The Spicy Cupcake

Thoughtfully crafted for every occasion
New
Huntington, NY
$300 starting price
See details

About this vendor

Vendor
Peyton Gadaire
BAKER & FOUNDER
Typically responds within 24h
I've always felt the need to create, build, and imagine from a young age. The Spicy Cupcake was inspired by my drive to be creative and my passion for baking. Over the past few years, I've learned that I can transform my passion for baking into something more. By starting off making baked goods for family and friends, my confidence grew, as did my skill set. Receiving positive feedback from loved ones and customers turned friends has really motivated me to practice new styles and techniques. I am self-taught with an incredible eye for detail and entirely committed to collaborating with you to execute your vision. I have experimented with many recipes over the years and have perfected various flavors to ensure all are able to enjoy a cake as beautiful as it tastes. Each creation comes from my heart. My goal is to bring you joy and happy memories that you'll cherish by taking your aesthetic, thoughts, and inspiration and turning them into reality!
Woman-owned Business
+2 years in business
1 team members

Prices & packages

Cupcake Package - Single Flavor / Small
$240 starting price
Cupcake Package - Single Flavor / Small
$240 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
48 cupcakes
48 cupcakes
Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
Intimate Package
$300 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake w/ 12 Cupcakes
2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake w/ 12 Cupcakes
For those celebrating w/ their nearest and dearest
For those celebrating w/ their nearest and dearest
Cake feeds 15-18 / Cupcakes feed 12
Cake feeds 15-18 / Cupcakes feed 12
Bottom Tier - 6" / Top Tier - 4"
Bottom Tier - 6" / Top Tier - 4"
Premium Cupcake Package - 4 Flavor / Small
$300 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
Choose 4 flavors
Choose 4 flavors
48 cupcakes
48 cupcakes
Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
Most popular
.
Cozy Crowd Package
$450 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
Cake feeds 40-43 / Cupcakes feed 24
Cake feeds 40-43 / Cupcakes feed 24
For those celebrating w/ a group of around 60
For those celebrating w/ a group of around 60
Bottom Tier - 8" / Top Tier - 6"
Bottom Tier - 8" / Top Tier - 6"
2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake / 24 Cupcakes
2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake / 24 Cupcakes
Cupcake Package - Single Flavor / Large
$480 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
98 Cupcakes
98 Cupcakes
3 Tiered Cake
$600 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
8" / 6" / 4" 3 Tiered Cake
8" / 6" / 4" 3 Tiered Cake
Feeds 80 - 90
Feeds 80 - 90
Premium Cupcake Package - 4 Flavor / Large
$612 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
98 Cupcakes
98 Cupcakes
Choose 4 Flavors
Choose 4 Flavors
Premium Cake & Cupcake Package
$840 starting price
Contact for hours
Contact for hours
48 Cupcakes
48 Cupcakes
Cake feeds 80-90 / Cupcakes feed 48
Cake feeds 80-90 / Cupcakes feed 48
8" / 6" / 4" 3 Tiered Cake
8" / 6" / 4" 3 Tiered Cake
  • Cupcake Package - Single Flavor / Small
    $240 starting price
    Cupcake Package - Single Flavor / Small
    $240 starting price
    Contact for hours
    Contact for hours
    Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
    Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Funfetti
    48 cupcakes
    48 cupcakes
    Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
    Red Velvet, Carrot, Oreo, & Pistachio add $2/cc
  • Intimate Package
    $300 starting price
    Intimate Package
    $300 starting price
    Contact for hours
    Contact for hours
    2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake w/ 12 Cupcakes
    2 Tiered 3 Layer Cake w/ 12 Cupcakes
    For those celebrating w/ their nearest and dearest
    For those celebrating w/ their nearest and dearest
    Cake feeds 15-18 / Cupcakes feed 12
    Cake feeds 15-18 / Cupcakes feed 12
    Bottom Tier - 6" / Top Tier - 4"
    Bottom Tier - 6" / Top Tier - 4"
  • Premium Cupcake Package - 4 Flavor / Small
    $300 starting price
    Premium Cupcake Package - 4 Flavor / Small
    $300 starting price
    Contact for hours
    Contact for hours
    Choose 4 flavors
    Choose 4 flavors
    48 cupcakes
    48 cupcakes
    Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
    Choc, Vanilla, Funfetti, RV, Oreo, Pistachio
  • Starting prices may not include all fees a vendor may charge.
  • Couples usually spend $500
Are you interested?
Reach out and share your wedding details.

