something gorgous and delicious for every couple's vision.
Reviews
4.9
out of 5.0244 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Sarah's Cake Shop consistently delivered exceptional service, beautiful designs, and delicious cakes for weddings, as per multiple positive reviewers. The desserts, including a 2-tier wedding cake and various other treats, were highly praised by guests. Reviewers highlighted the ease of planning, stunning presentation, and incredible taste of the cakes from Sarah's Cake Shop. Additionally, the team's professionalism, attention to detail, and flexibility in accommodating last-minute changes were appreciated, making it a highly recommended choice for couples looking for show-stopping and delightful cakes for their special day.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Nicole S
5.0
1/06/2025
Sarah's Cake Shop did a wonderful job with our wedding. They provided us with a 2-tier wedding cake and a variety of small desserts. Our guests really enjoyed the desserts and they were beautiful! Additionally, they arrived on time to set-up at our reception venue. Prior to the wedding, planning with them was easy and helpful. They helped us determine how many different types of desserts to order, as well as how many to order of each type. They also coordinated with me to help me surprise my husband with a Spiderman figurine on the back of our cake. This vendor was recommended to me by a friend who used them for her wedding. After having their desserts at 2 weddings, I would certainly recommend them again!
Vendor response 01/06/2025
Thank you so much for the kind words and wonderful review! We are so happy to hear that yo...
u and your guests loved the wedding cake and desserts. It was a pleasure working with you to make your day extra special, and we’re so glad the Spiderman figurine surprise was a hit! We truly appreciate the recommendation and are honored to have been a part of your celebration. Wishing you both a lifetime of happiness, and thank you again for choosing Sarah’s Cake Shop! 💕🎂
Kaylee P
5.0
12/17/2024
We couldn’t be happier with the beautiful and delicious wedding cake that Sarah's Cake Shop created for our special day! From start to finish, their service was exceptional. The cake was exactly what we envisioned—stunningly designed, with intricate details that matched our wedding theme perfectly. Note our flowers were placed by our florist.
Not only was the cake gorgeous, but it tasted absolutely divine! Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious it was! We went with their classic almond flavor!
The delivery process was seamless as well. The team at Sarah's Cake Shop arrived on time(even with a 1.5hr drive), handled everything with such care, and set up the cake beautifully at the venue. They took all the stress out of the cake portion of our wedding day, and we are so grateful for that.
Thank you, Sarah's Cake Shop, for making our wedding day even more special with your incredible talent, professionalism, and attention to detail. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for a show-stopping cake that’s just as delicious as it is beautiful!
Vendor response 12/18/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re overjoyed to hear that your wedding cake was ...
everything you envisioned and that it complemented your special day so beautifully. Knowing your guests loved the almond flavor and that our design matched your theme perfectly means the world to us. 💕
We’re especially glad to hear the delivery process went smoothly and that we could take some stress off your plate on such an important day—our goal is always to make the experience as seamless and joyful as possible! Thank you for trusting us to be part of your celebration, and for your thoughtful recommendation. Wishing you a lifetime of happiness together! 🎂✨
Any questions?
Marquita K
5.0
12/01/2024
We booked Sarah's Cake Shop to make our wedding cake for our fall 2024 wedding. The cake was just like we had envisioned and it tasted amazing. It was a hit at the wedding, and we got compliments from many of the guests.
Vendor response 12/18/2024
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re thrilled to hear that your wedding ca...
ke was exactly as you envisioned and that it was such a hit with your guests. 💕 Knowing it added to the joy of your special day makes us so happy. Thank you for letting us be a part of your celebration! 🎂🍁✨
Sarah N
5.0
11/20/2024
Sarah's Cake Shop did a wonderful job with my wedding cake and grooms cake. The wedding cake tasted delicious and was exactly what I had envisioned. The grooms cake blew me away and everyone raved about the german chocolate filling. I've gotten childhood birthday cakes from their bakery 15 years ago and still remember them vividly, so it made perfect sense to trust them to create the best cakes ever for my wedding day!
