Skip to Main Content
Columbus Wedding Cakes

The Pastry Bar

Make Sweet Memories
4.9 out of 5 stars and 10 reviews
·
All of Ohio
Service area
4.9
Verified reviews from real couples
I cannot say enough about how wonderful Maya is. Not only is she friendly accommodating and easy to work with, but the cakes were delicious and stunning! Highly Recommend!!
Farah O.
5.0
Maya was exceptional for our wedding. Meeting with her was easy and she gave us samples of her flavored cakes and filings to try. Everything was so delicious that we had a very hard time deciding. We don’t typically like cake but wanted it for our reception. It was outstanding and so delicious! Not only did the cake taste amazing the design we sent her she duplicated exactly. We also had her delicious shooters and cake pucks that everyone raved about too! We couldn’t have been happier with our choice to go with Maya and the Pastry Bar.
Marissa R.
5.0

About this vendor

Vendor
Maya
OWNER
Typically responds within 24h
The Pastry Bar is a home bakery in Columbus, OH, offering a variety of desserts for any event. We specialize in wedding cakes and provide a line of wedding and bridal party desserts. From cookies to cake shooters, we are your one-stop shop for all your sweet tooth needs. We offer cake tastings in the lead-up to your special day so you and your partner can sample our wide array of cake flavors, frostings, and fillings. We also provide cake delivery, stand rental and set up services, taking the pressure off you on the day of the celebration.
Woman-owned Business
5+ years in business
Speaks English
Just me
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Circle Message
Any questions?
Meet the team
Vendor
Maya
Owner
Hi! I’m the owner of The Pastry Bar! My love for baking began in high school when I started working at a bakery in Worthington, OH until it unfortunately closed. I ended up pursuing a career in I.T. after that until COVID came around and found myself needing a new job. I began working at The Suisse Shop in Columbus, OH eventually moving to become a pastry chef for Abercrombie & Fitch HQ in New Albany, OH. During that time, The Pastry Bar came about! The Pastry Bar strives for excellence and precision to create not only delicious desserts but also a piece of art for your special event! I am honored to be a part of your special day. We are woman owned and LGBTQ+ friendly!
Reviews
4.9
out of 5.0
10 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
sparkle

Review Summary

This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Reviewers rave about The Pastry Bar’s desserts—delicious flavors, moist cakes, and beautifully replicated designs. Customers praise fast, responsive communication, easy tastings, and reliable delivery and setup. Highly recommended for weddings and bridal events, with guests consistently complimenting the treats.
Review photos
AvatarF
4/06/2026
I cannot say enough about how wonderful Maya is. Not only is she friendly accommodating and easy to work with, but the cakes were delicious and stunning! Highly Recommend!!
AvatarM
11/17/2025
Maya was exceptional for our wedding. Meeting with her was easy and she gave us samples of her flavored cakes and filings to try. Everything was so delicious that we had a very har...
d time deciding. We don’t typically like cake but wanted it for our reception. It was outstanding and so delicious! Not only did the cake taste amazing the design we sent her she duplicated exactly. We also had her delicious shooters and cake pucks that everyone raved about too! We couldn’t have been happier with our choice to go with Maya and the Pastry Bar.
Circle Message
Any questions?
AvatarM
8/28/2025
We ordered our wedding cake through The Pastry Bar and it was the best and easiest experience! I emailed to get a quote and I heard back immediately. While we continued to discuss ...
what we were looking for I was amazed at how quickly Maya was getting back to us, it was record speeds! They executed exactly what we were hoping for! It was delivered and set up beautifully. Not only was the process beyond easy but the cake was so good! We selected the lemon flavor and it melted in our mouths. We are not exactly dessert people but I cant wait for our anniversary to have this cake again and not share this time! Maya was so amazing to work with!
AvatarJ
7/07/2025
Maya was amazing to work with! She provided a beautiful cake and delicious cupcakes for our wedding, and everyone enjoyed them!
Response from The Pastry Bar on 07/08/2025
Thank you so much! It was an honor being part of your special day!!
AvatarH
4/26/2025
Maya did an amazing job on a 6” chocolate cake for our special day! An amazing attention to detail and ability to make our cake unique and personal to us! Would recommend to anyone...
in need of a cake or desserts for their wedding!!!
AvatarC
10/29/2024
Very pleased with our wedding cake! I shared some photos of designs I liked and Maya did a great job using that to create a beautiful cake. Coordinating was so easy and the tasti...
ng box was an easy process as well!
Response from The Pastry Bar on 11/25/2024
Thank you so much Caitlin! It was a pleasure working with you.
AvatarA
7/18/2024
I asked for a stump cake with 48 cupcakes and got exactly what I hoped for. The sponges were moist and the frostings tasty. It was beautiful with lovely little cupcakes. The bakers...
were easy to work with and responsive.
AvatarL
2/14/2024
Everyone we spoke to was helpful in getting our order planned out. The test sample were all delicious and delivered quickly after speaking with them. The only real issues we had wa...
s on the day of, they first attempted to deliver to our house instead of our venue but we're still able to get everything set up in time. Also, the wedding cake did not have the correct type of filling we had discussed. It was still all delicious.
Response from The Pastry Bar on 02/23/2024
Hi Lia! We apologize for the incorrect filling in your cake and would love the chance to ...
make it up to you. We pride ourselves in making your desserts the least stressful part of your wedding planning. Please reach out to us as we’d like to offer you a complimentary cake with the correct filling! -The Pastry Bar
AvatarS
8/01/2023
I would give The Pastry Bar 10 stars if I could! Steph made a beautiful and delicious cake for my bridal shower that people are still raving about!
AvatarA
1/14/2023
The cake was delicious and ver cute. Everyone was impressed
Contact
Vendor Logo
Circle Message
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
meet the owner
The Pastry Bar
Maya
|
Owner
Typically responds within 24h
My wedding date is flexible

Wedding vendors in Columbus

Columbus Bridal Salons
Columbus Beauty Salons
Columbus Caterers
Columbus DJs
Columbus Florists
Columbus Reception Venues
Columbus Videographers
Columbus Wedding Bands
Columbus Wedding Photographers
Columbus Wedding Planners
  1. Wedding Vendors
    /
  2. Wedding Cakes
    /
  3. Ohio Wedding Cakes
    /
  4. Columbus Wedding Cakes
    /
The Pastry Bar
The Pastry Bar's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

  • Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
  • Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
  • Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
  • For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.