About this vendor
The Diamond Cellar is one of the largest independent jewelry stores in the US, representing some of the finest brands in the world including Scott Kay, A. Jaffe, Christopher Design, and Precision Set. Check out our selection, and visit us for the best price guaranteed.
Details
Rings
- Engagement Rings
- Wedding Rings
Wedding Jewelry
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.0112 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
We are beyond thrilled with our experience working with Michael, and we couldn’t recommend him highly enough! From the very first moment we met him, it was clear that he is an abso...
lute expert in his field. As first-time clients working with a jeweler, we had a lot of questions, but Michael took the time to explain everything to us in detail, ensuring we were completely comfortable with the process. His communication was crystal clear, and he was always available to answer any questions we had along the way.
What really set Michael apart from other jewelers we looked at was his professionalism, intelligence, and genuine care for his clients. He made sure we were getting exactly what we wanted and helped us find the perfect pieces that fit our vision. His expertise was evident in every step of the process, and it made all the difference in ensuring we felt confident and excited about our choices.
Michael was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly thoughtful in making sure we understood the different options available to us. His customer service was exceptional, and he truly went above and beyond to make our experience stress-free and enjoyable. We could tell he truly cares about his clients and the quality of the work he does.
If you’re looking for a jeweler who is professional, intelligent, and dedicated to making sure you get exactly what you want, Michael is the one. We are so grateful for his guidance and expertise and couldn’t be happier with the stunning pieces we now have. Highly recommend Michael and Diamond Cellar to anyone! Nothing but the highest quality.
Karl has been great to work with! He always answers any of my questions and provides exceptional service!
We used the Diamond Cellar for my engagement ring and wedding bands for our 8/5/23 wedding, and we were so beyond thrilled with their services. We worked with Marcie, and she was o...
utstanding. We also worked with her for our wedding gifts to each other, and for special wedding gifts for our moms. We were so happy with all of the items we chose. Marcie ensured that the items were our style and also stayed within our budget. We worked with her so frequently, that she became like family! She was so sweet and kind, and incredibly helpful. The service was outstanding, and we would 100% recommend the Diamond Cellar for any of your jewelry needs!
Karl was amazing. Very patient, kind and helpful when I was undecided about make a purchase of a vintage ring. I initially spotted the ring a year ago and didn’t get it. I stopped ...
back in six months later - still didn’t get the ring - then another few months stopped back in and I finally decided to make the purchase. He did not pressure me at all in these visits and was also helpful in getting some other jewelry of mine appraised and resized. Very personable and friendly. A pleasure to work with.
Had an extremely wonderful time working with Stephanie at The Diamond Cellar at Easton. She was insightful and helpful in finding the rings that my husband and I both described lik...
ing. Also, they do free cleanings and setting checks whenever you need so I love swinging by on my way to shop. There are so many options and they are a Columbus local company!!
I am from Cincinnati and I was having trouble finding someone to help me and my mother in law had used them in the past and what an absolute DREAM TEAM! Karl was my main contact a...
nd I did everything over the phone and sending photos and it turned out better than I could have imagined. I think it's a true testament to their level of quality and service that I am willing to make it work from out of the city to work with these amazing people. Cannot recommend them more and always tell family and friends they should be your first stop!
My husband had a great experience buying my engagement ring from Diamond Cellar! When we went back to look at wedding bands, they didn’t have exactly what I was looking for, so we...
had it custom designed. They did an amazing job with my rings! We will be going back for a matching anniversary band at some point!
I bought my engagement ring, plus both wedding rings from Diamond Cellar. Katie helped in both instances. She was very attentive and was able to answer all my questions about rings...
.
We received our bands during wedding band week sale. Even though it was busy, I still received great customer service. We viewed several rings and got to try on many styles. Even though we did our research online before we arrived, it was nice to try on several different types of rings. Thanks Katie for helping us pick beautiful rings that we are proud to wear.
We have purchased quite a few pieces from the Diamond Cellar and really appreciate the customer service and (lack of) sales attitude. Michael always seeks to educate and serve us ...
instead of pressuring us to buy something, he truly wants to make sure that our jewelry is perfect for our lifestyle and the occasion!
I had my rings custom made at the Diamond Cellar by Dan Mikel. He is an amazing, gifted artist. I would highly recommend him to make you a one of a kind piece from scratch, or a tr...
easure out of something that you provide to him from a family heirloom piece.
Shopping for an engagement ring may be even more stressful than buying a car! The selections are overwhelming! Ryan really helped pair things down by listening to what I wanted. Wh...
en I came in to pick up the ring Ryan was on his lunch. He knew how special this moment was and cut his break short to make sure I was satisfied and that I had everything I needed. The whole experience was pleasant and not pressure filled! Thank you to Ryan and the whole staff! The best ending to this review.....she said YES!
