About this vendor
Since 1990 we’ve earned our reputation as the premier catering source with fresh ideas and creative
design. A party for every budget! Voted best caterer in Grand Lake. Stone Creek catering will elevate
your tastes while sharing your best ideas from the beginning through “I do”!
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.7
out of 5.013 reviews
Carey and her team were amazing at our wedding. Their buffet set up was beautiful and the food was absolutely delicious! Many of our guests commented on the meal and my husband and...
I both loved it. Carey was very easy to work with and is extremely knowledgeable and talented at what she does. Thank you so much, Carey and team for such a wonderful experience!
I really loved working with Carey for my son's rehearsal dinner in Granby, Co. She made great suggestions for the venue itself as well as for the food choices. Planning a rehears...
al dinner from out of state is very challenging. My trust in Carey and her team was not misplaced! The fajitas we had were amazing as were the dessert donuts. Fabulous food and presentation in every way. Thank you for a beautiful evening!
Planning a wedding from 800 miles from home comes with many challenges. Working with Carey at Stone Creek Catering was NOT one of the them. She was wonderful! She stayed in contact...
with us through the entire planning process. On the wedding day we worked with Baja, Tina & Sabrie….they were so sweet and took great care of us. The food has great! Our guest were very happy. At kind of the last minute I contacted Carey about adding brownies as a dessert choice (the bride’s favorite). OMG….they were amazing!!! If you are planning a wedding or any event that you would hire a caterer for in the Grand Lake area, I highly recommend Stone Creek. You won’t be disappointed! Thank you Carey and team for helping make our daughter’s wedding so special!
Carey and her assistant Baja made our wedding dreams a reality. Carey was our caterer and Baja was her assistant/our day of wedding coordinator - their work as a team made our day ...
possible. Every detail of the food was amazing, from the hors-d'oeuvres, to the multi course dinner, to the cocktails. Our guests are still raving over their meal and the professionalism in the Stone Creek Catering staff.
Carey and Baja were able to thoroughly assist us in planning a wedding at a venue not typically used for indoor weddings. They not only organized all of the catering, but all of the rentals as well, and offered us extensive planning advice from their years of experience. We couldn't recommend them more. Thank you, Carey and Baja, for everything! We look forward to coming back to your restaurant to visit someday!
Stone Creek Catering is absolutely amazing! We had our wedding in August at the Daven Haven Lodge, catered by Stone Creek Catering. We met with Carey several times leading up to ...
our wedding and we were still blown away by the service and food on our special day. Appetizers and dinner were delicious, but the highlight was dessert! We had ice cream cookie wiches, key lime pie shooters, and a key lime cake. Several people told us the cake was the best cake of their lives. In addition to the delectable food, Carey took care to present and display everything with our wedding style. We could not be happier with our experience with Stone Creek Catering. Will definitely have them cater our Anniversary Party.
Carey and her staff at Stone Creek were great! Not only was the food delicious, but her and her staff were so kind, professional, and easy to work with. We hired them for our rehea...
rsal dinner and wedding dinner, and both were delicious. We had a BBQ set up for the rehearsal, and it was fantastic. The salmon cakes and the Brussel sprouts were my favorite on our wedding. We also hired a bartender from Stone Creek, which was a great help. Really, I can't say enough about Carey and her crew. She was very responsive and helpful during the planning phase (and we certainly had a lot of questions / back and forth with her). The day of she was right on time and was super patient with us as we changed the set up on her last minute. Thank you Carey and crew! So glad we decided on Stone Creek!
Carey and the Stone Creek Catering team are the best of the best.
We live in Pennsylvania and were married in Grand Lake, Colorado in September 2020. Despite the hurdles COVID thr...
ew at our wedding planning process, Carey and her team went above and beyond for us and executed an absolutely perfect wedding experience.
The decor was better than my wildest dreams and the food was delicious. We are still dreaming of the prime rib and twice baked potatoes....
I would recommend Stone Creek Catering to anyone!
Carey, Baja, and staff were incredible! They created the most beautiful setup for both our Rehearsal Dinner and Wedding! The food was delicious and the decor they provided was am...
azing! Stone Creek Catering helped make our day amazing!
Stone Creek Catering was great! They have many different options for food that really cater to everyone's different tastes. We opted for their Mexican buffet, as we wanted a more ...
casual, laid back feel. The food was delicious - we got many compliments. Their set up was beautiful and really fit in with our theme. The staff that worked the reception was so helpful and friendly. The price was quite reasonable and affordable - compared to other local caterers. For anyone getting married in or around Grand Lake, CO....highly recommend.
We planned our CO wedding from out of state and Carey and her team couldn’t have made it a better experience. From the planning process to the day of everything was perfect. The st...
aff did an incredible job of setting up a beautiful display and were very helpful throughout our entire event. We had several guests comment on how the food was “the best wedding food” they have ever tasted. Hands down best caterer around! Highly recommend.
Food was fantastic for our wedding - appetizers, dinner and dessert! My husband said it was one of the best carrot cakes he’s ever had and that’s saying a lot. Everyone LOVED the f...
ood and Baja/team did such a great job with service the day of. They did a great job of accommodating me being gluten free and the kids. Carrie also had some great recommendations with other vendors that we wouldn’t have found otherwise. We really appreciated all the efforts!
Stone creek catering seems to have a monopoly over catering in the Grand Lake area.
We found it difficult to find an alternative caterer, and despite previous bad reviews we had ...
read, we went ahead and have to say, I regret not putting in the extra effort to find an alternative.
Carey is unresponsive and doesn't seem to have a system in place to track her communication with customers. This meant we spent a lot of time repeating conversations which caused a lot of needless stress and anxiety leading up to and on the actual wedding day.
One small example: A week before the wedding, Carey came back to us saying that she was alarmed that there were no chairs at the venue. We had actually discussed this four months prior and she had even promised us some chairs on the day! She told us a few days out that those chairs were no longer available. In the end she was able to locate some, but we would be charged for these (unlike the original ones we were promised that came with no cost).
I had no idea when the catering team was arriving on the wedding day (imagine, I am calling whilst getting my make-up done to see where they are) and when I inquired about this and other basic questions, I was met with outright hostility.
I suspect that the uneven reviews on here and elsewhere reflect the fact that Stone Creek are just taking on so much work and cannot provide consistent service. We, unfortunately, got them at the end of a busy month.
I gave two stars because once they arrived, her staff delivered a great and attentive service. Although I must mention, that the entree fish was overcooked and vegetables looked like they had been reheated in a microwave.
Recommendation to Stone Creeek to invest in systems and processes to track comms and/or empower your staff to manage communications with your clients.
We planned our small wedding (25ppl) in Grand Lake all the way from Philly and I was in amazing hands the entire time. Carey at Stone Creek was friendly, knowledgeable, and very re...
sponsive...not to mention adaptable and full of amazing ideas! Her expertise shows! She even went above and beyond bringing decorations and setting up beautiful table arrangements. The food was very tasty and her staff was on point. Seamless night that was made even more special by the great service and warmth Carey's team provided.
Contact
604 Marina Dr, Grand Lake, CO
Stone Creek Catering