Sugar Divas Cakery

Best of Weddings (2x)

25 West Crystal Lake Street, Suite 172, Orlando, FL

About this vendor

Sugar Divas Cakery provides custom wedding cakes from their location in Orlando, FL. Open since 2014, this family-owned business is dedicated to giving happy couples delicious creations to dig into on their special day. Your leading cake and dessert station can be left in the hands of this team of dedicated bakers. Owner Clare Otto has had a passion for sweet treats since age 13, and is dedicated to giving her clients their ideal flavors and designs. Her team consists of bakers and cake artists, which will happily create your ideal wedding cake based on you and your partner’s favorite tastes. They will use your reception theme and personality as their main source of inspiration to make your favorite baked goods. Sugar Divas Cakery offers engaged couples complimentary tastings, which champagne to cleanse their palate and ease their nerves. You will have a variety of combinations to choose from for your wedding cake, ranging from classic strawberry to Amaretto Raspberry. They can also provide vegan and gluten free options to ensure all your guests can enjoy your delectable creations. They will deliver your desserts to your venue location, and handle setup to make sure everything looks their absolute best.

Details

Business Attributes

Woman-owned Business

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts

Dietary Options

Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Vegan

Awards and Affiliations

5

out of 5.0

29 reviews

Search reviews

3/21/2025 • Kristen S

Sugar Divas was a fantastic choice for our wedding cake. The cake came out beautiful and just as I wanted, and was even more delicious than I expected. They were also super easy to work with. We purchased multiple tasting kits with custom flavors and it was easy to order and pick it up. They were also great to work with when it came to designing the cake, following up with us whenever they weren't sure what we wanted. They delivered it to our venue, which is just outside of Orlando, with no issues. Their tasting samples were all delicious, and we ended up going with a creamsicle cake with lemon filling and vanilla buttercream. The cake on the day of was even better, you can see in the picture I posted I immediately went for another bite haha. I'm glad we got extra servings because we were able to keep the top tier, and have been freezing slices for later (it defrosts well too!).

4/17/2024 • Chelsea C

This cake was perfect. Fully Gluten-Free for my daughter as she is Celiac and didn't want her to miss out on any of it. We choose the top tier Chocolate Mint and the bottom Raspberry Rose, both were sooooo good. The cake was moist and the icing wasn't sickly sweet like lots of Gluten-free cakes are. The design was perfect for what I was looking for.

12/29/2023 • Richard S

We had a great experience using Sugar Divas Cakery for our wedding. We were able to get a quote through phone/email after describing what we wanted and showing inspiration photos. We loved the cake tasting experience which has a small fee but gets used towards the total if you decide to place an order. We decided in the end to order a small simple white cake, which we decorated with our own florals. Everyone we spoke to was so kind and easy to work with, and we’re so happy we ordered through them.

10/06/2023 • Kristen P

Sugar Divas provided the most delicious cake for our wedding, as many of our guests raved about it! I've never had a wedding cake that I genuinely enjoyed until I had my own - this is the best place to get your wedding cake!

4/03/2023 • Pamela D

Sugar Divas was wonderful to work with for our wedding cake - we did a to-go tasting which was very helpful with our crazy schedules and allowed us to select a few flavors and try them all at home. In the end we chose the champagne and berries cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream frosting - sooo good! I emailed inspiration pictures and explained what I wanted decoration-wise, we had a phone call to discuss everything and make sure we were on the same page. I felt like we were in good hands and the cake tasted amazing. We had several guests tell us they don't usually like cake, but they loved this one!

2/06/2023 • Jennifer A

Wow! Sugar Divas made my wedding cake, and it was PERFECT. It looked *exactly* like the inspiration photo I sent them, and it tasted like PERFECTION. The entire process was so easy and simple, and they made it so much fun. I will recommend them to any and everyone I know for their special cakes! They also do an anniversary cake on your first wedding anniversary so you don’t have to save the top tier if you don’t want to! Simply amazing!!!

