Calley Stredney
OWNER
AWARD WINNER (1X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
The Cake Boutique was founded over a decade ago in 2008 by Penny and Stella. What started as a small home-based business quickly grew into something much bigger. The talented duo created awe-inspiring cakes for all occasions and were even featured on several nationally televised competitions, including Cake Wars and Bake it Like Buddy, and were also awarded several titles along the way, such as being dubbed as The Knot's "Best of Weddings" pick. After a decade of building up a successful bakery, both Penny and Stella chose to step back from the company. Calley, who had been the senior baker, bought the company and has been dedicated to carrying on their legacy and continuing to grow the business. She, as well as all of her incredibly talented staff, believe that the quality of the products and service you receive is of the utmost importance. They will work with you every step of the way to make sure that your wedding cake is everything you envisioned, down to the finest of details. The Cake Boutique will go above and beyond for their clients to make sure this is the best memory that you can taste!
Services Offered:
The Cake Boutique is your one-stop-shop for all the desserts you might need for planning a wedding. We offer a wide variety of sweets--all of which can be customized!
engagement, shower, and wedding cakes
personalized sugar cookies
cupcakes
cake pops/cake balls
dessert cups
assorted cookies
Woman-owned Business
Prices & packages
No pricing details yet
Reach out to get a customized quote from this vendor.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Nut Free
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
Calley Stredney
Owner
Calley had been the head baker for several years before buying The Cake Boutique in 2021. Since then she has been dedicated to carrying on and continuing to build the legacy left behind for her. She is involved in the making of every cake all the way from baking to decorating to ensure that each cake leaves our shop meeting the expectations of every client.
Reviews
4.8
out of 5.041 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
The Cake Boutique receives glowing reviews for their wedding cakes and treats, with multiple reviewers praising the delicious flavors and beautiful decorations. Customers were impressed with the attention to detail, customization options, and excellent communication throughout the planning process. From accommodating allergies to delivering a variety of sweet treats like macarons and custom cookies, The Cake Boutique comes highly recommended for weddings and other events.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 5
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Sheila G
5.0
1/04/2025
We are so happy with the attention we got with the Cake Boutique. My husband has an allergy, and they were able to accommodate his allergy so that he could eat cake, too! Even more, they were able to make the 2 layers different flavors, so my husband and I each got what we wanted: spice cake with cheesecake buttercream filling and chocolate cake with raspberry mousse. The cake was delicious, and the decoration was exactly what I requested. I highly recommend The Cake Boutique for your wedding cake!
Alicia & Daniel C
5.0
8/18/2024
We used The Cake Boutique for our wedding cake and bridal shower, and were extremely pleased with our experience. From the first time we met they were attentive to how we wanted our cake to look and taste, laying out several options for us to choose from. The macarons they provided for the bridal shower were absolutely AMAZING, and we couldn’t have been happier with how our wedding cake turned out! Overall, we would recommend The Cake Boutique, not just for your wedding, but for any event you might be planning!
Any questions?
Jessie H
1.0
7/25/2024
I am an out of state bride. I called and set up an appointment/consultation and went over everything I was interested in advance. I came into town a couple months early to meet with all my vendors. I arrive at this bakery and it seemed like we were starting all over again. Okay, no big deal, I’m here and will do it in person. I said I was interested in a 2 tier cake to cap off my cupcake tower. I was told all my desserts/cake items had to be coming from them, as per their policy/business model. This was brand new news to me and to top it all off of they could not even deliver. I would have had to pick up and deliver myself. They wasted my time in every possible way.
response 07/31/2024
Hi Jessie,
I want to start this off by apologizing for making you feel like your time was...
wasted after having met with us. We understand how busy and stressful your schedule must be with planning a wedding from out of state, so we wanted to thank you for taking the time to drive all the way out here to meet with us, even if we weren't a good fit for you. After hearing about how disappointing the consultation was, I made sure to thoroughly look into what happened. I talked with our staff member you met with and also took a look at the footage from our lobby and consultation area to get a better idea of what happened before coming here to respond. I hope that this will offer some insight and correct a few points you have addressed above.
Firstly, I would like to address "having to start over." It may not have been made crystal clear when you called to set up your consultation, but the entire point of our consultations is to get an order started for you. We would not have had any other information for you prior to this consultation unless you had already come in for one previously and this was just an additional follow up. At the time of your phone call to set up the consultation, for which I was the one you spoke to, the only information taken and written down was your name and phone number, which was put into our calendar to book you for the consultation. We also asked when your wedding was taking place, and at that time we had not yet booked up. It does appear that you called two additional times after that to change your scheduled appointment, so if any other information was given during those phone calls, I cannot say for certain. When you came in to finally meet with us, us "starting over" was simply us confirming your name, wedding date, and phone number to make sure everything was correct and that nothing had changed, as these things sometimes do change or need updated. This is all done just to make sure we are not working with incorrect or otherwise falsely assumed information.