Vendor response 12/18/2024
Thank you for such a heartfelt review! We’re honored to have been a part of both your spec...
ial day and your cherished childhood memories. 💕 Hearing that the wedding cake was exactly as you envisioned and that the groom’s cake was a hit (especially with the German chocolate filling!) means the world to us. Thank you for trusting us again to make your wedding day extra sweet—we’re so grateful to be part of your story! 🎂✨
Brandi M
5.0
11/11/2024
We were THRILLED with our wedding cake and dessert station! The best cake I’ve ever had. From the tasting & consultation, to the design and color matching with our logo, the delivery - everything was fantastic. Our only note is that florals covered the groom’s name on the cake topper. Everything else was perfection! We can’t wait for our free anniversary cake!
Vendor response 12/18/2024
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re delighted to hear you loved your wedd...
ing cake and dessert station—it was such a joy to bring your vision to life. 🌟 From the tasting to the delivery, we’re so glad everything met your expectations. We appreciate your feedback about the florals on the topper and will keep that in mind for future orders. Wishing you both a lifetime of happiness, and we can’t wait to create your anniversary cake! 🎂💕
Allison B
5.0
10/23/2024
Delicious cake and amazing desert bar!! Very easy to communicate with! These deserts were a hit! We barely had any for my husband and I after the wedding! Highly recommend!!
Vendor response 12/18/2024
Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear that both the cake and...
dessert bar were such a hit at your wedding. It’s always the best compliment when there’s barely any left to take home! 🥰 We loved being a part of your special day and appreciate your kind recommendation. Congratulations again! 🎉🎂
Kate P
5.0
10/14/2024
It was so fun designing a unique cake and dessert bar for our wedding with Sarah’s. The tasting made it hard to choose flavors; but we ended up with a traditional almond and raspberry jam, a marble, and an apple with brown butter buttercream cake. All of our guests were so impressed! The small desserts really elevated the look of the dessert table and it was all set up beautifully. They coordinated with the venue and florist for us so we didn’t have to worry about any of that. We can’t wait to pick up our complimentary anniversary cake in a year, and we’ll be back to get goodies for many events to come!
Vendor response 10/22/2024
Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear that designing your ca...
ke and dessert bar was such a fun and memorable experience. It was our pleasure to help bring your vision to life, and we’re glad the tasting made it hard to choose – that’s always a good sign! 😊
We’re delighted that your guests were impressed with the cake and desserts, and we’re glad everything came together smoothly with the venue and florist. We can’t wait to see you again for your anniversary cake and to help with all the sweet celebrations ahead!
Warmest wishes,
Sarah’s Cake Shop Team
Christina A
5.0
10/10/2024
We couldn’t be happier with our cake from Sarah’s Cake Shop! It was absolutely beautiful. They listened to what we wanted and delivered just that. We had tastings from several shops and Sarah’s Cake shop, by far, had the best tasting cakes and it was awesome because they let you taste custom flavors whereas a lot of shops just gave the basic flavors. They also give you the option to get a cake at your one year anniversary vs keeping the top tier, which we appreciated. We definitely recommend Sarah’s cake shop!
Vendor response 10/22/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear that you loved your wedding ...
cake and that it turned out exactly as you envisioned. It’s wonderful to know that our custom tastings stood out, and we’re glad we could offer a personalized experience for you. We take pride in making every detail special, including the anniversary cake option, so we’re happy that it was appreciated.
Thank you for recommending us! We can’t wait to see you again for your anniversary cake and any other sweet occasions to come!
Warm regards,
Sarah’s Cake Shop Team
Sarah M
5.0
10/08/2024
Working with Sarah’s Cake Shop was a breeze throughout the entire process. We were in constant communication with Nicole and she was helpful Eve et time we had a question. Our desserts were delicious! We barely had any left at the end of our wedding. Thanks Sarah’s Cake Shop!
Vendor response 10/22/2024
Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We’re so glad to hear that working with Nicole made...
the process easy and enjoyable for you. Communication is key, and we’re thrilled that she was able to assist you every step of the way.
