No photos yet
4.8 out of 5 stars and 258 reviews Best of Weddings (8x).
4.8
(258)Northern Hudson Valley, Dutchess, Orange, Ulster, Putnam
About this vendor
We have been named Hudson Valley Magazine's "BEST BAKERY" for over 30 years! We take great pride in the fantastic artistic capabilities our decorators have developed. We strive to make each cake unique and to our client's specifications - call today to schedule a design consultation and cake tasting!
Details
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Kosher
- Organic
- Sugar Free
- Vegan
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.0258 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
We felt SO lucky that our venue had a deal with the pastry garden to include our wedding cake within the venue fees. The pastry garden truly did better than we could have expected!...
I forget the name of the lovely woman I had the pleasure of talking to but every experience I had with them was easy and helpful. She was upbeat and kind when I told her what samples we wanted, she also gave me some feedback on a few fillings I was indecisive about, and I’m so glad I went with her suggestions. I almost cried when I noticed the cake at my wedding, it was prettier than I expected and they did such a great job with the flower placement (see picture). We went with a white cake with white chocolate mousse and peanut butter mousse and WOW people raved to us about the cake! The venue sent us home with a few extra slices and we savored them, it was so delicious! We are planning on ordering some smaller cupcakes or tasting minis on future anniversaries because we were that obsessed with our cake.
The Pastry Garden made the most beautiful, most delicious wedding cake of our dreams! Our guests raved about the flavors and style. We also loved the tasting and talking through ou...
r design ideas with Sabrina. She was so helpful, kind, and patient with us. Thank you for everything!!!
We ordered our wedding cake with the Pastry Garden for our wedding at the Garrison. They made the whole ordering and tasting process really seamless and made it so easy to pick our...
cake! The cake was beautiful , it was so light and fluffy and tasted amazing!
Getting our wedding cake from The Pastry Garden was one of our favorite parts of the whole wedding! The cake tasting was so much fun, and we loved being able to work with them to c...
reate a custom cake that was exactly what we wanted. They brought our vision to life, and it tasted absolutely incredible. Our guests couldn’t stop complimenting how delicious it was. We can’t thank them enough for making this part of our wedding so special!
We loved our wedding cake from Pastry Garden! So easy to work with and the cake was absolutely delicious.
The Pastry Garden handled our wedding cake for The Garrison, and it was delicious! We went with the vanilla cake with cannoli cream and buttercream icing. Looked great and tasted e...
ven better!
Absolutely amazing! Not only did they provide the most delicious cake, they organized the delivery with our venue directly so it was completely hassle-free for us! The staff was su...
per lovely to work with. You won't regret booking with them!
The cake for our wedding was exactly what we envisioned plus it was delicious.
Mary was so incredibly helpful and worked around our busy schedules to help us get in to see her and pick our cake. The cake was beautiful and delicious!
The cake and desserts were both excellent. Our guests loved the assortment and said they were delicious.
We had an amazing experience working with The Pastry Garden! The cake was absolutely delicious and looked beautiful! We went with a red velvet with cream cheese icing as the fillin...
g. They were so sweet and easy to work with, and the tasting was a fun little afternoon during our planning process.
Extremely kind and communicative. The cake was gorgeous and incredibly delicious! In fact, were still eating it!!!
We booked with a venue who works with Pastry Garden and they did not disappoint. The cake tasting was a fun and helpful experience. The staff made it very easy to pick out flavors,...
colors and decorations. They really helped bring our vision to life. The cake was beautiful and delicious!
We worked with a venue that includes a cake from Pastry Garden in their package and we were thrilled with the cake! We loved the tasting and got to try multiple flavors of cake and...
filling combinations. Pastry Garden made it a breeze to choose the ultimate combination and design. On our wedding day, the cake was delicious and so beautiful.
We ordered a gluten-free cake for our wedding day. It was SO good. You could NOT tell it was gluten-free. It was so good that my husband and I finished it on the dance floor after ...
the cake cutting. LOL. We highly recommend Pastry Garden.
