Ocean Isle Beach Wedding Cakes

Spilt Milk

Gourmet Donuts, Cupcakes, Wedding Cakes, Gelato
4.8 out of 5 stars and 6 reviews
·
Ocean Isle Beach, NC

About this vendor

Vendor
Nancy
MANAGER
2023 Best of Weddings Winner
AWARD WINNER
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Based in Ocean Isle Beach, NC, Spilt Milk is a beloved local cafe specializing in wedding cakes, gourmet donuts, cupcakes, gelato, and many more treats. If you're seeking an eye-widening dessert display filled to the brim with delectable treats, this bakery would love to help. Offering a variety of decadent desserts sure to delight your guests, your sweet dreams can be made a reality with this fantastic business. Spilt Milk was founded by James Lane, an experienced business owner who wanted to brighten his local community with delicious treats. With a focus on gourmet donuts and desserts, quality gelato/ice cream, and amazing coffee, James and his team strive to bring a smile to every customer. They would be honored to help bring your vision to life for your special day with a scrumptious display of treats and a custom wedding cake. If you're looking for bespoke donuts and other amazing treats for your wedding, then you're in luck. Spilt Milk is more than happy to personalize orders to match themes and personalities and will listen closely to your desires. Some tasty temptations you can purchase include cupcakes, wedding cakes, gourmet donuts, desserts, and gelato.
5+ years in business
Speaks English, Spanish
Small team (2-10 members)
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Cutting & Serving
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Awards and Affiliations
2023 Best of Weddings Winner
Circle Message
Any questions?
Meet the team
Vendor
Danielle
General Manager
I'm Danielle, a passionate baker specializing in custom orders. I love transforming visions into delicious realities! Creating sweet treats that are delicious and beautiful, let's talk about your dream dessert table!
Reviews
4.8
out of 5.0
6 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review photos
AvatarH
Highlighted review.
11/06/2022
We picked Vicky and Spilt Milk to provide our wedding cake and donuts for brunch the following day, and would definitely recommend them to anyone else! The cake was exactly what we...
were looking for, it tasted great and was also beautiful. We also added cupcakes to have different flavors, we picked 3 different flavors and they were a huge hit! Everyone at the wedding kept talking about how good the desserts were. The donuts the following day were a perfect addition to brunch. They were tasty and decorated to have a bride and groom theme. Whenever we go back to Ocean Isle to visit we always go back to Spilt Milk to get a treat. We definitely recommend to anyone planning a wedding or any event! Vicky is super easy to work with and will accommodate any requests!
Response from Spilt Milk on 11/07/2022
Hi Heather and Jeff, you were such an amazing couple to work with. I really appreciated yo...
ur clear vision for your wedding and loved being a part of your momentous wedding day as well as your first day as a married couple. We love when you come back to see us! I hope you have another trip planned soon! Vicky
AvatarB
10/28/2025
For my wedding I ordered a single tier vanilla cake with cream cheese frosting and a dozen donuts. The cake and donuts were absolutely delicious! I was however, a little disappoint...
ed with the design of the cake. I sent reference pictures stating that I wanted a color fade of blues to look like waves (similar to other review pics I’d seen) but got a single color blue that was sloppily done. I also did not want “sand” on the cake which I stated at the in person meeting but that was added too. The donuts came out beautifully so I can’t complain there but I was not 100% happy with how the cake turned out.
Circle Message
Any questions?
AvatarP
10/24/2022
We were on vacation this year at OIB and stumbled upon Spilt Milk. From their donuts to their coffee everything we’ve had was great. My husband and I decided to use them as our des...
sert caterer since neither of us love traditional wedding cake. I reached out to them while on vacation and then a couple months before the wedding I spoke with Vicky (who is amazing btw) and she created the most beautiful donut arrangement for our wedding. She was always super responsive and so helpful during the planning process. So many of my guests raved about them. I couldn’t of been happier with how they turned out. We will definitely visit every time we come back to OIB.
Response from Spilt Milk on 10/24/2022
Thank you so much! It was such a pleasure working with you. I appreciated all of your inp...
ut and sharing your vision so I could make it happen. I hope to see you again very soon!
AvatarA
10/08/2022
It was just pure fate that we were able to find Spilt Milk, and my husband and I are eternally glad that we did. Words cannot express how grateful we are to have met Vicky and enjo...
yed the services provided. We had planned an event for the day before the wedding as well as the day after, and we made the right choice with Spilt Milk. From the flexibility, to the choices and freedom for customization, and the quality of the products, we would choose Spilt Milk over and over again. Not only that, we've gained a lifetime friend. Thank you so much Vicky for everything!!!!
Response from Spilt Milk on 10/08/2022
It was absolutely my pleasure! I can't wait to see you all again!
AvatarK
10/08/2022
They were Amazing. They set up and cleaned up. Their products are awesome!! There is none better. Great job!
Response from Spilt Milk on 10/08/2022
Thank you so much for your kind words... we aim to please! Please stop in soon for some m...
ore treats!
AvatarK
10/08/2022
Christopher and I love spilt milk we hired them for our wedding and it was absolutely amazing from the tasting to the special day!! Everyone raved how delicious the cake was and Vi...
cky is amazing!!! Definitely recommend them for any event 🤗😁
Response from Spilt Milk on 10/08/2022
Kaitlyn and Christopher, you were both so much fun and a pleasure to work with. I loved m...
eeting with you and then meeting your entire family and friend crew! I hope to see you a lot in the future!

Service area & Contact info

120 Causeway Dr., Ocean Isle Beach, NC
120 Causeway Dr., Ocean Isle Beach, NC
Open map
Travel area: Within 50 miles
Additional charges may apply
Vendor Logo
Circle Message
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
meet the owner
Spilt Milk
Nancy
|
Manager
My wedding date is flexible

Wedding vendors in Ocean Isle Beach

Ocean Isle Beach Bridal Salons
Ocean Isle Beach Beauty Salons
Ocean Isle Beach Caterers
Ocean Isle Beach DJs
Ocean Isle Beach Florists
Ocean Isle Beach Reception Venues
Ocean Isle Beach Videographers
Ocean Isle Beach Wedding Bands
Ocean Isle Beach Wedding Photographers
Ocean Isle Beach Wedding Planners
  1. Wedding Vendors
    /
  2. Wedding Cakes
    /
  3. North Carolina Wedding Cakes
    /
  4. Ocean Isle Beach Wedding Cakes
    /
Spilt Milk
Spilt Milk's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

  • Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
  • Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
  • Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
  • For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.