Sweet Tooth Ice Cream

A Scoop of Happiness to Make You Smile

Southeast Wisconsin and Northeastern Illinois

Service area

5.0

Verified reviews from real couples

Sweet tooth ice cart helped with the dessert for our wedding last weekend! They were amazing and the perfect additional to our wedding. We're not cake people and this was a great option for us! The attendant even made a point to find me and my husband and ensure we got dessert. They were wonderful and such a deal, I 100% recommend them!

Kelsey C.

5.0

We had Sweet Tooth Ice Cream bring their cart to our company picnic, and they were a huge hit! The setup was fun, inviting, and perfect for the event. Their team member was friendly, quick, and made everything feel effortless. Everyone loved the variety of treats, and it added such a special touch to the day. If you’re planning an event and want something unique that guests of all ages will enjoy, I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Ice Cream. They made our picnic feel extra memorable!

Naama P.

5.0

Andrea Pether

OWNER

AWARD WINNER (3X)

Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream is a wedding treats company based in Lake Geneva, WI. Conveniently situated between Chicago and Milwaukee, this purveyor of frozen delights is proud to serve southeast Wisconsin and northeast Illinois. Whether you’re a cookie monster or a cone connoisseur, the Pether family has what it takes to enliven your wedding celebration. According to owner Andrea, the company is the result of a family trip. In the course of that trip, the Pethers saw a number of amazing places and enjoyed a lot of delicious ice cream. In fact, they enjoyed this experience so much that they decided to start an ice cream business of their own. The Pethers love to see people smile, and serving great ice cream is certainly one way to light up a room. The Pethers delight in adding a bit of fun to any special occasion. They hope that their range of delicious ice creams will charm your guests and help make your big day a celebration to remember. Sweet Tooth Ice Cream operates an ice cream truck and two ice cream carts. Carts are rented for two-hour periods. Additional rental time is available for you to taste and savor all of your favorites. Choose from a wide range of novelty and premium treats. Enjoy fruit bars, ice cream sandwiches, and more.

No business details yet

No team details yet

Details

Awards and Affiliations

3-Time 'Best of Weddings'

2023.2022.2021.

Join couples who chose award-winning vendors for their wedding

Meet the team

Andrea Pether

Owner

The idea for Sweet Tooth Ice Cream came to us as we were taking a yearlong family sabbatical trip. We saw a lot or really amazing places and ate a LOT OF ICE CREAM. We wanted to start a business with one mission, to make people smile. Our main focus is private parties but you can still see us on occasion selling ice cream from one of our carts or truck along the shores of beautiful Lake Geneva, Wisconsin.

5.0

out of 5.0

38 reviews

Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Search reviews

Kelsey C

10/14/2025

Sweet tooth ice cart helped with the dessert for our wedding last weekend! They were amazing and the perfect additional to our wedding. We're not cake people and this was a great ...

option for us! The attendant even made a point to find me and my husband and ensure we got dessert. They were wonderful and such a deal, I 100% recommend them!

Naama P

9/09/2025

We had Sweet Tooth Ice Cream bring their cart to our company picnic, and they were a huge hit! The setup was fun, inviting, and perfect for the event. Their team member was friendl...

y, quick, and made everything feel effortless. Everyone loved the variety of treats, and it added such a special touch to the day. If you’re planning an event and want something unique that guests of all ages will enjoy, I highly recommend Sweet Tooth Ice Cream. They made our picnic feel extra memorable!

Any questions?

Jo S

9/06/2025

We have worked with Sweet Tooth several years now. Great service! Great ice cream Variety and great owners!

Tommy D

9/02/2025

This was such a big hit at our wedding! Thank you so much for being apart of our special day. Leading up to the wedding they were nothing but communicative and they were so sweet...

to work with. Highly recommend!

Kaitlyn G

8/13/2023

Andrea and the Sweet Tooth Ice Cream team was very responsive and easy to work with. A great variety of ice cream and our guests all loved it. Having a summer wedding outdoors thi...

s was a great break from the traditional cake.

