Where celebrations are a matter of tradition.
201 to 250 guests
Holds ceremonies and receptions
AWARD WINNER (1X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Based in Islip, NY, Tellers: An American Chophouse is a timeless wedding venue that is steeped in history and tradition. The team strives to combine the best of the past, present, and future to create a one-of-a-kind wedding experience. Boasting a selection of event spaces, this beautiful venue makes for a wonderful backdrop for your love story.
For those hoping to host a more intimate celebration, The Pavillion is the perfect venue for you. Suitable for up to 120 people, this bright sailcloth tent features exposed beams and an outdoor, romantic feel. Tellers: An American Chophouse can accommodate up to 250 guests spread across two buildings, depending on your guest list. The restaurant offers a selection of spaces, including the cozy and warm Gallery and the lavish Main Dining Room, which boasts 25-foot-high ceilings and large windows that pool natural light throughout the space. You can truly enjoy an intimate and exclusive experience at Tellers: An American Chophouse and avail of their full buyout option.
The team at At Tellers: An American Chophouse goes above and beyond to help make sure your wedding is extraordinary. Their team of in-house experts is committed to catering to your every need while working closely with you to bring your vision to life. They offer a variety of dining options, including cocktails, hors d’oeuvres, and seated dinner reception. Contact them today for more information on how they can make your wedding dreams come true.
No business details yet
No team details yet
Pricing details
No pricing details yet
We’re here to help! Find other vendors that suit your budget.
Continue browsing vendors
Amenities + details
Amenities
Ceremony Area
Dressing Room
Handicap Accessible
Indoor Event Space
Reception Area
Wireless Internet
Ceremony Types
Civil Union
Commitment Ceremony
Elopement
Interfaith Ceremony
Non-Religious Ceremony
Religious Ceremony
Second Wedding
Vow Renewal Ceremony
Guest Capacity
Up to 250
Settings
Ballroom
Historic Venue
Restaurant
Venue Service Offerings
Bar & Drinks
Cakes & Desserts
Food & Catering
Planning
Service Staff
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Availability
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.019 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Teller's Next Door is highly praised for hosting flawless events, ranging from weddings to corporate dinners and private parties. The staff, including event planners like Alex and Kate, and Maitre d's like Kevin, are commended for their professionalism, attentiveness, and dedication to making each event special. Reviewers highlight the delicious food, abundant cocktails, and impeccable service throughout the planning process and on the day of the event. The communication, organization, and attention to detail provided by the staff at Teller's Next Door consistently receive high praise from multiple guests across different types of gatherings.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
5.0
3/16/2025
We had our wedding at Teller's Next Door and it was absolutely perfect. We knew we wanted a venue with delicious food and they did not disappoint. Alex was wonderful helping us plan our big day. She was so patient with us and made the entire process simple and hassle-free. On the day of the event our maitre d, Kevin, was so nice and was always an arms reach away when we needed something. Along with Alex and Kevin, our servers, bartender, and the rest of the staff were fantastic. Our guests kept telling us how friendly everyone was. We cannot recommend Teller's enough!
Christina K
5.0
1/01/2025
I booked Tellers for a private party for my husband's milestone birthday and it was lovely. It was incredibly easy to communicate with them, they were fast and thorough in their response. The price was reasonable compared to other private rooms that I looked into. They also did some details to the menu and took extra steps to make it special. They were very fast to respond, which is notable because some of the others took a little while and it just made it annoying. Everyone who attended was raving about the food and service since it was A++. I really couldn't recommend it enough and I will absolutely use them again if I have another private gathering.
Any questions?
Laura K
5.0
12/27/2024
We recently hosted an event for 75 guests at Tellers Next Door and it was exceptional. It began with the planning stages- Lisa was wonderful to work with and made sure that no aspect of our party was overlooked. From the menu and room layout to the logistics and timeline of the evening. When the big day arrived, the team at Tellers went above and beyond to make sure every guest had a memorable experience. The food was excellent and the drinks were flowing all night. We have already booked our next event at Tellers and can't wait for it to arrive!
Carol A
5.0
12/19/2024
We recently booked a corporate dinner at Tellers for 32 people, and I cannot speak highly enough of the experience. Alexandra Ardizzone, our Banquet Manager, was exceptional throughout the entire process. She was incredibly patient and understanding, even as we made numerous changes to the table arrangements. Alexandra also guided us through the process of preordering appetizers, which worked out perfectly. Her attention to detail and organization made me feel completely confident that everything was in good hands.
On the night of the event, we arrived a little early, and Alexandra was there to greet us and reassure us that everything was taken care of. The food and service were outstanding, and the entire evening went off without a hitch. I would highly recommend both Tellers and Alexandra for anyone planning an important event. Their professionalism and dedication made our experience truly memorable.