This was the bakery that our venue worked with but we could not have been happier. We had our main cake as well as a special top tier just for the groom and they executed it perfec...
tly in both appearance and taste! The inspiration picture I gave them was matched to a T, I could not have asked for a better result. AND the cake was delicious, exactly what we asked for. Amazing!
We got married at The Garrison and our wedding cake from The Pastry Garden was included in our package. We couldn't have been happier with how beautiful the cake looked and how am...
azing it tasted. Our tasting at The Pastry Garden was so much fun and the staff helped us to pick the perfect design.
The Pastry Garden needs to take accountability with how their employees treat and disrespect their customers. My husband left this very heartfelt review and it was dismissed and hi...
dden. Nobody responded with our very serious concerns. If they do this again, we will request to talk to the manager to make sure this is addressed and we get an apology as a lot of the comments made by the employee were very hurtful even a year later. Here was the original review that was left by my husband:
“The Pastry Garden made our wedding cake for our October wedding. Our 3-layer red velvet cake was incredibly delicious and gorgeous! The cream wasn't too heavy either and didn't make anyone feel too weighed down to dance. We couldn't ask for a more skilled team!
However, the cake tasting we had a few months prior to our wedding is the primary reason for the low rating. While the cakes we tasted were truly delicious, the person assisting us was just as distasteful and hurtful as their cakes were good. Completely unprovoked, during the tasting after I complimented her on her technological knowledge, she made an ugly comment about Gen-Z kids and young adults, stating they're the dumbest generation. She then went on to make several homophobic and transphobic remarks, all the while I'm trying to shut her down and steer the conversation back to something more cordial and appropriate. She also claimed some wild political views, like how teachers make too much money in the U.S. This was not the right time nor place to make any political statements, nor is it ever ok to be transphobic or homophobic.
I'm not sure if this woman was the owner or just a manager, but this is a public post -- they can look up my name in their database and see who assisted me that day. Regardless, it was someone with seemingly high authoritative power in the store based on how she talked to the employees behind the counter. This experience completely ruined my day after a 2-hour drive to the bakery. The only reason I went through with the order was because I thought the wedding venue I chose already paid $500 to this bakery as a voucher for my cake, which I would lose if I went elsewhere. I should have asked my venue about this, but found out after the wedding the voucher was not locked in, and I could have taken it to a different bakery.
Don't make the same mistake we did. Do not support businesses which employ people with harmful and dangerous views like this. Go find a bakery with great cakes which promote community and the betterment of everyone.”
We were required to go with The Pastry Garden by our venue (The Garrison), but we could not be happier! The design was beautiful and elegant, exactly what we wanted. We went with w...
hite cake with chocolate and strawberry mousse for filling with buttercream frosting, and it was really delicious--moist and not too sweet, and so many guests told us they loved it!
We ordered mini-pastries from Pastry Garden and they were fantastic! We had so many guests compliment the chocolate cake truffles (which were gluten free). We were glad to have a l...
ot of the options be gluten free as well!
We were recommended The Pastry Garden by our wedding venue. We were able to make an appointment in the same week that we called. We tried a few flavors and there were all so good! ...
The buttercream was so delicious. We got some helpful advice on how we might decorate our cake. My husband and I were unsure what we wanted, but thankfully we were able to send emails with inspiration photos and discuss the designs. Everything was simple and not stressful at all. Thank you so much for a beautiful cake to match my beautiful day.
The Pastry Garden Bakery was stellar to work with! They were flexible in optionality during our tasting and executed well a design that met our vision. We went with a chocolate mar...
ble cake with strawberry preserve and it was absolutely delicious! Our guests loved it and we did too. Couldn’t recommend them enough!
The Pastry Garden was our designated cake vendor and they did not disappoint! Not only was the cake delicious, but it was also stunning. We did our tasting with the owner, who coul...
d not have been nicer. Would highly recommend working with them!
