Sweet Tooth Baking Company

Serving Wedding Cakes from Lake Tahoe to the Bay

Travel area: Within 100 miles See details

5.0

Verified reviews from real couples

Grace is such a sweetheart (no pun intended)! She was amazing to work with and was incredibly responsive and communicative. The cake she designed us was SO cute, fun and bright and totally met the vision. It felt like she really understood us. Other than the cake being beautiful it was SO good. You can really tell that she uses high quality ingredients. The buttercream was perfectly sweet and the cake was moist and flavourful and lasted a surprisingly long time. We opted for one of the premium fillings of pistachio and it was REAL pistachio flavour (not the fake one) and as a pistachio lover 10/10. I think about this cake daily. Grace, you rule I only wish I had an excuse to have your cake every day. Thank you for making this part of our wedding day so easy, fun, and tasty!

Natalie K.

5.0

Grace did an absolutely fantastic job on mine and my new husband's wedding cake!! She was so patient, kind, and made sure to get every detail perfect. We got red velvet with salted caramel filling, and it was DELICIOUS!! I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Baking Company for any and all of your desserts at events!!

Bree B.

5.0

Grace Colla

EXECUTIVE CHEF AND CEO

Typically responds within 24h

AWARD WINNER

Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot

Sweet Tooth Baking Company is a professional wedding cake bakery in lovely Grass Valley, CA. Your wedding treats will be carefully crafted by expert baker Grace, who brings years of experience and a personalized touch to your big day. Grace is originally from San Francisco and has loved baking since her early childhood, when she would make delicious desserts for her classmates. In 2023, after designing and baking her own wedding cake, she decided to pursue her passion on a full-time basis. Before your special day, she'll meet with you to ensure you receive a showstopping cake that matches your budget and vision. Your desserts with Sweet Tooth Baking Company will be handcrafted, made using the finest ingredients such as homemade vanilla extract and fresh local fruits. Grace can create anything from dozens of cupcakes to custom-designed, multi-tiered cakes that can feed over 150 guests. Guests will rave about the sweet treats from Sweet Tooth Baking Company long after you've said, "I do."

LGBTQ+-owned and Woman-owned Business

21+ years in business

Speaks English

Just me

Details

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Accessories

Cake Stands

Cake Toppers

Cake Cutting & Serving

Cake Delivery & Setup

Cake Tastings

Cupcakes

Groom's Cakes

Other Desserts

Dietary Options

Gluten Free

Vegetarian

Awards and Affiliations

2026 'Best of Weddings'

Join couples who chose award-winning vendors for their wedding

Meet the team

Grace Colla

Executive Chef and CEO

I am the face behind Sweet Tooth Baking Company! A little bit about me- I was born & raised by my two mom's in San Francisco & then lived in beautiful Lake Tahoe for 10 years where I met my partner, Brian. I've been baking since I was 3 years old and Sweet Tooth was created when I started selling cakes in the 5th grade. Cakes are 100% my passion & nothing brings me more joy than portraying each couples unique love through cake. I LOVE love & weddings & will 100% be your hype girl on your special day!

5.0

out of 5.0

12 reviews

Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Review Summary

This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.

Reviewers rave that Sweet Tooth Baking Company delivers stunning, customizable cakes and cupcakes that match couples' visions. The desserts are moist and flavorful with high-quality buttercream and real fillings (like pistachio), and guests loved the taste. The baker is responsive, professional, budget-friendly, and reliable with delivery.

Search reviews

Lucas K

Highlighted review.

5/21/2025

We recently had the pleasure of working with Gracie at Sweet Tooth Baking Company for my wedding cake, and I cannot express how thrilled we were with the entire experience! From ou...

r first meeting with her, it was clear that she was dedicated to creating something truly special for us. The customization options were fantastic, and Gracie took the time to understand our vision and how important the cake was to us. The cake not only looked stunning, but it also tasted absolutely divine. Each layer was a delightful blend of flavors that left our guests raving about it long after the reception. She worked with our budget and made the most incredible cake/cupcake set up I could’ve imagined. We received so many compliments from our friends and family, with many claiming it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted! Gracie truly exceeded our expectations, making our special day even sweeter. I wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone looking for a talented and creative baker who will go above and beyond to make your dream cake a reality. Thank you, Gracie for being such an integral part of our celebration!

Natalie K

7/08/2026

Grace is such a sweetheart (no pun intended)! She was amazing to work with and was incredibly responsive and communicative. The cake she designed us was SO cute, fun and bright an...

d totally met the vision. It felt like she really understood us. Other than the cake being beautiful it was SO good. You can really tell that she uses high quality ingredients. The buttercream was perfectly sweet and the cake was moist and flavourful and lasted a surprisingly long time. We opted for one of the premium fillings of pistachio and it was REAL pistachio flavour (not the fake one) and as a pistachio lover 10/10. I think about this cake daily. Grace, you rule I only wish I had an excuse to have your cake every day. Thank you for making this part of our wedding day so easy, fun, and tasty!