Elizabeth G

7/23/2023

I worked with Sweet Tooth Ice Cream for my June 2023 wedding in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin and truly could not have had a better experience! Andrea is extremely helpful, professional, ...

and kind. She accommodated every request we had, was flexible and understanding, and her ice cream offerings can't be beat. Our guests absolutely LOVED the novelty ice cream treats, and it was truly was one of the most fun aspects of our wedding. I would recommend Sweet Tooth Ice Cream for any wedding or event! 11/10!🍦

Kathryn K

4/19/2023

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream was a HUGE HIT at our wedding! We aren’t really cake people and we’re looking for something fun and unique and Sweet Tooth delivered! Our guests LOVED the ice...

cream truck and we loved that they were able to set the cart up right on the patio. Super fun and great treats! Andrea had excellent communication and was so sweet while planning and at our wedding. If you’re looking for something fun and unique for your guests, sweet tooth is it!

Alyson C

8/26/2022

We loved having Sweet Tooth Ice Cream at our "Wedding in the Park" - they fit perfectly with our theme and the guests loved it! Working with them was easy and I wouldn't change a t...

hing - super friendly during the planning and at the event! Thank you so much for making our day so sweet ;)

Rebecca G

7/19/2022

Andrea was always super responsive and great at communicating during our wedding planning process. We knew we didn't want to spend a lot of money on cake/cupcakes and wanted someth...

ing a little unique - Sweet Tooth Ice Cream was the perfect answer! You get to select so many options to stock the ice cream cart so there's something for everyone. All of our guests loved it and it was an awesome way to have a unique touch to our reception.

Jennifer S

7/06/2022

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream was the perfect dessert for our summer wedding! The staff were timely and the tie dye cart with lights was super fun. Pricing was reasonable, and the product ...

much better than traditional cake. Sharing a Choco Taco with my husband was the evening’s cherry on top. Plus, we got so many compliments from our guests. I’d consider booking Sweet Tooth for other parties I host in the future.

Danica H

7/05/2022

We hired Sweet Tooth Ice Cream for our private country club 4th of July picnic. They were great, everyone loved them and will definitely have them back again next year!

Marla K

7/05/2022

Sweet Tooth ice cream was amazing to work with!! They came on time and provided great service for our guests. We went with the premium package and it was perfect! So many great op...

tions for our guests to choose from! The ice cream cart was a HUGE hit at our daughters wedding!! I highly recommend!

Emily S

7/05/2022

Always friendly and inviting! Ice cream is always a hit, a nice cold treat on a hot day!

Jim T

6/01/2022

Sweet tooth is the way to go!! Super nice friendly! Due to Covid had to reschedule and very accommodating! The ice cream cart was a HUGE hit at our wedding!! Thank you sweet tooth ...

for helping us out!!

Mia L

10/12/2021

What a fun way to serve our guests dessert! Andrea was prompt and prepared. You can't go wrong with a variety of yummy ice cream treats. Looking forward to hosting another event so...

we can use her services again.

Rachel F

10/06/2021

We had Sweet Tooth Ice Cream for our late night snack at our outdoor wedding. It was a huge hit! Andrea was easy to work with and the treats were delicious. Would definitely recomm...

end for your wedding!

Megan P

10/03/2021

Could not have picked a better vendor to bring all the sweetness to our big day! Sweet Tooth Ice Cream gave top notch service and answered all of our questions. When it came to ser...

ving guest they did it quick and with a smile! Literally can’t recommend them enough for your event!

Robert S

9/05/2021

Had them at our Company party, they did a great job as always

Kathleen S

9/04/2021

Amazing service; great happy choices!!

Heidi P

8/30/2021

I have used Sweeet Too Ice Cream for the past few years for an event. They are amazing. I love the cute carts they have and my quest always love the ice cream! I recommend them ...

to everyone. Thank you Sweet Tooth Ice Cream!!

