Historic Property on the Shores of Nagawicka Lake
Holds ceremonies and receptions
Julie Gerber
DIRECTOR OF CATERING & CLUB OPERATIONS
Located in Hartland, WI, The Commodore – A Bartolotta Restaurant is a beautiful waterfront property providing couples with the perfect space to celebrate their wedding. First opened in 1902 as the Pleasant View Hotel and Resort, The Commodore has become the premier events destination in Wisconsin's Lake Country. Boasting exquisite views of Nagawicka Lake and featuring event settings of various sizes, this wedding venue is ideally suited to hosting both the grandest of gatherings and the most intimate of affairs.
The Grand Heritage Ballroom can seat up to 200 guests and features a full wall of windows overlooking the serene waters of the lake. If an outdoor ceremony fits your wedding vision more aptly, the Pleasant View Pavilion can seat up to 200 and is perched on the water's edge. The Fountain Patio is a quaint space situated next to the Pavilion that wraps around a gorgeous fountain, a fabulous option to host the cocktail hour. The Nagawicka Suite is named after the lake on which the premises are located and features a magnificent room for the wedding party to prepare.
The Commodore is a Bartolotta restaurant, and as such, couples can expect the very best cuisine to be served at their celebration. Bartolotta Restaurants is a nationally recognized restaurant and catering organization that has become the premier culinary brand in the Greater Milwaukee region. Inspired by the traditional cooking of France and Italy, you and your loved ones will be astounded by the culinary journey that the talented chefs at The Commodore lead you on.
Amenities + details
Amenities
Ceremony Area
Covered Outdoors Space
Dressing Room
Handicap Accessible
Indoor Event Space
Outdoor Event Space
Reception Area
Wireless Internet
Ceremony Types
Civil Union
Commitment Ceremony
Elopement
Interfaith Ceremony
Non-Religious Ceremony
Religious Ceremony
Second Wedding
Vow Renewal Ceremony
Settings
Backyard
Ballroom
Beach
Waterfront
Historic Venue
Restaurant
Venue Service Offerings
Bar & Drinks
Cakes & Desserts
Food & Catering
Planning
Rentals & Equipment
Service Staff
Any questions?
Meet the team
Julie Gerber
Director of Catering & Club Operations
Your wedding day deserves nothing less than extraordinary. At Bartolotta Catering & Events, we pride ourselves in restaurant-quality cuisine, first-class service, and a one-of-a-kind venue to transform your dream wedding into an unforgettable celebration. Let's create something magical together – I can't wait to hear your vision!
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.05 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
The Commodore is highly praised by multiple reviewers for providing a seamless and perfect wedding experience. Guests were impressed by the beautiful facility, delicious food, and impeccable service from the staff. The professionalism and organization of the team, including Julie, Alyson, Shari, Katie, and Justin, were highlighted, making the wedding planning process stress-free and enjoyable. The venue's stunning lake views, included linens and tables/chairs, as well as prompt and informative communication further added to the positive experiences shared by guests.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 6
Katherine R
5.0
1/22/2026
So fortunate we could hold our wedding of our dreams at The Commodore! Our ceremony, cocktail hour and reception were all held on site. We had nearly 50% of our guests fly in from ...
out of state and they, along with WI locals, were GUSHING about the interiors, exterior, the food and drink and how well everything flowed. Julie and team were beyond communicative and made sure no detail was spared. The Commodore also has gorgeous linens and tables/chairs included so that was less rental! I could go on and on. Go check out the space and see for yourself!
Martha E
5.0
11/19/2024
I cannot begin to describe how impeccable The Commodore was for mine and my Fiancés wedding. My Fiancé and I previously had our wedding planned in Florida and due to the recent hur...
ricanes, we had to complete a last minute change in 30 days. The Commodore and its staff were the ones that allowed us to have the most perfect wedding anyone could dream of and I do not say this lightly. Every. single. detail. was spot on and nothing was missed. Alyson, Shari, and Katie are extremely professional and organized women that will not disappoint. It’s hard nowadays to find service like The Commodore. Its professionalism is like nothing I have seen before. All of our wedding guests could not stop talking about how beautiful the facility is, how nice the people are, and how delicious the food was. All I can say is HIRE THEM!!! You will have a seamless wedding that you will remember and cherish forever <3
Any questions?
Carolyn H
5.0
10/12/2024
The Commodore and the staff made my daughters dream wedding come true! We were at the Commodore from 9am until midnight and every single thing about my daughters wedding was simply...
perfect! The food was delicious and the staff was impeccable! The Commodore team exceeded our expectations! Gratefully, Carolyn Hoffman
Heidi C
5.0
8/30/2024
This venue was incredible and far exceeded our expectations as it just opened this August! Justin, Katie, and all staff were so professional and a joy to work with planning our son...
's wedding. The appetizers and food were a 10 out of 10. The service was excellent and you can not beat the lake views.
I highly recommend-you will be in good hands!
Kaitlyn M
5.0
8/28/2024
We had the best experience with The Commodore for our wedding. We were lucky enough to be the first wedding hosted as this venue and everything went perfectly. The staff was fantas...
tic - we had many of our guests tell us it was the best service they have ever received at a wedding! The food was delicious and the venue itself is beautiful right on the lake. Communication with the team was always timely and informative. We were only able to see the venue 2 weeks before our wedding, but we were never concerned given the clarity and consistency of our communication with them. Would highly recommend!!
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
The Commodore- A Bartolotta Restaurant
Julie Gerber
|
Director of Catering & Club Operations
Wedding vendors in Hartland
The Commodore- A Bartolotta Restaurant
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.