My girlfriend and I walked into Diamond Cellar looking for customizability and the perfect ring to reflect our commitment to each other. Right away we were assisted by Kathy. She h...
elped guide us through the process and my soon to be fiance was beyond thrilled with the ring and whole experience. If you're interested in finding the perfect experience and more importantly the perfect ring, ask for Kathy Dennis! She was the perfect guide, helping at our pace, all in the best place possible... the Diamond Cellar ♥️ The next time I need a diamond I'm calling Kathy!
We bought our wedding bands here and had a pleasant experience. Our rings are quality and it is convenient that we can go back there anytime to have them cleaned.
We adore our rings! They helped my husband design a beautiful set of rings that I absolutely love and did so with so, so much professionalism and friendliness. They were tuned in w...
hen we discussed what we were thinking about in terms of styles and designs and showed us so many different options. When we had questions, they were knowledgeable and receptive. Before the wedding, they even shined up and treated my rings for free so that they would look perfect on our special day! We were able to find the perfect rings, and I give the staff so much credit for this. They will treat you respectfully and are so kind! I highly recommend The Diamond Cellar for all your wedding jewelry needs!
I am biased, but I have the best engagement ring ever. My husband made several trips from Detroit to Columbus to consult with Dan and help design my unique ring, which resembles a ...
diamond flower and contains rubies in a beautiful setting underneath. I couldn't be more pleased.
Marcie at the Easton location was fantastic! She incredibly knowledgeable and helpful in guiding me to the perfect ring for my fiancé! Marcie was very accommodating and made the bu...
ying process enjoyable! Highly recommend!
Michael at Easton was very professional and very pleasant to work with. He was able to find the perfect stone for our budget and style. I would definitely recommend diamond cell...
ar to family and friends.
My fiance got excellent service at this location when choosing a ring. They were able to get a mock-up made of a ring he saw in an advertisement so he could make sure it was exactl...
y what he wanted. They also helped him choose the best center stone for the setting and gave him advice about what ring to choose based on his budget and what he said he wanted (they listened well). When we came back to choose his wedding band they were very patient and never minded when we came in several times just to look and try rings on. Very good customer service from everyone we interacted with at this location and at the new Easton location.
Harold at the Easton location was a gem (pun intended)! He was welcoming as we explored different styles of engagement rings, helpful throughout the process, and did his best to wo...
rk within our budget. With his help, the perfect ring was created. Highly recommend!!
My husband had a wonderful experience with Ryan when he purchased my engagement ring. Of course we returned for our wedding bands! Ryan is very personable and honest. Our rings are...
outstanding quality and we couldn’t be happier. We will continue to patronize diamond cellar!
I seriously have nothing but amazing things to say about Diamond Cellar! My now husband got my engagement ring and our wedding bands from Diamond Cellar and we have had nothing but...
extremely positive experiences from day one. Two days before my wedding, I went in to have my ring cleaned only to learn that 8 stones had become loose! Laura was very professional and handled the situation seamlessly and got my ring back to me promptly. They even took care of my dad and step mom when they came to pick it up for me. I wouldn't recommend anywhere else.
After going to a few other places this was by far the best! Randy at the Easton location was very helpful! I loved that the rings were ready to try on with sample diamonds in the...
m. When I went other places they just had the settings and you had to place a diamond on the ring to see what it would look like. Everyone was kind and very friendly. Plus it’s a family owned business!
They did a wonderful job on the engagement ring and were so helpful for selecting both of our wedding rings!
Randy was inviting and helpful the entire visit. He really listened to my fiancée about what he was looking for in a men's wedding band. I mentioned that my ring was loose and he g...
rabbed me a plastic sizer to keep my ring on my finger until I got the chance to go resize it! Fantastic customer service. We didn't feel pressured and felt well informed about the product. I was so happy to buy from them. Would recommend a visit to Randy!
My fiance and I shopped around before he decided to purchase my engagement ring from Diamond Cellar. Ultimately, we felt that the customer service was exceptional, honest, and over...
all a very positive experience. Other jewelers were either pushy, rude, or seemingly incompetent. We anticipated that Diamond Cellar rings were out of our price range, but they are very actually competitive in pricing and as the saying goes, you get what you pay for.
They did a great job sizing my ring and cleaning them!
We customized my engagement ring and designed a matching wedding band at the same time so everything lined up. We also ended up purchasing my husband's wedding band from the Diamon...
d Cellar as well. The knowledge and selection that the Diamond Cellar has is unbeatable. We had gone to a variety of different jewelers and could not be happier with our purchase here. Mike DiCello was so helpful throughout the entire process up to the soldering of the rings after our wedding. We could not have asked for a better experience!
