The Cake Boutique

Sarah was incredible for the moment we first reached out! Our cupcake tasting was personal (and delicious). She communicated well and quickly. We were able to tell her our vision and she executed it flawlessly! The final product on our big day exceeded our expectations and we loved the unique nature of many of the cupcakes we chose (strawberry-key lime is the best!) Highly recommend The Cake Boutique!!!

I cannot say enough good things about our wedding cake. We had so many compliments on the design and the taste! I have never had a wedding cake like Sarah's. She took great care in helping us find not only the flavor but the best design. Instead of doing a traditional groom's cake, we did a design on the back to incorporate where we met and got married. On the back was each state that we grew up in (Oklahoma and New York) and on the bottom tier was Virginia with a heart in Winchester. So classy and romantic. People stopped dancing just to go try her cake. And it was worth it :)

We absolutely loved working with Sarah for our wedding cake! She made the process enjoyable and seamless from the get go with her warm personality and seasoned experience. The day of cake was absolutely delicious and beautifully done! Thank you so much Sarah for the fabulous cake!

Sarah was incredible to work with. She was more than accommodating to my strict dietary needs and respected our budget. She was always responsive to my messages and very kind! Our guests loved the vanilla with raspberry filling cupcakes for our summer wedding. We were able to order gluten free cupcakes for our guests with allergies! Our cake was absolutely delicious! The icing was our favorite part. She was able to make our cake look incredible even with my vintage cake topper. She arrived on time for delivery and set everything up while we were getting ready. We can't thank Sarah enough for making our wedding cake and cupcakes! Highly recommend this baker for your wedding!

The Cake Boutique was recommended to us by our wedding coordinator, and clearly for good reason. After our visit with the owner/baker, Sarah, we knew we’d made the right choice. The selection of flavors, fillings and frostings were all delicious and we struggled to pick just a few for our event. Sarah kept in close correspondence with us throughout the process to ensure all the odds and ends were figured out prior to the day. She made suggestions and helped us with a custom cupcake stand we wanted to incorporate and the final result was better than expected. Sarah’s deserts were unanimously enjoyed by everyone at the wedding! HIGHLY recommend!

Wow. What can I say about this cake and working with Sarah. She was so easy to work with, the price was unbeatable, and the cake...INCREDIBLE. I am a baker myself, so I am quite picky - but dang Sarah CAN BAKE! We had our parents come to our cake tasting and we had a blast. Sarah is professional and sweet (no pun intended!) We ended up doing a cutting cake as almond with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream. It was so elegant and beautiful. We then did cupcakes for our guests. We had a set to match our cake flavor, a set of Pink Champagne cupcakes with citrus buttercream, and a set of chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter mouse and oreo buttercream (I am picky about chocolate cake - this cake is a WINNER!) The Almond and pink champagne cakes were also stunning; my mom, die hard chocolate only fan, even loved these!! Lastly, we did a dozen gluten free - these were great gluten free cupcakes - even according to my guests who eat gluten free all the time! If you are debating on a cake vendor or do not have the ability to taste...GO WITH SARAH. You will not be disappointed. Each bite of her cakes you see and taste the love. I only wish I lived closer to eat her cake more frequently!

A little over a year ago, I sent an inquiry to Sarah asking for a black wedding cake (with gold leafing) to accent our Harry Potter-inspired New Years Eve wedding. She got super excited about creating something unique and different for us. When we did our cake tasting in March 2021, it was almost impossible to pick flavors because they are all truly so delicious. In the end we ended up going with a smaller, 2-tiered black carrot cake for us and then for our guests we went with carrot cake, lemon w/lemon curd filling & citrus frosting (trust me), & vegan chocolate cupcakes. Not only was our cake gorgeous, but all the flavors were absolutely delicious. I really enjoyed working with Sarah and when we wanted to make a flavor change, it wasn’t an issue at all. She’s very talented and truly fantastic to work with! Can’t wait to take our topper out of the freezer at the end of the year!!!

We absolutely loved our wedding cake from the Cake Boutique. Sarah was great to work with and so flexible and helpful after we had to postpone our wedding due to COVID. Our cake was delicious, we had two flavors in the four tiers- lemon cake with a raspberry jam filling and white cake with lemon curd and raspberry frosting. Everyone raved about the cake and I can't wait to eat our anniversary tier next year!

No need to look anywhere else! Sarah truly is the best. Her bakery is too cute and you can tell she loves what she does! Out of all things wedding related, the cake tasting was the most memorable, she really knows her stuff! She has a great network of people in the event community too and she was able to assist me in finding the right people! Oh and her cake flavors.... amazing. She has a great sense of taste and can help you finding your perfect flavors too!!

Sarah is the best ever! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! We got married on Halloween and wanted something different from the norm. She took my idea to the next level! Everyone was amazed by how her cake looked and tasted. She was super easy and fun to work with. If you are considering her for your wedding, just do it!!