As briefly mentioned, at the time when you had initially called to set up your consultation, we were not yet booked for your date. Being that your wedding is taking place in October, which is perhaps one of, if not the busiest months for weddings, it often books up rather quickly. By the time of your consultation, we still were not fully booked, but as it happened, we did have limited availability and were only able to do local deliveries. Having only 1 delivery vehicle, 1 delivery driver, and 5 other weddings booked on your date already, it simply is not in the realm of our capabilities to deliver to your venue, which would be a 3 hour+ round trip when your venue is an hour and a half away from us. But from what you said, you would have happily picked everything up the day before. If we had had the availability to fit you into our schedule, we would have loved to. We could have even delivered to your venue the day before had arrangements been made.
Regarding our cake policy for weddings, yes, you are correct. Our policy as outlined in our contract is that any and all cake products, including sheet cakes, cupcakes, and such, must be provided by us. As explained, we had had issues in the past with customers purchasing cake from different bakeries and calling us with issues regarding cakes that were not ours. Furthermore, it is simply not fair to us, and this is not an uncommon practice or policy within our industry. Would you order fish from one caterer and then hire another to make chicken? This policy is by no means at all applicable to all desserts you plan on having at your wedding, and you were told as much that this policy did not apply to things such as a cookie table, candies, pies, or cheesecakes. Had your intentions to get a cake and then cupcakes from two different bakeries been mentioned in any of your initial phone calls, we would have certainly mentioned this policy to prevent you from, again, wasting your time. What you maybe did not hear your consultant get to before you got up and left exclaiming "I guess we're done, this is garbage" is that this policy is also not upheld in the event of dietary restrictions, allergies, or other extenuating circumstances for which we agree to waive that part of the contract. In fact, we regularly make exceptions for our couples to order cupcakes from one of the local businesses we work with that specializes in gluten and dairy free products. Had you been able to discuss the matter more in depth with your consultant, perhaps an agreement could have been made.
Regardless, we are very sorry to have wasted your time and apologize for any frustrations this has caused. We wish you all the best and do sincerely hope that you find someone that better fits your needs and desires for your cake.
With warm regards,
The Cake Boutique
Caleb T
5.0
10/14/2023
The cupcakes turned out even better than we had hoped and they were delicious. Our guests were very impressed with them.
Jessica B
5.0
9/08/2023
They made a 2-tier wedding cake, cupcakes, and custom cookies for my wedding! Everyone was obsessed with the flavors and looks! They even messaged me when making them to make sure the colors were what I had in mind!
Trisha M
5.0
6/09/2023
The Cake Boutique was wonderful to work with for our wedding. They did exactly what I envisioned. We had 3 different flavors: lemon, bananas foster and white almond raspberry cheescake; they were all delicious! Our cake was beautiful. They were easy to work with, communication was excellent and their delivery was perfect!
Moira P
3.0
8/17/2022
I ordered a cake for my parents 50th Wedding anniversary and I also ordered personalized sugar cookies. I went in to the store to show the owner a picture of the wedding cake I wanted re-created And I sent her the picture to her phone for a reference when making the cake. I paid up front and had it delivered. When it arrived I immediately noticed the colors were way off. The cookies looked amazing but I was a little disappointed that the cake colors were Navy blue and light blue instead of Deep Purple and Lavender. It was too late to do anything about it and I already paid. Maybe the person who made the cake was color blind? The cake tasted great so that was a huge plus. Just wish the colors matched my parents original cake.
Photo of The Cake Boutique - Warren, OH, United States.
Jenna O
5.0
10/24/2021
The cake boutique made our cake exactly how we wanted it and it was so affordable when compared to other cake boutiques! I’d recommend them to anyone!!
Eden H
5.0
11/05/2018
Our wedding cake and 11 dozen cupcakes from The Cake Boutique helped to make our wedding reception perfect. The Cake Boutique were nothing but helpful and patient with us and I'd highly recommend them to anyone! The cupcakes are absolutely delicious and we still stop by to pick some up anytime we are in Warren.
Julie P
5.0
10/07/2018
Stella was so amazing from the minute we decided to hire her to make our wedding cake! We were planning our wedding from out of town and she helped accommodate our schedules. Deciding on flavors was a challenge because they are all so delicious...so we had 3 cakes (it was a big wedding and we just couldn’t pick one!) Our cake was perfect, beautiful and so delicious and the sheet cakes were heavenly!! We received so many compliments and questions about where we got our cake. We happily told everyone we hired The Cake Boutique and would recommend Stella and her team to anyone! Thank you!!