It’s fantastic to know that your desserts were a hit and that there were hardly any left at the end of your wedding! We appreciate you choosing Sarah’s Cake Shop for your special day, and we hope to be part of many more celebrations in the future!
Best wishes,
Sarah’s Cake Shop Team
Carly F
5.0
9/26/2024
Amazing cake - nailed our vision for the color of the cake, the simplicity of the design, and our guests loved it!
Vendor response 09/29/2024
Hi Carly,
We love a bit of color! Thank you so much for your positive review, and for let...
ting us be a part of your wedding day!
Hannah G
5.0
9/16/2024
Sarah's Cakes did a dessert bar for us at our wedding at Knotting Hills in September of 2024. Every dessert was so good! They did a wide selection for us- fruit tarts, lemon shooters, glitter bites, petite bites (mini bites of cake which was the perfect bite size!), macaroons and a 2 tiered wedding cake. They added our puppy dogs peaking out of the bottom of the cake which was the cutest touch! They also have rentals available, so when they came out to deliver the desserts, they also set everything up on platters and labels and it looked so nice!! Another nice option they have, is that on your one year wedding anniversary they will bake you a replicate of your top tier cake to take home and enjoy, such a nice special touch!
Vendor response 09/29/2024
Hi Hannah,
Thank you much for your kind words! We loved incorporating your adorable fur b...
abies! Thank you for choosing us to be a part of your big day!
Nicole D
5.0
7/23/2024
10/10 - use Sarah's cake shop!! My husband and I used them for our wedding in May and we had the most wonderful experience. The tasting was delicious and was so hard to choose from so many good options. We ordered a two tier cake and a dessert bar from them. Everything was gorgeous and SO delicious. The guests were raving about it. The communication and customer service was amazing. Nicole, the wedding coordinator and baker was so great. She was also quick to respond and so helpful with any changes we requested. They did my sisters wedding as well, we will continue to use them in my family!!
Sarah W
5.0
7/23/2024
My husband and I are so happy that we used Sarah's Cake Shop for our wedding cake and dessert bar. They were very easy to communicate with and graciously let me change details close to the wedding date. The cake and dessert bar itself was so good and we received many compliments. I would definitely recommend this bakery!
Vendor response 07/23/2024
Sarah,
We are so glad that you enjoyed your cake and desserts! Thank you for choosing us ...
to be a part of your special day!
Amanda P
5.0
4/24/2024
Sarah’s Cake Shop provided us with a cake and a bunch of cupcakes for our wedding. We did a tasting, and paired our favorite cake, filling, and icing to pick out our favorite combination for our wedding cake. The cake was so good and the cupcakes were perfect. Our guests commented several times that it was the best wedding cake they’ve had and asked for a business card. Sarah’s Cake Shop offered a free 6 inch replica cake for your one year anniversary with a purchase over a certain amount, so we are excited to have our cake again, and fresh, on our first anniversary next year!
Jaime G
5.0
3/08/2024
We used Sarah's Cake Shop for our grooms cake & wedding cake and loved both so much!! They captured the vision perfectly for the grooms cake. We live out of state and it was so easy to hop on a zoom call or a phone call to discuss details. When we were in town, we were able to taste test custom combinations to pick our cake flavors. They delivered our wedding cake and everything was perfect! Would recommend!
Vendor response 03/08/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words, Jaime! We are so happy we were able to make your v...
ision a reality!
Thank you for choosing us to be a part of your special day!
Ashley A
5.0
1/13/2024
Our cake was delivered promptly and was so stunning . Tasted amazing. Made our day special
Christine K
3.0
12/08/2023
The cake was delicious and but the overall design was as not what I expected, as it did not have flowers on it like I had discussed with the baker and the florist. It was supposed to have flowers placed on it, but there were no flowers placed at all, and the flowers were to be the main accent for the cake. I guess there was some kind of miscommunication between the florist and the baker about who was doing that, but it was my understanding that the baker would be doing it as long as the florist provided the flowers (which they did, but we had trouble finding them, so maybe they did too). Luckily my mother in law and her sister are very crafty and were able to throw something together at the last minute and fix it up. Not what I had in mind, but it ended up looking pretty good.