We had an amazing experience with Sarah for our wedding. She was so professional, so helpful, so easy to work with, and she is an amazing baker! We had so much fun at our cake tasting at her adorable baking studio where we got to try a bunch of yummy flavors. We found the perfect flavors and she was very helpful with helping us find a good cake design. We loved it and the cake was beautiful. I would definitely recommend using Sarah and we would use her again in a heartbeat! Thank you Sarah!

Sarah was so amazing to work with for our November 14th wedding! Being a bride in the middle of a pandemic means many ups and downs and several changes throughout the process. Sarah was amazing about it all. She was flexible, kind, patient, and her cakes are just so, SO delicious! I have told her many times that I dream about our snickerdoodle wedding cake with cinnamon cream cheese frosting because it was just so delicious! My husband and I did a small wedding cake for ourselves and then a cupcake table with four different flavors of cupcakes. We asked Sarah to box and label half of the cupcakes as favors and have the other half sitting out. She did this without hesitation and it was all set up so beautifully! Our guests have been asking for weeks where we got our cupcakes from. They were a hit! Thank you, Sarah for making such delicious treats for our special day and for being so amazing to work with!

Sarah the owner is fantastic to work with, we had so much fun during our tasting coming up with flavors for our big day. The day of there was only one piece left everyone loved the cake and had multiple servings.

The best cake ever! I cannot wait to have our anniversary tier, haha. Sarah was so easy to work and communicate with, especially during this pandemic. We were able to pick up our tasting and take it home. She even helped us pair a tasting- the citrus buttercream (which I would have never picked) with pink champagne cake & raspberry filling. This ended up being our choice! It was a great summer flavor combo. Everyone kept telling us how they’ve never remembered other wedding cakes, but they thought ours was delicious and the best they’ve had! The presentation was also stunning and she helped us with deciding the right size for a dog figurine we wanted to use. If you’re looking for a reliable, personable, and talented cake baker then Sarah is your person! I definitely recommend her!

I typically don't like buttercream frosting but I fell in love with Sarah's! We were able to sample a few flavors and ultimately chose funfetti with caramel frosting and snickerdoodle with cinnamon frosting. My guests loved the flavor combos! The cake was absolute perfection and exceeded our expectations. It was still cool 3 hours after delivery in the middle of July! We couldn't believe it! Sarah did an incredible job! I cant wait to find another excuse to order a cake from her!

Our experience with Sarah and The Cake Boutique was nothing short of amazing! She was such a pleasure to work with during the entire planning process and was able to nail the vision we had for our wedding cake! From your first interaction with Sarah you can really tell that she cares about her work and puts 100% into her craft! It was so difficult to pick a cake flavor after our initial tasting, as everything we tasted was THAT GOOD! We decided on the traditional almond cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream, but also decided to have Sarah make us an anniversary cake for our one year anniversary so that we could have the opportunity to enjoy another flavor!! We received so many compliments from our guests on how flavorful and moist the cake was, and even had guests requesting to take home leftover cake the following morning! Definitely give The Cake Boutique the opportunity to dazzle you with her creativity and flavor!

Sarah was amazing to work with! We did a three layer cake with a coconut cake with vanilla pastry cream and vanilla buttercream, and a chocolate fudge cake with chocolate mousse and a vanilla buttercream. Everyone loved the cake and the cake looked beautiful! We highly recommend her!

Best. Cake. EVER! Sarah – we cannot thank you enough for the beautiful, delicious cake you made for our wedding day! I’ve had to exercise a ton of self-control to not dig in to the Anniversary tier early! So fun to work with, very responsive and provided great recommendations to help make our vision even better than we could’ve imagined. The cake was moist and the filing was to die for; we loved your recommendation to alternate tiers with different fillings so that guests (and us) could enjoy two different flavors. We will definitely be back for any/all cake-required occasions!

My "naked" cake was gorgeous and delicious thanks to The Cake Boutique! It was simple and elegant with a touch our rustic, exactly what I wanted. Sarah also worked well with my florist to add flowers to my cake that gave it just the right touch of color! It was beautiful and I received so many compliments on the design as well as the taste!

Sarah was really pleasant to work with and our wedding cake came out great! We loved meeting her in her shop and chatting with her while trying out her different flavors. On the Big Day, the cake was beautiful and super tasty. Many guests commented about how good it was. We will definitely contact her in the future when we need cake for the many cake-worthy occasions life brings. Try the lemon- so good!!

The cake tasting was great and Sarah even gave us extras to take home. It was very well organized. Sarah made a special chocolate raspberry cake with raspberry filling and white buttercream icing that was absolutely delicious and beautiful. The cake was a fair price and Sarah was wonderful to work with! Highly recommended!

Sarah at The Cake Boutique is great to work with! From the time of contact she was very responsive and easy to work with. At the tasting, she got to know our vision and made recommendations on what would look and taste best to fit with our wedding. Very knowledgeable and everything we tried tasted amazing! She delivered at the scheduled time and got everything set up the day of the wedding, 4/21/18. Everything looked exactly as expected and we got so many compliments on how great all the cupcakes were. Highly recommend!!

