Kailey is the best!!! Highly recommend her as she was easy to work with despite us making a few changes along the way, even  as late as 2 weeks prior to my daughterâs wedding! The cakes and cupcakes were all phenomenal! We had so many compliments from our guests!!Â
K M.
5.0
Kailey was so sweet and easy to work with!! I ordered a cake with strawberry filling and cake shooters for my wedding. The cake was the best my husband and I had ever had and gorgeous as well!!!Â
Avery W.
5.0
Deals
Custom discountPermanent
Get 10% off!
Claim Deal
About this vendor
Hi đ¤
My name is Kailey, and Iâm the home baker behind Sweetie Bakery LLC serving Southern IN and Louisville, KY greater areaâ a licensed wedding cake & dessert spread baker specializing in brownies, blondies, cupcakes, cookies, and more!
I offer:
⨠Traditional wedding cakes
⨠Cookie cake stacks (a fun, unique alternative!)
⨠Beautifully styled dessert spreads
⨠Delivery & professional setup
As a 2026 bride myself, I truly understand how important it is to feel supported and confident in the vendors you choose. I love working closely with couples to bring their vision to life while being mindful of budget and details đ¤
Sweet perks I offer my couples:
đ¤ Free consult call & free quotes
đ¤ Cake tasting boxes available for $35
đ¤ 10% off for healthcare workers, veterans, firefighters, and police officers as a small thank-you for all you do.
Iâd love to connect and be part of your special day!
Woman-owned Business
2+ years in business
Speaks English
Just me
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Any questions?
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.0
11 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Sweetie Pie Bakery is praised for beautiful, delicious wedding cakes and dessertsâincluding cupcakes, cake shooters, brownies, and cinnamon rollsâwith allergy-friendly options. Reviewers highlight prompt communication, attentiveness, professional setup, and last-minute flexibility. Highly recommended.
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 4
Nicole B
Highlighted review.
5.0
8/31/2026
Kailey is the absolute best! My cake vendor cancelled a couple months before the wedding and she was able to fit me in. The cake was so beautiful and the brownies were a HUGE hit w...
ith all my guests. She setup the cake and desserts for me and the cake looked AMAZING even in the late August heat.
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 08/31/2026
I am so happy to have been able to make your wedding cake and desserts! it was a very hot ...
day, but glad the desserts prevailed :)
The theme and colors were stunning!
K M
5.0
10/05/2026
Kailey is the best!!! Highly recommend her as she was easy to work with despite us making a few changes along the way, even  as late as 2 weeks prior to my daughterâs wedding! The ...
cakes and cupcakes were all phenomenal! We had so many compliments from our guests!!Â
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 10/06/2026
Thank you so much Kim! It was so nice to work with you to make your daughters dreams come ...
true. Im so glad everything turned out well and the guests enjoyed it! The venue was beautiful- look forward to pictures!
Any questions?
Avery W
5.0
9/28/2026
Kailey was so sweet and easy to work with!! I ordered a cake with strawberry filling and cake shooters for my wedding. The cake was the best my husband and I had ever had and gorge...
ous as well!!!Â
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 09/30/2026
I wish I could show you how this review makes me feel - I am so flattered that you all lov...
ed the flavor of the cake! Your Wedding was beautiful - thank you for choosing Sweetie Bakery!
Beth R
5.0
9/22/2026
Kailey was a dream to work with. Very sweet, attentive, prompt with communication - and provided services others could not. My daughter's cake was delicious and exactly what she wa...
nted. The cake shooters were equally delicious! Highly recommend!!!
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 09/30/2026
SO thrilled I could be a part of your daughters big day. I am so thankful you all chose Sw...
eetie Bakery to make your desserts!
Abby S
5.0
9/15/2026
Kailey was the sweetest, most detail oriented and attentive person to work with. I would recommend her to anyone! There was not a worry in the world while we worked together. âşď¸
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 09/30/2026
Thank you! Happy to have worked alongside your big day!
Krissie G
5.0
7/03/2026
You absolutely can not go wrong with hiring Sweetie Pie Bakery. My cake was abaolutely gorgeous and tasted amazing. Kailey added the flowers I had on sight. I was planning my we...
dding from Illinois and Kailey made that process so easy for me. Will definatly be using Sweetie Pie Bakery in the future.
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 07/03/2026
It was a JOY to do your wedding cake! Thank you for such kind words- I pray for years and ...
years of joy between you two! Look forward to helping you with anything in the future!
Trinity U
5.0
5/25/2026
She did my wedding cake!! Kailey is incredibly kind and accommodating. If you're in or around the Louisville area, I can't recommend her enough! It was delicious!
Danielle H
5.0
1/10/2026
Sweetie bakery made both my bridal shower desserts and they were not only so pretty but also incredibly delicious! She also made cinnamon rolls for me to serve to my bridesmaids an...
d they were so good!!Â
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 01/12/2026
It was a dream come true being a part of your lovely shower as well as your unique gift of...
cinnamon rolls the morning of your wedding to your head table! Thank you for your trust in your special day!
Elizabeth H
5.0
1/09/2026
Kailey created a cake more beautiful and perfect than we ever dreamed of for our special day. She was extremely easy to work with, responded quickly to messages as we were planning...
, and most importantly our cake was delicious. We had such a great experience we have ordered from her since for other needs we had. Highly recommend her!Â
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 01/12/2026
Elizabeth! You are one of my favorite repeat customers right from the moment you told me h...
ow you found me! I was honored to do your wedding cake and wish you continued happiness through it all!
Mikayla L
5.0
1/09/2026
I was first introduced to Sweetie Bakery at a friendâs bridal shower, where they provided beautifully crafted edible flower cookies and a strawberry shortcake. The strawberry short...
cake was exceptionalâso much so that I went back for seconds and even brought some home for my family to enjoy.
Based on that experience, I chose Sweetie Bakery to create the cake for my best friendâs bridal shower, which I hosted. The showerâs theme was Love Is in the Air, as it took place around Valentineâs Day, and I requested a heart-shaped cake to match. The cake was absolutely perfectâelegantly designed and exactly what I envisioned. Most importantly, the taste exceeded expectations. Our guests loved it and repeatedly asked where the cake was from.
I highly recommend Sweetie Bakery for any bridal or special event
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 01/12/2026
This made me smile so big! I was SO in love with the cake, the theme, you and the bride!! ...
I was so happy to hear others feed back from the shower desserts and your kind words make it even more better. Thank you!
Kathleen W
5.0
1/08/2026
Although we were referred by another resource, and not The Knot, we can still attest that Sweetie Bakery knocks everything they do out of the park! Kailey can accommodate any size ...
crowd, taste preferences, has allergy friendly options, and can help you stay on budget, too! Her flavors are both unique and incredible. Quality shows at every turn. Highly recommend!Â
Response from Sweetie Bakery on 01/12/2026
Happy to hear satisfaction and taste were great things for you! I love to accommodate and ...
work with my brides! Thank you for your sweet review!