Kent L

8/30/2021

These guys are great, and so are the ice cream treats:) You will not be disappointed!

Alyssa M

8/27/2021

We had the Sweet Tooth ice cream cart out for an employee appreciation event over 2 days and it couldn't have been easier! Our employees enjoyed the ice cream on a hot day (great s...

election) and Andrea was on time each day and super friendly! I would definitely recommend this for ANY event!!!

Rona C

8/13/2021

We had Sweet Tooth Ice Cream come to our subdivision picnic and it was a huge hit for all ages! Many people commented that it brought them back to their childhood and some great me...

mories!

Rachel M

8/11/2021

Andrea made the whole process so easy for me! Also our guests absolutely it- in fact they are still talking about it! We did a custom package which worked out great and have us the...

variety we were looking for. Would definitely recommend!

Alexis R

8/01/2021

Andrea was great to work with and they had great ice cream to choose from! They arrived on time and were very accomodating.

Amanda A

6/22/2021

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream was amazing! We had them for a family reunion and it was a great treat. Wonderful set up and so many yummy options. Could not have been easier!

Gretchen T

10/25/2020

Best experience ever! Guests loved the many choices of ice cream treats and Andrea was great at providing variety of options. Communication was prompt and professional. Sweet Tooth...

was excellent all around. Can’t go wrong with this service at your next event.

Jennifer K

10/24/2020

Responsible, fairly priced and punctual. Nice selection of items to satisfy everyone at your event.

Barb K

10/24/2020

Our friends have had Sweet Tooth for their summer parties and everyone has loved their setup and variety of ice cream.

Stephanie L

10/24/2020

Fun and different!! Very professional and accomodating. Great ice cream choices. Brought me back to my childhood!

Jane M

10/24/2020

Loved working with Andrea with Sweet Tooth! Her adorable cart was great at our wedding in Lake Geneva. She stocked it with everyone’s favorites and provided great customer service....

She has great pricing and is easy to work with. I would definitely recommend using her services for a fun wedding treat.

Dana F

10/24/2020

Such a clever dessert option for any event! The setup is adorable and the staff even sweeter. Would highly recommend for your wedding as well as any upcoming event.

Rob S

10/10/2020

I have used them several times for corporate events and have always done a great job. Very reliable and professional

Katie B

10/01/2019

AMAZING! My guests were head over heels for ice cream! They were very professional, came in set, up and immediately gave out ice cream! Our dinner line was running late, so some of...

our guests even got ice cream before dinner! Super excited! The price was also awesome! Thank you all! I 100% recommend them!

Ashley B

7/09/2019

We took a chance and hired Sweet Tooth for our wedding this past weekend. I was a little nervous because there weren't many reviews but it was awesome! Andrea was so nice. The ice...

cream cart was adorable and all our guests loved it and enjoyed the ice cream!

Lauren M

11/17/2018

Sweet Tooth was at a wedding I recently went to. It was a hit! They were very professional and friendly. Would recommend to anyone!

Rebecca C

11/17/2018

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream was the perfect addition to our desserts for our wedding reception. The frozen treats were loved by all guests, young and old! Andrea and Dan were wonderful t...

o work with and had such great interactions with guests. They brought such a great selection of ice cream, and even had dairy free options for those that were lactose intolerant. The cart they brought was so cute and went perfectly with the decor and room we had our reception in. I cannot recommend them enough!

Jo S

10/01/2018

It was so much fun having them at our July 3rd party. The variety of ice creams were amazing. Service amazing! Thank you! Fun was had by all!

Contact

(262) 215-8679

Curious to learn more?

Start the convo

*=Required

Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream

Andrea Pether

Owner

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.

Sweet Tooth Ice Cream

About this vendor

Wedding vendors in Lake Geneva

Why use The Knot to message vendors?