10/13/2022 • Emmy T

We booked Sugar Divas Cakery for our wedding at the Orlando Science Center on 8/6/2022. The cake was flavorful and moist, even a week later after we indulged in some left overs! We would recommend reaching out to the bakery at least 2 months early to ensure they have availability for your date; they’re very responsive both by email and by phone. I needed to provide updates to the design 2 weeks before our date and they were very accommodating and flexible. The flavors we had were coconut cake with pineapple filling; amaretto raspberry cake with strawberry filling; and champagne and berries with cream cheese filling. We also had them make a mock up of our dog and cat peeking out from under the second tier, which was a fun element to add! We paid for the delivery fee, which is 100% worth it to not have to stress about whether or not the cake will make it to the venue in one piece. Overall, if you would pay for unique flavors and fun designs for your wedding cake, we would definitely recommend Sugar Divas Cakery!

10/10/2022 • Gabriel G

Wow. Every single bit of our wedding’s dessert bar from Sugar Divas was gone within the hour! It was a huge hit! Sugar Divas was such a fantastic dessert vendor for our wedding. It was easy to schedule our extremely fun tasting. They are the only vendor that offered yummy blueberry cake as a possible flavor, which was immediately very persuasive over our other options, but then we received their quote and that was the icing on the cake. Easily the best price for what we wanted, and it included delivery and set-up. They were easy to book for the date with only a small deposit. We got mini cupcakes and cake pops for the guests, and a small cake for the bride and groom. Everything was so beautiful and delicious! Thank you so much to the Sugar Divas team for helping make our wedding so scrumptious!

5/10/2022 • Alexandra V

Oh. My. Gosh. If I could give 10 extra stars I would… I struggled finding a bakery that was available for my wedding date and that had flavors we liked. Not only was I able to book this vendor pretty last minute (about 2 weeks in advance) but the flavors we chose were amazing! The cake looked almost exactly like the inspiration photo we gave and it was fully intact upon delivery; that may not be super impressive to some people but I was definitely worried about the 40ish miles it had to travel in pretty trafficy areas. Overall, I highly recommend this bakery for weddings or any other event that you would like a cake for! We got the champagne and berries with strawberry filling and vanilla buttercream/ marble with white buttercream options for different tiers.

3/14/2022 • Jessica H

I loved they way our cake turned out for our wedding! We live abroad and never did any tasting. The cake was so much better than I could have wished for and the design was lovely! Would highly recommend them for a wedding cake!

3/04/2022 • Sarah R

Our wedding cake was so beautiful and delicious! Sugar Divas was so great to work with and they created a cake more beautiful than we imagined.

2/19/2022 • Alice M

Throughout the months of planning our December wedding, the people at Sugar Divas were always there to answer our questions and were exceptional throughout the entire process. Our 3-tier wedding cake (red velvet, chocolate, vanilla) was delicious, and our guests had nothing but great things to say about the cake. Sugar Divas were also able to put a figurine of our dog on the 2nd tier of the cake, and we were extremely pleased with the result. Thanks Sugar Divas

1/03/2022 • Chelsey C

Incredible! Stunning! Delicious!! We were blown away by our wedding cake. We wanted something that went with our nerd/fandom theme and Sugar Divas delivered. It was exactly the way we pictured when we ordered it! On top of looking amazing, it tasted absolutely delicious. Super fresh and full of flavor. All of their flavors we tried were so great it was hard to decide, but really with any flavor you can’t go wrong. The staff was so helpful in getting the design we wanted and the process was super easy. We can’t wait to order another cake from them in the future!

12/22/2021 • Carol S

I showed them a photo of the design of the wedding cake I wanted and they made it happen! not only was it beautiful but it was also delicious!! The guests complimented it too. Her cost was reasonable in comparison to other cake vendors so I was pleased! They are also located near the wedding venue, Cypress Grove Estate House where we got married.

8/10/2021 • Sara D

Sugar Divas Cakery was amazing!! My husband and I were looking to have a variety of different designs and elements to our wedding cake that represents our nerdy side, and they were able to incorporate everything we wanted and more! That cake was even better then we had envisioned and had all the details we wanted. The staff was very invested in listening to our request and were able to accommodate our requests on short notice as well! Amazing team highly recommend, especially if you want something customized!

7/15/2021 • Michelle D

Sugar Divas Cakery I simply the best! We had ordered 2 cakes previously from them, so it was a simple decision to have them make our wedding cake! The cake and icing sampling was amazing! I sent them my pic of my cake inspiration and they nailed it! It was beautiful! The team is always so nice and helpful! You will not be disappointed!!!