I've gone twice to the Easton store and had HORRIBLE experiences both times. The first time was to look for an engagement ring for me. We said our budget was $7K and the guy showed...
us rings that were J in color - aka YELLOW and ugly. We left and went to another jeweler and got a beautiful ring - 1 carat center stone and 1 carat on the band, E in color, gorgeous for around our budget. I came back into the diamond cellar to have them check for loose stones and they told me how horrible my ring was, how "cheap" it looked and how they suggest we pay $500 to "recast" it because it looks TERRIBLE. I literally sobbed in the middle of the store because the man was so incredibly rude to me and my now husband. When I came back to pick up the ring (had them tighten two stones. No recasting BS), a friendly man was working the counter. I didn't tell him the whole story..but asked his opinion on the quality of my ring. He told me the quality of the stone and band were lovely and he saw no problems. WTF?! Stay AWAY from this place.
Michael Parise was awesome! Very knowledgeable and understanding of what I was looking for. I would definitely recommended coming to the diamond cellar for michaels professionalism...
alone! Best service, quality and craftsmanship. I give it a 10/10
Mike Parise at the Easton location was amazing! He provided instant comfort in what I thought was going to be a stressful situation. He gave me great options, a lot of space to ma...
ke my decision and a little bit of wine :) Mike also made the resizing and insurance process a breeze. Great experience overall!
My fiance worked with Pete. We had a great experience picking out my engagement ring. He let us take our time, we did not feel pressured to buy & he explained every detail to us! I...
get compliments on my ring almost daily. It's beautiful! We will be back to the Diamond Cellar for future jeweler needs!
Michael Parise has been incredible. We sat and discussed every aspect of the diamond-selection process, from sourcing to cut. The experience was custom to my plans and personalized...
, every step. I've gone back even for personal jeweler needs.
What an awesome experience! Marcie Gold help me reset my diamond. She was so kind and professional. Such amazing workmanship and customer service. I was so happy. Marcie was t...
he best! I am absolutely thrilled with my necklace!
Ken at the Sawmill Road location is really helpful and patient. Highly recommend!
Ryan helped to make sure our experience was as great as it could be, from start to finish! We highly recommend their services, whether buying or designing. Ryan made the process ea...
sy, understandable, and informed us of each step along the way.
Ryan was great. He took the time to find exactly what we were looking for and made sure to stay within our price range.
Marcie Gold at the East on Diamond Cellar was fantastic! She was knowledge, friendly and took the time to show me anything and everything! I highly recommend going to see her! She ...
will take great care of you!
AMAZING Customer Service! Picked up my solitaire that we had reset -- it is absolutely gorgeous! Marcie Gold's service and expertise was phenomenal! I am a very picky client -- Mar...
cie patiently worked with me to pinpoint the PERFECT setting and then she helped me custom order the setting in platinum. I am also very impressed with the quality and detail of the appraisal I ordered with the reset. Diamond Cellar has a customer for life!
My fiancé and I worked with Michael Parise at the Easton Commons location in Columbus, OH. From day one Michael took the time to explain the ins and outs of the diamond industry an...
d what they had to offer. Michael was also a great listener and mindful of our budget. He was patient, understanding and got us exactly what we wanted! The entire process was flawless and we couldn't be happier. We would 150% recommend Michael and the team at Easton.
Harold Mills has been providing top-level customer service to me since 2009. He is consistent with his professionalism and always goes above and beyond to meet my needs. I always...
refer friends and family to Harold because I know they will be in great hands. The Diamond Cellar is very lucky to have Harold as a part of their company. I would also like to acknowledge both Ron Croft and Kevin Ballard for their top-level customer service!
My wedding band came from Diamond Cellar and I could not be more pleased. We were having a difficult time finding a ring that fit my vision. We worked with Kevin and after an initi...
al mix-up with my first choice (completely my fault) we were able to correct and I absolutely love my band!
I would highly recommend The Diamond Cellar. You will not be disappointed! My (now) husband and I got our wedding bands here, and both our bands ended up being custom orders. We co...
uldn't find quite the perfect fit, so we were very excited they were able to do custom work. We worked with Daniel who was phenomenal! He was very personal and really listened to what we wanted. We also had the pleasure of meeting Igor, the goldsmith, who designed/created the wax model for my wedding band. Everyone there is very polite and professional with a strong work ethic and commitment to their clients!
My husband purchased my engagement ring from The Diamond Cellar and worked with Sarah Schaffner. I finally got to meet her soon after and when we set a date for our wedding, I was ...
so excited to work with her to pick out my band. She is so knowledgeable about their products and is such a joy to work with! She takes such good care of you there, treating you like family. I highly recommend Sarah, you will love her!
