The Cookie Catastrophe

Central Florida

About This Vendor

Custom Printed Sugar Cookies and Dessert Tables

The Cookie Catastrophe is a family-run bakery serving weddings and events in Winter Haven, FL. Owner Stephanie Middleton bakes with her dream team of decorators and enthusiastic tasters who make sure every product is top-of-the-line. Together, they create a range of confections to adorn your dessert table and edible favors to sweeten your special day. Catering to every occasion, popular items on their menu include but are not limited to: - Custom-printed sugar cookies (photos, names, dates, etc.) - Gourmet cookies (with over 90 flavor options) - Buckeyes and other specialty cookies - Brownies and blondies - Chocolate-covered treats - Homemade marshmallows - Custom printed M&Ms - Edible place card - Cookie cakes - Cupcakes

Details

Business Attributes

LGBTQ+-owned Business, Woman-owned Business

Cakes & Desserts

Cupcakes, Other Desserts

Pricing for The Cookie Catastrophe

Curious to learn more?

The Cookie Catastrophe Reviews

5 out of 5.0

6 reviews

5 Star

100%

4 Star

3 Star

2 Star

1 Star

Reviewed On 5/24/2023 by Nicole D

We ordered custom cookies for wedding favors and couldn't be happier! The cookies were delicious and were a hit with all our guests - they kept asking how we got our monogram logo on the cookies! Stephanie was wonderful to work with and I am lo...

oking forward to working with her again.

Response from the Vendor on 05/24/2023

Thank you so much for the kind words! We look forward to working with you again!

Reviewed On 5/10/2023 by Yuliya F

I ordered custom printed sugar cookies from them 2x, once for a bachelorette party, and then again for the wedding! They looked great and tasted amazing.

Response from the Vendor on 05/10/2023

Thank you so much! All great orders to design and create!

Reviewed On 5/09/2023 by Jackie C

We could not recommend anyone better ! We had cookies made for our wedding side 7&8 for guest to take home for a late night snack. They were so delicious everyone raves about them. Definitely a life long customer.

Response from the Vendor on 05/11/2023

Thank you so much! Those sets were so much fun to make!

Any questions?

Reviewed On 5/08/2023 by Kathy D

Purchased the beautiful cookies (slide #5) for a special nephew’s wedding reception . I couldn’t of been more pleased. They shipped to PA, packed so securely, not one cookie was broken. There was a table full of cookies and everyone, and I do m...

ean everyone, commented on these special cookies. I also ordered a variety of other cookies for this event from “The Cookie Catastrophe” and was very pleased with every single one.

Response from the Vendor on 05/08/2023

Thank you so much for your kind words! This was such a beautiful set to make!

Reviewed On 5/06/2023 by Marline D

We discovered the deliciousness that is Cookie Catastrophe at our local farmers market in Winter Haven. All their goodies are absolutely delicious. We chose them to be a part of our special day because we wanted to keep things as local as possi...

ble. My husband and I are nerds and we had several nods to Star Wars for our wedding. Including the delicious fall flavored mini cookies from Cookie Catastrophe with the custom Star Wars label featuring my hubs and I. They are amazing to work with and everything went smoothly from Order to delivery.

Response from the Vendor on 05/07/2023

Thank you so much for the kind words! We loved the creativity of your wedding!

Reviewed On 5/06/2023 by Janette H

Couldn’t recommend enough! They made us an assortment of cookies and by the end of the night they were all gone! Definitely a must to book them for your wedding!! Your guest will love the cookies and you will not regret it!

Response from the Vendor on 05/07/2023

We were honored to be part of your wedding! Thank you so much!

Contact Info for The Cookie Catastrophe

Winter Haven, FL | Central Florida

Meet the Team

The Cookie Crew

Owner

Baker: Stephanie has been baking since she was a toddler, and continues that love for baking by making delicious cookies and other baked goods to bring your dessert table to life! Graphic Designer: Krystal has been a designer for more than 20 years. She’s here to create custom prints and labels to match your theme! Taste Tester: Abigail, our daughter, will ensure only top notch products are leaving our kitchen! Abigail Wranglers and Assistant Taste Testers: Steve, Deb and Maribeth are the unsung heroes of our bakery, ensuring Abby is in good hands when we are in full cookie mode!

Message Vendor

Starting Cost: $$ – Affordable

By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree that your information will be shared with the vendor and used to create an account on TheKnot.com. Please see our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details.