Charlee R
5.0
8/22/2018
Our wedding cake was beautifully decorated and it tasted great too! The shop was very helpful in designing the cake and they have a great selection of flavors—we had a three-tier cake with vanilla raspberry, banana's foster, and carrot cake. Our guests loved it. Highly recommend!
Aura D
5.0
8/04/2018
Not only was our cake a beautiful art deco masterpiece, it was crazy delicious.
Stacy R
5.0
12/27/2017
Amazing cupcakes and wedding cake
Cat W
5.0
8/23/2017
My experience with the Cake Boutique was wonderful. I planned my wedding from hundreds of miles away and they were a breeze to work with via phone and email. When we were in town, they made time so we could sit down to discuss and do a tasting. They made suggestions that fit our reception size rather than simply adding dollars onto the bill. They took time with us to make suggestions and to try different combinations of things. I called a week prior to ensure all was going to go as planned, that we were on the same page and come the day of the wedding my cake was sitting there gorgeous as could be. We are beyond amazed at the simplicity it was to work with this company and how much they went over and above, even for a smaller cake like ours, to make sure everything was perfect.
Rachel G
5.0
7/03/2017
Our cake was beautiful! We didn't get to eat any at the reception except for the bite during the cutting but it was delicious!
Sara S
5.0
9/18/2016
We came to Penny and Stella with an idea for a Cinderella themed cake. We wanted it to appear that the Cinderella birds were decorating our cake. They said this wasn't like anything that they had done before but they were willing to give it a shot. Our cake was AMAZING! I couldn't have wished for a prettier cake.
Kristy M
5.0
6/05/2016
The cake and cupcakes were amazing and very affordable!
Marissa R
5.0
8/05/2015
I decided two weeks before the wedding that I wanted to surprise my groom with a Dukes of Hazzard Groom's Cake. The Cake Boutique agreed to do it for a great price and they delivered it. It looked EXACTLY like the picture I sent in. They took my order over the phone and were so nice and helpful. Thank you Cake Boutique!
Aimee K
5.0
10/24/2014
We had ordered a small specialty cake for cutting and a larger sheet cake for the guests. We wanted a unique design to our cake that most places weren't able to do. Everything tasted delicious and the designed cake looked amazing. Our only issue was that the fondant was very thick on our little cake making it difficult to cut, but that may have been a communication issue when we were telling them how we wanted our cake.
Megan G
5.0
9/10/2014
The cake was so delicious!!! We chose the tuxedo flavor and all we are still hearing about is how good our cake was!! The faux wedding cake is such a great option when you are planning on a budget!!
Ronni
4.0
8/26/2014
The cake was great! The decorations came out a little different than the picture we gave them, but it was still gorgeous.
Natalie F
5.0
6/16/2014
Stella and her team have done several cakes for me and I've always been thrilled with the service, design & taste. I recommend The Cake Boutique to everyone looking for a beautiful cake that tastes just as good as it looks!
Rebecca S
5.0
1/25/2014
I used this vendor for my shower and my wedding. So many of my guests said it was the best cake they has ever had!
Terra M
5.0
10/02/2013
The Cake Boutique was amazing! I have never tasted cake so delicious, and the designs were beautiful. They did cupcakes for us, as well as a cake for cutting. Everyone loved it, and it matched our decor perfectly. They were so easy to work with, and everyone we talked to was so friendly and nice. Perfect!
Janhavi S
4.0
9/07/2013
Stella was a pleasure to work with. I was an out of town bride but Stella was very responsive over email. We had ordered a 2 tier cake - top tier was red velvet with cream cheese filling, bottom tier was white almond with strawberry cheesecake filling. We used fondant since we had a faded yellow look for the cake. The cake looked beautiful and our guests enjoyed it! Stella also delivered it for free.
Ashley H
5.0
8/08/2013
For our wedding, the one thing I didn't want to splurge on was the cake. Luckily, The Cake Boutique offered the 'faux'/fondant cake that I had read to do in magazines. They designed it with the design I wanted and it came out AMAZING! They even texted me personally an image the day before of how it turned out. Our guests didn't know that our cake was fake and we had sheet cakes in the kitchen for them to eat. We bought our sheet cakes through Cake Boutique as well and they were delicious. Loved the many flavors we got to choose from (Chocolate infused with Guinness + Bailey's Irish filling - because my fiancé and I met in Dublin). Don't look anywhere else for your cake/cupcakes :)amazing experience and staff was great to work with.
Amanda Z
5.0
6/13/2013
The Cake Boutique makes delicious cakes! I got three different flavors: white almond, chocolate fudge and bananas fosters. All three were excellent. I got rave reviews on the cake after the wedding.
Delicious!!
Nicole B
5.0
4/30/2013
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! We did two flavors white almond and bananas foster. My husband doesn't even like banana and he loved this! Not only did they do our beautiful wedding cake, they also helped me create my husband's groom's cake and it was flawless (it was his fraternity letters). LOVED IT!