Alan A
5.0
12/16/2024
We recently hosted an event at Tellers in the Parlor Room. The experience was top notch from start to finish. I worked with Alex to plan the event. She was friendly, professional, and a great communicator. The night of the event Kevin, the Maitre d' joined Alex to oversee a truly flawless experience. The venue was amazing, the entire staff were friendly, professional, & efficient, while the timing of the service was impecable. We will most definitely be hosting many more events at Tellers in the future.
Monica V
5.0
12/08/2024
A big thank you to Kate, Alex and Kevin for making our wedding reception on 9/21/24 amazing. We are so grateful for everything that you all did for us. We started working with Kate. She gave us a tour and answered all of our questions. Once we booked, we began working with Alexandra who was just amazing. Alex is so warm and professional at the same time. She made us feel like the most important couple (although I am sure there were many she was working with). She answered all of my questions and gave us such great ideas and tips. We were able to book the Parlor room for 40 guests.
The day of the actual reception was perfection! The food was delicious. Everyone raved about how great the food and drinks were. Kevin was our maitre d and he went above and beyond to make sure that we had everything my husband and I needed. Everything went right! Our guests were so impressed!
Thank you Tellers! Special thanks to Kate, Alex and Kevin for making our wedding reception the best. You guys are amazing!
Patricia H
5.0
12/07/2024
We had our company Holiday Party on 12/2 and we were quite impressed with Alexandria’s professional approach to coordinating this event. She was a pleasure to work with and the event went very well Kevin also managed a wonderful dining room service team and the food was excellent Bravo 👏 to All
Thank you
Patrica and Kevin
Brookside Multicare Center
Temeshia M
5.0
11/28/2024
Alexandra did an incredible job in bringing my vision to life. I couldn’t thank her enough for her consistency and dedication. To the staff of the evening, thank you for making my night even more incredible. The night went exactly how me and my fiancé envisioned.
Courtney D
5.0
11/16/2024
Alexandra Ardizzone was the coordinator for my engagement party, and I can’t express enough how professional and helpful she was. My family and I can be very indecisive, but Alexandra was incredibly patient with us, maintaining consistent communication up until the event. She was always willing to accommodate any requests, and her support made the entire evening run smoothly and beautifully. I would absolutely host another event here if she were the one overseeing it. The food was praised by all of my guests, and the drinks were not only stunning but also tasted phenomenal. Every detail was meticulously considered, thanks to Alexandra’s expertise in event planning. If there was anything I hadn’t thought of, she took care of it. I am beyond thrilled with how the event turned out. Thank you!
Ada L
5.0
11/04/2024
We wanted to extend our heartfelt thanks to Tellers for making our wedding day truly unforgettable. From start to finish, everything was wonderful, and we couldn’t have asked for a better venue. The food was absolutely incredible, and our guests were so happy and satisfied with every dish—they’re still talking about it!
A special thank-you to Alex, who was incredibly responsive and attentive throughout the whole process. Their support and thoughtful recommendations helped us make the best choices, and we’re so grateful for their expertise and guidance. Your entire team went above and beyond to ensure every detail was perfect, and we felt truly cared for.
Thank you for creating such a memorable experience for us and our loved ones—we’ll always cherish our celebration at Tellers!
S R
5.0
10/15/2024
Thank you again for all your help with the party. Thank you as well to all the staff, servers, chefs and everyone else that was involved, their kindness and attentiveness was incredible and especially in this day and age a breath of fresh air. Please extend my gratitude to them all.
That was far and away the best experience I've ever had throwing an event for someone, the guests could not stop complimenting how nice the staff, and how good the food was. Everyone left with a memorable experience for sure, and a lot of them want to go to the restaurant now =)
Penny P
5.0
10/11/2024
Excellent customer service! Event planner is organized and responsive.
Leanora K
5.0
10/02/2024
My daughter didn’t have a bridal shower so when it came time to plan her baby shower I wanted someplace special. Tellers Next Door hit it out of the park! Every detail was taken care of by the impeccable staff, especially Alexandria. She went above and beyond to make sure we got exactly what we wanted. She always made herself available to answer any questions I had.
The food at Tellers is always delicious and every one of our 60 guests commented on how great it was!
I highly recommend Tellers Next Door. It is definitely worth the money and the room is beautiful!
Alyssa S
5.0
10/02/2024
When we were searching for a wedding venue, the quality of food and cocktails was our top priority, and Tellers delivered above and beyond. The value they provided was incredible. Our guests are still talking about how amazing the cocktail hour was—the food was abundant, delicious, and the staff was so attentive. The dinner was equally impressive. Unlike most venues, Tellers offered a unique, restaurant-style dining experience that made it feel like we were hosting our guests at a fine dining establishment rather than a typical catering hall. We especially loved the European-style dinner service, which gave us the chance to spend meaningful time with our family and friends before heading to the Parlor for dancing later in the evening. The entire space is gorgeous—the pavilion was a dream for both the ceremony and dinner, and it photographed beautifully. For our guest count of 87, the space felt intimate and perfectly sized.