Details

Cakes & Desserts
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cupcakes
Dietary Options
Gluten Free
Circle Message
Any questions?

Meet the team

Vendor
Peyton Gadaire
Baker & Founder
Born and raised in Huntington and eager to collaborate with you!

Availability

Reviews

5.0

out of 5.0
3 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
  • Top reviews
  • Newest first
  • Oldest first
  • Highest rated
  • Lowest rated
Sort by
AvatarN
Highlighted review.
2/10/2025
Absolutely love Spicy Cupcake! They have been my go-to bakery for multiple occasions, and every time, they exceed my expectations. Their cakes and cupcakes are not only beautifully designed but also incredibly delicious. The flavors are always rich and perfectly balanced, and you can truly taste the quality ingredients in every bite. Spicy Cupcake is professional, creative, and always willing to go the extra mile to bring my vision to life. Whether it’s a birthday, a special celebration, or just a sweet treat, they never disappoint. Their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction make them stand out from the rest. If you’re looking for a baker that delivers both style and flavor, Spicy Cupcake is the one! Highly recommend!
response 02/11/2025
Noel I am so honored to be able to help you celebrate such incredible milestones! So bless...
ed to have you in my life and can't wait to share and celebrate so many more amazing memories! All my love my girl!!!
AvatarH
2/11/2025
Obsessed with these cakes and cupcakes ! So delicious and so beautiful I didn’t even want to eat them ! The taste is out of this world and Peyton is so easy to work with. Worth it !
response 02/11/2025
Heather you are the BEST! Thank you so much for your continued support and kind words my g...
irl! <3
Circle Message
Any questions?
AvatarS
2/10/2025
The Spicy Cupcake is such a wonderful company! From their professional service to the quality of their pastries, everything is just perfect! I’ve ordered from here a few times, and each time, I’m in total disbelief at just how beautiful and well made each pastry is. Not only do they look amazing, but they taste incredible!! The cupcakes and cakes are so soft and fluffy. They never disappoint. I can’t wait to order from the spicy cupcake again! 😍
response 02/11/2025
Stace, I LOVE you! I am so grateful for your support and to be able to celebrate such incr...
edible milestones with you, to many more my girl <3

Service area

Huntington, Huntington, NY
Huntington, Huntington, NY
Open map
Circle Message
Want to book a visit?

Contact

Vendor Logo
Circle Message
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
meet the owner
The Spicy Cupcake
Peyton Gadaire
|
Baker & Founder
Typically responds within 24h
My wedding date is flexible
  • 0–50
  • 51–100
  • 101–150
  • 151–200
  • 201–300
  • 300+
Number of guests*
  • Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
  • Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
  • Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
  • For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.

Wedding vendors in Huntington

Huntington Bridal Salons
Huntington Beauty Salons
Huntington Caterers
Huntington DJs
Huntington Florists
Huntington Reception Venues
Huntington Videographers
Huntington Wedding Bands
Huntington Wedding Photographers
Huntington Wedding Planners
  1. Wedding Vendors
    /
  2. Wedding Cakes
    /
  3. New York Wedding Cakes
    /
  4. Huntington Wedding Cakes
    /
The Spicy Cupcake
The Spicy Cupcake's photos

Why use The Knot to message vendors?

  • Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
  • Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
  • Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
  • For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.