Michelle A
5.0
1/13/2013
Best cake I ever had! They designed it exactly as we wanted it and it matched our decor perfectly!
Michelle N
5.0
12/03/2012
The cake boutique was wonderful. The cake was delicious. They do faux wedding cakes and it was cheaper and easier. I gave them the design I wanted for my cake and they made it perfectly. They will even send you a picture to your email the week of the wedding while they are working on it to make sure it is what you want and if you want to add or change anything.
Janelle M
5.0
11/10/2012
These girls are great. They did our traditional wedding cake as well as a custom Pittsburgh Penguins grooms cake for my new husband. You would have thought they printed out the Pens logo and put it on the cake - it looked sooo good! And the cake itself was delicious! So many flavors to choose from and we couldn't get enough! Great service, pretty decent prices for what they do and everything was delivered on time and looked great!
Falisha P
5.0
10/11/2012
Great job! I had cupcakes, display was set up on location. Grooms cake was a 3D race car. Everything looked great and tasted even better!
Amanda K
5.0
10/09/2012
Delicious cake!
Jamie B
4.0
10/02/2012
I got so many compliments on my Wedding Cake. People said it was the best wedding cake they have ever had. It looked great too.
Jessamyn N
4.0
8/19/2012
Delicious cake. Everyone raved about the flavors. One staff member did not want to put any pink on my cake, telling me it would look like a birthday cake and not be pretty. She also kept telling me to bring in flowers for my one tier, even after I told her to make them. She also did not put my initial topper on my one tier because she could not figure out how, even after I told her how to do it. The driver put my cake topper on and it kept falling off, and they blamed it on the topper having nothing to anchor it in, when most don't. When I called to complain they did not want to go out and fix it. It continued to fall off, until I shoved it inro the too thick layer of fondant. That was another problem, the fondant was so thick we could not cut through it, we had to saw it!!
Pamela M
5.0
8/07/2012
People are still talking about it! It was so moist it was almost like pudding, we couldn't believe it! Many cake flavors available with a multitude of different fillings. We had buttercream icing, four layers: two layers of white almond with fresh strawberry filling, two layers of red velvet with cream cheese filling. You can have as many different flavors as you have layers! PLUS, they make you your own anniversary cake so you don't have to keep the top-most layer :)
sherry S
5.0
8/01/2012
My Cake Boutique cake was FAB-ulous!!! Not only was the outside heavenly to look at, it was heaven in the mouth too! I ordered it for a Saturday wedding celebration and the left overs are still as perfectly delicious on Tuesday (as I had the last piece today and it hurt my heart it is gone!).
White cake with Buttecream icing is the one dessert I am weak for and my reception cake nailed it (I had a small destination wedding in Florida in April and was pleased with the cake I had for my actual wedding, but when I came to Ohio in July for a wedding reception with my family, my Cake Boutique cake, knock me over it was so good!). We saved the cake top layer from The Cake Boutique to have on our one year anniversary and I wish my anniversary would get here already as I loved the cake.
I live in Chicago so I conducted all business with Stella via e-mail and she was a joy to work with. Very responsive, profession and sweet. The Cake Boutique is the real deal, my cake was gorgeous and delicious! I wish I lived closer so I could get a cake from here all the time.
Last summer I bought a cake from Carlo's Bakery in New Jersery (the one from Cake Boss on TLC). My Cake Boutique cake was 100% better than the Carlo's Bakery cake. It was more moiste and sweet and stayed fresh longer.
If you can't tell I loved my cake!
Danita W
5.0
5/14/2012
The Cake Boutique was very acomodating when it came to me changing my wedding date due to special circumstances. The cake itself is beautiful and delicious!!
Janette S
5.0
11/17/2011
Best tasteing cake ever, so good, there were no left overs. for a four teir cake. No left overs. Tasted amazing and looked just as good. Very helpful and replied in a timely manner. No problems with delivery. The best part about my wedding, hands down. They do, however, charge for cake tasteing which is odd. BUt the cake was so yummy, I guess i cant blame them.
Amy F
5.0
10/11/2011
We got soooo many compliments on how beautiful our cakes were (we had a groom's cake along with our traditional wedding cake) The detail in both cakes were amazing and so many guests raved about how delicious they were! My sister was married one year prior to our wedding and she used this vendor as well for their 2 cakes so we knew they'd be wonderful.
danielle k
5.0
7/28/2011
my wedding cake was so delicious and it looked amazing! They did exactly what I wanted and I loved it!
response 07/29/2011
Thank you so much, it was a pleasure to take part it your special day!
Contact
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Calley Stredney
OWNER
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.
Wedding vendors in Warren
The Cake Boutique
The Cake Boutique's photos
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.