HIRE SARAH NOW!!!!!!! You will NOT be disappointed. She was such a joy to work with and made my dream cake a reality. Sarah goes above and beyond with her cakes and there is so much heart put into it. She’s so personable and puts your needs first. Our wedding cake was beautiful, delicious and Sarah is just the cherry on top. I HIGHLY recommend her to anyone and everyone. Thank you so much for making our cake the best one yet! And war eagle to that!

Beautiful cake and a great experience! Sarah at the cake Boutique is great, we set up a tasting with her and absolutely loved the samples. She helped with the design and the cake came out beautiful and delicious.

The cake was delicious and absolutely beautiful! It was a 4 tier cake with all over swiss dots and our flowers cascading down one side. It was chocolate cake with peanut butter icing inside. I've been eating left overs for the past three days. Sarah is the best and very easy and fun to work with!

Sarah, the owner, truly outdid herself with our wedding cake. We had so many compliments and the head chef at our venue said it was the most beautiful cake he has seen in 25 years of working weddings. She had great suggestions and I have honestly never seen a more beautiful wedding cake- it truly was the wedding cake of my dreams! Our guests are still commenting on how delicious it was!

Sarah at The Cake Boutique was fabulous and we couldn't be happier! We set up a tasting where we were allowed to sample 3 flavors of cake/icing of our choosing. Once we had tried the snickerdoodle cake with buttercream icing there was no turning back- we had found our wedding cake flavor, unfortunately we liked too many flavors, so we ended up getting cupcakes so we could get multiple flavors! They were all too delicious- guests left nothing to bring home. Sarah took the picture of my dream wedding cake and made it reality! She also helped me plan a surprise groom's cake for my husband. I gave her my vision with no solid pictures/ideas in mind and she made a cake better than I could've ever imagined!! I can't wait for another excuse to get a cake from Sarah!

Sarah, the owner of the Cake Boutique, was so much fun to work with! We had a tasting/consultation with another cake baker, and we left feeling extremely confused. Sitting down with Sarah and tasting her delicious cake flavors was an easy and enjoyable experience! She listened to our ideas and answered every question. We decided to go with alternating tiers of carrot cake and snickerdoodle. All of our guests commented on how good the cake was. Confession: my new husband and I couldn't stop ourselves from eating the entire anniversary tier within the first week of marriage!

Delicious! We had gone to several cake tasting and were not impressed by the people or the cakes. We finally found The Cake Boutique and fell in love! You would not think much of it, since the bakery is in a tiny little shed, but the cakes were unbelievably delicious! We came to the tasting with a picture of what we wanted our wedding cake to look like and it was spot on! The price for such an amazing cake was so incredibly reasonable. We are now trying to think of an occasion to have another cake made! I would definitely recommend The Cake Boutique to anyone!

I had such a pleasant experience with the Cake Boutique, starting from the cake tastings to the very end when I walked into the ballroom and saw my beautiful 5 tier cake. We couldn't decide on which flavor we liked more so we ended up choosing pumpkin and lemon/raspberry for every other tier. The buttercream frosting was done so perfectly, that it looked just like fondant icing. I had so many compliments on how delicious the cake was, I would recommend the Cake Boutique to anyone! And the price is definitely worth it!

I used the Cake Boutique last fall for my wedding and the work was wonderful. The cake was one of my favorite parts of my wedding just because it was so beautiful.

Amazing cake, flavor, design, and unique. Sara was amazing with her creativity and skill. I could not have asked for a better overall package - from cost to taste. She made it personal - a new friend made our cake. Can't wait to have another reason to order more cakes!!

We chose The Cake Boutique because of the reasonable price. Cake was not our main priority at our wedding, but we did want it to be pretty. I found MANY pictures of what I thought I liked and Sarah was able to bring together that vision and create a BEAUTY! The cake was a little dry, but like I said, it wasn't our main priority. This is a newer business and I see it going far! Looking forward to trying our anniversary tier in a year...it is a different flavor then what I tried at the wedding and have heard that it was moister....can't wait to try it! :)

First off, I made a great friend when I was referred to Sarah from the Cake Boutique! She is simply a pearl! We talked with her and picked out flavors of which she made me a dozen cupcakes as a "sample". The cupcake "sample" was SO good that my husband, daughter, and I went back and ordered another dozen before the wedding came! That dozen was just as delicious as the first! The cake was PERFECT! I told her what I wanted, she drew it up, and then she made it come to life! I got compliments from almost everyone about how good the cake was and I only had a small portion left when my cake was more than double what I needed! =) That made me so happy! The ONLY BAKER in Winchester who not only agreed to attempt a "topsy turvy" cake, but she also executed it brilliantly! And also, threw in a few dozen cookies for the price! She is PHENOMENAL and I recommend The Cake Boutique highly! I have already ordered my daughter's birthday cake from her for next month!!!!!!

Not only was our cake drop dead gorgeous, it was also the best tasting cake our guests and us have EVER had! I'm usually not a cake eater, I really hate cake. But I could not get enough! We had a cappuccino cake, a chocolate and peanut butter cake and a pineapple/coconut cake. The layers of different cake. Our guests just loved it! They devoured it! And plus everyone commented on how beautiful it looked! The Cake Boutique in winchester was cheap, friendly, flexible and delicious!