Working with the team at Tellers was such a wonderful experience. Alex was incredibly communicative, helpful, and genuinely eager to make sure everything was perfect. She was knowledgeable, kind, and so patient throughout the entire process—I really couldn’t have asked for more. On the day of, our maitre’d Kevin and bridal attendant Victoria were just as amazing. They were beyond attentive and made us feel so comfortable and taken care of, making sure everything went smoothly. The entire team was professional yet made us feel like family, and everything we wanted to customize or change even up until the day of was handled with ease and executed as promised. The bridal suite was also stunning and the perfect spot for us to decompress before and throughout the night.
Our wedding day was the best day of my life and beyond my wildest dreams thanks to the incredible team at Tellers. I highly recommend this venue to anyone who values great food, drinks, and a unique, elevated wedding experience. Me and my husband cannot wait to visit the restaurant often and relive the wonderful memories we made there.
Gina B
5.0
10/01/2024
Everyone knows the name!
My fiancé and I decided we were having an intimate wedding of 70 guests and wanted to do a speak-easy theme. Teller’s is a name that everyone knows and respects due to its reputation. It was our first choice and our final decision! The establishment runs like a well oiled machine on a busy Friday or Saturday night! Their employees are friendly and professional. Sandra and Alex continually checked in with us and made sure our itinerary was exactly what we wanted. We received so many compliments after the wedding about how much everyone enjoyed themselves and how great the food was. They even have their own CANOLI GUY! Every location that we took photos at was iconic, including the safe, the cobblestone alley way and the beautiful glass front door. We left Tellers with our hearts full and memories that will last a lifetime.
Dan O
5.0
9/04/2024
We had our son’s graduation party at tellers next door and everything from beginning to the end was truly amazing. Alex the banquet manger couldn’t have been nicer and more helpful. We had some food allergies in the family and she accommodated us with no worries. The cocktail hour we had was fantastic. All our family and friends really had an incredible time. Every staff member seemed to have a smile and really made the day memorable. I would recommend this venue in a heartbeat.
Elena S
5.0
8/30/2024
I had a birthday dinner for my two adult children in the Boardroom. We comfortably fit our 14 guests at a beautifully set table. Our waiter and servers were friendly and accommodating. Our food was delicious! We had the steaks, seafood, mac and cheese. fries, and potatoes and so much more! It was a great dining experience and I would definitely go back!
Chris B
5.0
8/25/2024
We had our son and daughter in law’s rehearsal dinner at Teller’s Next Door and the event could not have been better. Food, staff and venue were a 10. Alex, our banquet coordinator was absolutely delightful to work with.
Sara G
5.0
2/07/2024
A Perfect Celebration at Teller's Next Door: A Review of Unforgettable Service and Delightful Cuisine
My experience at Teller's Next Door exceeded all expectations, marking a memorable occasion that will forever hold a special place in our hearts. We chose Teller's Next Door for our Happily Ever After party, a celebration bridging the gap between our wedding and the impending arrival of our bundle of joy. From the outset, Kate, our event planner, showcased unparalleled dedication, ensuring every detail reflected our vision. Her meticulous planning and unwavering support alleviated any pre-event jitters, allowing us to focus solely on the joyous occasion ahead.
The staff at Teller's Next Door went above and beyond, transforming our dreams into reality. On the day of the party, we were greeted with seamless execution, leaving us with zero stress. From setting up our personalized favors to meticulously packing our car at the end of the night, every aspect was flawlessly executed. Despite being eight months pregnant, I was expertly cared for by Kevin, the Maitre-d, who ensured my comfort and hydration throughout the event. Their attentiveness and dedication to our well-being underscored their commitment to exemplary service.
The culinary offerings at Teller's Next Door were nothing short of exceptional, garnering rave reviews from our guests. The diverse array of stations, including the Asian Station, The Carving Station, and The Sunday Sauce station, showcased the culinary expertise of the chefs. However, it was the RAW BAR that stole the show, captivating guests with its freshness and variety. Moreover, the wine and beer package surpassed all expectations, offering top-notch selections that complemented the culinary offerings perfectly. Teller's Next Door truly embodies the epitome of five-star dining, ensuring an unforgettable gastronomic experience for all.
In conclusion, Teller's Next Door surpassed all expectations, delivering an unforgettable celebration marked by impeccable service and delectable cuisine. From the moment we began planning with Kate to the final moments of our event, every detail was executed flawlessly. If you're seeking a venue that embodies excellence in every aspect, look no further than Teller's Next Door. I wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone seeking an extraordinary event experience.
Contact
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.
Wedding vendors in Islip
Tellers: An American Chophouse
Tellers: An American Chophouse's photos
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.