I bought my husband's wedding band from the Diamond Cellar. The quality is fantastic and he loves it so much. Although my engagement ring and wedding band is not from the Diamond C...
ellar I have brought them for repair to the Diamond Cellar and they have always done a great job with the repairs. The customer service is fantastic and I always feel welcome every time I walk into the store at Easton. The staff is really accommodating.
My fiancé (Amanda) and I decided to stop into the Diamond Cellar on Sawmill a few months ago when we began talking about getting engaged. Every time we drove past the DC, I joked w...
ith her and asked if she wanted to go look and she gave me the typical “oh be quiet”. We finally said why not since we were both very naïve when it came to jewelry and diamonds.
We were greeted at the front by a worker and they had great coffee and other beverages to sip on while we waited for a sales associate to free up. We were then introduced to Sarah Schaffner who took us upstairs to the engagement ring section. They had a huge selection of rings at many different price points. Sarah was patient and walked us through every case so that Amanda could look at all of the styles. She eventually picked out a handful that she liked, and I tried to take mental notes of those particular features that she liked on each. I liked them all too but was envisioning something a bit different, so I decided to stop back in at a later date without Amanda.
We discussed doing a custom ring and putting together some of Amanda’s favorite features of each that she previously had looked at. I was pleasantly surprised to find out that the “custom” piece wasn’t nearly as expensive as I initially thought it would be. We sat down with one of the CAD designers to go over the specific dimensions and diamond sizes that I wanted on the ring. I then picked out the main diamond, but first shopped around to ensure that I was getting a fair price. The DC has a price matching policy for any diamond with the same specs at a competitor’s brick and mortar store, which will ensure that you are getting the best price in town. Once I felt comfortable with the design, I put down a deposit so that they could begin a full CAD design on the ring. Once that was completed, I was able to look at a very lifelike computer design of the final. I then gave the “ok” to begin the casting process. After a few more weeks, the ring was cast and polished, and the diamonds were set. Overall, the process took about a month before I could pick up the new STUNNING ring.
Throughout the whole process, Sarah was very helpful with educating me about diamonds (there was way more to learn that I would have ever thought!), ring styles, and answering the many questions I had. My fiancé absolutely loves her ring and that makes the month of waiting for it to be finished totally worth it. I would definitely recommend the Diamond Cellar and/or their custom services to any of my friends and family. They have such a great selection and knowledgeable staff that will ensure you will leave with the perfect piece.
The best around! They are wonderful to work with! Love my rings :)
I can't stress enough how great the Diamond Cellar was in creating a custom engagement ring for my fiance and me! We worked with Jeannie (service) and Scott (goldsmith) and from o...
ur first consult, it was clear that this was the place to build our dream engagement ring.
Not only did they offer excellent prices for customizing our own ring, they were very knowledgeable about rings, diamonds, etc. And, to top it off, they made every effort to finish the ring in time so I could propose before Christmas!
In short, I would recommend the Diamond Cellar to anyone interested in an engagement ring, and especially in designing their own custom ring. We plan on returning for all of our future jewelry needs.
My fiance and I went to the Diamond Cellar for our wedding bands, after he had a wonderful experience buying my engagement ring from them.
We went to the Easton Town Center loc...
ation, and were thrilled to be able to work with the same salesman (Bill Johnson) that sold my fiance my engagement ring. He is great! Not pushy, or fake like many other salesmen in the jewelry industry. Rather, he seemed genuinely interested in our story and helped us choose the wedding bands that fit our personalities and lifestyle perfectly. My now-husband works with his hands, and we were concerned about the hazard a ring can create. Bill was very knowledgeable about different materials we should steer clear of as well as look towards and their longevity. He also kept our budget in mind without being pushy. I would highly recommend Bill at the Diamond Cellar location at Easton.
My husband worked with Steve Remias at The Diamond Cellar and I'm so glad he did!
Steve helped my husband create my DREAM ring and has gotten continued business from us because ...
of his superior service.
We are very open and honest with him with budget and he respects that and doesn't push us past it.
We also got our wedding bands from Steve and were very happy with this purchase as well.
We highly recommend you go and visit Steve if you are considering purchasing or upgrading a ring. He will take great care of you!
I can't even begin to describe what a wonderful experience my fiancee and I had at the Easton Mall location. We got engaged in February (this review is far overdue) and went the le...
ss traditional route where I got to be there to pick out my ring :)
All I can say is WOW. The selection and customer experience is top notch and it is a very low pressure buying experience.
We both highly recommend Michael DiCello. He made us feel so comfortable, relaxed, and we felt very well taken care of. He is also very honest and knowledgable about the product!! You are the best Michael!!
Don't waste your time looking anywhere else. Your first stop should be The Diamond Cellar. I know we will be back to pick out our wedding bands!
Contact
960 New Bond St., Columbus, OH
The Diamond Cellar