We got our Wedding cake from The Pastry Garden for our December 2023 Wedding! The were truly lovely to work with. The Pastry Garden made an amazing, beautiful and delicious wedding...
cake for our day! I had so many guests come up to me and rave about our delicious the wedding cake was! Thank you to The Pastry Garden for an amazing cake!
The Pastry Garden nailed the cake design we were looking for. It was beautiful, elegant, and most importantly, delicious. Since we had a summer wedding, we decided to do things a l...
ittle differently, and went with lemon. It did not disappoint. I would absolutely use them again (oh wait I have!). Highly recommend... thanks so much!
They provided a sweetheart cake and cupcakes for our November 16th, 2023 wedding. The whole process was very simple and the person I talked to on the phone was very pleasant and he...
lpful. On the day of, the cake and cupcakes all looked amazing and exactly like we wanted and were also super tasty!
From the tasting to the presentation of our cake the day of, The Pastry Garden does everything right. We had so much fun choosing a unique cake flavor profile (spice cake with whit...
e chocolate mousse) and the design I envisioned came to life perfectly. I can't wait to get more baked goods from them.
My husband and I got our cake from the Pastry Garden Bakery for our wedding. Stephanie, the owner of this bakery, is a true gem. She is so kind and accommodating! I have a dairy al...
lergy and she made sure that all of our tastings would be dairy free. For our wedding day- we had a small separate dairy free cake along with our standard cake and both my husband and I LOVED the cake. Not only was it beautiful but it was absolutely delicious. Thank you Pastry Garden, and Stephanie, for making our wedding cake dreams come true! (: You are incredible!
We had a great experience getting our wedding cake here! Our venue was contracted with The Pastry Garden and we were really glad they were. They made it easy to make an appointment...
for a tasting and choose the flavors we wanted beforehand, which they had prepared when we came in. We ended up going with a vanilla cake with lemon preserves because it was SO refreshing. We got so many compliments on the cake from our guests. Looked absolutely beautiful too!
This bakery is professional and they love what they do there products shows. We got our wedding cake here. It was amazing. The cake looked beautiful and the icing and filling and t...
he cake it’s self tasted amazing.
So so happy to have used pastry garden for our wedding cake!! We got to meet with them, taste 4 different combinations of cakes and frostings and share pictures of what we wanted f...
or our cake. I’m attaching a picture of a one layer cake that we used for inspiration and then attaching our wedding cake picture. Such a great match, with everything that I wanted. It was so perfect!! They took care of everything day of- bringing it to the venue and having it set up, we had nothing to worry about and I would recommend them to anyone!
The Pastry Garden created the most beautiful cake for our wedding day! We went in for a tasting and design session a few months before getting married and it was a really seamless ...
and easy process. We showed pictures of what we liked and were able to try 3 different AMAZING samples! They confirmed multiple times between then and the wedding that the cake would be delivered on time. When I saw the cake on the day of the wedding, I almost cried at how perfect it was! It really was a dream come true. The design was perfect and it tasted even better than I remember at the tasting. All of the guests were raving about it and I can't wait to have the rest on our year anniversary!
Created our dream cake!
They bought my drawing to life! Cake was flawless and delicious!! Thank you!!!
We were so pleased with The Pastry Garden for our wedding cake! Not only did it look beautiful, but it also tasted absolutely delicious. The flavor we decided on was a lemon cake w...
ith raspberry and champagne mousse, and it was a hit with all of our guests. The staff were very easy to work with and provided a great tasting experience. They were very accommodating and willing to work with us to create the perfect cake for our special day. We would highly recommend The Pastry Garden to any couple looking for a delicious and beautiful cake for their wedding!
Pastry garden made my cake for my 11/5/22 wedding and it was everything I had wanted and more! I went in with a picture from Pinterest and they went above and beyond to make my dre...
am cake happen. The lace decoration was EXACTLY aa it was in the picture!