Brenda S
5.0
11/13/2023
My family has always loved Sarah’s in Eureka, so we’re confident in our decision to hire the Cake Shop for our daughter, Taylor’s wedding. They did not disappoint. Nicole met with my daughter and I a couple of times to ensure she had all the details captured. She made helpful suggestions for portion sizes and variety. The cake and dessert tables were as gorgeous as they were delicious.
Samantha W
5.0
10/26/2023
The communication and professionalism we got at Sarah's Cake shop was phenomenal! We can not recommend them enough. Not only did they create the cake I asked for exactly but they delivered on time and coordinated everything perfectly all the way to Union Station. They are very reliable, reasonably priced and I can not recommend them enough. Of course the cake was delicious as well.
Brittany H
5.0
10/16/2023
Sarah's Cake Shop was so easy to work with for our wedding cake! They listened to all our preferences and inspirations and made a beautiful wedding cake that was delicious. We had their cake a friend's wedding years ago and knew we needed to have their cake at ours as well. I can easily say this is the best quality cake we've ever had. Highly recommend using for any important events!
Dalette B
5.0
10/09/2023
This cake shop is AMAZING. We got exactly what we wanted, and our guests were so in love with the cake design!
Miranda B
5.0
9/25/2023
Oh my goodness... There aren't enough words to describe how wonderful working with Nicole at Sarah's Cake Shop was. From our very first interaction, our tasting, and our wedding day, everything was absolutely perfect. Our cake featured our four dogs, and they were made with exquisite detail. Book Sarah's Cake Shop for your big day, you won't be disappointed.
Vendor response 09/25/2023
We had the best time making all of your fur babies! We are all animal lovers here, and th...
ought your cake was amazing!
Thank you for choosing us to be a part of your special day!
Cassidy G
5.0
9/06/2023
From tasting to wedding day, Sarah's Cake Shop was great to work with. The cake was delicious and designed exactly as I had hoped. Nicole (wedding coordinator and cake artist) was responsive and knowledgable. Price was reasonable as well. I will be using Sarah's for future events as well!
Vendor response 09/06/2023
Hi Cassidy,
We are so glad you enjoyed your wedding cake! Thank you for choosing us to be...
a part of your big day!
Courtney P
5.0
8/06/2023
My husband and I ordered our wedding cake from Sarah's Cake Shop for our wedding July 1, 2023. We worked with Nicole to transform our inspiration images into a beautiful cake. The coordination with Nicole on the tasting kit and the final details was seamless. We ended up ordering a small two-tiered cake with kitchen cakes to feed 200. We barely had any leftovers as all of our wedding guests were eating multiple pieces of cake it was so good. We did white cake with lemon buttercream, chocolate cake with dark chocolate mousse and raspberry jam with chocolate buttercream and a traditional almond wedding cake. We couldn't ask for a better experience and would highly recommend Sarah's Cake Shop. We are looking forward to visiting next year to redeem our "free top layer" to celebrate our anniversary instead of trying to keep our top layer in the freezer until then. Thanks again Nicole and the Sarah's Cake Shop team!
Ann R
5.0
7/31/2023
Our bakery cancelled on us a month before our wedding, but Sarah's saved the day! We were able to book with them, and they were so kind and patient as we worked on a heavily modified timeline to get everything done in time for our wedding. They squeezed us in for a very rushed tasting and design consultation, and Nicole was able to take my frazzled thoughts and turn them into a beautiful cake and dessert bar. Our flowers and cake-topper were arranged perfectly on our cake, but the animal sculptures that we ordered blew those items away. I wish I had pictures to attach! We had our three cats peeking out from under the icing of our cake, and I received endless complements about them. Not to mention, the cake and desserts were all delicious.
