About this vendor
Simply Frosted by Mackenzie specializes in all things cake for every celebration! We use the freshest quality and source locally grown ingredients to fulfill each recipe. The foundation for our cakes originate with recipes from the kitchens of Mackenzie's mom and grandmothers. Each cake is a beautifully crafted work of art with tastes of love folded throughout the batter.
Based in Cincinnati, OH, Simply Frosted by Mackenzie creates customized cakes for weddings and other special events. Owner Mackenzie has always found joy while baking and loves sharing her passion and creativity with couples to enhance their special day. From cake jar desserts to cupcakes and three-tiered masterpieces, Mackenzie combines delicious flavors with elegant designs. Whether you are looking for a stunning centerpiece or small treats to delight your guests, Simply Frosted can help you spread sweet joy at your celebration.
After a consultation, Mackenzie begins your custom cake design. You will have the chance to taste the cake in private and make adjustments necessary for your event. Her recipes are flexible and can suit gluten-free, lactose-free, or vegan guests.
Details
Business Attributes
- Black-owned Business
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Cutting & Serving
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Cupcakes
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Nut Free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.3
out of 5.06 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 6
We eloped and had a small cake made. It was a beautiful! We traveled 10 hours with it and it had no issues whatsoever. It also tasted amazing!
Our wedding was 3-15-24. The taste of the cake itself was amazing. My wife and I went with a classic white cake with vanilla bean frosting. Also, the delivery was very timely.
The...
issue with our cake was that the upper portion of the design/formwork, as well as the texture, was way off from the inspiration photos we presented. We were never given any heads up that the cake we received would vary in appearance to the degree that it did.
We intentionally chose a very contemporary, minimal, and simply designed cake, and we were severely shocked, confused, and let down at the results.
A number of individuals at our wedding ridiculed the cake itself, as it sat directly adjacent to the bride/groom dinner table.
We reached out in order to get some kind of explanation as to why the execution was so far off, and unfortunately we were ghosted with no response whatsoever.
We intentionally chose Simply Frosted because of our love and support for small Black businesses; we were greatly disheartened with what we received.
Please see the inspiration photo given to Simply Frosted, and what was provided to us attached below.
Mackenzie went over and above with our wedding cakes. I have a gluten and dairy allergy and am used to having just a few sad options when it comes to cakes. Mackenzie experimented ...
and created 4(!!) different gluten and dairy free cakes for us to taste!! And they were all delicious! We ended up ordering three of them for the wedding and the guests loved them. Mackenzie is another class of baker, our minds were blown.
Mackenzie was the most thoughtful kind person ever. I gave her a few ideas and she ran with it. I was in awe the day of my wedding to see how beautiful my cake looked. Mackenzie’s ...
cakes are so delicious. By the end of the night there wasn’t any for me to take home! I highly suggest working with Mackenzie not only for her amazing cakes but her wonderful personality.
Mackenzie delivered! It was such a wonderful experience working with her to capture the vision of my cake for my engagement party. She delivered the cake right on time and I was in...
absolute awe once I saw it! The flavor was everything and more; the guests were quick to tell me how amazing the cake was. Highly recommend and we will be working with her again.
I have hired Mackenzie in the past, to make custom cake jars with my company logo. She made 150 of them, packed them on ice, drove them from Harrisburg, PA to Cleveland, made sig...
ns to distinguish the different flavors and set them up. She is creative and professional. Her smile and personality is only shadowed by her amazing baking skills!
It goes without saying that when I found out she was here that I would seek her out to do our most special day! You will never be disappointed in Mackenzie!
Contact
Central PA and Greater Cincinnati/Cbus
Simply Frosted by Mackenzie