Any questions?

Bree B

7/01/2026

Grace did an absolutely fantastic job on mine and my new husband's wedding cake!! She was so patient, kind, and made sure to get every detail perfect. We got red velvet with salted...

caramel filling, and it was DELICIOUS!! I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Baking Company for any and all of your desserts at events!!

Logan T

4/21/2026

Sweet Tooth Baking Company did an incredible job with our wedding cake. They created a beautiful two-tier cake that was not only stunning to look at but absolutely delicious. We ch...

ose two different flavors, and both were a huge hit with our guests—people are still talking about how good it was! Their attention to detail and ability to bring our vision to life really stood out. The cake was a perfect centerpiece and truly elevated the whole experience. We’re so grateful for their work and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for both style and flavor!

Katie D

4/05/2026

Gracie absolutely went above and beyond with our cake. I had a vision for a 4ft long statement cake, and she turned it into a full-on work of art. It was one of those pieces that ...

stops people in their tracks, I was hearing comments about how stunning it was all night long. Not only was it beautiful, but the execution, detail, and creativity were next level. If you’re looking for someone who can take a bold idea and absolutely nail it, Gracie is your girl.

Fantasia J

11/11/2025

Grace was so sweet and professional, working with me until my dream cake was a reality. She added in a lot of personal touches, and made the wedding day easy at a reasonable price....

She was wonderful! And the cake was delicious made with fresh high end ingredients.

Tara D

9/23/2025

We absolutely loved our wedding cake! Grace was wonderful to work with and took the time to go back and forth with us to make sure the design matched exactly what we had envisioned...

. The cake turned out gorgeous and tasted even better than we imagined. Everything was perfect, and we’re so grateful to Grace for bringing our vision to life.

Molly C

9/03/2025

Gracie did SUCH an amazing job with our wedding cake! It was beautiful in aesthetic as well as absolutely DELICIOUS. It couldn’t have been more perfect. It was exactly what we had ...

asked for!! She always answered our questions in a timely manner when we had them, and was just the absolute best. Her vanilla cake with cookies n’ cream buttercream was to die for. Her service from the day of the quote through the day of the wedding was exceptional . I’m glad that we had some leftovers to enjoy for a while. If you are wondering who to hire for your desserts for any occasion, you should choose Sweet Tooth Baking Company. Thank you SO much again Gracie!!

Kelsey R

8/12/2025

I am not a big cake person and when I thought of a sweetheart cake, I wasn't too excited about it so I was trying to think of other options. Until I tried some of Grace's cakes at ...

a styled shoot....I knew she had to be the one to create something for my wedding day! She has so many flavor options and it's so much fun to mix and match. You can tell she puts so much heart not only in to the baking, but the decorating as well. She executed my vision so beautifully, we almost felt bad cutting in to it! It tasted just as good as it looked. Thank you so much for contributing to our special day Grace! Everyone was in awe of what you created :)

Emerson J

6/21/2025

Grace made my husband and i’s cake for our wedding and it was the most delicious and gorgeous cake we’ve ever seen and tasted! We talk about it at least once a day! 😍Not only is s...

he incredibly talented she’s the most genuine, personal, and kind person you’ll ever meet! Look no further for your cake artist, Grace will make all of your dessert dreams come true! 🤍

Orlee M

6/02/2025

Grace is the best. She makes a stressful decision of choosing a cake fun! Grace is so knowledgeable about options and if you are lost, like we were, can recommend what she thinks w...

ill work best. The cakes are not only perfect and gorgeous, but they taste incredible. We ate the top (after freezing, thawing) on our first anniversary and it was just as good, maybe even better? She asks the right questions and figures out the details that matter with the couple or the planner so that the cake will arrive in perfect shape, whatever the weather may hold. And she's just a fun person to work with. Can't recommend her enough!

stephanie j

5/30/2025

Gracie made our wedding cupcakes, and they were a huge hit! She is very responsive, professional and creative. She made us each our favorite flavors of cupcakes and delivered to my...

venue same day. We will definitely be reaching out to her later for other events in our lives!

Service area & Contact info

Travel area: Within 100 miles

Additional charges may apply

(415) 298-6740

Curious to learn more?

Start the convo

*=Required

Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.

Sweet Tooth Baking Company

Grace Colla

Executive Chef and CEO

Typically responds within 24h

Sweet Tooth Baking Company's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.

Sweet Tooth Baking Company

About this vendor

Review Summary

Service area & Contact info

Wedding vendors in Grass Valley

Why use The Knot to message vendors?