Sarah's was also able to accommodate my husband's peanut/tree nut allergy and some of our guests' gluten allergies. They gave us a lot of peace of mind on our wedding day, knowing we wouldn't have to worry about cross contamination with our desserts.
Hilary V
5.0
7/18/2023
Our wedding cake was amazing!!! My husband and I had a great time trying the different cakes, coming up with our design and letting Nicole and her team do their magic. Our cake turned out delicious and so many people have told us that it was the best wedding cake they've had in a while!! We highly recommend Sarah's Cake Shop for your wedding dessert needs!
Susie S
5.0
6/29/2023
Our wedding cake could not have been more perfect! It was absolutely delicious and designed exactly as I had imagined it. Nicole was so helpful and was a dream to work with. Thank you!
Alex S
5.0
6/13/2023
Absolutely love Sarah's Cakes. Nicole and her team were a joy to work with! They consistently communication with us despite it being a very busy wedding season and made the dessert bar of our dreams come to life.
Kristen P
5.0
11/30/2022
Sarah's Cake Shop created the perfect wedding cake for us. From the initial cake tasting to the final product, we were very impressed with the team and cake. We provided pictures of the cake we would like and they made that vision come true. Excited to be able to eat cake again next October with the complimentary fresh first tier on our anniversary.
Elaine M
5.0
11/04/2022
Sarah's Cake Shop did an outstanding job on our wedding cakes! The designs were better than we could have imagined- they were absolutely beautiful! And better yet, the cake was DELICIOUS! Our guests were raving about how amazing all the flavors were. We highly recommend!
Jennifer H
5.0
10/13/2022
I can’t even say enough great things about Sarah’s. I’ve been using Sarah’s for years for small cake needs, so it was no question that I wanted to use them for my wedding. Obviously the taste is to die for, but they have so many options to choose from and really cater to you. Highly recommend!
Emily J
4.0
10/10/2022
Sarah’s Cake Shop was a great place to use for our wedding cake! It was delicious and we would definitely recommend them!
James R
5.0
10/05/2022
Excellent experience. We purchased both a wedding cake and a large desert bar from Sarah's. Both were delicious and beautiful. We were not intending on having the cake the focus of our dessert, because neither of us are cake people. However, cake was delicious and even better than the sample cakes that we had. The staff is also very accommodating. We left for our honeymoon shortly after the event, and the bakery was to be closed that day. The staff came in anyway for us to drop off the dishes. highly recommend.
Morgan G
5.0
9/18/2022
Sarah's Cake Shop did such a wonderful job on our wedding cake. They brought my vision to life perfectly and met with me several times to nail down the final touches. They also worked in two figurines of our doggies that absolutely made my day! Not to mention, the cake is delicious. We would recommend them to any couple planning their big day!
Abby L
5.0
9/16/2022
Sarah's Cake Shop is amazing! When I graduated high school years ago, my parents got me a cake and glitter bites from Sarah's for a party and I fell in love. Since then, I had always wanted Sarah's to do my wedding cake. They have so much options that you can do to customize your cake, or dessert bar! We ended up doing a 3-tier cake and desserts to provide some variety. The cake tasting Sarah's provides is well worth it and everything was so good, it was hard to choose. We opted for the almond cake with almond buttercream and raspberry filling and it was delicious! Unfortunately, I didn't have much time for dessert the night of the wedding, but Sarah's is extra special because on your first wedding anniversary, they give you a small cake, freshly baked of what you had on your wedding day! I think this is so special and will definitely taste better than a year old, freezer burn cake if we were to do it the 'traditional' way :) All of the items we chose for the dessert bar were amazing as well. We heard awesome things from the guest about the petit fours, key lime pie dessert cups and cheesecake. The staff was easy to work with and they were organized with our order and delivered it perfectly. I also wanted cake tier separators and Nicole and team made my dream cake come to life because of it! Highly recommend Sarah's for not only weddings, but any event that you need a sweet treat for.
