The Cakery

Make your day a little bit sweeter

Western New York, Northern Pennsylvania

Service area

5.0

Verified reviews from real couples

I cannot recommend Peggy at The Cakery enough! Everything not only looked beautiful but tasted AMAZING! We had mini pies, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cannoli, brownie bon bons, chocolate chip cookies everything came out absolutely delicious and you cannot beat Peggy’s prices. I recommend her to everyone looking for delicious treats for their wedding!

Alysa C.

5.0

The Cakery staff was very professional and made sure to understand what I wanted 100%! When our wedding day came, I didn’t even have to worry about the arrival of the cake, as I knew the time it was going to be delivered and The Cakery delivered perfectly! The cake was delicious. We got raspberry filled and it was amazing. Can’t wait to have it again on our 1 year anniversary! Thank you so much Cakery, I am very happy with our choice to use you as our cake vendor for our wedding this past summer.

Hannah U.

5.0

The Cakery is a wedding cake bakery based in Fredonia, NY. This custom cake shop can bring your sweet dreams to life with a stunning cake that tastes as good as it looks. In business since 1988, The Cakery brings the skills and experience to deliver the cake of your dreams. They are passionate about making your special day a little sweeter with their lovingly crafted creations. What they do is all about you, and they build, bake, and create the perfect centerpiece for your wedding event. No matter what you have in mind for your wedding cake, a timeless multi-tiered cake adorned with cascading florals or delicate fondant details. Or something with a natural aesthetic adorned with fresh flowers, fruits, or greenery. Whatever you have in mind, their expert bakers will create a show-stopping cake that reflects your style.

Woman-owned Business

Details

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Accessories

Cake Serving Sets

Cake Stands

Cake Table Decorations

Cake Toppers

Cake Cutting & Serving

Cake Delivery & Setup

Cake Tastings

Cupcakes

Groom's Cakes

Other Desserts

Dietary Options

Gluten Free

Nut Free

Vegan

Any questions?

5.0

out of 5.0

5 reviews

Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Review Summary

This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.

The Cakery, led by Peggy, receives glowing reviews for their delicious and beautifully designed wedding cakes and treats. Customers commend Peggy's creativity, professionalism, and ability to bring their visions to life. The staff's attention to detail and prompt delivery on the wedding day are praised, with guests raving about the variety and flavors of the cakes, cupcakes, and treats provided. The Cakery's accommodating nature, especially in catering to dietary restrictions like gluten sensitivity, is highly appreciated by couples, making them a top choice for wedding desserts.

Search reviews

Alysa C

10/26/2025

I cannot recommend Peggy at The Cakery enough! Everything not only looked beautiful but tasted AMAZING! We had mini pies, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cannoli, brownie bon bons, chocolat...

e chip cookies everything came out absolutely delicious and you cannot beat Peggy’s prices. I recommend her to everyone looking for delicious treats for their wedding!

Hannah U

9/16/2025

The Cakery staff was very professional and made sure to understand what I wanted 100%! When our wedding day came, I didn’t even have to worry about the arrival of the cake, as I kn...

ew the time it was going to be delivered and The Cakery delivered perfectly! The cake was delicious. We got raspberry filled and it was amazing. Can’t wait to have it again on our 1 year anniversary! Thank you so much Cakery, I am very happy with our choice to use you as our cake vendor for our wedding this past summer.

Response from The Cakery on 09/17/2025

Thank you Hannah, It was my pleasure being part of your wedding. Peggy Rose

Any questions?

Emily V

11/04/2024

We had the most beautiful (and delicious) cutting cake and cupcakes at our wedding! We loved how we were able to provide a few pics as inspiration and they really delivered!

anonymous u

6/25/2024

The best, yummiest, cake ever!!! Peggy was able to accommodate my gluten sensitivity with cake that was not only moist but incredibly delicious! The guests all raves about how grea...

t the cake and cupcakes all tasted. Everything was beautifully done.

Emily B

4/17/2024

When my husband and I got engaged, there was no question where we were going to have our wedding cake made. Peggy sat down with both of us and made our simple - albeit DELICIOUS - ...

chocolate chip cannoli cake come to life. We wanted a smaller cake to compliment our sweets station and even sweetened the deal by adding on some chocolate chip cannolis for our sweets bar! Peggy is all things amazing; articulate, creative, and really knows how to bring your vision to fruition (even if you kind of have no idea what you want *ahem* -me-). She was so patient as we were originally to be married in June of 2020, and rescheduled two more times before we finally landed on a solid date. We can not recommend her business enough and continue to make The Cakery our first stop for all of our sweet treats for all occasions with our growing family!

Service area & Contact info

24 West Main Street, Fredonia, NY

Open map

Western New York, Northern Pennsylvania
Typically included in the starting cost

(716) 679-6408

Want to book a visit?

Start the convo

*=Required

Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.

The Cakery

Peggy Rose

Owner

The Cakery's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.

The Cakery

About this vendor

Review Summary

Service area & Contact info

Wedding vendors in Fredonia

Why use The Knot to message vendors?