6/15/2021 • Keshaye C

We are from Oklahoma but I ordered a cake for my daughters Disney birthday trip. We went with a Minnie mouse cake with a bow for my daughters 2nd birthday. She was so excited when she seen the cake! Everyone was so nice over the phone and super nice and friendly when we met in person. Since it was an out of state cake order I didn’t know what to expect but it was perfect! We shall return!

5/27/2021 • Courtney T

My son was married April 10th down in Orlando. My husband and I were able to do the cake testing as he and his fiance were not able to make it down. Yay, for us! It was SO GOOD! Our favorite was the French toast cake. Oh, my word, it was amazing. We used this one for the top tier of the cake. I highly recommend Sugar Divas.

5/26/2021 • Jessiann M

I booked a trip to Florida For my husbands birthday and I was trying to find a place to make a very specific custom cake. I was so blessed to come across Sugar Divas Cakery!! Not only was the cake just as I requested but it also tasted soooo good!!!! I highly recommend this place. They made my trip complete. Thank you!!

5/25/2021 • Erika C

Tasting was more than we expected, they took the time to explain all details, draw a sketch tailored to our desires. We took flowers and they placed them perfectly on our cake.

5/04/2021 • Jodi D

I have got several custom cakes from Sugar Divas and most importantly the taste is amazing. Absolutely delicious. They always take my idea and bring it to life. Everything is always perfect. I have never had a fondant covered cake that taste as good as Sugar Divas and we have had several flavors. You won't regret it!

4/26/2021 • Sabrina S

OMG!!! Words cannot describe one how BEAUTIFUL my daughter‘s 18th birthday cake was, you can tell they took their time putting the details of her personality cake… not only did her cake look AMAZING! it smelled even better and the flavors were so delicious..! Sugar Divas Cakery will be making a lot more cakes for us in the future!

4/18/2021 • Brian C

We had a custom made cake as a surprise and had some design notes (it was a twist on Disney). It came out beautifully -- the service and communication before and after picking up the cake was incredible. The cake designer did research on my concept and sent me several ideas which only made it better. They have a professional and personal interest in making sure they produce the best work - and it shows. The cake was a hit, I would recommend highly

4/08/2021 • Donna P

Delicious!!! I used to pass this bakery when I was out and about and would marvel at their beautiful cakes. I think we tried every combination of cake flavors and fillings you could try, thanks to their cupcakes they have daily. We decided on a three layer cake with a different flavor on each layer and one was more delicious than the next. I did not think a wedding with 70 guests would go through a cake for 100 but I sadly realized I only went gone with a few slices I asked for them to put aside for us. We loved the cake, our guests loved the cake. Not only was it beautiful it was delicious. The ladies there were so attentive and helpful, going over all the different options and sizes and allowing me to change my mind to make sure we got it perfect.

3/12/2021 • James L

Me and my fiance like to do fun things for specific holidays this year she surprised me with cupcakes that were x-rated and she set a bar I cannot say what they were but they were 12 cupcakes and they spelled out a specific four-letter word and it also said the words best of so I decided to one up her and I decided to call a couple bakeries to see if they would be able to do any x-rated cupcakes and or cake could not find any until I called sugar divas not only were they able to make what I requested but they went above and beyond I was highly impressed my fiance was extremely happy with them and the cupcakes were fabulous I will definitely use them again for the next time I want to do something crazy I highly recommend them and they do more than just x-rated stuff let me just throw that out there but I highly recommend them You will be extremely satisfied I know I was

1/21/2021 • Bexy F

I order a Transformers cake for my 3 year olds birthday party. They accommodate me at the last minute when ordering the cake. My son is allergic to eggs & finding a bakery that customize in vegan cakes and it still taste amazing can be hard, I was overly thankful that I found Sugar Divas Cakery. My cake was beautiful & so yummyyyyy!!!!!! I couldn’t be more happy with my son’s cake & cupcakes!

1/16/2021 • Adanma F

Everything was great from beginning to end. Our cake tasting was a wonderful experience and in the creative process they captured my unique ideas for our wedding cake and cupcake designs. A year later we’re looking forward to eating our complimentary anniversary cake because I still remember how amazing our cake tasted. Some of the best cake I’ve ever had.