Kalee H
5.0
8/23/2022
Sarah’s cake shop did an AMAZING job with our elegant 4 tier rose gold cake! It came out as pictured but even better. They are easy to work with and very professional. The cake was absolutely DELICIOUS… we chose to do almond cake with almond butter & raspberry filling! I recommend Sarah’s cake shop for anyone who has a wedding in STL!
Love,
Kalee & Andrew❤️🍰
Paige T
5.0
8/01/2022
Sarah’s cake shop is the best! The booking process was so smooth and they coordinated day of delivery with our venue. We got so many compliments on how great the cake was and can’t recommend Sarah’s enough!
Jessica Z
5.0
7/25/2022
The cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious! We got so many compliments from people. We went with the almond cake, which is their most popular. Prior to tasting, we assumed this would be a bland combination and really only tasted it because they included a slice in our tasting for free. But it was so good!! We had a July wedding and the cake option was great for the warm weather.
Alli S
5.0
6/19/2022
By far the best cake we tasted! We did a chocolate sheet cake and then a three tiered semi-naked almond cake with raspberry filling and it all tasted amazing. We also used Sarah’s for my bridal shower and did all of their small desserts, and everything tasted amazing. Additionally, the price was very reasonable! Definitely recommend Sarah’s :)
Bekah S
5.0
5/24/2022
Cannot recommend enough! We had to postpone our wedding due to Covid and so went back and forth on our cake design a handful of times. The team at Sarah's Cake Shop was always so helpful in discussing ideas and providing updated information. It turned out exactly the way we'd envisioned, and the cake itself was scrumptious. Our guests loved it.
Katie B
5.0
3/10/2022
The cake was beautiful and our contact communicated with us throughout the entire process. Probably the best cake we've ever had and would definitely recommend to anyone.
Tess D
5.0
1/07/2022
Sarah's Cake Shop did a great job with our cake! We did two different flavors and had each tier decorated differently. We had one flavor of almond and raspberry and another with apple and carmel (a favorite of my parents from the tasting) and we got a lot of compliments from guests on both! Sarah's Cake Shop also did delivery which we appreciated, and the flowers they added flowers to the top were beautiful. The process was seamless and the cakes were delicious. Thanks for being part of our special day!
Kayla S
5.0
12/30/2021
Book them now! Our wedding cake was so delicious. I can’t wait to have it again on our anniversary. We received so many compliments on the cake. My husband and I went for the almond cake with white chocolate mousse and raspberry jam filling and a brown butter icing. Amazing. Seriously.
Deanna S
5.0
12/18/2021
We cannot recommend Sarah’s cupcakes and dessert bar enough! It was the hit of our reception and we still hear all our guests talk about how good the sweets were. Such variety, and yet everything tasted and looked amazing. They were so nice to work with too!
Tommy F
5.0
10/31/2021
We were extremely pleased with Sarah's for our wedding. We had 5 cupcake flavors and a small round cake for us to cut. All of it tasted amazing. We had so many guests rave about the cupcakes, so much so that we had very little to take home at the end of the night. They will be making us a new cake for our one year anniversary as well. They had so many cupcake flavors to choose from it was almost impossible to narrow down but we have a reason to go back and try some that we weren't able to pick. Highly recommend Sarah's if you're considering them.
Jessie H
5.0
10/23/2021
Our wedding cake was exactly what we wanted - simple, elegant and beautiful!
Annalise K
5.0
10/19/2021
Sarah's Cake Shop did an amazing job on our somewhat unconventional cake. I knew I wanted a small cake for my husband and I to cut, but I also knew I wanted the layers of the cake to be made out of petit fours to make snacking easier for guests. Nicole arranged multiple meetings with me to ensure they were able to accommodate my vision, and they did a beautiful (and delicious) job. There was not one petit four or piece of cake left at the end of the night! We highly recommend them.
Vendor response 10/20/2021
Hi Annalise,
Thanks so much for choosing us for your big day! We had so much fun with you...
r awesome painted mountain cake and matching small desserts! Everything turned out really cool and unique!