Not only was the cake stunning, but it tastes amazing! We had marble cake with layers of vanilla custard and chocolate buttercream. It was the most delicious wedding cake!
Pastry Garden did an amaizing job on our wedding cake! We had white cake with lemon filling. It was delicious and our guests loved it. We wanted our hulk action figure attached...
at the top in a King Kong way and they did it perfectly!
Our cake was absolutely beautiful! Stephanie and her team did a wonderful job. We chose a marble cake with buttercream frosting and cookie dough mousse. It was delicious and all of...
our guests complimented it as well! Thank you, Pastry Garden!
The Pastry Garden made our wedding cake. Tasting and selection was delicious and professional, and the cake was absolutely scrumptious. Many complements. Would highly recommend....
(also, they have the best cannolis in the area...)
Our wedding cake was SO delicious and the Pastry Garden was a pleasure to work with. So kind and accommodating. We worked with Stephanie and she was so sweet. We went with a chocol...
ate cake with chocolate butter cream icing and espresso filling. It was extraordinary! The best wedding cake I have EVER had!
Our wedding cake from The Pastry Garden was absolutely beautiful and delicious! The process of choosing them, going to our tasting, and the delivery for the big day so was professi...
onal and easy. I could not recommend The Pastry Garden more!!
We loved our cake!!! Thank you Pastry Garden!
Above the rest! We had our wedding cake done by Pastry Garden as part of our package through The Garrison, and it was so tasty! We chose a vanilla custard with raspberry mousse a...
nd vanilla cake / vanilla frosting. Not only was it delicious, it was such a beautiful / classy piece of art! The customer service at this bakery is also above the rest - highly recommend!
Incredible, beautiful, and delicious cake four our wedding. It was SO big that we kept eating it for days and days after! Highly recommend!
What a delicious cake we had for our wedding! The Pastry Garden is a preferred vendor of our venue Interlaken Inn. We chose a chocolate cake with raspberry preserves and raspberry ...
mousse! It was AMAZING. Thank you so much. And to the lovely owner, Stephanie, thank you so much for your kindness. Thinking of you and hoping you are doing well and watering the flowers <3
Our cake was absolutely delicious! Everyone ate cake! It was decorated beautifully!
Delicious!! We ordered the lemon cake with the white chocolate filling! The lemon flavor was the perfect hint of lemon. The white chocolate mousse wasn't too sweet and the perfec...
t creamy texture. They told us that most couples usually eat their 1st year anniversary cake before the the anniversary because the cakes are so good! I think if we save half it still counts right? 😁
Our wedding cake was everything we dreamed of — beautiful and delicious! The style and substance is all thanks to The Pastry Garden. Our tasting was a breeze and when I called to a...
sk if they could make cookie platters as wedding favors, they were happy to accommodate. I can’t recommend them highly enough.
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! Our wedding colors were three shades of blue and The Pastry Garden matched the buttercream flowers on our cake perfectly! The process ...
for sampling the cake was simple and convenient. They had our samples ready to go when we arrived. My husband and I are both chocolate lovers. We went with the chocolate cake with fudge filling and vanilla icing. It was so good! The cake looked gorgeous – we almost didn’t want to cut into it! We highly recommend The Pastry Garden!
We got our wedding cake from the Pastry Garden (they work with our wedding venue, The Garrison) and it was SO delicious! We had a marble cake with chocolate mousse and vanilla cust...
ard filling with buttercream frosting. We also decided to add assorted cookies for a small cookie buffet at our wedding and it was a hit! Mary was especially helpful with setting that up. Through our venue, the Pastry Garden handled delivery so there was nothing we had to do to coordinate. Would recommend!
Contact
2600 South Road, Poughkeepsie, NY | Northern Hudson Valley, Dutchess, Orange, Ulster, Putnam
The Pastry Garden Bakery