Ashley K
5.0
10/12/2021
Sarah’s Cake Shop is where we will buy all of our cakes for any occasion going forward..we loved it that much! The wedding cake was just incredible and the grooms cake that I had made by them turned out so cute! People that don’t even enjoy cake were saying how much they enjoyed it! We had vanilla and almond tiers with raspberry jam and vanilla frosting. Nicole was so helpful and responsive, and we knew as soon as we tried our tasting that we had to go with Sarah’s. I highly recommend!!
Vendor response 10/20/2021
Thank you Ashley! We are thrilled to hear that you and your guests enjoyed your wedding ca...
ke and groom's cake!
Brianna M
5.0
9/12/2021
Sarah’s cake shop is the best! We had multiple different flavors at our wedding and they were all delicious. They were so easy to work with, and worked tremendously with our budget.
Vendor response 09/15/2021
We are so happy you chose us to be a part of your special day!
Braden R
5.0
9/09/2021
Absolutely LOVED my cake. Not only was it gorgeous it tasted amazing too!! It was absolutely everything I wanted and will recommend them over and over again!! Nicole was incredible to work with and made sure it was everything I wanted. I can’t wait to use them for my next event!
Vendor response 09/15/2021
We are so happy you loved your wedding cake as much as we loved making it!
Thank you for...
being wonderful to work with!
Heather B
5.0
7/01/2021
We had a 4 tier cake from Sarah's Cake Shop for our wedding-- their cakes are delicious! We had a hard time picking the flavors after trying all their tasty flavors and small bite options. The cake was also so beautiful that we didn't even need to add the fresh flowers we planned to put on it.
Vendor response 07/02/2021
We are so happy that you enjoyed your wedding cake and small desserts! Thank you for lett...
ing us be a part of your special day!
Hollie M
5.0
6/09/2021
SO GOOD! Sarah's Cake Shop cake is sooooo good. So good that I received multiple compliments that it was the "best cake they ever had" and went back for seconds! They were great to work with throughout the planning.
Vendor response 06/09/2021
We are so happy that everyone loved the cake! We love making your wedding day extra speca...
il! Thank you for choosing us to be a part of it!
Maddie N
5.0
5/04/2021
We just got a small cake for our wedding just for the two of us to cut and eat, and it was perfect! Sarah helped me right away from my email inquiry. We decided on a delicious chocolate cake with strawberry frosting in the middle and vanilla buttercream on the outside. The cake had a simple spatula mark design, and it perfectly matched our simple design with a cake topper and some fake greenery! They were great to work with, and I would highly recommend this shop for any and all desserts!
Andrea R
5.0
3/29/2021
The cake was delicious and they were very easy to work with. We highly recommend them. We choose four different flavors for our wedding and our guest enjoyed all of them. Even with ordering extra we didn’t have much left at the end of the night.
Alison C
5.0
12/09/2020
Delicious and beautiful cake!
Aly B
5.0
11/30/2020
Sarah’s Cake Shop nailed our wedding vision! We had many compliments about how tasty our cupcakes were. Our personal wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Sarah’s worked with us so much the day of the wedding. I highly recommend!
Katie P
5.0
11/04/2020
We got our wedding cake and desserts from Sarah's and I could not be happier that we did! Planning our wedding during COVID felt impossible at times, but Sarah's made everything so simple for us. Everything arrived precisely on time, and their staff was SO easy to work with. The cake was beautiful - exactly what I wanted and had envisioned! We had the PERFECT amount of cake and desserts for everyone at the wedding. By the end of the night, there was almost nothing left - everyone absolutely devoured the food! People were raving about how tasty everything was all night! I would 10000% recommend that any bride looking for a dessert/cake caterer should choose Sarah's. They were perfect for my wedding!
Joana G
5.0
10/30/2020
We got our wedding cake from Sarah's Cake Shop and we will forever get all our desserts from here! Our cake was so beautifully made and tasted so great! All our guests loved it! We were able to do two different flavors so our guests could have options and they honestly loved everything about it. They also placed our flowers on the cake for our decor and we couldn't be happier. You can really trust them to help create the wedding cake you envision!
Megan W
5.0
10/25/2020
2 years ago when my now husband and I first got engaged, he resolutely told me "I want Sarah's Cake Shop for our wedding", it was actually one of the only things he specifically wanted for our wedding throughout all of the planning.
Gotta give it to the man, he knew what he was talking about! We got a cake (the Nicole decorated BEAUTIFULLY) and a dessert bar for our wedding and all of our guests RAVED over it all!
I couldn't have asked for yummier cake and desserts!
Vendor response 10/26/2020
We couldn't be happier to hear that you loved everything about your wedding desserts! We ...
love making your wedding day extra special!
Amanda Z
5.0
10/13/2020
I would just like to say that my husband and I were estatic when we saw our dessert table. We got married this past weekend and it was such a beautiful day. Our cake was AMAZING! We also had mini desserts (caramel apple tarts, gooey butter cake, and cheesecakes) that our guests devoured. We still have guests telling us how amazing the dessert was. We did our tasting back last August and it was such a blast. They made it easy and fun! One thing we love about Sarah's is that they make you a cake on your one year anniversary for free so you don't have to freeze you actual cake and then it actually tastes good. We felt like that was a nice touch. We recommend Sarah's not only for weddings but for any event you have. We know that in the future we will be using them for major life events! You will not be disappointed going with Sarah's Cake Shop!
Monica A
5.0
9/18/2020
Our wedding cake was not only beautiful, it also tasted great too! Strongly recommend!!
Vendor response 09/22/2020
We are so happy you loved your delicious cake!
Meghan B
5.0
9/09/2020
Incredible!! Our cake exceeded our expectations by far!! Nicole was absolutely amazing. Took all our ideas and made a cake that was more than we ever imagined. And so dang delicious! Sarah's cake shop was very accommodating to our massive changes in our guest count. If you want the prettiest and tastiest cake ever you have to see Nicole at Sarah's cake shop!
Emily M
5.0
9/06/2020
We could not have asked for a better or more beautiful cake! Nicole at Sarah’s was so incredibly helpful and listened to exactly everything we wanted. They are so timely with responding, too. Thank you Sarah’s!
Vendor response 09/08/2020
Thank you so much Emily! We love when our clients are happy :)
Lynda S
5.0
8/25/2020
Sarah's Cake Shop is an excellent choice for your wedding cake. During these hard times they were understanding and easy to work with when it came to rescheduling. We had a simple wedding with Harry Potter and Star Wars themes. The decorators at Sarah's did a wonderful job creating a simple yet whimsicaly elegant cake for our special day. We would recommend them as time, and the flavors are delicious!
Vendor response 08/26/2020
Thank you so much Lynda! I always love making a Harry Potter cake, but yours was very uni...
que with the galaxy swags! So cool!
Susie H
5.0
8/13/2020
Sarah’s cake shop was so fun and easy to work with! I loved trying their cakes, mixing and matching different flavors. We chose a vanilla/chocolate/swirl cake with strawberry jam and champagne butter cream for our main wedding cake, then a red velvet cake for our grooms cake. Sarah’s made our cake exactly how we wanted it to look. I could not get over how delicious it was!
Vendor response 08/17/2020
Thank you! We loved being a part of your special day! The design you picked was truly el...
egant, and we loved making your beautiful wedding cake!
Brittany H
5.0
7/14/2020
Replanning our wedding was a nightmare! We changed our date and had just over a week to find a new cake place as our original one was already booked for the new date. Sarah's Cake Shop came to the rescue and designed us a beautiful cake that tasted incredible! All of our guests were ranting about how delicious the cake was. The cake was everything we could have wanted!
Vendor response 07/14/2020
We are so glad we were able help! This has been a crazy wedding planning time for so man...
y couples, and we are just happy to make this time a little less stressful for you! We always love being a part of your special day!
Thank you for your kind words!
Kayla D